5 ms·
0, 1, infinity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule I mean, it's potentially possible Ea
by pixl97 3y ago
0, 1, infinity.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule
I mean, it's potentially possible Earth is the only planet with intelligent life (though highly, highly improbable). But the moment we discover any other planet with intelligent life, then we must assume there are an infinite amount (if the universe is infinite).
Of course this brings up more questions about what is intelligence? Is a slime mold intelligent?
- mr_mitm 3y agoI agree with your conclusion, but it does not follow from that statement, which is just a made up rule of thumb. I'd rather apply Bayesian statistics. If we found life on one more planet, what were the chances of that assuming those are the only two planets with life? Pretty low I'd say.
- WithinReason 3y agoNot really, one planet could have seeded the other
- mr_mitm 3y agoTrue, I should have added "independently" Actually, without any additional knowledge I'd assume that some sort of seeding has happened, as that's presumably more likely than live developing independently.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> (though highly, highly improbable) Its highly probable that, if human-scale intelligence/civilization exists on other planets, Von Neumann probes (or some similar, highly detectable signs of activity) would have reached us by now. And they have not. This is an interesting paradox.
- bladeee 3y agoHow can you assert that they haven’t?
- qayxc 3y agoWhy, though? I hear this argument a lot, but never ever is it backed up by actual facts aside from assumptions (i.e. that technological civilisation build Von Neumann probes in the first place). So first question: why even Von Neumann probes? What would be the purpose of a self-replicating spacecraft? If it's science, then there's no reason to assume we would even be able to detect it. If it's some kind of colonisation effort, it only requires more assumptions. The basic assumption that the Fermi "Paradox" (I refuse to see it as a paradox) requires, is that technological civilisations remain unchanged over geologic time spans. That's a bold assumption, judging from our sample size of 1. Another assumption is that such civilisations grow exponentially for a practically unlimited amount of time (yeah, yeah, millions of years isn't exactly "unlimited", but on a human time scale it kind of is). Given the vast distances in both time and space, it's much more reasonable to acknowledge that technological civilisations are simply too far apart (in both time and space) to make contact in most cases. A thriving local interstellar civilisation on the other side of the Milky Way within the Zone of Avoidance would be virtually undetectable by us, for example.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> that technological civilisations remain unchanged over geologic time spans Actually I think the opposite assumption, that civilization radically changes over time, is an argument for it. Future humanity is not people on (sublight) space boats touring the stars like Star Trek, its seemingly some kind of unfathomable transcendent intelligence. Maybe its not even recognized as "civilization" by our standards. And why would such an intelligence not explore its environment? What's the likelihood, if there are many such intelligences, that essentially all of these intelligences choose to remain static, stagnant and stealthy instead of making their presence known within their light horizon?
- qayxc 3y ago
- softg 3y ago> In real-world software design, violations of this rule of thumb are common. For example, the FAT16 file system imposes a limit of 65,536 files to a directory. If the rules of software design apply to the universe, what is to stop us from assuming that our almighty creators are storing an $intelligent_life_form_count variable in a single byte somewhere and there can only be 255 of us ?
- cafeinux 3y agoOnce a 256th develops, the overflow causes every intelligent form of life to disappear.
- paholg 3y agoI'm sure the angels are working hard on the Y256 bug to prevent that from happening.
- gpvos 3y agoOr there could be a maximum on brain processing power and we're hitting that with our population growth. Possibly affecting intelligent life elsewhere as well.
- SpaceNoodled 3y agoNot sure how I never managed to hear about that rule before. It seems pretty self-evident since I've come up with a similar idea.
- johnchristopher 3y agohttps://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/if_all_you_have_is_a_hammer,_everything_looks_like_a_nail https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/if_all_you_have_is_a_hammer,_...
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoIf the universe is infinite then would there not also be infinite Earths with infinite people posting on infinite Hacker News?
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoCome to think about it, if the universe is infinite, then every physically possible arrangement must occur somewhere.