3 ms·
Skill exists. Some of us are programmers. Some of us are artists, musicians, writers, photographers, engineers. The time we put into our craft, learning, practi
by krapp 3y ago
Skill exists. Some of us are programmers. Some of us are artists, musicians, writers, photographers, engineers. The time we put into our craft, learning, practicing, has real value. AI does not replicate that value, at best it only steals it. We aren't united by shared capacity, because the capacity belongs to the AI, not to you. We don't share understanding because, when a black box does all the work, there's nothing for you to understand.
You're standing in the dojo wearing the black belt you bought at Wal-Mart and condescending to the masters for acting as if any of the discipline and hard work they put in meant anything, because look - you have the same belt as everyone else, and didn't have to do shit for it.
This is why people hate AI and the people who use it.
- bobsmooth 3y ago>This is why people hate AI and the people who use it. And you all sound like luddites.
- krapp 3y agoAnd you don't understand what the Luddites were about, because they weren't wrong.
- bobsmooth 3y agoYes, they were. Technology always advances. You either adapt or get left behind. You're just mad because after 100 years of industrialization it's finally coming after your job.
- krapp 3y agoTo hell with progress. I don't want to live in the future where corporate black box AIs generate everything society considers "art" and "culture", where no one knows how to so much as code a for loop or draw a stick figure because human expression no longer has an outlet. I don't want to simply be forced to adapt to a life where my only option is to blindly consume what the machines feed me like I'm in a tube in the Matrix. Yes. It does make me mad. And I should be mad. Everyone who cares about anything but the bottom line should be mad. The wholesale commoditization and destruction of human intellectual skill and creative talent in service of the relentless pursuit of capitalism through automation is a bad thing and you should feel bad for cheering it on. "Adapt or get left behind" isn't what someone who actually cares about the quality of their craft says, it's what the Borg say before injecting their nanoprobes into your brain. "we only want to improve quality of life." Fuck that.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoI appreciate your righteous screed. I imagine it won't be a decade before we see a fork in society between those who embrace a UBI and a world filled with bots, centaurs and llm-mediated-hive-minds and those who simply want nothing to do with it. Maybe the luddites made it clear that destroying capital doesn't make for a winning endgame, the Amish might be a better model - they still participate in the broader economy but they've built their pockets of antiquity where they get by with more elbow grease than they otherwise would have to, and have a spiritual basis for meaning that most of secular society lacks. I probably won't be joining them but could see a new movement that accepts diesel engines, lithium batteries and computers, but draws the line at anything that starts to mention "hidden layers" or "nondeterministic behavoir" (outside that randomness needed for accurate simulations and cryptography) Haven't come up with a name yet.
- bobsmooth 3y agoThe existence of AI art does not mean that human art won't be created. >I don't want to simply be forced to adapt to a life where my only option is to blindly consume what the machines feed me like I'm in a tube in the Matrix. How is that any different from your life now, except it's humans feeding you slop instead of human-guided machines? >Everyone who cares about anything but the bottom line should be mad. The wholesale commoditization and destruction of human intellectual skill and creative talent in service of the relentless pursuit of capitalism through automation is a bad thing and you should feel bad for cheering it on Go join an Amish commune then. I love the irony of a programmer (I'm assuming) complaining about automation.
- beepbooptheory 3y ago"Progess" itself, as construed by these people at least, is a specter. It is an empty faith for the sycophants, and a tool of compliance for the stakeholders. Hardly anyone ever asks where this progression is leading, and if they do, usually the answer is to "more progress." Which, to me, doesn't really sound like progression at all! It's just a way to justify not actually changing anything that matters, and to make sure there is always some faux-horizon of greener pastures to promise your customers. You should be angry!
- blibble 3y ago> You're just mad because after 100 years of industrialization it's finally coming after your job. what's your plan for when the only humans needed for the world economy to function are Musk and Zuckerberg? you certainly won't be needed
- bobsmooth 3y agoHasn't that been the goal of humanity since the first tool was invented?
- blibble 3y agoto engineer modern feudalism? I don't think so
- bobsmooth 3y agoTo have robots do all the work.
- pedrosorio 3y agoWhy would the ones who control the robots keep you and your descendants alive and enjoying the wealth generated from the robot work if you provide no value to them?
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y agoNo, you don't understand the Luddite in the slightest. https://www.vice.com/en/article/ae379k/luddites-definition-wrong-labor-technophobe https://www.vice.com/en/article/ae379k/luddites-definition-w... https://doctorow.medium.com/brian-merchants-blood-in-the-machine-a666e61846b1 https://doctorow.medium.com/brian-merchants-blood-in-the-mac... https://www.buzzsprout.com/1004689/13638517 https://www.buzzsprout.com/1004689/13638517
- bigstrat2003 3y agoThis argument isn't persuasive in the way you want it to be. If anything, it just makes people realize that the Luddites were more reasonable than they are given credit for.
- beepbooptheory 3y ago> This is why people hate AI and the people who use it. For me personally, I just hate that they don't stop talking about it! I think focusing on the AI-shit is missing my point: why do you even care about this? What is really at stake in this? Is it really just the idea that there is some kind injustice being done? An injustice to whom? If you spend your life doing all the hard work it takes to excel at something, the rewards of that hard work are intrinsic to your new mastery. What someone calls you or not because of your skill is like the least important thing about the entire pursuit. I too am quick to point out how annoying the AI stuff is, but I think if we are going to defeat them we need to hold on and affirm shared human capacity more than we need to protect titles.
- krapp 3y agoYou don't want to defeat them, you want people to stop complaining and accept AI with open arms. You don't even understand why anyone would think AI needs to be defeated, or why anyone would even care. That you seem to believe my comments are just about pride and ego and "protecting titles" suggests you either can't comprehend the nature of the arguments being made against AI, or refuse to. Fine. Don't say you weren't warned, though.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoI'm sorry I can't understand if your rhetoric here is saying that I really don't want to defeat them, or if none of us should want to. At least for the first one: I definitely do! "Defeat" is maybe a little clumsy, and its less wanting to squash AI itself (for one thing, because this new stuff isn't really "AI"), but rather what it represents and who is going to use it, or even right now, who is going to use the bare idea of it to hurt workers and demoralize us in general. The whole hype train is a big jumping of the shark of an already fraught and misguided industry. An industry propped up by senseless financial instruments and false ideals of technological determinism. It is no good! If you really can only see this whole argument as only a pure black and white dilemma, that either this guy is a "programmer" and AI is good || this guy is definitely not a programmer and AI is bad, then I would urge you maybe to invite more nuance into your thinking. But also not a big deal! It's more important we are on the same side about the big stuff, then whether we agree about words. Which was kinda my whole point all along!