7 ms·
mAh Is an Industry Mistake
- Faaak 3y agoTL;DR: mAh is not a unit of energy. Energy = Capacity * Voltage (mAh * V). Industry should use Wh (or Joules, which is the same unit type), instead of mAh.
- lnx01 3y agoAnd Ah is a measurement of charge, it reduces to Coulombs. Amps is couloumbs per second (Q/t), if you multiply by time again you get (Qt/t) which is just Q, or charge.
- hyperhello 3y agoIn a battery, isn’t voltage the thing that scales easily (just add more series cells) while mAh is a measure of quality of each cell?
- stetrain 3y agoYou can have a battery cell that is 3v, 100mAh. And another cell that is 6v, 100mAh. The second cell has double the energy storage as the first cell. Really mAh is only useful when comparing cells of the same voltage. It became a common metric since so many battery cells in electronics are 3.7v, so you could assume a constant voltage and just compare mAh. But not all cells are 3.7v, so sometimes that mAh comparison falls down completely and you should really be using watt-hours (milliamp-hours * volts).
- ilyt 3y agoNope, current scales more easily. Just add more batteries in parallel. The problem starts with voltage because now you need each battery or battery set connected to have very close capacity or else it will be "wasted", and you need cell balancer to keep them equally charged.
- asddubs 3y agoputting batteries in parallel comes with its own problems, namely that you need far higher current to charge them at a reasonable speed, which is more difficult to scale up effectively than voltage
- magicalhippo 3y ago> which is more difficult to scale up effectively than voltage For those who don't know, this is because losses scale as current squared, instead of just proportionally like it does with voltage. For example, charging a power bank with 20W of power at 5V you need to supply 4A of current. If you have a good USB cable with 0.1 Ohm resistance, that results in P = V*I = (I*R)*I = (4*0.1) * 4 = 1.6W of loss in the cable[1]. If instead you could use 20V to charge, then the current would only need to be 1A and hence the loss just (1*0.1) * 1 = 0.1W. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohm%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ohm%27s_law
- jaguar1878 3y agoIf a battery is internally a set of connected cells, then as a battery designer you have the choice of wiring the cells in series or parallel. Need more voltage: series. Need more mAh: parallel. Cell 'quality' is a vague term since some applications may care more about discharge rates or operating temperature range than total capacity. Usually though, batteries are designed with a particular application in mind and that application will define a voltage that is acceptable, such as ~3.8V for phones or ~19V for laptops. Significantly above this would damage the device. Likewise, below that voltage and the device doesn't function. This is why mAh is a decent proxy for Wh; for a given application the voltage is fixed and so the conversion - for that application - is fixed. mAh for a given application can be compared easily. Comparing batteries for different applications is harder, but not just because you have to convert mAh to Wh: different applications require different performance characteristics beyond just voltage. You might care about weight, physical dimensions, operating temperatures, discharge rates, charge rates, self-discharge rates, output impedance.
- trashtester 3y agoI think it's easier to think of voltage as the speed per thread of a processor and amperage as the max number of threads. Neither measure the "quality" of the battery. What DOES have to do with quality, though, is the amount by which voltage falls as the load increases, or in other words, how efficient the battery is. This is similar to the efficiency of a power supply in a computer.
- darken 3y agoThis has bugged me for so long and I hope the industry finally stops someday. To summarize for anyone not versed in electrical power: * mAh measures how much current your battery holds, irrespective of voltage. * However, actual POWER is measured in Watts (or watt-hours cumulatively). * Watts = current * voltage. * A 2000mAh hour battery at 2 volts has half the power of a 2000mAh battery at 4 volts. * As voltages can vary based on battery arrangement (parallel vs series cells), this makes a huge difference. You can half or double your mAh by arranging your cells differently, without changing actual power stored. Using Wh or mWh instead of mAh would make this whole problem go away. But then that means low voltage batteries (like often used in phones) can't inflate their reported mAh compared to high voltage cells (e.g. in power tools). They also tend to conveniently leave out the battery voltage, so you can't tell when it's an apples to apples capacity comparison. It's so silly. /rant
- zelon88 3y agoSo who's going to explain to 99.999% of the world why a 10w/h battery that is 5v is incompatible with their 12v device that also takes a 10w/h battery?
- dv_dt 3y agoNo one? Just like no one explains that the 1.2v 1500mah battery isn’t compatible with the 9v 1500mah battery.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dgacmu 3y agoI 99.9% agree with you. Some nitpicks, since this is a discussion of getting units right: mAh doesn't measure "current", because current is the flow of electrons. It measures charge. 2000 mAh hour is redundant - the 'h' in mAh is hours. :) But your basic point is 100% correct: All batteries should show their capacity in Wh.
- zelon88 3y agoThe ones saying this is a mistake are scientists and electrical engineers. They know what a w/h represents as a unit of measure. They have the frame of reference and know the equation. So they would rather see a standardized measurement that takes into account all factors in one measurement. But you don't use batteries like that. Consumers use batteries that are a specific voltage. Watt hours obfuscates this fact. So when a user tries to plug a 1.2v 40w/h battery into a 12v device that takes a 40 w/h battery, they will not know why it does not work. So we break it out into two separate, and unequally important properties for these consumers. The important property being voltage. If the voltage is the same, the battery can be considered by consumers to be "compatible" with their device. If the mAH is greater, they will have more battery life. Lower, and they will have less battery life. W/H is insufficient for describing batteries unless you specify the voltage you are working with. People don't care about potential energy unless you tell them it's important. That's why batteries are represented as # of amps per hour @ a specific voltage. Also, thank you for reminding me of how terrible and sophmoric Reddit is.
- spookie 3y agoYup, that makes perfect sense
- nicoburns 3y agoThere is no such thing as a device that takes a 40wh battery. A device will take a battery with a specific voltage, and will last for different amounts of time based on the capacity.
- fanf2 3y agoYour theory might make sense if the voltage was actually specified, but when I last bought a USB-C power bank I could not find that information anywhere, so I did not know if I was comparing like with like.
- jfengel 3y agoIn a saner world, it would be implicit in the USB-C. As it is, you know that it supports 5V. It might also support higher voltages (up to 20V), though if it doesn't specify I wouldn't assume. If you need higher voltage, you'll have to look for a battery that specifies it. (And hope that the package isn't lying.)
- ravedave5 3y agoWe really need a 'Nutrition facts label' for electronic devices/batteries. Usage Facts Serving size: 1 hour Servings per charge: 3.5 Total power (watt-hours): 56 Voltage: 12 Amp hours: 4.57
- kube-system 3y agoData sheets are a thing. More data doesn't help though, unless the consumer knows what it means. Also, it isn't really even that simple, battery capacity can vary depending on discharge rates. The root of the problem is that batteries are complicated and most people aren't engineers. https://mm.digikey.com/Volume0/opasdata/d220001/medias/docus/56/815_815_OEM_DS.pdf https://mm.digikey.com/Volume0/opasdata/d220001/medias/docus...
- billpg 3y ago"Total power (watt-hours)" Nitpick, but Watt-Hours is energy, not power. Why yes, I am very clever. Thank you for noticing.
- pickledish 3y agoFor others -- based on the title I believe OP may have meant to link to this specific comment in the thread: https://old.reddit.com/r/macbookair/comments/w2eqxs/whats_the_battery_capacity_in_mah_of_the_m2_air/jvj0q2y/ https://old.reddit.com/r/macbookair/comments/w2eqxs/whats_th...
- praash 3y agoI'm also irritated by how the SI prefixes get abused here - saying TEN THOUSAND MILLIAMPERE-HOURS is just stupid when people rarely need to compare that to sub-Ah capacities. Why shouldn't we go further and start using nAh? Storage capacity seems to deserve proper prefixes instead of madness like 100 000 000 kB.
- Joker_vD 3y agoIt's not an abuse, just as 2000 kilometres (that's 2 megametres!) or 200 grams (that's 2 hectagrams!) or even 20 milligrams (that's 2 centigrams!) are not. One of the points of prefixed units was that a field could find "base" resolution for their measurements such that most of those could be integer multiplies of some chosen unit.
- numpad0 3y agoIt's not clear to me where the mistake is. Almost everything uses Li-ion batteries with nominal voltage of 3.7V, so if it's mAh, 3.7V is assumed. else if Wh, implies raw_terminal_voltage != 3.7. mAh ratings normalized for 3.7V are comparable, and Wh ratings are comparable too. It's also probably not wise to connect mAh rated battery to Wh rated ones(if it ever could be). In electrical design, electrical current(A) matters to trace widths and wire thickness selection; voltage(V) matters, separately, in matching supported voltage ranges, and also insulation for components. Total wattage(W) do not tell either of the story. It will concern me if a single strand of 32AWG wire was supposed to carry 10kA, or two studs 1.27mm apart would be energized to 10kVDC, but same for 10W of power at unknown current or voltage... I won't be so sure. mAh is fine. So long you don't mix different techs. Like standard alkaline, NiMH, and Li-ion, in a same bucket. Which you don't anyway.
- tuetuopay 3y agoyou missed the point. the laptop's battery is not 3.7v but more likely to be in the 20-ish volt region because the cells are in series. the assumption of 3.7v is plain wrong.
- numpad0 3y agoLaptop batteries are Wh marked always, because there are 4, 6, 9 cell options, always in series. Power banks are 99Wh or fractions thereof due to airline safety requirements. If you want to charge a laptop with a 4S 11Wh slim pack using a 20100mAh battery with 20V/3A USB-PD out, that's 4 times worth laptop capacity...? Who cares? Is that why you want everything to be Wh marked?
- wepple 3y agoThe mistake is that many (most?) devices use batteries in series as well as parallel. So as soon as someone builds a 2S battery with nominal 7.4v, mAh is useless as a sole datapoint
- blueflow 3y agoIts a unit of charge and not capacity. You have the full charge voltage, and the cutoff voltage where you assume the battery be drained (min operational voltage for your circuit), and the charge that gets you from the first to the latter is the mAh number. I find it more practical than using plain energy (Wh or Joule).
- jrochkind1 3y agoAnyone know why using the wrong unit without enough info became common in the first place?
- jdietrich 3y agoMarketers like big numbers. A 3500mAh li-ion cell is more betterer than the same 12.6Wh cell, because 3500 is a bigger number than 12.6.
- falcolas 3y agoI'm not an expert, but as a (former) drone enthusiast, it's probably because of C values. C values tell you how quickly a battery can be safely discharged, and it's based on the amperage. Specifically, it's a direct multiplier for the amperage. And for batteries in the before times, the voltage was clearly printed on the battery, as was the mAh and C values.
- kec 3y agoC is a multiple of current but is linear with (nominal) energy, no reason that would force this.
- trashtester 3y agoWhat is the Wh of a "12V" 1000 AH car battery with internal resistance of 20 milli-ohm? Try that for starter engines that draw 50A, 100A or 200A One may think that at 100A, the starter engine will be able to consume 1200W However, if you pull 100A, the internal voltage used to overcome the internal resistance is 2V, so you really only generate 1000W, or 5/6 of the raw energy stored in the battery. At 50A, the voltage loss is only 1V, so the start engine gets 550W, or 11/12 of the energy tapped from the battery. Finally, at 200A, the voltage loss is 4V, meaning that the starter engine only gets 1600W, or 2/3 of the energy stored in the battery. And this is under relatively good conditions. If the battery is freezing cold, the internal resistance can become much higher. In all cases, the internal resistance leads to heat inside the battery. Hopefully, it should be clear that for low resistance / high wattage loads, the Wh metric is not very accurate.
- josu 3y agoExplanation: This is not a good thing - it's an industry mistake. Energy is measured in watt-hours - meaning "a watt for an hour". Watts are (simply put) volts times amps - so, 1 volt at 1 amp is 1 watt; 5 volts at 1 amp is 5 watts; 5 watts for 1 hour is 5 watt-hours. Similarly for amp-hours - 5 amps for 1 hour is 5 Ah (5000mAh). The problem is, with amp-hours, you don't know the voltage - 20 volts, 2 amp-hours (2000mAh) is 40 watt-hours (Wh). This is where the industry mistake exists - companies labeling things to have a certain number of "mAh" instead of Wh gives completely nonsensical values that can only be relatively compared to each other (sometimes). It's a nightmare for people that actually understand energy capacity and speak and think in watt-hours. Take that 40Wh / 2000mAh example. Now, imagine it were 5 volts instead of 20 volts - now the same battery becomes 8000mAh. Woaa, so much bigger?? Must be gooder?? No, it's the same battery, just a different voltage - but because you're only looking at one of the two critical numbers (amps, not volts), you see bigger numbers. Given that phones and devices charge at a variety of different voltages, and battery packs have different cell arrangements (in fact, usually 3.7-3.8 volts per cell - what even is the standard voltage reference they're using?), the mAh value has always been meaningless in any context. Watt-hours, though, are what actually power your devices - laptop batteries hold between 45 and 100 watt-hours, phones between 8 and 15Wh, watches in the <1Wh range, rechargeable mice low 1-2's, power tools in the 60-130Wh (or more) range, and at the very top, EV batteries - which are measured in kWh (kilowatt-hours) - range from 20,000Wh to 150,000Wh. (this is why you never need to worry about charging your phone in your EV... it's like blowing a pinwheel in a hurricane). I hope the industry stops talking mAh soon - it's seriously getting annoying having to dig through spec sheets to find the actual battery capacity somewhere expressed in watt-hours to know what I'm actually looking at. https://old.reddit.com/r/macbookair/comments/w2eqxs/whats_the_battery_capacity_in_mah_of_the_m2_air/jvj0q2y/ https://old.reddit.com/r/macbookair/comments/w2eqxs/whats_th...
- trashtester 3y agoOne problem is that a 18V, 2Ah battery MAY deliver 36Wh if the load has a resistance much higher than the internal resistance of the battery, but may ALSO deliver 18Wh if the load resistance equals the internal battery resistance. For batteries that need to deliver a high current (meaning the resistance of the load is low), Wh can be imprecise. An example could be a car battery that is used primarily to start the engine. Apart from such cases, I agree that one should strive to use Wh as labels instead of Ah.
- eternityforest 3y agoWhy do they like to tell you mAh, but never power consumption in different states? They'd probably have to call it "mAh per hour" to avoid people needing a science lesson to read it, but still. mAh just says "to achieve our battery life we needed this much energy". It's not that much of an interesting spec on it's own, since it would be better to have less energy drain and less mAh, if we could get the same performance, rather than more of both. It's more useful in power banks, or would be, if they weren't often lying.