11 ms·
Indoor wood burning raises women’s lung cancer risk by 43%
- gjsman-1000 3y agoHave they examined if it is the wood itself; or the (possible - no idea if true) accumulations of microplastics and other chemicals into the wood? I would not be terribly shocked if we found out that wood is more dangerous to burn today than it used to be. Edit: For the downvoters who think it’s unlikely, consider that microplastic and PFAS in rainwater has passed safe levels. What do trees grow from? https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a40859859/rainwater-not-safe-to-drink/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/science/a40859859/rainwater...
- zorrotorro 3y agoLegit interesting question.
- bbor 3y agoDefinitely possible IMO! Seems like it would be surprising tho - consider the disparities in volume. I think the boring answer is that breathing smoke is dangerous, despite the occult and ambience benefits of a hearth ;( it forms minute bits of plastic that are tinier than 5 millimeters long. Their size means they end up everywhere, even in our blood, where they range in size between 700 nanometers and 5,000 nanometers.
- zdragnar 3y agoWood is already known to be cancer causing (via inhaled sawdust). Smoke is not going to be any better, and the quantity of microplastics trees available won't really move the needle on that.
- gjsman-1000 3y agoCan you give me some studies on that, assuming that the sawdust is from straight wood and not any form of wood beam which contains glues and treatments?
- mrangle 3y agoLook up any of the mountain of studies that connects air particulate, in general, to cancer. If you want to argue variables for air particulate's relationship to lung cancer, then more power to you.
- zdragnar 3y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8266936/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8266936/ Money quote from the abstract: "The strongest association of exposure to wood dust and development of nasal cancer is observed in those occupations where workers are exposed to hard wood dust and chemical additives are not used." Note that the strongest association is when chemicals are NOT used - I suspect this might be more due to how people work the wood (less likely to sand particles board, more likely to wear protective gear) than the nature of the chemicals themselves. It does go on to say that various respiratory cancers are from both untreated and treated wood sawdust, but wood alone is well known to cause cancer.
- belval 3y ago[flagged]
- 2devnull 3y agoSo if I’m reading this right, for never smokers who lived in a house that used a woodstove between 1-29 days of the year have the same risk as smokers who used one everyday if the year?
- gjsman-1000 3y ago1-29 days is… vague. However, the study also does not seem to consider the much, much tighter particulate emission rules that new wood stoves and similar have had to follow. The EPA has tightened it every few years (I think the last one was 2015?) An old wood stove is almost nothing (and I literally mean almost nothing) to a modern wood stove in efficiency or air cleanliness. It would almost be like if you did a study about the toxicity of cars but used data from when we had leaded gas. There’s still a toxicity there but your results are going to be a mess.
- happytiger 3y agoIt’s a study in correlation, presuming causation. Research on whether dual burning stoves that reprocess their own exhaust and don’t leak like old ones (the ones you’re referring to) or other systems could be done, but this is baseline research. You can use the same logic to attack the choice of fuels, or species of wood, or types of seals and whether air is taken from the inside or the outside of the structure, and all of it would also be as valid as your argument. You could also try to invalidate this for only focusing on women. But, while valid arguments (as is yours), it sidesteps the purpose of the study. It’s simply not the hypothesis of this particular study, which was simply establish a correlation between the presence & use of wood burning fuel in fire burning devices and lung cancer incidence in women. Don’t throw out the bathwater with the babe.
- fzeroracer 3y agoIt's still an important investigation because unfortunately things are never idiot proof. For example, my parents have a pellet stove and it was not uncommon for it to occasionally leak, followed by my parents putting in a shoddy self-made fix. These kind of studies could indicate some flaw in the way we're creating wood stoves, or some consumer-related failure that needs to be better worked around. Or it could be that consumers are just using older wood stoves. But you gotta start with a baseline.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nwellinghoff 3y agoI don’t get it. I thought with a properly functioning stove all the smoke goes outside not into the room. Same thing with a fireplace.
- xattt 3y agoLighting the fireplace causes some smoke to drift into the room, before the fire is hot/large enough to cause a strong draft. There are also some times when the wood is a dud and takes a long time to start.
- aaomidi 3y agoSpecifically until the chimney is hot enough. You can speed up the process though by using a fresh air intake for the stove rather than it using the air in the house.
- andtong 3y agoPerhaps some of the smoke leaks out of the stove into the room. Maybe a rocket mass heater[1] could help. It uses a thermal siphon to pull all the exhaust outside. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_mass_heater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket_mass_heater
- nwellinghoff 3y agoI mean wouldn’t you see it? I use my fireplace all the time in the winter and I would classify the amount of smoke that gets into the room as “negligible”. Especially compared to smoking a cigarette.Would love if this study actually followed up with some measurements and the “why” of actual fireplaces and stove setups.
- mrangle 3y agoYou can measure. Buy an AQI meter. But I recommend buying an air filter with an AQI meter attached, as when you see what the supposedly negligible amount of smoke is actually doing to your air quality you are going to want the former.
- zemvpferreira 3y agoGreat prospective study. If I'm reading correctly, using a wood-fired stove/fireplace for around a month per year for 10 years or more will increase your chance of lung cancer by ~70%. To put that in perspective, smoking regularly in the same time-span increases your chance of lung cancer by over 20x.
- sampo 3y ago> smoking regularly in the same time-span increases your chance of lung cancer by over 20x. But what if you were to smoke only for the same amount as you mention using the fireplace, around a month per year?
- zemvpferreira 3y agoYou'll have trouble finding many people to study. From the evidence I've seen, intensity of smoke exposure is much more problematic than volume. Light smokers still have 5-10x the chance of developing lung cancer than a non-smoker. That might be a good first estimate for smokers who only smoke one month out of the year.
- cannonpalms 3y agoYou're conflating correlation with causation. Adding only a single factor under study (use of wood-burning fireplaces) will not necessarily produce the measured result; it could have been the result of a confluence of factors correlated with use of wood-burning stoves that you personally may lack.
- jncfhnb 3y agoSmoke is a highly likely casual factor. You don’t really win any points for saying IT COULD BE CORRELATION. This one seems like an extremely safe bet. It’s not even a huge effect size.
- zemvpferreira 3y agoYou've clearly not read the study at all or live in a world where only perfect double-blind studies are acceptable. I wish we could all live there but sometimes you have to make-do with reality.
- 2devnull 3y agoSo merely owning a stove but never burning wood gets you to HR 1.42. That makes the 1.6 for occasional use less bothersome (ymmv).
- mrangle 3y agoBuy an air filter with an AQI meter. Not only will you never use your wood stove again, you may end up cutting down on your pancake Saturdays.
- stephen_g 3y agoI still feel like there must be a difference in particulate matter from things like combustion products (which we know are very bad) and those from cooking - as long as nothing is getting hot enough to char and smoke… Still a good idea to have a good exhaust fan in your range hood (and pick induction over gas if possible) but still…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kibwen 3y ago> and those from cooking I presume the parent commenter is referring to cooking using a gas stovetop, rather than to any particulate emitted by the food itself.
- mrits 3y agoA good vent hood does wonders here
- nkurz 3y agoPresuming you've actually done this test, I think it must depend on your woodstove and how it is installed. We heat almost exclusively with wood, and have a modern EPA compliant wood stove connected to a continuous stainless steel liner that runs to the top of the chimney. We got an AQI meter based on comments on like this. The AQI meter showed that there was no perceptible difference in air quality with the wood stove on versus off. Startup shows some smoke that decreases in an hour, but continuous operation shows no effect. Since we are in a cold climate, we burn essentially 24-7 for the entire winter, and thus startup effects can mostly be ignored. You are right that there was a tremendous decrease in air quality when cooking, especially anything that was fried. So I agree that you might cut down on pancakes, but my evidence does not back your assertion you will "never use a woodstove again". To the contrary, using the meter tremendously reduced my worries about indoor air quality due to using the woodstove. Did you actually do this test and find different results? What sort of system were you testing?
- hmottestad 3y agoIn Norway it’s very normal to have a stove and burn wood pretty much every day in the winter season. Open fireplaces are rather uncommon though, essentially because they produce a lot of smoke and very little heat. I hope they do a follow up study that separates fireplace and stove.
- sneak 3y agoWoodsmoke re-enters buildings within a 500-1000 meter radius of the fire. Burning wood is a very bad idea. It smells nice and we like it, but it is positively terrible for our health and should not be done. Traditions, however, are strong.
- amdolan 3y agoProperly operating a wood burning stove will release very little smoke. This is where the center stone is in the range of approx 300-600F (100-300C). The chimney will produce clear heat and there is no detectable smell when standing outside. Much different result than a fireplace. It’s referred to as double combustion, or secondary combustion.
- simonsarris 3y ago> it is positively terrible for our health Norway is top 10 in the world for life expectancy. Compared to all other possible ills, it suggests the danger here is a tad histrionic.
- 3y ago
- hirundo 3y agoI run a wood stove all winter long and some years never turn on the central heat. I wonder how much of the extra risk is offset by * lower fire risk from burning the fuel surrounding my house for the last few years. * more exercise from cutting, splitting and hauling wood * an air purifier running next to the wood stove all winter * about ~$1,200 per year saved on fuel * more open windows during the day during the winter due to cheaper fuel costs. That might not fully compensate for the extra lung cancer risk but it might be significant. Also since heat is cheaper this way, I heat my house more and am more comfortable all winter. This doesn't seem like it would offset the health risks, but it is a hedonic compensation.
- natdempk 3y agoYou could do (most of) the good things from the above and not have the wood burning stove. I think this is kind of a false dilemma. :)
- TacticalCoder 3y agoIn my vacation house (where I went to live for one full winter season), I turned the fireplace into an enclosed (still wood-fueled) fireplace: there's a fan (if I want to) but it's not blowing smoke, it's blowing warmth from the warmed up "firebox" (whatever that is called) inside the house. It's day and night compared to that same house back when it had a regular open fireplace: smoke would drift inside the house, no matter how cautious I'd be. And the efficiency was terribly bad. Now I still get to enjoy the view and once the fire is well started and the smoke correctly goes through the chimney, I can even open the enclosed fireplace's for a while and hear the crackling / get the full ambiance. Lovely. I hope to go there in december. Falling asleep in front of the fireplace is one of my greatest joy in life. It did cost about 5 K EUR IIRC (to transform the open fireplace into an enclosed one) but then warming the house with wood is super cheap (an enclosed fireplace is much more energy efficient than an open fireplace). FWIW I warmed the house during the entire summer with five "stères de bois" [1] (an old french unit that isn't used for anything anymore beside wood logs meant to be used as fuel), paid 60 EUR each. So 300 EUR to warm the house (south east of France, mild winter). BTW: house in the middle of nowhere, hardly any neighbors. So they don't get my smoke and I don't get their. [1] https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/St%C3%A8re https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/St%C3%A8re
- ahaucnx 3y agoI second this. My sister has an enclosed fireplace and last time I visited her, I measured the air quality next to it and was surprised to find no elevated PM2.5 inside the room. However keeping the door just a bit open emitted a lot of smoke into the room and gave a completely picture. So I would recommend measuring the air quality in your home if you run any fire place. I should probably write a blog post about it sometime.
- X6S1x6Okd1st 3y agoYup I got a pm2.5 & AQI monitor a couple years ago and was so excited to have a fireplace in my new house, but trying it with the monitor showed me I really shouldn't. I am considering an enclosed fireplace to still be able to use it. I am now wondering if just emitting it into the air (out of the chimney) is acceptable. EDIT: also it's been shocking to check on it while cooking, our vent hood is mediocre to bad so we end up keeping a door open most of the time we are cooking
- snapplebobapple 3y agoWhats the absolute risk change? Relative risk is utterly meaningless for actually deciding what to do in the context of alternate choices.
- jskrablin 3y agoI heat my house with a wood burning enclosed fireplace connected to an external air supply. Any other heating solution is kind of the less optimal choice when you own wood supply chain (forest and some tools to prepare wood for heating). But yeah all those planet saving heat pumps need some advertising anyway.
- mindslight 3y agoOutdoor wood boiler. It keeps the wood mess and smoke outside. Plus you can either stack wood near it or use equipment to move it in bulk, rather than carrying wood inside by hand and re-stacking. They got a bad rap because of poor efficiency (the first generation was essentially a barrel inside a barrel) and people's tendency to burn trash in them, but newer models are two stage gasifiers just like modern wood stoves. Although honestly I kind of still want a heat pump for the shoulder seasons and the times I'm away.
- Eumenes 3y agoBurn wood for many years and couldn't care less about these studies. If you're burning dry wood with a clean chimney and insure your seals are good, you're fine. There has been renewed interest by climate warriors to ban wood stoves (they love to cite women and children being "most at risk", the emotional argument must be present to change hearts and minds). Ironic, given it's mostly poor and working class people burning wood. Must be a big push by heat pump and geothermal industries to get rid of wood stoves in the name of "public health". Despite urban populations living with AQI magnitudes higher than rural populations who use these heating sources.
- abid786 3y agoThe science speaks for itself, but to a climate skeptic that might not be true.
- Eumenes 3y agoThe "science" has no mentions of the stove itself, the wood used, how the wood was dried, the physical setup where the stove is being used, they also lumped in "fireplaces" which imo, negates the entire study, because those are open to the air. I'm not about to throw away 500k+ years of human history of burning wood because a few graduate students produced a paper.
- FreeFlyFreeFall 3y agoGood points. I do think economical geothermal AC shouldn't be too difficult in many places, but money has a way of influencing things; look at the septic industry horror stories. I'm curious about how urban vs rural AQIs look for different areas. It does seem more and more like climate control is used to control people through moral and consequently legal claims, and some whistleblowers seem to support that idea. Any skepticism is labeled "conspiracy theory". Also mentioned here, modern double and triple burning stoves are much more efficient, and catalytic combustor stoves leave almost nothing but CO2 and water vapor coming out of the flue pipe. At least for stoves and enclosed fireplaces, if temporary smoke from an initial burn is still a concern, then I'm sure a separate pipe with a fan could be set up to draw air through the flue until a thermometer reaches a certain temperature. A fresh air intake should eliminate smoke leakage during startup. A strong flame used to start the fire, and a draft can also reduce the total smoke produced during this process. Alternative formats like rocket mass heaters may help with this as well. Rather than draw attention to a real danger, encourage education, and distribution of better technology to help people burn a renewable resource safely, some would rather ban a medium that supports the survival of the poor completely. And some here would condemn all wood burners as ignorant archaic people who poison everyone around them and are too unintelligent to realize it. Sam Harris's post, (https://www.samharris.org/blog/the-fireplace-delusion https://www.samharris.org/blog/the-fireplace-delusion) also has this air of incredulity that anyone would burn wood since science shows that it produces harmful byproducts. He seems to fail to realize that wood can burn cleanly, and suggests that we burn gas, which we know also often produces harmful levels of benzene; he suggests that we burn nothing at all, while even the electricity we use comes from coal burning, and alternative "green power" still has a large carbon footprint at this point, no? Geothermal seems good, and avoids radon issues, but is a specialized wood-burning system better if geothermal won't be enough? How do we move forward knowing that industry often influences studies? He writes, "The unhappy truth about burning wood has been scientifically established to a moral certainty". This is yet another "scientist" saying, "The science is settled." Unfortunately for him and climate alarmists, no it hasn't been, and posturing himself as correct because he believes in "scientific rationality" while simultaneously missing simple solutions to simple problems seems typical for him. That said, I do think sharing this info with communities who burn wood inefficiently is a good idea, and I see why their arguments about tradition and it being natural are criticized. He seems to see no exception to this "traditional" attitude among those who burn wood. If these communities don't care about inefficient burning, and aren't regulated, move away; stay mobile. Alternatively, perhaps using an air filter with a high MERV rating helps. Why ban a viable, renewable heat source that can be used to teach people valuable lessons? So that they can become dependent on wind turbines, such as the ones that froze in Texas a year or two ago, leading to the deaths of many who were wholly dependent on electric heat? I'd rather breath some smoke than freeze to death anyway; banning wood burning is worse than imposing regulations to make it almost completely safe, and seeing conclusive opinions before people consider alternative burning systems concerns me, especially when the alternatives posed are often just as dangerous. The most important thing is educating people though. When they know why a safety regulation exists, they're much less likely to hate it and disobey it, as long as it doesn't restrict alternatives and freedoms that it shouldn't.
- pmontra 3y agoThere should be no smoke coming out from a modern stove or fireplace. They are enclosed, take air mostly from outside and blow their exhaust into the sky. Of course some smoke can come inside from the windows or aeration holes.
- dist-epoch 3y agoSo why do you smell them at street level if the smoke is blown into the sky.
- Proven 3y ago[dead]
- sneak 3y agoHalf the comments here are just providing an implementation of the fizzbuzz instead of addressing the article’s point. https://www.samharris.org/blog/the-fireplace-delusion https://www.samharris.org/blog/the-fireplace-delusion > Once they have exited your chimney, the toxic gases (e.g. benzene) and particles that make up smoke freely pass back into your home and into the homes of others. (Research shows that nearly 70 percent of chimney smoke reenters nearby buildings.) Children who live in homes with active fireplaces or woodstoves, or in areas where wood burning is common, suffer a higher incidence of asthma, cough, bronchitis, nocturnal awakening, and compromised lung function. Among adults, wood burning is associated with more-frequent emergency room visits and hospital admissions for respiratory illness, along with increased mortality from heart attacks. The inhalation of wood smoke, even at relatively low levels, alters pulmonary immune function, leading to a greater susceptibility to colds, flus, and other respiratory infections. All these effects are borne disproportionately by children and the elderly.
- dathinab 3y ago> and into the homes of others. I really wish indoor wood burning, especially if not used for heating but luxury, would be banned at least in cities like wtf. is it legal to harass your neighbors with smell and toxic fumes every day just because you want to feel a bit comfy (to clarify: I mean comfy by having a fancy looking fire place you use additional to your normal heating system because you like how it looks) sure there are countries and areas in countries where for various sociology economical reasons banning it isn't acceptable at all and should not be done but a ~4 million city where one of the _most costly ways to heat_ is by burning wood logs it's a bit of a different story ;) and I know some parts of the city are poor and use very old ovens, but funnily they have less of an smell issue (I can't judge the toxicity) because they tend to burn preprocessed pellets for heating instead of not necessary well suited or fully dry wood for the looks
- Fatnino 3y agoI live on a street of single family homes in Palo Alto and my next door neighbor smokes weed every day starting around 10am and it's totally legal for that stench to drift into my backyard shed and harass me where I'm trying to work.
- zapdrive 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoIf you keep breaking the site guidelines like this, we will have to ban you. Please see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37202760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37202760 and the links back from there. If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it.
- dathinab 3y agothe ways you can (short term) kill yourself by doing indoor wood (or pallet) burning wrong are quite many and even in countries which relative strict regulations when it comes to chimes and similar deaths by it aren't that rare if something can kill you just because you used it somewhat wrong it it's somewhat broken in some aspect of ventilation you probably should assume that even a more correct long term usage might have a good chance to have serve long term negative health effects
- robg 3y agoIt’s amazing to me that active air exchanges for filtering and even humidity are not well optimized as part of modern housing HVAC. Is it costs or simply system integrations? For instance, another big indoor pollutant is cooking fumes, from both the heat source and to cook, carmelize, burn, etc - the food and vapors of changing temperatures. The range hood required by fire codes to stove sizes is not turning on automatically with pollutant detection.
- trappist 3y agoI'm not seeing any attempt here to control for obvious confounders such as the relationship between this exposure and the climate you live in. I think I'm also not a fan of the (editorialized) verb (implies causality) used in this headline, for a purely observational study.
- FreeFlyFreeFall 3y ago"...confounders such as the relationship between this exposure and the climate you live in." I'm not sure what this is suggesting, and I'm curious.
- this_steve_j 3y agoI’m really grateful to the HN community for bringing quality research (like this study and others) to my attention. If there are old habits and behaviors, like indoor fires in this case, that can be easily avoided (by me) in exchange for a better chance at avoiding lung cancer, I’m surely glad to have that knowledge so I can avoid unwitting cozying up to a serious ailment later in life. There is so much anecdotal evidence around old habits but a high powered study, followed by more like it, can usually be relied upon.
- whoopsie 3y agoTell this to Big Candle
- sambeau 3y agoI recently did a deep dive into woodsmoke as I couldn't understand how ~2 million years of evolution with woodsmoke hadn't rendered us completely immune to its effects. I couldn't at that time find a paper that showed that it was very harmful to humans, just a lot proving that it was harmful to mice, rats, rabbits, and guinea pigs (and a lot of forwards stating the dangers then linking to another animal research paper)—which bothered me—rodents don't have ~2 millions years of woodsmoke in their evolution history. I found papers about forest fires that some showed bad effects other were inconclusive and wouldn't;t draw conclusions as there were too much smoke from other combustable substances mixed into the smoke. I also found a paper about firefighters exposed to woodsmoke that found no ill effects on them. So I remained unconvinced. But this paper is different: not animals, large study, evidence. SO I will read it in-depth. But I am still baffled. How could over a million years of evolution not have bred this out of us? I'm genuinely curious.
- not_your_vase 3y agoMaybe we just devolved. Most of the people have been living close to nature up to like a 100 years ago. And today? I have like 8 allergies, and I have no idea about the root cause of 6 of them. I would die in 2 days on a field of random weed, by sneezing myself to death. And I suspect I am far from the record holder in this site.
- vba616 3y agoMaybe it's the weeds that are evolving.
- cstrahan 3y agoWhy should you expect ~2 million years of evolution to bread that out of us? The ability to start and control fires for warmth and cooking purposes greatly increases the odds of survival for individuals and their offspring. If I may personify evolution as form of rhetoric: evolution doesn’t care if you limp along through a painful life, or if your genes guarantee a horrific death at the end of it. Evolution only cares about your ability to produce offspring that in turn reach maturity and produce offspring of their own, and so on. Resources are finite in this world, so sure, the fittest tend to outcompete less fit creatures, and the former will perpetuate its genes while the latter won’t. This is where the notion of “survival of the fittest comes from”. But it is a mistake to interpret that implication the other way around: that is, survival does not necessarily imply greater and greater fitness over time. Evolution isn’t about species becoming the best they could be, it’s only about being good enough.
- inglor_cz 3y agoI understand that smoke is noxious, but I am still somewhat bewildered by the lack of corroborating historical data. My own grandparents grew up in fairly modest rural settings, where burning wood was literally the only way not to freeze (I am talking about the 1930s here). At least one of their native villages was located in a tight valley where smoke tends to stay. But lung disease wasn't that much of a problem among them and their neighbors. People typically died of heart attacks, strokes etc., or lived to be fairly old. (Two of my four grandparents made it to 90.) I would expect a much more prominent data peak there. With other toxic substances, we often have it. With asbestos, even ancient Romans knew that slaves who mined asbestos died early of some weird lung disease etc.; the ancients lacked equipment, but were often good observers anyway.
- s3krit 3y agoIn the UK recently, there has been a designation of 'smoke-free' areas, specifically as a result of research done on the harm to health caused by PM2.5 particulates. It's become quite popular for middle-class homes to fit multifuel stoves (i.e., wood, coal, whatever) in order to heat the main room of their house. Largely because they look nice but there is some argument to be made that with the cost of living increasing, especially around energy, that it is somewhat economical to do so - particularly if you have access to free/foraged wood. The idea is you can still use these stoves so long as the fuel you are burning is considered 'smokeless', which in reality isn't actually smokeless but refers to wood that has a moisture content between 15-20%, as well as a number of commercially-available fuels you can buy from large hardware stores like B&Q and some supermarkets. Another development that personally affects me is that local councils are now able to start enforcing this 'smoke-free' thing on owners of narrowboats[1]. For those that don't know, the UK has a 2000 mile network of inland canals on which thousands of us live, in canal barges of about 7ft beam. In the winter, a lot of these boats' primary method of heating our homes is using multifuel stoves. It's an itinerant lifestyle that can be hard at times but incredibly freeing and requires one to live somewhat more in tune with the seasons. A lot of boaters don't have a ton of money and primarily fuel our stoves with foraged wood at varying levels of seasoning (the process of drying wood to reduce moisture content and make it burn better and cleaner). For instance, this year I got a knock on the roof of my boat by a tree surgeon, informing me we needed to move our boat as they had to chop down an ash tree that had succumbed to ash dieback [2]. I asked if I could take some of the wood and he said no problem, saves them a bit of work getting rid of it. And that's now my wood for the winter. We are, of course, aware of the health hazards of groups of boats burning not the best wood, but a large percentage of live-aboard boaters really don't have any other option. Sorry, not particularly relevant to the article posted but I thought it worth mentioning that there are cases where not burning things to stay warm in winter is not an option for some groups of people. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narrowboat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Narrowboat [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hymenoscyphus_fraxineus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hymenoscyphus_fraxineus
- Ferret7446 3y agoAre men immune to lung cancer? This seems like an oddly targeted study, and one cannot help but wonder if there are political reasons for it.
- curation 3y agoI'm aware of this project: https://www.noeton.fi/ https://www.noeton.fi/ They have a device that goes into your fireplace removes cancer causing substances to EU standards. They are a group of Finnish scientists and friends who wanted to find a way to make something they love less polluting and safer to use.
- susiecambria 3y agoInformation like this--the link and the discussion--is why I love HN. Unlike others, though, with posts like this, I'm thinking about wood stove use and burn piles in my part of rural America. What does the Census data say about the use of central heat? What is the health of those who live around me and rely on wood stoves? What can be done locally to transition folks off of wood stove use? What positive health impacts will we see? What can be done via public education to reduce the installation of fireplaces in new homes?
- demandingturtle 3y agoglad it does no harm to men
- onecommentman 3y agoThe statistically significant cancer risk occurs when wood-burning occurs for more than 30 days a year. (Table 2). Burning 1-29 days looks statistically insignificant unless I’m reading Table 2 wrong - HR of .88-1.12 with CIs including 1. Suggesting no statistically significant effect observed from incidental or short-term exposure…roasting chestnuts for Christmas in your fireplace seems a fairly safe bet for most. As a point of public health calibration, women smokers are 13 times more likely to be a lung cancer victim than non-smokers, according to the American Lung Association. https://www.lung.org/lung-health-diseases/lung-disease-lookup/lung-cancer/resource-library/lung-cancer-fact-sheet https://www.lung.org/lung-health-diseases/lung-disease-looku... “Men who smoke are 23 times more likely to develop lung cancer. Women are 13 times more likely, compared to never smokers.” 2004 US HHS Surgeon General report Wood smoke use for more than 30 days/year is a ~50% increase in lung cancer, according to this one study. Maybe focusing on the order of magnitude greater causal agent would be the wiser public policy choice, in the US at any rate.