6 ms·
Finnish president says undersea pipeline, cables damaged by 'external activity'
- dist-epoch 3y agoTotally unrelated news from 5 days ago: > Putin: Russia can still supply gas via Nord Stream 2 as one line intact https://www.reuters.com/article/russia-putin-nord-stream-idUSS8N3A2079 https://www.reuters.com/article/russia-putin-nord-stream-idU...
- gerikson 3y agoHow convenient those shadowy saboteurs left that pipeline intact.
- lostlogin 3y agoHas anyone good a decent summary of the likely series of events, ideally from a good source? My understanding of it is very confused and the series of finger pointing exercises has left me baffled at who is likely to blame. I have followed along but it’s not at all clear to me who is to blame.
- dist-epoch 3y agoLong read, TL;DR in the title. https://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/investigating-the-attack-on-nord-stream-all-the-clues-point-toward-kyiv-a-124838c7-992a-4d0e-9894-942d4a665778 https://www.spiegel.de/international/europe/investigating-th...
- misja111 3y agoAccording to European intelligence, most traces lead to Ukraine. See e.g. https://www.tagesschau.de/investigativ/nord-stream-explosion-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/investigativ/nord-stream-explosion... (German)
- jessepasley 3y agoI feel it's down to two suspects: 1. The US said they would do it, then did it 2. Ukraine did it, because most European intelligence agencies believe this to be true.
- mc32 3y ago[flagged]
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> if history is any help we did it again The U.S. blew a pipeline between Estonia and Finland, two NATO members? A pipeline that was going to carry LNG, a product the U.S. is a major exporter of?
- mc32 3y agoI mean, look, this was the same logic hurled at Russia blowing up their pipeline. Like who would do such a thing? But apparently till Hirsch provided corroborating info that NATO did it, people totally believed Russia would shoot themselves in the foot. To the majority it was a "reasonable" explanation. Anyhow, Russia can pump gas through this pipeline as well. Since it would hurt them, we might spite our own face.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> this was the same logic hurled at Russia blowing up their pipeline. Like who would do such a thing? This was some peoples' logic. But it wasn't the compelling evidence. The motivations of individual Russian actors, instead, was germane. (The most compelling evidence points to Kyiv.) > till Hirsch provided corroborating info that NATO did it This is total nonsense. On one hand, we have various nations' official statements and open source intelligence. On the other hand, we have a dude with an anonymous source.
- mc32 3y agoHe's not a random dude. He's a renowned and one of our best investigative reporters who has uncovered government wrongdoing. He's got a pretty good record.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago
- bell-cot 3y agoHmm... You know, just like the Sea of Azov and the Black Sea, the Baltic has some natural pinch-points, with bridges across them, where access to the Atlantic Ocean could easily be restricted... EDIT: Yes, I'm aware of the legal details. For purposes of symbolism, intrusive surveillance (of maritime activity), and saber-rattling, those details hardly matter. I'll even speculate that no respected international judges nor squeaky-clean lawyers signed off on the "external activity" that damaged the undersea pipeline and cables near Finland.
- Xylakant 3y agoBut unlike the Black Sea, there’s no legal contract that gives any of the states the power that Turkey has: Block warships from entering and leaving. Even the Black Sea is open for civilian shipping from and to Russia, including Russian flagged merchant vessels. Now, in time of war, Denmark and Sweden would control the entrance to the Baltic Sea, and Finnland and Estonia could make it hard for the Russian fleet to leave the port of St. Petersburg, but for now neither state is at war with Russia, the international shipping lanes remain open, even for Russian military and spy vessels.
- jcranmer 3y agoThere is no bridge (/set of bridges) that completely cuts off the Baltic Sea--the Øresund is a bridge-tunnel, so the shipping lanes are completely unencumbered by bridges. Although like the Black Sea, there is a corresponding treaty governing the the straits as an international waterway.
- bell-cot 3y ago> ...there is a corresponding treaty governing the straits... So I've heard. I've also heard of a treaty guaranteeing Ukraine's territorial integrity, and signed by Russia.
- Xylakant 3y agoYes, indeed. And Russia violated the Treaty and now there's war in Ukraine. But it upheld the treaty regarding the Dardanelles strait, probably because Turkey is a NATO member and war with the NATO is really not something anyone wants, inlcuding Russia and the NATO. So in the Baltic sea, there's essentially two options: Either respect the treaties and keep the shipping lanes open or violate it and risk war with Russia. Until now, no critical infrastructure was attacked (the nord stream pipelines were out of use when they were blown up), so a less aggressive posturer seemed reasonable. Maybe that'll change now. Apart from that, the Dardanelles are 1.2km wide at the narrow point, the Gulf of Finland is 70km wide - blocking that is essentially impossible unless you go for a naval blockade and attack civilian ships.
- adasdasdas 3y agoWhy does the narrative that Russia blew up its own pipeline exist.
- dist-epoch 3y agoBecause sometimes you sacrifice the queen to win the game.
- nickff 3y agoBecause there are a number of internal actors who would have benefited from doing so. For example, if Putin had felt threatened by someone trying to overthrow him, and negotiate an end to sanctions (and the Ukraine war), it might make sense to sabotage Nordstream and reduce the potential financial benefits from the coup. In short, while it might not make sense for "Russia to blow up its own pipeline", it would make sense for 'certain Russians to blow up a pipeline owned by other Russians'.
- leptons 3y agoThey destroyed their own economy for no good reason, why wouldn't they blow up their own pipeline too? Very little makes sense with regards to Russia's belligerent actions.
- kypro 3y ago"Destroyed" is far too strong. Their economy is doing fine all things considered.
- leptons 3y agohttps://www.google.com/search?q=price+of+ruble https://www.google.com/search?q=price+of+ruble Hit the "Max" tab.
- somenameforme 3y agoAll things considered? Their economy is doing much better than the majority of Europe. [1] Austria = 0.4, Canada = 1.7, France = 0.8, Germany = (-0.3), Sweden (-0.5), Switzerland 0.8, Italy = 1.1, etc. The overall growth rate in Europe is 0.6. Russia is at 1.5%. And Wiki is somewhat outdated. Their 2nd quarter growth has been published, and it's now up to 4.9%. IMO we're currently looking at a major inflection point in history, yet so many have no idea of what's happening. In the USSR there were two major state newspapers, pravda (meaning truth) and novosti (meaning news). A USSR era joke was, "Why do we have two newspapers, truth and news? Well that's because there's no truth in the news, and no news in the truth." [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_real_GDP_growth_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_real_GDP_...
- mschuster91 3y ago[flagged]
- lostlogin 3y agoIs ‘we’ the US? The Ukraine situation needs a lot more than just the US to chip in. The US can win the war in short order - I saw reports of a carrier sent towards Israel within hours of that attack. But Europe needs to sort out its bickering too, then maintain it. It’s a European problem, it hurts Europe and depending on the US is a problematic way of maintaining themselves.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Is ‘we’ the US? The entire Western nations. NATO was founded as a deterrent to Russia, and yet we let Russia run rampant after the fall of the USSR: countless "interventions" that were nothing more but thinly disguised massacres (and drove all Eastern European nations to beg NATO for accession), cyber criminality and cyber warfare, propaganda efforts so immense that they shifted politics in the US, UK and a lot of Continental European countries massively towards the far-right, the 2014 Ukraine invasion, supporting the war criminal Assad in Syria, destabilizing half of Africa to the tune that Europe and Turkey got to deal with millions of refugees, the Ukraine invasion, the destruction of North Stream, dealing weapons with Iran and North Korea... Just how much more are we willing to tolerate? When will we finally respond to all of that in an appropriate manner? (I know, this was a rhetoric question, the answer is: likely never as no one but the US has actually taken care of their military, and the US want to focus on China for good reasons) > The US can win the war in short order - I saw reports of a carrier sent towards Israel within hours of that attack. Yeah, if they're willing to glass Palestine?! Anything that should not devolve into a massacre will involve infantry warfare in just about the most hostile environment since probably Vietnam and take months - the Israelis are preparing for that, and I hope they're successful. The US carrier, I think, is for now purely a signal towards anyone else to stay the f..k out of Israel. > But Europe needs to sort out its bickering too, then maintain it. It’s a European problem, it hurts Europe and depending on the US is a problematic way of maintaining themselves. Agreed (especially given that it's very well possible that the Republicans win in 2024), but that will take time that a lot of the crises in the current polycrisis don't have - and it's not made easier by Hungary and now Slovakia being governed by Kremlin puppets.
- danielovichdk 3y ago[flagged]