3 ms·
Pretend they didn't make up their own title. Pretend it was a direct quote. Does that help at all? And this link was not going to be submitted otherwise, so
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Pretend they didn't make up their own title. Pretend it was a direct quote. Does that help at all?
And this link was not going to be submitted otherwise, so focusing on that part didn't steal the spotlight from anyone else.
I really don't agree that the guideline was written to make certain kinds of post impossible. I think it was written to avoid people stealing the spotlight, and it's a little bit too broad for that goal.
> We could have had an informative post that provided the relevant news, the supporting context, and even the 2022 presentation about why the standard exists at all.
Cool. But you shouldn't have to do that. It would be interesting if every post had to be an informative user-written blog post, but as argued earlier HN is not that site.
- altairprime 3y agoYou need to take your arguments to the site operators, not to me. Email them your view, highlight this thread, and ask them to reconsider. They may or may not agree, it might take a few days, but at least you’ll get a reply. Or don’t: HN users and mods will continue flagging and reverting editorial title edits by whatever definition the mods are currently using that is unacceptable to you, and nothing will change. Personally, I’d take the chance of persuading them by sending an email, over the certainty of having my opinion disregarded by not sending an email at all. Up to you, though.