2 ms·
Yeah I think the point about monorepos vs submodules is probably the biggest non-usability issue with Git. In a very large project you can have a monorepo, and
by IshKebab 3y ago
Yeah I think the point about monorepos vs submodules is probably the biggest non-usability issue with Git.
In a very large project you can have a monorepo, and then everything is slow and you can't easily use and work on a subset of the code.
Or you can use submodules and then testing, refactoring and making commits all become a nightmare.
Binary files is another crap area of Git. LFS is useless. Lots of people have Stockholm syndrome and think that Git doesn't support large/binary files well because it's immoral rather than just because it's not something Linus ever needed.
I'm still a bit sad that most of the attempts at replacing Git focus on the poor conflict resolution story (which is poor but tolerable) rather than these more fundamental issues.
- gavinhoward 3y ago> Yeah I think the point about monorepos vs submodules is probably the biggest non-usability issue with Git. As a lone developer, I admit that this is what surprises me the most about the experience of other people. But I'm going to solve it. Partial checkouts, fully-transactional cross-submodule commits, the works. Really, these problems are easy with a good design. It's unfortunate that Linus didn't have time for design. > Binary files is another crap area of Git. LFS is useless. Lots of people have Stockholm syndrome and think that Git doesn't support large/binary files well because it's immoral rather than just because it's not something Linus ever needed. Yeah, I don't get this either. I am implementing a general plugin system for creating format-aware operations. This will include source code and binary files. > I'm still a bit sad that most of the attempts at replacing Git focus on the poor conflict resolution story (which is poor but tolerable) rather than these more fundamental issues. I fully agree. I'm going to the doing UX studies, and that's my first priority. I am going to handle conflict resolution better, though.