5 ms·
Could Earth be the only planet with intelligent life?
- AlbertCory 3y agoA long time ago, I heard an analogous statement about software bugs: Testing can only disclose the presence of bugs. Never their absence. So it's impossible to prove there isn't any life beyond Earth.
- Koshkin 3y agoAnd the intelligent life will likely be bugs.
- asynchronous 3y agoConversely it’s impossible to prove there is life beyond earth. PROOF is a high standard. All our existing evidence seems to point to the fact that we are indeed alone in the universe.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> it’s impossible to prove there is life beyond earth. why do you say that? If SETI finds unambiguous signals, and they're independently confirmed several times, why would that not be "proof"? As for the last sentence, the less said the better. "All our existing evidence" is pathetically small.
- cafeinux 3y agoOur lack of evidence tends to suggest that we are alone. But it's a mere conjecture. A single counterexample would invalidate it.
- ksherlock 3y agoOne strategy for estimating bugs is to intentionally seed your code with bugs and then see how many of them the QA team find. ie, if the QA team identifies 5/10 intentional bugs and 20/?? true bugs you can estimate there are 40 true bugs (20 still unidentified). Likewise, we just need to seed other star systems with intelligent life and see how many our astronomers can find.
- AlbertCory 3y agoThere's that "just" word again /s
- gls2ro 3y agoI think this could be a maybe a way to assess the efficiency of the QA team, but I am skeptic of using it as a metric about estimating the number of bugs. This is because QA is there to help with reducing the probability that an important bug will happen to a real user. But the total number of bugs a system have is a sum of bugs found by developers + bugs found by QA + bugs found by average users + bugs found by power users + bugs found at scale/big numbers. The more we move to the right of this sum the hard is to replicate conditions to find bugs and so we move from finding to probabilities and risk management.
- cafeinux 3y agoFor the moment, astronomers found 0 life forms out the 42 we seeded. Unfortunately, 0/42 is equal to 0/n where n ∈ ℕ, so we don't gained much knowledge on the matter so far.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 3y ago0, 1, infinity. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zero_one_infinity_rule I mean, it's potentially possible Earth is the only planet with intelligent life (though highly, highly improbable). But the moment we discover any other planet with intelligent life, then we must assume there are an infinite amount (if the universe is infinite). Of course this brings up more questions about what is intelligence? Is a slime mold intelligent?
- mr_mitm 3y agoI agree with your conclusion, but it does not follow from that statement, which is just a made up rule of thumb. I'd rather apply Bayesian statistics. If we found life on one more planet, what were the chances of that assuming those are the only two planets with life? Pretty low I'd say.
- WithinReason 3y agoNot really, one planet could have seeded the other
- mr_mitm 3y agoTrue, I should have added "independently" Actually, without any additional knowledge I'd assume that some sort of seeding has happened, as that's presumably more likely than live developing independently.
- brucethemoose2 3y ago> (though highly, highly improbable) Its highly probable that, if human-scale intelligence/civilization exists on other planets, Von Neumann probes (or some similar, highly detectable signs of activity) would have reached us by now. And they have not. This is an interesting paradox.
- bladeee 3y agoHow can you assert that they haven’t?
- standardUser 3y agoThe universe does not appear to be random, instead it appears to be based on a pattern. For every other level of detail we've been able to view with advances in technology the pattern seems to hold. It would be a leap of logic in the wrong direction to assume life isn't part of that pattern simply because we can't yet observe it.
- owlstuffing 3y agoGiven the ever growing discoveries and complexity of single cell life, it is evermore unlikely that life randomly “sprung” into being. The primordial soup argument is akin to lightening striking a wheat field and spontaneously producing a birthday cake complete with icing, candles, and balloons.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoTo go from nothing to that level of complexity in one stroke seems impossible. But nobody thinks that single celled organisms sprang into existence like that. Most theories postulate simpler replicating chemical reactions, maybe around hydrothermal vents or pools, possibly forming in mineral structures and cavities. Later on membranes may have formed, and so on. Many steps, not one.
- jononomo 3y agoEveryone has a theory just like everyone has an opinion. Some people think Trump won the 2020 election. Other people think life came from crystals. Whatever, man. No one has a clue how life emerged.
- owlstuffing 3y agoA series of unlikely but dependent events is no more likely. This is pure speculation, not science.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoI would disagree that a series of simpler steps is just as unlikely as life emerging fully formed. It is of course speculation as we just don't know. But if you agree that life occured naturally without supernatural intervention (or aliens, but that just pushes the speculation to how the aliens occurred), then there must be such a set of steps.
- cafeinux 3y agoYet, if the primordial soup is indeed what happened, it created a birthday cake complete with icing, candles and balloons, through the creation of humans. The primordial doesn't speculate that life appeared from one day to another, it speculates a long and slow process, just as the refinery of wheat into flour then a pastry (along with other ingredients) is a long and slow process (faster than the creation of life, but still).
- elliotec 3y agoThe Fermi paradox covers this quite interestingly: “The Fermi paradox is the discrepancy between the lack of conclusive evidence of advanced extraterrestrial life and the apparently high likelihood of its existence.” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox
- canistel 3y agoIn Dragon's Egg by Robert L. Forward, intelligent life evolves in a neutron star. But then again, it's fiction.
- Habgdnv 3y agoI doubt it. In fact, due to human activity, Earth may be the only planet that can't support intelligent life in a sustainable way. Even if we were to discover intelligent life on earth, it might not survive long in our current internet-meme-dominated ecosystem.
- CapitalistCartr 3y agoLife as we know it seems to depend on have a large Moon, a planetary makeup infused with heavy metals, a distance from our star and rotation that makes most of the planet a temperature good for our kind of life, a star that's safely boring, and LOTS of water. But with 10 to the 24th stars, even one in a billion odds are no deterrent.
- candiddevmike 3y agoAccording to some articles on Google, there are 275 million stars born every day. That's a lot of dice rolls.
- DennisP 3y agoBut we also don't know how life started. There's a big gap between the simple organic molecules that pop up everywhere, and metabolizing reproducing life, and we have no idea how many improbable events had to occur to bridge that gap. For all we know, it takes a whole universe rolling those dice before it's likely to happen even once.
- bmitc 3y agoIt is probable that Mars had life even before Earth. It had water oceans for hundreds of millions of years, which is approximately how long it took life to emerge on Earth. Venus potentially had life as well, in addition to some of the moons. Let's be conservative and say that 2 of the n bodies in the solar system had life and one had so-called intelligent life emerge. It seems pretty damn likely given the sheer numbers of the Universe that intelligent life also emerged elsewhere. We currently can barely detect exoplanets. It isn't a surprise that we haven't detected intelligent life. How can you find something you can't see? From what we know, life is effectively guaranteed to emerge on a planet with a rocky core and water in the habitable zone. Are there planets like this? Yes, lots, probably.
- DennisP 3y agoWe can't know that life is guaranteed unless we find another example of life arising independently. We don't know how many random chemical reactions are required for life to be likely. We probably agree that a small puddle isn't likely to spontaneously generate life within a century. We like to think that one planet for a billion years is about the right size. But it could be that it takes a whole universe of planets before it's likely to happen once. If that were the case, then the universe would look exactly like it does now, with us living on the planet where it happened and no life discovered elsewhere so far.
- bmitc 3y ago> We can't know that life is guaranteed unless we find another example of life arising independently. Of course not. But that's why we discuss probabilities. We also can't discuss definitively about things that we have no reasonable ways to detect. So claims about there's no life because we would have seen them is completely worthless given that we have very, very few, if any, ways to detect such life. Assuming it existed, are we even able to detect a planet like Earth with similar animal and human activity in any other solar system, even in the Milky Way? I am personally not aware of such general capability.
- DennisP 3y ago
- m3kw9 3y agoThat’s how intelligent we are thinking there is no higher/ equivalent/ lower else where. You have zero or greater than zero and you choose zero?
- dvh 3y agoIt took 4.5 billion years on earth to invent radio, which is only 3x the age of the universe. I think we are one of the firsts.
- politelemon 3y agoDo you mean one-third the age of the universe?
- m3kw9 3y agoEvery other planet should have independent probability as earth to have life, so that’s trillions op on trillions. Plus the way we evolved may not be the template on how other intelligent life will evolve. We make the mistake of thinking it can only work the way we’ve seen it done and exclude any other possibilities.
- m3kw9 3y agoThe op is on a high horse, thinking the only intelligent life that could exist can onky survive on what humans need to survive.
- jononomo 3y agoNot only that, but Earth is probably the only planet that has life of any kind. There is simply no explanation for the existence of life at all. Nobody has the faintest idea how life came into existence, and the question of the origin of life is, frankly, the only interesting question because it is a prerequisite for the existence of any other question. Without life there are no questions.
- m3kw9 3y agoI would in fact postulate that sufficient intelligent life would have moved beyond 3d/physical and would have exist in higher dimensions/virtually but hidden from sight. The way humans is trending certainly is going towards virtual/ augmented reality, virtual reality. In even 1000 years I can imagine direct brain implants for some reality augmentation. Also in 1000 years what other physics will we discover and able to manipulate? Certainly if we discover ways to manipulate actual reality, we will. With that said, this could explain why we will not detect life because we only had the technology to detect what we call life, and this window could be only 1000-2000 years before we moved beyond physical reality. So the chance that a similar intelligent life with similar tech era out of billions of years makes it almost nil. Both windows has to match.
- jawns 3y agoOne thing I like to bring to these debates is the idea that people, in general, are really bad at understanding probabilities at the scale that is required here. And I'm not talking about probabilities that deal with how large the universe is. We know that it is unfathomably huge, with countless galaxies, stars, and planets. But in "Fermi's Pair o' Decks" there is an illustration of just how few things need to align "just so" to make it almost certain that we are the only life in the universe: https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/aliens.html https://shaungallagher.pressbin.com/blog/aliens.html In fact, all you need are two decks of playing cards to understand how combinatorics can very quickly overwhelm our intuitions.
- doubloon 3y agoeverybody asks whether exo civilizations are, but nobody asks how exo civilizations are.
- gmuslera 3y agoYou can't never say yes. It will definitely a "no" when we find clear evidence of intelligent life elsewhere, but we should know for sure when we inspect every other place in the universe, in all history of it, and that is billions of light years spanning billions of years to say "yes". And we can't even rule that out even in our closest star system, at just 4 light years from here, yet. Everything is too far away from our view to rule out that is not in some place that we didn't see yet, because practically everything fits in that definition.
- gwerbret 3y agoOne problem with this article, and many others of its ilk, is that they somewhat underestimate the enormous complexity of this thing we call "life". Here's an incomplete list of what the most primitive single-celled lifeform has to do: -- create some way of sustainably separating "self" from its environment, so that all the components of downstream steps don't diffuse away. The separating material, which could be a cell wall or cell membrane, also has to allow selective exchange of raw materials in and out of the cell, and provide protection against damage to the cell. -- design and build a chemical template (DNA/RNA in our case) which allows it to reproducibly recreate itself and all its components. -- design the molecular machinery which builds that chemical template, and which is also responsible for reading and interpreting the template, regulating its use, and providing error correction. Instructions for creating machinery that makes the template are encoded in the template. -- design the molecular machinery (enzymes and other proteins) that builds molecular machines, using a design language encoded in the chemical template. -- establish a chemistry program that takes in raw materials from the environment, and converts it to energy, building blocks for the machinery and template, and allows for repair, defense, and other tasks. -- establish and implement reliable reproductive (data backup) framework, minimally involving the creation of a copy of the chemical template, and often copying and spinning off a second, complete cell. These are the elements of basic, independent (i.e. non -parasitic) life. As far as we can tell, the core elements (information stored in DNA/RNA encoding proteins as molecular machines) of this life solution emerged fairly early in this planet's 4.5 billion-year existence, and every other organism since then has simply iterated on the same solution -- no other competing solutions exist to our knowledge. It thus makes sense to account for this complexity when we calculate the odds of finding life in the universe. In my opinion, the Fermi paradox is nonsense.
- beeforpork 3y agoYes, that! And on top of this complexity of life, it took like 4 billion years on earth (that's roughly 1/3 of the age of the universe) from RNA/DNA to intelligent life forms that can talk about this on the internet. And during this time, no catastrophic global event has happened to undo all that development. Comparing Earth to other planets in our solar system (we cannot really compare to other systems, obviously), Earth is really lucky that there was no such catastrophic event. So many factors are important for this -- our sun is just the right size (not too harsh UV radiation (bad for molecules to be stable), not too small to make our orbit so small that rotation would stop (blowing away the atmosphere)). Our moon is unusally large for a planet like ours, yet it was vital for stabilising the Earth's axis (stable axis == stable weather) and slow down its rotation. And for the moon to emerge, a very nearly fatal impact from another body of the right mass (Mars sized) needed to happen at the right time (very early). At the right speed and the right angle. The availability of water and oxygen at the right times in Earth history where also quite a big unlikelyhood. And it goes on and on: Earth is unimaginably lucky. Taken all this together, I doubt that anyone could multiply the probability of life on a planet with the amount of planets in the Milky Way (or the universe) we think would be Earth candidates, and claim to have a sensible number. The later is an unimaginably large number, but the first is an unimaginably small number and also a very unknown number. So: we just don't know how often life happens. And also, detection is not trivial: it is not that easy to see other planets (they are far away), or alien space probes (they are small, space is large), other radio waves (they are weak), or any other signs of intelligent life.
- highpost 3y agoStar Trek may have made us think that Class M planets are abundant, but the probability of detecting intelligent life on any given habitable planet is remote. There may be many Class M planets within our detection range, but the trick is to find one that has an intelligent civilization at precisely this moment in time minus the time it takes for radio signals to reach Earth. Let’s say that Earth is about 4.5 billion years old and that intelligent life has been externally detectable for about 120 years since radio was invented around 1900. And it’s by no means certain that just because a civilization on a given Class M planet achieves radio signal generation that it will soon achieve warp drive technology and build a fleet of starships. That civilization could simply watch episodes of the Golden Bachelor while consuming all of its available resources and then fade away. Or just blow each other up. I’m not saying that intelligent life outside of Earth does not or has never existed. We can only detect a small part of the known universe. And we can only detect what’s going on roughly right now because there isn’t a WayBack Machine for interstellar radio signals. All this requires the combination of several low probability events: * A planet must be within detectable range of Earth. * A civilization must have developed. * The civilization needs to survive for a meaningful period of time. One century is not meaningful. * The civilization must be visible essentially right now. The combination of those events yields a very low probability. I’m not saying that the search for intelligent life on other planets isn’t interesting or worthwhile, but I do think that Elon Musk should stop wasting his time on space travel and start spending it on global warming. That will give us the best chance of extending our run as an intelligent civilization.
- wawayanda 3y agoI used to read articles like this and nod my head about the plausibility, perhaps inevitability of life in the universe, then I read this paper and it completely changed my view. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0094576518314000 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00945... "the results indicate that the probability we are alone (<1) in the galaxy is significant, while the maximum number of contemporary civilizations might be as few as a thousand"
- johnea 3y agoEarth's claims of "intelligence" are dubious...
- hackeraccount 3y agoWe have a sample size of one but my take on life from that sample is: Life pops up really fast. Going from Prokaryotic to eukaryotic takes a really - almost weirdly - long time. Presumably going from eukaryotic to something we can easily recognize as intelligent takes an even longer, which again is weird, amount of time. From that I'd expect life to be common and intelligent life that's reachable to us - that is on a time frame / distance that is reachable for humanity as a species - to be either non-existent or rare as hens teeth. It may be common in terms of the universe though just not knowable.