4 ms·
> It would be nice if anyone explained what those risks are, and why they don't apply to Facebook et al. First of all, any company operating out of China can b
by mschuster91 3y ago
> It would be nice if anyone explained what those risks are, and why they don't apply to Facebook et al.
First of all, any company operating out of China can be assumed to be under more or less direct control of the CCP. When the Party comes knocking, there is no non-compliance to whatever they want. That alone is more than enough reason to be more skeptical of anything China. (Yes, I'm aware of FISA, but that's nowhere near comparable to having Party members on your board)
The second difference/risk comes with looking whom these apps target: kids. Basically, whoever controls the algorithm that ranks what content kids watch, has a very effective way of mind control... kids are sponges, they soak up whatever they see, and especially compared to the old radio/TV era, a lot of what's available on the Internet is pretty dangerous and not vetted by anyone. Be it all kinds of dangerous "challenges", Incel/Gamergate/far-right propaganda, hate against LGBT or whatever - it's all completely intransparent. That's bad enough if done by Western companies for profit reasons, but even worse as a capability in the hands of an enemy nation.
- coldpie 3y agoIf we agree that that's bad, why do we allow Facebook to do it? Why not craft a ban on the bad behavior, which would then necessarily also preclude Tiktok from doing it?
- kibwen 3y agoSure, let's do it. I haven't seen anyone defending Facebook's own shitty behavior here. If you mean why don't politicians do it, the answer is corruption (lobbying).
- gardenhedge 3y agoBecause the US government has more authority over Facebook than it does for a Chinese tech company.
- coldpie 3y agoI don't understand how. If Facebook or Tiktok('s US branch) violates some law against whatever bad behavior, we can punish them or shut them down. If we don't have such a law, then by definition we have no control over it. What is the difference?
- ejlxsh 3y agoIf you ban Facebook because the US government has too much of a reach, then you’re asking the party in control to block themselves
- gardenhedge 3y agoI don't understand the confusion. Tiktok is under Chinese control and Facebook is under USA control.
- ramblenode 3y agoWhat law does Facebook's product have to comply with that TikTok's product doesn't?
- carapace 3y ago> why do we allow Facebook to do it? We shouldn't. They are starting to make AI personas to interact with teenagers. https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/meta-ai-chatbot-younger-users-dab6cb32 https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/meta-ai-chatbot-younger-users-da... This should almost certainly be banned. I'm not sure on what legal grounds but I am sure this is bad.
- joenot443 3y agoThe very, very straightforward answer is that Facebook is accountable to the US govt in ways that TikTok is not. It's entirely reasonable for the US to legislate accordingly.
- Spivak 3y ago> Facebook is accountable to the US govt in ways that TikTok Why wouldn't it be? TikTok is now a US company with the data of US citizens stored in Austin TX. https://usds.tiktok.com/usds-about https://usds.tiktok.com/usds-about https://usds.tiktok.com/usds-myths-vs-facts https://usds.tiktok.com/usds-myths-vs-facts This is actually insane, the level of paranoia surrounding ByteDance has forced TikTok to jump through a billion hoops that no other foreign company has to and weirder still they did. Like my HIPAA is less protected than this. > Myth: Under its 2017 National Intelligence law, the Chinese government can compel ByteDance to share American TikTok user data. > Fact: TikTok Inc., which offers the TikTok app in the United States, is incorporated in California and Delaware, and is subject to U.S. laws and regulations governing privacy and data security. Under Project Texas, all protected U.S. data will be stored exclusively in the U.S. and under the control of the U.S.-led security team. This eliminates the concern that some have shared that TikTok US user data could be subject to Chinese law.
- intrasight 3y ago> TikTok is now a US company Not sure if I would agree. A friend works there and he's the only English speaking and Caucasian.
- osti 3y agoBy this logic, Amazon would be an Indian company, Google and Meta also have many teams composed of mainly Chinese so they would be Chinese companies as well.
- Mountain_Skies 3y ago@intrasight, my first job out of college in 2000 was for a small dot com owned entirely by a Jewish family in Texas. I was the only non Mandarin speaking software developer in the company. It's not all that uncommon in the tech industry regardless of ownership.
- Hizonner 3y ago> The second difference/risk comes with looking whom these apps target: kids. [...] kids are sponges So far as I can tell, the people most vulnerable to Internet propaganda, manipulation, and general bullshit, aren't kids. They're old people. And maybe younger people who've been raised in bubbles that were a bit overprotective. TikTok users are mostly teenagers, not little children. By the time you hit your teens, whatever anti-manipulation systems humans have seem to have largely kicked in. That's what you'd expect, really, since that's always been about when you had to start playing the manipulation and anti-manipulation game in real life. Another part of youthful plasticity seems to be an ability to adapt your defenses to the particular threats you're seeing. When I was a kid, seeing something in 4 or 5 apparently "independent" written sources was pretty good evidence that it was true, or at least widely believed. My own kid seems to have a pretty good intuitive knowledge that she can't just trust those sources' independence, or their credentials, or their judgement.
- zknow 3y agoI'm not sure if the concern is really blatant disinformation ( which as you point out is easier to smell test ) or if its really more of the thought that the Chinese have a cambridge analytica level style access to American social data. Sure teenagers can parse bias in the media they are consuming, but is it that effective when the media company can tailor content based on the user's preferences + the preferred political manipulation? Not saying you should ban it, just a thought.
- usernomdeguerre 3y agoBeing able to effectively 'tailor' anything to their users pretty much proves they have that (or generate it within their app).
- AlexandrB 3y ago> cambridge analytica level style access to American social data. Have you read/seen any of the follow up[1] on the CA scandal? Basically CA couldn't do most of the things they promised they could do with the data they collected. Their supposed ability to manipulate the public was effectively a "fake it till you make it" startup pitch. I find it funny that it keeps getting brought up as a worst case scenario when it seems like it was a nothingburger. [1] https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-213-rewriting-cambridge-analytica-p1-feat-anthony/id1428209307?i=1000591147501 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-213-rewriting-...
- tinus_hn 3y agoCensorship as the answer to unwanted opinions. Along with the old adage ‘But think about the children!’
- snarf21 3y agoIt is far easier for the government to pressure and control (and spy on?) FB than it is for a CCP company. We don't no one spying on our citizens but us!!!!
- standardUser 3y ago> First of all, any company operating out of China can be assumed to be under more or less direct control of the CCP. Statements like that really make me question people's knowledge of basic history and international politics. Yes, a nation's major commercial actors often work in conjecture with their government. Is this news to anyone? This is not unique to China in the least. > The second difference/risk comes with looking whom these apps target: kids. And this argument is so tired that it even has its own Wikipedia page explaining that it is a logical fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children
- usernomdeguerre 3y agoif he had directed it as "Think of the adults" would you feel differently? It seems silly to say that propaganda/news/information has no influence on people when we demonstrate that it does every single day of our lives.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Statements like that really make me question people's knowledge of basic history and international politics. Yes, a nation's major commercial actors often work in conjecture with their government There's a difference between cooperating with the government - my country, Germany, is infamous for the close webs between government and its car companies - but there is no chain of command (other than a partial stake that Lower Saxony holds in VW) between the industry and politics. If anything, it's the other way around, companies pay a shitload in "party donations" to have the government represent its interest in the EU and abroad. > And this argument is so tired that it even has its own Wikipedia page explaining that it is a logical fallacy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children A lot of TOTC is bullshit and usually pulled for the ulterior motive of (effectively) banning stuff for adults by imposing obscene obstacles (such as the planned EU chat control, or British anti-porn legislation). But here, it's aimed squarely at adolescents who use Tiktok as their most popular news source [1] - no matter what, that IS dangerous. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jul/20/tiktok-is-the-most-popular-news-source-for-12-to-15-year-olds-says-ofcom https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2023/jul/20/tiktok-is...
- hammock 3y agoYou still didn't explain the risks too clearly. Let's grant that TikTok is under direct CCP control, and specifically targets kids. Targets them for what? Mind control?
- beachy 3y ago> Targets them for what? Mind control? Attempts to change/form their views to be favourable towards dictatorships and antagonistic to democracies.
- Clubber 3y agoIt's a good thing the US has a strong, incorruptible democracy and fair criminal justice system to counterbalance that propaganda! /s
- hammock 3y agoIs that/should that be illegal?
- jkubicek 3y agoIn the same way Shell targets[1] the youth and attempts to change/form their views to be favorable to fossil fuels. I still don't understand how TikTok is doing anything worse than what any other popular American-based social platform is already doing today. If we're going to legislate TikTok, we should also target Facebook, Fortnite, Twitter, etc. equally. 1: https://www.techspot.com/news/100426-shell-using-fortnite-social-media-promote-fossil-fuels.html https://www.techspot.com/news/100426-shell-using-fortnite-so...
- mschuster91 3y agoFor what it's worth, yes we should, it's time to show Big Capital that yes, they can't run rampant and fuck up our society. But at least we can, in contrast to TikTok whose operations run outside of our reach.
- 3y ago
- throwthrow1010 3y agoI find you to be a dangerous degenerate who should be banned from the internet and any form of communication. I do mean this, it's not a hyperbole. What now?