3 ms·
From that article: 1.5m users and up to 50% of their code is now being produced by Copilot. Sounds to me like the verdict on its value is in already.
by simonw 3y ago
From that article: 1.5m users and up to 50% of their code is now being produced by Copilot.
Sounds to me like the verdict on its value is in already.
- woolion 3y agoThey don't give any source or anything; the way it's worded sounds ambiguous enough that I suspect it's not that 50% of their code is generated by Copilot. Is there something a bit more convincing elsewhere?
- jamala1 3y agoHaving used Copilot for a year now I very much doubt this figure. In my experience it only works well in boilerplate kind of situations where most code is copy/paste work anyhow. As soon as the code gets a little complicated it stops working well. It has also gotten quite slow for me lately. So I doubt it increases my work efficiency by more than 5%, but I do like it for reducing strain on the hands. For that I find the price appropriate.
- ptero 3y ago> In my experience it only works well in boilerplate kind of situations where most code is copy/paste work anyhow. As a data point, this matches my personal observations. But reducing the time spent on that bolierplate plus not needing to search where the "copy" portion comes from, may justify $30/month (and probably much more than that). My 2c.
- smoe 3y agoThe quote from the article says "more than 1.5 million people have used it and it is helping build nearly half of Copilot users’ code" Not a native speaker, but to me this sounds much more ambiguous than up to 50% of code is produced by Copilot. Also, how different from previous solutions is this actually? I use autocomplete and code snippets extensively. Never measured it , but I wouldn't be surprised if my IDE had generated more source code than I myself typed over the last 10 or so years.
- marcosdumay 3y agoIt doesn't sound ambiguous to me. It says that those people have Copilot enabled while they write more than half of their code. AKA it's on the editor they use for most things. It doesn't say anything about its value.
- jazzyjackson 3y agohalf of co-pilot users' code, not half of all users' code.
- norir 3y agoI mean you could have made a similar argument about the productivity benefits of smoking cigarettes 100 years ago. Just because a lot of people are doing something doesn't mean it's valuable or that we have an accurate picture of the cost/benefits. The verdict is still very much out on LLMs.
- bhouston 3y ago> The verdict is still very much out on LLMs. Any new product that gained +1M paying subscribers (Github Copilot) in its first year is a success. You cannot like it, that is allowed. And it may not help you, but +1M subscribers is a lot of people. They are definitely here to stay until they are superseded by even better technology or it gets sued into oblivion.