5 ms·
Toyota CEO: "Our ammonia engine is the end of EV's" [video]
- butppl 3y agoReminds me of Sony trying to rent seek off license fees for popular storage formats like Memory Stick. Toyota is pulling a Canonical who wrote their own desktop. Toyota will flop… again, after hydrogen… trying to win it all.
- cyanydeez 3y agoToyota failed in capturing EV by betting on hydrogen fuel. They still can't admit they missed the boat.
- ClassyJacket 3y agoToyota will do anything except take electric cars seriously. Shame. They were the industry leaders with hybrids.
- johnea 3y agoToyota, along with all other Japanese auto makers, have developed the worlds most long running internal combustion engines. Now, electric is threatening to completely eliminate their market advantage of high longevity cars. So, they'll come up with any excuse not to switch away from complex mechanisms. Since this is their primary advantage in the market. Hybrid, which is still a gas powered vehicle, is even more complex mechanically. Having both an internal combustion AND an electric power train, with a complex mechanical transmission for allowing both to run at once. So while hybrid cars where even more in the Japanese expertise of long lasting mechanisms, electric vehicles are in the exact opposite direction. Etremmely simple mechanically. It is sad. Not only did they lead with hybrids, they also led when the US "big 3" were so entrenched and had allowed their products to become crap, because no one really had a choice. Then Datson, Honda and Toyota brought very small, inexpensive, high reliability vehicles to the US, and were massively successful. It's so ironic that now they want to sell bloated "luxury" vehicles, just likje the US big 3. They've become the pox they originally succeded by countering...
- ChatGTP 3y agoWhat's also kind of stupid is, if they entered the EV market, people would just buy them on their reputation alone. This hope is fading now as the competition takes over, but they absolutely no doubt would be able to build a reliable EV and once that reliable EV was for sale world wide, it would be a huge success just because people love Toyota. I personally think they could've dominated the market on reputation alone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gumby 3y agoI thought they solved their "gearhead" problem by ejecting the last CEO, a Toyoda. The new one seems to be wearing the same blinders. They are doomed if they keep whistling past the graveyard like this.
- holoduke 3y agoI expect Toyota to come with a nuclear powered fuel cell car next year. Drive your car for 50 years without taking external charges. Easy to maintain and very safe.
- 000ooo000 3y ago"The design is very human"
- red-iron-pine 3y agoAI and nuclear cars, plus looming resource wars and beefs with China. moving closer and closer to the world of Fallout
- legohead 3y agoToyota is so weird about their EV stance. What I particularly like about EVs is their low maintenance. You remove many components that are required with ICE. Regenerative braking makes your brake pads last a crazy amount longer. And now with this ammonia engine we are adding even more components to the vehicle? No thanks. Not to even mention the fuel distribution problem.
- isilofi 3y agoYou like "low maintenance". Car companies don't. A significant part of their business is tied to replacement parts and their chains of brand dealerships and brand workshops. With EVs, that whole gravy train might end, or at least loose a lot.
- jki275 3y agoToyota absolutely wants your car to never break. That's their entire business philosophy, and why I drive Toyotas and have for decades.
- red-iron-pine 3y agoBut you pay for that privilege, e.g. the "Toyota Tax"
- jki275 3y agoYou are correct, and I'm happy to pay it!
- nostrademons 3y agoIt destroys a lot of the competitive advantage Toyota has. Toyota is very, very good at making mechanical components to very high precision & quality levels. They've built up this core competency by careful attention to detail over decades. It's one of the main reasons why people buy Toyotas. With EVs, you remove many of the components that are required with ICE. Hence, it doesn't matter how good you are at making those components and sourcing them from suppliers. Hence, a random startup can do nearly as well as Toyota, with their billions in capital invested and decades of experience. It's kind of a shame, though, since I'd love to have something with the reliability of a Toyota that also applies that reliability to the EV powertrain. Maybe one of their ex-employees will start something.
- e44858 3y agoI hope they come with a warning sticker so I can make sure to stay a mile away from them: "Anhydrous ammonia is stored as a liquid under pressure. When released to the environment, though, it becomes a toxic gas. Liquid anhydrous ammonia expands 850 times when released to ambient air and can form large vapor clouds. It may aerosolize and behave as a dense gas, even though it is normally lighter than air. Anhydrous ammonia may also cause water vapor to condense in the air forming a visible white cloud. Therefore, when anhydrous ammonia is released to the air, it may travel along the ground in a cloud instead of immediately rising into the air and dispensing." https://msdh.ms.gov/msdhsite/index.cfm/43,320,230,349,html https://msdh.ms.gov/msdhsite/index.cfm/43,320,230,349,html
- globalreset 3y agoI'm surprised about the negativity in the comments. I'm happy someone is testing alternative approache. If they're wrong, they just wasted a bit of their own capital. If they are right - we might all benefit. You've got to treat technology as means to an end, not a religion that requires conformity.
- jaggs 3y agoIt's actually sad and rather weird at the same time. The Japanese motor industry has been caught completely flat footed in the future car stakes - despite arguably starting ahead of the pack with the Leaf, Prius etc - and now spends its time desperately trying to make various random techs 'sexy' as they scramble to catch up. If they spent half this time making cool EVs, or delivering great battery improvements, they could be back in the game. Instead of letting China dominate more with each passing month. So strange.
- donor20 3y agoToyota had the most real world electric drive train miles, regen braking, battery mgmt etc etc. I thought for sure they’d move Prius to an extender model maybe, phev earlier etc etc. instead it was hydrogen endlessly- the amount they spent on hydrogen has to be huge!
- nucleative 3y ago"A company cannot disrupt itself" - Clayton Christensen Toyota has mastered precision replicable production of internal combustion engines and related components. This has been Toyota's perpetual money tree. I'm sure the reward systems inside Toyota management favor those who improve it and protect it. I'm sure at first they laughed at these pipsqueak EV guys with software backgrounds. Toyota engineers who propose and work on alternative fuels, like ammonia, are probably not laughed out of the room - which is also full of other career internal combustion engineers.
- barrysteve 3y agoI sincerley doubt they are ideologically committed to a specific engine technology. W. Edward Deming helped start the Toyota Way, by introducing high quality manufacturing processes after ww2. I'm sure they laugh at Elon for being unable to produce a high quality and error-free product, with infinite money and all the latest technologies at his fingertips. Toyota's unending crisis will continue, by design.
- jeo123 3y agoWhether Toyota will pivot to EV or not doesnt matter. This is solar all over again. The Chinese EV market absolutely dominates any EV markets in the world. BYD alone would make Tesla look like just Porche vs Toyota. I forsee Tesla will just fizzled out. Their solar already gone. Their cybertruck is a joke. Their sales in China after so many years with advantage of tech and factory still dwarfed by almost every other EVs in China. Now imagine those Chinese EVs are Huawei and let loose.
- slowmovintarget 3y agoSo... A month ago it was also the BMW CEO saying the same thing. Then Ford. Now Toyota? Three months ago, Mercedes was about to "destroy" the entire automotive industry. Nine months ago, Ford was going to "destroy" the EV market with... batteries. Oh wait, those are all video titles from the same YT channel. Next.
- userinanother 3y agoThe common wisdom on HN is that Toyota missed the boat on evs but I don’t think the boat will really set sail for another 7-10 years. Sure there are some evs out there and the market segment is growing but the charger network isn’t there. The charger standard will probably looks like it will finally converge in 2-3 years but good availability of ev chargers across the country will take at least 7 years. So Toyota has time to build and buy more mature tech without burning crazy new tech dollars.
- bdamm 3y agoThere is no "reset" button on gaining market share. In 7-10 years, if Toyota hasn't got some class of EVs locked up, their only option will be to buy one of the other players. The charging standard is converging to the current dominant player who has functioning charging and who's cars road trip just fine - Tesla. If Toyota doesn't get some decent EVs to market soon they will simply be left behind and will turn into a financial and branding husk while everyone else does the real work, eventually vanishing into the dustbin of history as one of GM's sub-brands. They can't magically produce innovative products unless they get into the game. In 7 years it will be game over.
- userinanother 3y agoThey have a ev it’s good enough as a tech demonstration and and R&D platform but Toyota and Tesla are opposite ends of the spectrum. Toyota is like freeBSD it’s tired true and rock solid. Tesla is like some new beta distro it’s got all the bells and whistles but tons of reliability and quality problems. I don’t see Tesla ever overcoming quality problems. Poor quality is built into their culture and you can’t fix culture
- fomine3 3y agoLet's see IR documents rather than random YouTube cut clips
- 0xbadc0de5 3y agoToyota's anti EV stance would be funny if it weren't so tragic. It's practically a meme at this point.
- red-iron-pine 3y agothe real tragedy is the Prius. they had such a head start, and could have created a PriusE or something that would have had a ton of pull. imagine a Hilux or Tacoma truck EV with Toyota reliability added on there. meanwhile TSLA can't do QA to save its life. the EV F-150 is so hot Ford can't keep up with demand.
- KevinMS 3y agoSo clean energy cars will smell like clean restrooms?
- nateAK 3y ago[flagged]
- dexwiz 3y agoSure, its carbon free, but NOx (NO, NO2, N2O etc) are really terrible greeenhouse gases and one of the main causes of smog. Catalytic convertors are there just to address this and try to mitigate the problem since all fuel contains a small amount of nitrogen compounds. Let's hope they don't replace one GHG with another.
- Enginerrrd 3y agoI think it's a closed system, fuel cell, no?
- isilofi 3y agoBetter really hope it is closed. Ammonia is no fun. Imagine the stink and effect of tear gas, plus eating your tissues, plus eating through metals and concrete when splashed. Oh, and if you think "well, i've got some ammonia cleaner somewhere, it isn't too bad". Well, that is the dilute watery kind, anhydrous ammonia is much much worse.
- bdamm 3y agoNo, they are advertising an ammonia-based internal combustion engine.
- KiwiJohnno 3y agoI'm not buying this at all. People freak out about EV battery fires now (never mind that this is not actually the problem it is made out to be), can you imagine the hazmat situation from a couple of cars carrying who knows how many KG of Anhydrous Ammonia crashing into each other? I mean, you might make the fuel tanks extremely robust (and heavy) but fuel lines etc will still break. Ammonia in the air at 300 PPM will cause SEVERE injuries to anybody in the area not wearing a respirator. And how are you supposed to fuel these cars? Have you seen the PPE you have to wear when handling Anhydrous Ammonia?
- 369548684892826 3y ago> People freak out about EV battery fires now (never mind that this is not actually the problem it is made out to be) Looking like quite a problem over in Luton https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-beds-bucks-herts-67073446 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-beds-bucks-herts-67073...
- almost_usual 3y agoNow imagine when a large earthquake hits a place like San Francisco. Most of the damage from the 1906 quake was caused by fire.
- sindriava 3y agoSo what was on fire in 1906? Presumably cars were not nearly as widespread. Has anything relevant changed since then?
- scrlk 3y ago> Within three days, over 30 fires, caused by ruptured gas mains, destroyed approximately 25,000 buildings on 490 city blocks. The fires cost an estimated $350 million at the time (equivalent to $8.08 billion in 2021). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1906_San_Francisco_earthquake#Fires https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1906_San_Francisco_earthquake#...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]