3 ms·
Imho we should move AI out of the realm of CS, very quickly. The information overload is getting too much. As an analogy, it would be strange if psychology was
by amelius 3y ago
Imho we should move AI out of the realm of CS, very quickly. The information overload is getting too much.
As an analogy, it would be strange if psychology was a part of physics.
Physicists would (I think) not be amused if their work literature became flooded with papers about the human psyche. Even if the underlying "hardware" is physics.
- actionfromafar 3y agoOn the other extreme, what distinguishes CS from math?
- phkahler 3y ago>> On the other extreme, what distinguishes CS from math? Doesn't that support the argument even more? CS and math share a lot more then CS and AI, yet CS and math are different disciplines.
- ethbr1 3y ago> what distinguishes CS from math? The art of application
- orra 3y agoNo? Applied maths is maths, so applying maths does not stop maths from being maths. Of course, computing is closer to pure math than applied maths. Computing is applied pure maths, perhaps.
- ethbr1 3y agoThe "computing" that's closer to pure math is algorithmic theory, cryptography, and computational engineering, which is an extremely small subset of the field. The majority of what computer science practitioners do is general purpose coding, which doesn't have nearly as much to do with the underlying math. Or, in other words, how proficient would an applied math person be at building a front end? And how many of their skills would they be able to leverage? That's the overlap, or lack thereof.
- orra 3y agoWe were specifically talking about comp sci, not software engineering [sic]. Yes, software engineering is way less rigorous. It is hardly is maths—or comp sci for that matter.
- superlopuh 3y agoTime
- uoaei 3y agoAI is not CS. AI implementation is CS but AI theory is firmly in the field of statistics. The newcomers with their strong opinions seem to have become confused because programmers hit APIs and think they're doing "AI". Software architecture and neural network architecture are not synonyms.
- ethbr1 3y agoI'm hopeful AI will end up being probability/statistic's "CS", in the same way that CS relates to its mathematics. IOW, an intellectually-linked discipline that drives so much revenue (and thus has so much work to be done in it) that it comprises its own field (about 75% of which is unique "applications-of-thing" problems).
- uoaei 3y agoSoftware engineering is already CS's "CS". CS is a field of study, not a role. There may be something like "AI engineering" but I can't see a way it would be much different from existing ML engineer roles. And if you do ML engineer minus specialized statistics knowledge you're just back to plain old software engineering. I don't know that this particular aspect of the "AI revolution" needs some disruptive paradigm shift.
- ethbr1 3y agoPo-tato potat-o, re: CS vs SE and role vs field. I'm hesitant to appropriate "engineer" into what we do. There are certainly people who work with code who earn that title. There are also many who don't. I do think it would be healthy for people who work with ML to separate more decisively from people who work with general purpose code. There are enough unique problems and solutions in ML that a clear community would better serve the field's maturation. As opposed to getting an endless summer of "Why don't you just" software developers fouling things up, because it's "similar".
- fragmede 3y agoAs a nascent field, "why don't you just" ends up with new, useful, applicable techniques, along with many that aren't. We don't know which is which until after the fact.
- nexuist 3y agoIf we end up developing AGI, computer science itself will become useless since all economic progress will be driven by businesses using their own AGI to develop software. It won't matter in the same way nobody designs microchips by hand anymore.