13 ms·
You've just spent $400 on a baby monitor. Now you need a subscription
- dmitrygr 3y agoAnd this is reason #4534 why i refuse to buy internet-connected anything. Cannot force a subscription on me without a way to connect to the internet! I spent a lot of time looking for a non-smart washer and dryer. Recently I spent a lot of time looking for a non-smart dishwasher. I suspect my next car purchase will be complicated by this as well.
- vosper 3y agoReason #1 why I would never buy an internet-connected camera is all the times people have hacked them. Someone I know recently had a random talk to her out of her cloud-connected baby monitor. The companies who make internet-connected baby monitors do not give a shit about security. We have an Infant Optics DXR-8 Pro for our baby monitor. It's cheaper than the device mentioned in the article, is not connected to the internet/wifi in any way, and works great. I've just bought another one.
- tivert 3y ago> Someone I know recently had a random talk to her out of her cloud-connected baby monitor. The companies who make internet-connected baby monitors do not give a shit about security. Yeah, I bought an old-school audio-only radio baby monitor for just that reason. Sure, a HAM in a van could theoretically creep out my kid that way, but the physical proximity required makes that extremely unlikely.
- heavyset_go 3y agoBack in the day, you could listen to neighbors' phone calls and baby monitors by just turning your own wireless phone and/or monitor.
- Cerium 3y agoI agree that the Infant Optics monitor is great. Totally foolproof, decent range (unless you have concrete walls) and much lower latency than any of the internet connected devices I have seen. I also recommend Phillip's line of audio only monitors. They are even lower latency and have an excellent filtering algorithm built in. I can play lullaby at a decent volume and it won't let any audio through, but as soon as baby makes a tiny noise the audio comes through clearly (including the music of course). It saves a bit of mental load from listening to baby music all the time.
- throwaway14356 3y agobuy old world device's, they are remarkably repairable.
- tivert 3y ago> I suspect my next car purchase will be complicated by this as well. Yeah. I bought my car 5 years ago, and even then it was a trend to stick a cellular modem in the car to sell a subscription remote start/car tracking service. It was hard, but I determined that my car didn't have a modem (by asking the sales guy if they needed to install a part to activate the service, or if they could just do it from their computer over-the-phone). My wife's care does have a modem, and I've been tempted to disconnect the box for those features (it's separate from the head unit), or install a dummy load in place of the antenna.
- jstarfish 3y ago> Cannot force a subscription on me without a way to connect to the internet! They also can't retract, brick, or remotely-control whatever it is post-sale. Tech is entering the post-intimacy, post-honeymoon, abusive phase in its relationship with users. The companies involved are seeing what's possible to get away with and exploiting it at every opportunity.
- jkaplowitz 3y agoInteresting - I've seen that washers, dryers, and maybe dishwashers can connect to the Internet, but I've never yet seen it be mandatory as it sometimes is with e.g. smart TVs. And I did buy a washer and a dryer within the last few years, although that was in Canada rather than the US. Where are you looking that you're only seeing washers and dryers that require rather than merely permit an Internet connection?
- donw 3y agoI long ago hit the point that I simply won't buy things that require "the cloud" or a smartphone app to function. Does this mean I miss out on a bit of convenience? Yes. Does this also mean that I don't need to worry about my barbecue going on strike because "the cloud" is down? Also yes.
- throwaway14356 3y agoThey won't tell you in advance.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIf you look at the website for this monitor, it makes no secret of requiring a smartphone. They frame these requirements as "features" so if you pay attention to what you buy it's pretty hard to get tricked into buying something that requires a phone. They do a worse job of disclosing the subscription necessary to use most of the advertised features (this is explained on the 'membership' page of their website, but not the product page itself). But if you avoid this product for requiring a smartphone at all then the problem is neatly avoided.
- modzu 3y agokeep whining peasants, and we might decide we don't even really need you anymore
- robes 3y agoKnowing this was possible along with the privacy concerns is the main reason I told friends and family not to buy a baby monitor for us. Instead I used Polycom VOIP phones and Asterisk PBX install to act like intercoms throughout the house using the DIDs 10, 20, 30, etc. Then I made extensions 11, 22, 33, etc to add a SIP-header to the call so that the receiving handset auto answers. Works really well, my wife and I use it every day, and our now 6 year old has started to too. Ran Asterisk at work so it made sense to put it to use at home, albeit without any external connectivity.
- eh_why_not 3y ago> ... only to find their device left with less functionality than a $30 webcam unless more money is handed over. $400, it would appear, is not enough to buy the device and run the services behind the scenes until Junior is old enough... It's crazy that the company's action is legal.
- bell-cot 3y agoYou can buy a lot of lawmakers for (say) 10% of ( $400 - $30 ) x units_sold. Or of $10/month x subscriptions_sold.
- omneity 3y agoSounds like a no-brainer to implement an open source solution for baby monitoring, such a universal need. Tech wise, RTSP feed from a camera + motion detection model + homeassistant (maybe) and bob's your uncle? But I guess the ones who need this the most (parents) also lack the time to do anything about it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- donw 3y agoMost people don't have the time or knowledge to set up a Linux box, much less an OSS baby monitor. This is one category of problem that should be solved through legislation, but I doubt that should such laws be passed, that they would be actually enforced against bad actors. Like most regulations, it'll be just another weapon to entrench existing players, and keep new entrants out of the market. The way things should work: right-to-repair means not only schematics, BOMs, and source code; it also means documentation on network protocols, and the ability for the end-user to repoint any sort of cloud/smartphone connected device to another endpoint.
- bhuber 3y ago> This is one category of problem that should be solved through legislation, but I doubt that should such laws be passed, that they would be actually enforced against bad actors. IANAL, but I would think this would be covered by existing false advertising laws, and maybe breach of contract. They advertised a product as coming with features x, y, and z; people paid for those features; and then the company unilaterally disabled those features. So now features x, y, and z no longer work on the product as advertised. I'd be surprised if we don't see class action lawsuits for this.
- gerdesj 3y ago"Most people don't have the time or knowledge to set up a Linux box, much less an OSS baby monitor." Luckily this granddad does. I also get deployed by daughter in law to deal with any safety critical stuff in their house eg stair gates and mounting TVs on the wall that will survive an acrobat practising a new routine. Ironically enough, her other half is a railway safety engineer. Technology isn't the be all and end all. Whilst I can and have rigged up a baby monitor from a spare Riolink, a spare PoE switch, a VPN back to my home Zoneminder etc, it isn't actually required. Yes I do have a lot of spare stuff and grandad's cloud is acceptable.
- aeturnum 3y ago> $400, it would appear, is not enough to buy the device and run the services behind the scenes until Junior is old enough to pull it off the wall and give the thing a good chewing. I have no idea what the BOM is on this product but that seems entirely possible? I haven't checked the options but I am sure there are cheaper options that offer fewer features. I'm really tired of "oh so you're telling me it costs money to do something" articles. It really might! It's also possible the company is lazily trying to get some recurring revenue on its balance sheet. Without actually being inside their process you really can't know.
- nirvdrum 3y agoThe product was sold with the monitoring baked in. There was no expectation by consumers that they would have to pay an ongoing fee for functionality that was included at the time of the purchase. I don't have the BOM either, but $400 is very much on the premium side for such a product. This included monitoring functionality is a large component of justifying that price. Without the monitoring, it's a $400 product with essentially the same functionality as a $30 one. Moreover, a $10/month subscription is far from selling things at cost. Maybe the company has too much overhead and they really need this revenue to stay afloat, but the bait and switch is still not to be excused. Given the sequence of events, it has the hallmark of a company purchasing another specifically with the intention of rent seeking. On a side note, I think startups are really doing themselves a disservice here. With stories like this, Nest, and others, I have very little interest in buying a product that isn't from an established player. Because the odds are really good that company is aiming to get acquired and then the nature of my device changes. Maybe it gets discontinued. Maybe the privacy policy changes. Maybe features get removed and replaced with subscription fees. It's not terribly often that I end up having the same experience I enjoyed when I purchased it. More often than not it ends up being e-waste because it won't even function without an always-on connection.
- aeturnum 3y ago> I don't have the BOM either, but $400 is very much on the premium side for such a product. That was really long-winded way to say, "I don't have any more info than you but it looks bad." Sure it looks bad! If I have to guess (and I do) I'd say they're not delivering good value. But this is supposed to be a website for people building companies! Hardware costs money and has ongoing support costs! These aren't shameful flaws, they're the nature of the business. It's not "more ethical" to use a model that hides the costs of ongoing support for a product by packing extra margin into each sale. I would not buy this product. I agree it's overpriced (and its subscription is poorly disclosed). I do not care about the high-end features it delivers. But the fact that it has a high cost (and a subscription for ongoing support) is not a problem by itself.
- heavyset_go 3y agoI can't imagine using cloud-enabled video baby monitor. Predators are already hacking them[1]. [1] https://reviewed.usatoday.com/baby-monitors/features/your-baby-monitor-can-hacked-and-heres-what-do https://reviewed.usatoday.com/baby-monitors/features/your-ba...
- ipaddr 3y agoYour link didn't provide anything to backup they are hacking now only they could be hacked. Be scared predators are lurking? I can't think of a more undesirable cam to hack.
- jstarfish 3y agoNot every camera is positioned like the stock photo. Wherever voyeurs are, there's usually an unwitting female victim-- so I assume the interest is more in half-asleep, half-dressed mothers doing things like breastfeeding in view of the camera.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoNot every baby monitor is strictly used for babies, either. They are just surveillance devices with different marketing, made in the same factories with the same software as the non-baby versions.
- mywacaday 3y agoI wish that people who invested in baby monitors that monitor breathing also took the time to learn infant CPR. On the relatively small chance that your child stops breathing from something that can be recovered from waiting for an ambulance isnt an option. Also breathing monitors go off if the child moves away from the padded area and it's enough to give a parent heart failure of their own.
- AussieWog93 3y agoSimplest solution is to just not buy one. They solve zero problems and just feed into your anxiety. Kids will cry if they actually need you.
- mattlondon 3y agoNot if they are smothered and/or can't lift their head yet to breathe. Newborns are very weak in the neck and generally struggle to lift their heads. We had a wireless monitor that velcroed around their foot that monitored heart rate and blood oxygen level (Owlet brand). It went off once after an ill-fated breast feeding session at god-knows-when-o'clock where they got into a weird position between a very very drowsy mum and some cushions and we didn't notice. Would they have suffocated eventually, or maybe they would have mustered a cry? Who knows, but I am glad the alarm went off and we were able to wake up mum and reposition the baby so their face was not mushed into skin. For us the monitor was something that allowed us to relax a bit. It also had the added bonus of you could tell if they were getting a cold before they had any other symptoms as their heart rate was usually higher than normal when they were sleeping. Very useful.
- bhuber 3y agoI take it you've never actually cared for small children. One of the most obvious problems they solve is the ability to go outside earshot of the nursery - doesn't matter if the kid cries if you can't hear them! Besides that, kids often cry temporarily and then go back to sleep like 30 seconds later. It's very convenient to be able to detect if that's likely to be the case without having to walk across the house and open their door.
- brunoqc 3y agoIt's like having a pixel watch. I mean, you don't need fitbit premium, but it's silly.
- geoelectric 3y agoWe need consumer protection that comes down to terms locked in at time of purchase for any aspect of the device fundamental to its advertised functionality.
- kingsloi 3y agoI purchased a Miku when I brought home my newborn from the ICU, who had 24/7 oxygen needs. Although not 100% accurate, the Miku did give my wife and I peace of mind when we didn't connect the pulse oximeter and laid our baby down in her crib. Hearing that Miku will now be subscription-based is really disappointing. From being at the top, to bottom with the other wifi monitors. We'll still use as a monitor, but wont be recommending to anyone anymore like we used to.
- 23B1 3y agoYou can buy cheap non-networked baby monitors just about anywhere, and they work great. Mine has a range that works across the entire house, battery lasts all day, and only 'wakes' when junior is crying/moving. IOT was a massive hype-cycle long dead. I even swapped out my Sonos system after those clowns making dumb privacy decisions.
- proamdev123 3y agoI haven’t seen any non-networked baby monitors anywhere, but perhaps I’m looking in the wrong places. Can you suggest any monitor brands/models or places I could find them? (Genuinely asking)
- cbruns 3y agoInfant optics
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoWe just use one of those Anker ones that do not even connect to the internet— they just feed the dedicated screen they come with. Works fine for us. I know Anker had some scandal with their internet connected cameras, but I think we’re safe from that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rcoveson 3y agoThis is my baby monitor setup. It uses a GoPro (already owned) and a BeagleBoard. If you have a webcam lying around this is a lot cheaper than any baby monitor out there. If you have a webcam and a raspberry pi or something lying around, it's free. Point-to-point encrypted video from a sender with a GoPro plugged in with a USB cable to a receiver at 192.168.0.2: Sender: curl http://172.29.114.51/gp/gpWebcam/START?res= # Put GoPro in webcam mode ffmpeg -nostdin -threads 1 -i 'udp://@0.0.0.0:8554?overrun_nonfatal=1&fifo_size=50000000' -f:v mpegts -fflags nobuffer -vcodec copy -acodec copy -f rtp_mpegts -srtp_out_suite AES_CM_128_HMAC_SHA1_80 -srtp_out_params ${FORTY_CHARACTER_PRIVATE_KEY} 'srtp://192.168.0.2:5005' Receiver: ffplay -srtp_in_suite AES_CM_128_HMAC_SHA1_80 -srtp_in_params ${FORTY_CHARACTER_PRIVATE_KEY} 'srtp://192.168.0.2:5005'
- Condition1952 3y agoYou don’t need a baby monitor. You just need a laptop, Signal and a mobile phone
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoLast thing I want are internet enabled baby monitors. Give me a radio and some authentication so I can pair the base station without somebody listening in.
- rasz 3y ago$400 is just a filter, if you can afford to be so uniformed to spend $400 on a webcam you can afford the subscription.
- anotherhue 3y agoI submitted this story a few times a month or so ago, glad to see it getting some traction. We have two of these monitors so are extra annoyed. The absence of consumer protection for online dependent services is astounding.
- nilespotter 3y agoSomewhat off-topic, my apologies, but as this thread is sort of anti-IoT themed, can anyone recommend a robot vacuum that can be used without a route to the Internet?
- 31337Logic 3y agoWe used a pair of cheap walkie talkies we already owned (though you could easily pick up for cheap-to-free, I bet). Bonus that it doesn't operate at any potentially unhealthy levels.
- more_corn 3y agoNo, you need a return.