4 ms·
Big enough to carry a discussion doesn't mean you have an entire blog post ready to write all by yourself. In general my complaint is that it's hard to link to
by Dylan16807 3y ago
Big enough to carry a discussion doesn't mean you have an entire blog post ready to write all by yourself.
In general my complaint is that it's hard to link to a specific section or piece of information inside a larger article.
So letting comments become stories willy-nilly is not my suggestion. This is about having an external story, but no good way to point at it.
And a submission like this can't just be a comment because there's no story for it to be a comment on. The video would not otherwise have been submitted.
And yes the option of "submission plus comment" exists but again that's a bad way to start a discussion when the submission has nothing obviously interesting about it. And it makes the experience even worse for someone that tries to read/watch the entire submission before looking at the comments, when most of the submission is pretty boring and the submitter only wanted to submit one portion.
- pvg 3y agoI mean, this is all very theoretical so perhaps you can come up with an example of something that would be a good story but isn't actually just a comment. Because this submission? Just a comment. Nearly all of them are and primarily revolve not around the difficulty of linking some subsection of a story but around the importance the poster assigns to their commentary. when the submission has nothing obviously interesting Again, the argument here is 'what I have to say about an uninteresting thing is interesting enough to be its own HN story'. You can see how this is tricky, right? Like, the point of the site is not uninteresting things. The trivial solution is 'find something interesting to post'.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Because this submission? Just a comment. A comment on what submission? > Like, the point of the site is not uninteresting things. The trivial solution is 'find something interesting to post'. Sometimes interesting things are inside larger uninteresting things. Imagine if you could only link to a domain. Half the submissions people make would become far more difficult to make. > Again, the argument here is 'what I have to say about an uninteresting thing is interesting enough to be its own HN story'. It's not. The argument is "this section is interesting enough to be a submission, but it would be unreasonable to expect everyone to find it in this large article/video". The pure form of this has no commentary, just linking to a very very specific part. This exact submission isn't the purest example since it's more of a caption, but I've seen many pure examples where someone wants to submit a specific section without even a single word of extra explanation. The kind of thing you could do with text fragment links but only in some browsers and only for text.
- pvg 3y agoA comment on what submission? This submission was just a comment, is what I mean. It wasn't really an HN story. Sometimes interesting things are inside larger uninteresting things. Sure but those are almost never interesting enough to be HN stories. There are ways to turn them into HN stories but that's done by adding interestingness. Playing logic games about what is and isn't a comment really isn't adding interestingness, it's simply claiming one can rule-lawyer one's way to interestingness and it seems sort of obvious one can't? It's not. The argument is "this section is interesting enough to be a submission, but it would be unreasonable to expect everyone to find it in this large article/video". Well, it is, because those things are rarely actually interesting. Like, you have to demonstrate interestingness not just claim it. And this practice is effectively elevating a claim - my claim to interestingness in someone else's uninteresting thing is so important, it deserves its own title. It's a serious special pleading and you could make the case for it with examples but as far as I can tell, there aren't many or any. The pure form of this has no commentary I'm not sure what the 'pure form' is, we're talking about people making up their own titles, i.e. turning their comment into the most important comment. Incidentally, there is a site dedicated to not-having a distinction between 'comment' and 'story' and the exchange of snippets of things - twitter. It works pretty well for that use case.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> This submission was just a comment, is what I mean. It wasn't really an HN story. Why not? "Apple backs X standard" sounds like enough for an HN story to me. > Sure but those are almost never interesting enough to be HN stories. There are ways to turn them into HN stories but that's done by adding interestingness. It happens often enough. Lots of news articles talk about multiple things. Sometimes you even get multiple unrelated stories in the same article. Isolating one story shouldn't be a weird thing. You didn't reply to my question of "what if you could only link a domain" but I think that comparison is important. Sometimes URLs aren't granular enough. > Playing logic games I'm not playing logic games. > Like, you have to demonstrate interestingness not just claim it. That's what voting is for. But first is has to be a submission, and also people are supposed to be able to get a hint of what's interesting from the title. > my claim to interestingness in someone else's uninteresting thing is so important, it deserves its own title. It's a serious special pleading Again, the "entire domain" thing. Finding an interesting thing inside an uninteresting thing that deserves its own title happens constantly. The difference is that most of the time there's a URL you can use, but sometimes there isn't a URL you can use. > I'm not sure what the 'pure form' is, we're talking about people making up their own titles, i.e. turning their comment into the most important comment. The purest form is someone using a direct quote from the article, with no words of their own. Maybe they're even using a heading directly from the article. Then behind that is someone giving a very basic description for something that doesn't have its own title. Because article sections often don't have their own titles. In the former case they are completely objectively not making a "most important comment". In the latter case, they're doing the best they can, it's not like HN blocks submissions that don't have a preexisting title. > Incidentally, there is a site dedicated to not-having a distinction between 'comment' and 'story' and the exchange of snippets of things - twitter. It works pretty well for that use case. And sometimes people submit tweets to HN. HN is supposed to be for anything interesting, no matter the length. The goal here is not to confuse comments and stories. "Here is a thing I found, here is what it is in a few words, nothing further." is something I would call a valid story.