4 ms·
Born poor, stay poor: what my $120k student debt says about class in the US
- catlover76 3y agoI am highly sympathetic to the problem, but if not being poor is a priority goal for a person, then being a writer/teacher is not an optimal career path. Hopefully this person's book makes a good amount of money.
- vondur 3y agoDepending on the state, being a Teacher is a good job. However, she probably should have attended a state university to save money.
- imajoredinecon 3y agoI just don’t feel sympathetic for someone buying something really expensive and then complaining that it cost a lot of money.
- FrankoDelMar 3y agoYep, yet I constantly have to be told by others that despite my deciding against more expensive schools and deciding to study computer science in lieu of a pet passion in art knowing full well that my immigrant parents wouldn’t support me, my outcome is due largely more to luck rather than to hard work and risk aversion.
- readthenotes1 3y agoYou were lucky to have enough sense to make good decisions:) I'm only semi-joking. I'm pretty sure good judgement can't be taught, though it can be learned, based on looking at siblings who make radically different life choices .
- beej71 3y agoWe should add "teacher" to the list of careers not to pursue in school. That should end well.
- SenAnder 3y ago> I imagine it’s disorienting to hear the voice of your exploiter come out of your child’s mouth. They said I had lost my common sense, and they were right. I had entered into an imaginative place inconceivable to them, one where I dreamed of better things for them, and for me. Despite all the talk about how her family chided her for "losing common sense", there's no single, specific example, of what exactly they objected to. There are allusions to it, like how (expecting?) a reprimand from your employer for taking sick leave is common sense, or how "dreaming of better things" isn't common sense, but those come from the author, not her family. Maybe you think it's unfair to expect such specificity from an opinion article/book promotion, but as a result, I have no idea what her conversations with her family were like. Was it really "Wouldn't it be nice if you didn't get fired for missing work when sick/things were better?" "Hush child, you're talking nonsense. All that book learnin' got your head all confused." I can't imagine it was, but those are the only hints the author gives.
- hindsightbias 3y agoShe implies it was all that liberal education used by their capaitalist overlords to oppress them. Perhaps she should have majored in Marxist studies.
- FrankoDelMar 3y agoThat way, not having money would then be considered a virtue! Problem solved.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoThis is the typical politically oriented piece form The Guardian and as such it is indeed 'liberal' with facts. Apparently, "At the median, graduates with a bachelor’s degree earn $2.8 million over the course of their careers, according to the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce, compared to $1.6 million for high school graduates" [1] So a student loan seems like a bargain if the median return over a career is $1.2 million or 75% more income. [1] https://www.forbes.com/advisor/student-loans/average-salary-college-graduates/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/student-loans/average-salary-...
- readthenotes1 3y agoBetcha the average return isn't there for teachers and writers.
- 0xfaded 3y agoBrushing over individual experience with aggregate statistics. How utilitarian. Much of the article is about the author's experience of being lifted out of her family's social level, only to find herself not belonging to any class. Her family mocks her, and the saddled debt makes it harder to keep up with her debt free peers. Also, before cherry picking convenient statistics, it's important to control for other correlation, such as income compared to parents income, and college attendance compared to parents income. Here are some more liberal facts: https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2021/05/18/first-generation-college-graduates-lag-behind-their-peers-on-key-economic-outcomes/ https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2021/05/18/first-g... Given that median income of first generation college graduates is 27% lower than their peers, I think it is indeed likely that there is greater issue here. To plug the numbers into your above math, we're now looking at $2.05m vs $1.60m. Not bad, but frankly in real terms over 40 years they'd probably be better off putting the $120k against the s&p500. Which is probably what the author's debt free peers will be doing. I still think for this individual college was likely the right choice and will lead to a fulfilling life. I also still think loading up teenagers with $120k of debt is utter bullshit.
- mytailorisrich 3y ago
- nonameiguess 3y agoIt's just one person's story, and it's sort of the curse of a person who writes a memoir in their early 30s to lack perspective. This story isn't super dissimilar from mine. I was the first person in my family to ever go to college, on either side. My parents were stable at least, poor when I was a small child, but at least middle class by the time I was an adult, just still not enough to provide any meaningful level of support. Further generations back were doing almost exclusively low paid domestic labor or farm work. I was an exceptional smart kid who stood out from my family. I spent most of my free time in the library, got a perfect SAT score in 6th grade, won a television quiz show when I was still a kid. No idea where it came from. My dad is street smart but failed out of every level of school. My mom is the kind of person who thinks flouride is bad for you and believes in crystal healing. But I had a serious break down my first year of college (going to which was also my first time ever on a plane), so Ivy League was out of the question. Nobody was going to take me after what happened, no matter how smart I was. I spent a few years at LA City College before going to a Cal state, but was so directionless, I went to grad school just because I didn't know what else to do. At one point, I'm sure I had 120k in student debt. And it didn't quickly get a ton better in my 30s, even though career started to go reasonably well and I was no longer poor. I had serious spine problems and could only inconsistently work for a few years. I couldn't even dress myself for a few years. But where you stand at 32 is not the story of your entire life. I am no longer in any debt and am by far the most prosperous person in my family. Maybe somewhat ironically, I also wanted to be a writer for most of my 20s, but I not only never achieved any level of success, I never even really tried. I finished one novel, but didn't believe in it enough to even try sending it to a publisher. But I guess maybe that was a blessing in disguise if this is the life of a best-selling author. My best friend from college ended up winning an Emmy at one point, but is still poor, has never married, struggles with continuing mental illness. If there is a lesson here, I'm not sure it's don't go to college or don't go into debt or the poor always stay poor. It's that creative careers are a fool's bet almost no one wins even when they win.
- znpy 3y agoI think the main issue this person is having is with their own expectations. Things do get better, but it doesn’t always take just one generation.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Simulacra 3y agoI graduated from a state school 10 years ago with $11,000 of debt. I worked two jobs, took 15 hours every semester, and paid that loan off in 8 years.. everyone has a different struggle, but it still boggles me how someone could have so much debt from education. Maybe there should be a cap on how much you can borrow.
- readthenotes1 3y agoMaybe the cap should be close to zero since the advent of loans and grants to college students was fairly swiftly followed by an incredible increase in the price of a secondary education in the United States. And some other countries, the secondary education is free, but there is a test. My understanding of politics in the United States is that would never fly.
- Simulacra 3y agoVery good point. The size of University bureaucracy has exploded. Someone suggested that when students don't pay back their loans, the universities should be on the hook. This could work but it might make higher education out of reach but for only the best, or limit majors to only those with "viable" career earnings. Whatever that would mean..
- nathan_compton 3y agoWhere I grew up any student who could maintain a 3.5 or higher could go to a state school for free, no loans. I even got a stipend. So in some places it might work. [EDIT: to clarify, I grew up in the United States and in a not particularly progressive state.]
- readthenotes1 3y agoIf it were general policy, the minimum gpa these days would be 3.5 because anything different would go against the misguided "all students college-bound" dogma.
- 3y ago
- dartharva 3y agoAuthor's experiences aside, the American government looks like it really went through some absurd mental gymnastics when designing their college financial support policies. They intervened in precisely the manner they should not have intervened and got everything wrong, it's almost remarkable. How did any policymaker with common sense not point out that playing the loan game would only end up in disaster? That it's downright moronic to forbid college loans from being eligible for bankruptcy and give every bank essentially a free pass to hand out as many bad loans as possible, and the colleges a free pass to charge as ridiculously as possible? They could have done a hundred other things to make higher education affordable without landing in this mess - scholarships, price ceilings, subsidies... What the hell happened?
- catlover76 3y agoLawmakers are elected on the basis not of wisdom or skill, but because they win elections. Once in office, lawmakers have to worry about getting reelected. They aren't subject to an incentive structure that would encourage them to think long-term, etc.
- dartharva 3y agoEven so, this is so ominous anyone would be excused to suspect something more nefarious than sheer incompetence. Whether or not the lawmakers made it with vested interests, there should still have been someone to point it out! If the democratic setup of the most powerful country in the world can allow such degrees of stupidity it is quite concerning.
- catlover76 3y ago> If the democratic setup of the most powerful country in the world can allow such degrees of stupidity it is quite concerning. Well, it's a democratic setup, so its competence is unfortunately proportional to that of its voting public... edit: to be clear, my two comments in this subthread should not be construed to be the typical cynical "politicians are dumb and corrupt" opinion; many of them are smart and well-meaning, but the overall system is not conducive to allowing or encouraging anyone to do anything useful.
- wdb 3y agoIt's not clear to me after reading the article if she borrowed $120k or that it somehow due to interest and other things ended up being $120k.
- tzs 3y agoHere's a site where you can look up average debt at graduation by school [1], and what percent of students borrow. [1] https://www.collegetransitions.com/dataverse/average-student-debt https://www.collegetransitions.com/dataverse/average-student...
- dekhn 3y agoThe obsession with Ivy League is unhealthy. Combining that obsession with an unrealistic career path is doubly so.
- taylodl 3y agoWhat nobody talks about is there is a process for social class advancement. Getting $120K in debt right out of the gate is not part of that process. Poor folks have to utilize community colleges and state colleges and even then, they may have to attend part-time. That's what I did. It's not glamorous and it's not the "all-American" college experience complete with extensive networking - but it will advance you to the next social class. Instill those values and "hacks" into your children and they'll be able to advance further. What you can't do is play the game as though you were already in the social class you're aspiring to. There's one set of well-known rules for them, another set of lesser-known rules for you.