9 ms·
HP fails to derail claims that it bricks scanners on printers when ink runs low
- farseer 3y agoI have been using using the HP P2055 network printer for almost two decades now with bootleg toner. Never had a problem, the thing is built like a tank.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoEven if you only print things once a month, a laser printer is far less wasteful in time, money, and bullshit than ink that's perpetually dry or consumed. Rather than an entry-level laser printer that cannot be economically repaired, a used mid-level enterprise printer is often the cheapest option long term and saves useful electronics from becoming e-waste. Office furniture rental/repo places and secondary markets like eBay have these. In large enterprises, a printer's cost per page tends to be inversely proportional to (increased) initial acquisition cost and availability of repair parts. Put another way, giving everyone an entry-level printer would be far more expensive in acquisition costs, per-page costs, and an inability to repair them. (hitting TCO 3 ways). I had a HP LaserJet 4 (released 1992, purchased new ~1994) until 2013 with a used JetDirect card. It had expansion options with cartridges and SIMM RAM and font options, but they weren't strictly needed.
- solarmist 3y agoAgreed. I have an HP Color LaserJet Pro and the toner is expensive, but lasts forever if I don't print and the quality is fantastic as well. Plus, they have automatic duplexing which is a must have feature for me. Newish ones like mine even support AirPrint and NFC printing.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoBuy color toner refill kits. Melt a hole in the cartridge with a soldering iron, refill it, and seal it with aluminum tape. Better to spend $70-150 than $300-1200 on new cartridges. PS: I'm currently in the market for an 5-15 year old HP Color LaserJet but still assessing which model tends to be more reliable. There were a lot of lemon SMB Color LaserJet models. Suggestions welcomed especially by staff IT people who support these things.
- solarmist 3y agoIt's expensive, but like $295 to replace all the color toners (high capacity), not $1200 or $300 each.
- bgirard 3y agoI followed this advice and it's been great. I have a $350 laser Brother printer, my iPhone can find the printer without fiddling with drivers, it wakes up, print, goes back to sleep. Works fine even if I go months without printing. After my last 'free ink forever' HP inkjet that never worked, a working printer is a blessing.
- esel2k 3y agoWhich brother do you have / recommend? I have been quiet happy with my OKI but the phone connection is the only letdown so far and I might change for a brother in the future.
- politelemon 3y agoI don't think you can go wrong with any Brother (or laser printer) as long as you don't need color printing. I have a DCP 1612W only for light printing. It works with Ubuntu, no special drivers required. I've had it for a few years now and I'm still on the toner the printer came with. If you need color printing, it tends to be expensive.
- Scoring6931 3y agoI have one of the same model. WiFi connection doesn’t seem to work. I’ve tried every troubleshooting article I could find, to the extent of setting a static IP for it in my router. Otherwise a great printer, but that issue did leave a bad taste in my mouth
- tivert 3y ago> Which brother do you have / recommend? I have been quiet happy with my OKI but the phone connection is the only letdown so far and I might change for a brother in the future. I have a brother HL-2270dw that I've been using for more than 10 years that I'm happy with. I don't think they make that exact model anymore, but Wirecutter recommends the HL-2350dw (I don't know what you get for the extra $10 to get a HL-2370dw): https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-home-printers/ https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-home-printer... I've got it hooked up to my wired network, and have never had an issue with it. I really like the duplex printing. I prefer my devices to do one thing, so I've avoided combo devices.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoSame thing. I have laser Xerox B230 for printing, because constantly dried up ink, especially when you need that printer NOW, was driving me crazy.
- Tepix 3y agoNowadays there are inkjet printers that are cheaper (cost per page) than laser printers. I would only get one if i were to print regularly, however. And never again HP of course.
- Retric 3y agoExamples? My research showed some inexpensive inkjets had reasonable cost per pages, but when you’re talking 10+k pages per month lasers easily win. They also win at the ultra low, 1 page per month side of things.
- coder543 3y agoI haven’t done the math to see if they’re right, but they’re likely talking about the various ink tank printers that exist, such as the Epson EcoTank series. Refilling the ink is supposed to be quite cheap, especially if you don’t care about the ink being name brand. Personally, I print like 5 pages a year, so unless I get into photo printing… the cheapest AirPrint-enabled Brother laser printer has served me well for like the last 5 years.
- Retric 3y agoThe nominal cost per page on those edge out many home office laser printers, but the printers themselves don’t last very long which then bumps up the cost per page. It’s like the razor blade model of inkjets use high ink costs and the unsubsidized bulk ink versions use planned obsolescence. Though it could just be the basic mechanics of inkjets as moving around the ink + print heads involves significant mechanical stress per page and EcoTank style inkjets prints lots of pages.
- coder543 3y ago> the printers themselves don’t last very long A high quality citation is seriously needed for a claim like that. That’s not a complaint I’ve ever heard about the EcoTank printers, and googling it didn’t turn up anything. I strongly doubt this is a characteristic of EcoTank printers. That unsourced claim sounds suspiciously convenient for your side of the discussion. Epson also makes a dedicated line of business EcoTank printers ("EcoTank Pro") which are clearly intended to print very large numbers of pages. But again, even the very basic ones seem to do a great job, with very high reviews across the board when I look at retailers.
- djaychela 3y agoAbsolutely. I have a laserjet 4000 I've had since I was given it in 2002 at an office clearance. It's printed about 10000 pages while I've had it,and in that time I've had to change the toner once. And I was given two original HP cartridges with the printer,and installed the first one a full 17 years after getting it. Worked perfectly,and is still in there. Works with windows, mac os, chromebooks without issue, all over the network. I even got a duplexer from gumtree a few years ago as it was going for nothing. One day it will die and then I'll have to deal with all the current printer grief!
- ryandrake 3y agoRIP my laserjet 4000. So many plastic pieces became brittle and finally broke, but it kept on working. Finally a few things went that could not be readily replaced/repaired and I finally gave up on it. It was a sad day. Of today's options, Brother is fine, but nothing compares to the GOAT.
- 2muchcoffeeman 3y agoHP laser keys are still difficult to replace the transfer belt. Go brother if you want a laser. All the consumables are easily replaceable.
- cptskippy 3y agoThere's no belt in a Laser Jet, at least not modern ones.
- 2muchcoffeeman 3y agoOh? What’s modern?
- cptskippy 3y agoTransfer belts are still used in high volume enterprise grade printers and print shops because of the speed advantages. But I haven't seen a transfer belt on a consumer laser printer in 20 years. I don't think they've been used on consumer laser printers since the early color laser jets in the late 90s.
- r00fus 3y agoMost inexpensive (ie, $200 or less) AirPrint (or google/MS equivalent) enabled BW laser printers are good solutions. I have a Canon that's lasted me several years of moderate printing (I hardly print but my kids love to print stuff out). Every year I buy a 2-pack of off-brand toner from Amazon for $30. When the printer complains, before replacing toner, I just pull out the existing toner, shake it, and get probably 10-50 more (faded but usable) prints.
- throwaway234524 3y agoBack in my university days some students owned (used) business color lasers solely for printing bootleg textbooks. 3rd party toner is cheap and a couple books already paid for the price of the unit.
- temporallobe 3y agoThis. About 5 years ago when my wife started her doctoral program, she started printing a ton of resources (and still does). We were constantly buying expensive ink monthly. I did some research and bought her a Brother laser printer for something like $300 and never looked back. You do have to buy toner about once a year, but it’s far more cost effective and efficient. Now if I could somehow convince her to use PDFs instead!
- yieldcrv 3y agoyeah same, I ditched inkjets for a canon laserjet you just have to value your time and then it all makes sense
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoI just installed a new NOS toner cartridge in a 20 year old HP 4050n. The big caveat with those is that the old cartridges have long been out of production and the dried up rubber seals on them crumble into bits after removing the OE sealing strip. You need to fill in the opening to prevent toner from vibrating out into the machine.
- userbinator 3y agoParts and consumables are still available for the LaserJet 4.
- usr1106 3y agoIn the 1990s HP was a great brand. Nowadays it's a nightmare. My neighbor asked me to troubleshoot one. Obviously the whole printer cannot be used without WiFi and a connection to HP cloud nonsense. Only that the cloud and Windows driver could not agree whether the printer had been set up or not. And the neighbor could not remember their HP account. It took me 2 hours to figure out how to do a factory reset. 1990 a printer was a peripheral and if you had a driver it worked. Today it's a spyware, ink-selling nonsense.
- davisr 3y agoThis underscores why libre software is so important: if you don't control the software running on your devices, then somebody else does. One day, that somebody /will/ work against your interests. Don't let that happen. Apply the (A)GPL and put an end to the bullshit.
- wolverine876 3y agoBuy their corporate line of printers, which work as you expect (at least the ones I've seen).
- cyberax 3y ago> 1990 a printer was a peripheral and if you had a driver it worked. LOL no. Printing and scanning have ALWAYS been terrible. A fortune cookie somewhere: "GNU is a printer driver gone horribly wrong". I have a theory that printer drivers are somehow produced by aliens, who are hellbent on destroying the Earth's infrastructure.
- JohnMakin 3y agoif you print things once a month go to your nearest staples and print it there for a couple bucks
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoConsider standby power consumption though if you aren't going to manually turn it on and off. The old printers may be very expensive in that regard.
- londons_explore 3y agoI was annoyed to find that a laser printer I've had for a decade used 30 watts just to keep the network link up, while the manual claimed it used 0.5 watts while on standby. 30 watts over 10 years is about $500 where I'm at...
- jojohohanon 3y agoI swear by the lowest end brother duplexing monochrome laser printer. Mine is the dw2270 which was <$150 at the time. Rock solid. No fuss ever. I’ve praised it here before. It’s the sort of printer that I wonder they stay in business selling because each customer is a customer for life but only buys one item.
- Johnny555 3y ago>Even if you only print things once a month, a laser printer is far less wasteful in time, money, and bullshit than ink that's perpetually dry or consumed Especially if you only print things once a month a laser printer is better, otherwise as you said your ink will dry out or you'll consume more ink in cleaning cycles than in printing. My wife has an office size inkjet printer that she uses nearly daily (prints ~500 - 1000 pages/month for work) and it works flawlessly, ink is cheaper than toner for her old laser printer. If she was only printing once a month, I'm sure the inkjet would be less reliable or economical.
- ornornor 3y ago100%. I have a 5–10 years old business HP laserjet and it just works. It’ll happily take third party consumables that cost around 25$ for 5k pages. It’s firewalled off the internet just in case. I paid 30$ for it on the classifieds. HP’s consumer stuff has been hit garbage for a while now. I don’t know about their more recent enterprise stuff.
- tinus_hn 3y agoBe aware of two things: Modern HP is not the HP of the LaserJet 4. The new printers, also the lasers, are crap. And second, these old printers are workhorses but they waste energy like crazy, the standby mode still uses a lot of power so unless your electricity is free it very quickly makes sense to replace them.
- yourusername 3y ago>Rather than an entry-level laser printer that cannot be economically repaired, a used mid-level enterprise printer is often the cheapest option long term and saves useful electronics from becoming e-waste. Office furniture rental/repo places and secondary markets like eBay have these. My print volume is extremely low, my 70 euro Samsung has lasted me over a decade. I suspect i'll be dead before i see any savings on a mid level enterprise printer, assuming the thing lasts decades without the rubber inside it disintegrating. If i have to service it my grandchildren will have to reap those savings. I decided to go completely printerless. So far i've gone about a year without printing anything. I don't think there is anything in my life that still requires a printer.
- jdthedisciple 3y agoYou must be lucky. Some places are still cursed with enough antiquated forms of red tape that it becomes impossible to do so...
- ed_elliott_asc 3y agoIt might very well be the better option but the printing execs want their subscription pricing dollars.
- bArray 3y agoI recently purchased an Epson Eco Tank printer (their budget mono without a scanner) [1], I'm quite impressed so far. The first thing I did was print 200+ pages, and it kept up well. My biggest cost now is the price of paper (as it should be). I would suggest ink jet still could be useful, especially with cheap refillable ink rather than this expensive cartridge bullshit. I remember years ago wanting to buy a new ink cartridge for my HP printer. In the shop the printer was something like £25 (printer + scanner, black + colour ink) - or - I could pay something like £20 for black and £25 for colour cartridges. I explained to the service person "so you're telling me, it would be cheaper for me to buy a new printer, throw the printer in the bin and just take the cartridges out?". They answered "yeah". I tried to refill the ink cartridge manually with a syringe and an online guide, but never could get it to work due to their "smart secure" cartridge lock-ins. HP time and time again prove to be a massive problem in the printing industry. I think I have said on HN a few times that I would be very much interested in building an open source ink jet printer (including head) - it can't be impossible. [1] https://www.epson.co.uk/en_GB/for-home/ecotank https://www.epson.co.uk/en_GB/for-home/ecotank
- poulpy123 3y agoI bought a first price laser printer few years ago, it was twice the price of a inkjet printer with the same quality, and B&W only but it paid itself by having more ink in the package and not having ink drying when I'm not using it
- Simulacra 3y agoIt's like Mercedes trying to charge a monthly subscription fee for heated seats. When you do something like this to consumers, you lose their trust and you will never gain it back.
- Tomte 3y agoUnfortunately, people will misremember and trash unrelated brands' reputations online. It was BMW.
- barbazoo 3y agoOr maybe they just misremembered the exact shitty thing the brand did https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-63743597 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-63743597 > Mercedes-Benz is to offer an online subscription service in the US to make its electric cars speed up quicker.
- throwaway20304 3y agoMercedes did something similar, though: https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-63743597 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-63743597
- gruez 3y agoAFAIK they offered monthly, yearly, and "unlimited" subscription. In that case what's the issue? Heated seats are frequently an upgrade option. What's the problem with offering payments as an option?
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoAnd, in fact, if you're only going to keep the car for a few years, the subscription may be cheaper.
- SuperNinKenDo 3y agoWell, let's use our imagination for a minute and consider why they'd be happy to sell and "unlimited subscription", but not a subscriptionless, permanent feature. Or rather than imagination, simply draw on experience with other companies and ither subscription models.
- seanhunter 3y agoAs I sit here I look at my HP-35S and HP-12C calculators that I have on my desk. My 12-C in particular is about 15 years old and still on its original battery. I remember fondly the HP-85a that I learned programming on when I was 8 years old or so. HP used to make amazingly great hardware. The first HP laserjet printers were an absolute marvel. It makes me so sad what has happened to HP.
- bitwize 3y agoBack in the days when HP was a scientific-equipment company, everything they made was built like a tank. Still have fond memories of the HP-7475A plotter.
- PopePompus 3y agoThere is no sadder story in American capitalism than the decline of HP from a wonderful equipment engineering company to a racket for selling tiny little tubs of overpriced ink. Think a young Steve Jobs would be excited to get a job there now?
- sneak 3y agoBoeing, perhaps. The same thing happened there, as I understand it. There’s also a strong argument for post-Jobs Apple being an even more tragic arc (that’s earlier on the curve). Time will tell. These things happen on the order of decades, not years. Brain drain is real.
- PopePompus 3y agoGood point! At least the sad husk of HP isn't killing people.
- FredPret 3y agoWhen’s the last time Boeing killed anyone?
- whartung 3y agoI don't have a laser simply because I haven't seen an "all in one" full color laser that's as compact as the Epson inkjet I'm using. I can't speak to the color quality of lasers really vs inkjet, but I've printed a bunch of photos that come out "good enough" on photo paper with my printer. Mind, if we need any volume, we ship 'em off to the drugstore, but that can actually be a bit of pot luck when it comes to framing and such. We use the scanner often enough to make it worthwhile, and we don't have the room for a second, compact B&W laser. The only real thing I need to do is replace this with a tank version. Ink is still crazy, but momentum keeps us going with it. A full set of ink cartridges cost about 1/2 of a new printer. Other than that, I'm pretty content with this thing.
- Macha 3y agoYou probably won't find one as compact, colour laser printers are basically 4 monochrome laser printers in a row with different colour toners loaded, the process doesn't lead itself to having small toner catridges on a moving head like how inkjet work. This is a plus and a minus. The minus you've found, they're pretty bulky, but reducing moving parts also has pluses for durability and lifespan.
- snitzr 3y agoMy in-laws needed a printer scanner because they are getting old and needed to scan paperwork to move to a retirement community. They went out and bought an HP printer scanner and asked me to help them set it up. It took me multiple hours and I still couldn't figure everything out. It took them the next two days to really get it up and running. Poorly designed actively hostile software.
- wly_cdgr 3y agoIt's just so low and shabby. How can anyone work for a company that does this and not feel constant shame? Any decent person should and would.
- 20after4 3y agoThat's the thing, all the decent people (who had a choice) left years ago. All that's left is marketing nitwits, indifferent assholes and people with H1B visas who are largely helpless and trapped.
- jononomo 3y ago[flagged]
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoSir this is a Wendy’s.
- jononomo 3y agoYeah, I lost it a bit there and I deserved those downvotes.
- ajb 3y agoBecause of this kind of thing I haven't actually replaced my printer, since it broke, and have been actively looking for ways to avoid doing so. - In the UK, Royal mail will now print the label for you, when you order a collection. DPD claims to do so when you drop off but the shops often turn out not to have a printer - Libraries print more cheaply than shops, neither are suitable for printing where confidentiality is required (your doc is likely to hang round on some random insecure PC) - They don't advertise it, but some print-to-mail companies (eg CFH docmail) will do print runs down to a single copy. This is considerably cheaper than your local shop, for more than a couple of sheets at least, but has a latency of 5 days. It's suitable for confidential prints (for most plausible threat models), due to their scale. Also, if you intended to mail the doc anyway, you can send it direct from them.
- kibwen 3y ago> Libraries print more cheaply than shops Highlighting this. My local library lets you print 100 pages per month for free (color printing counts for three pages), which is more than enough for my needs these days.
- Justsignedup 3y agoBuy a brother laser printer. Anything that's not a laser printer is not worth it except for very very very specific use cases. Because of this laser printers are actually profitable to sell. So they don't have to loss leader their income from you.
- perfectstorm 3y ago+1 to Brother laser printer. i had mine for over 5 years and it still works great (i had to replace the original toner cartridge once). i recently had some smudges on printed paper and a quick chatGPT search later i was following Brother's troubleshooting guide which helped me get rid of the smudge (essentially showed me how to clean the print header). i even bought an updated printer for my parents whose old hp laser printer died after a firmware update (there are posts about it in their support forum).
- mattlondon 3y agoCanon 100% does this on my printer/scanner if the ink dries up (long time without printing) or it thinks you have pirate ink. It throws up some error message that you can't clear until you put in new ink cartridges. This is very annoying as I scan frequently but very, very rarely print. I'd readily replace it but I cannot find a laser printer with duplex scanner with ADF that isn't obscenely expensive and/or huge.
- distract8901 3y agoI had a Brother brand B&W laser printer with a duplex scanner many years ago. I had it for 10 years and it was still working when my ex took it. As far as I know its still going. Unfortunately, laser printers are just bigger than inkjet. The paper route is more complicated and the mechanism has to be larger. That's the benefit of inkjet, it's an extremely simple mechanism that can be reduced to a very small footprint. IMO, laser is better in almost every way. It's well worth the drawbacks.
- subhro 3y agoXerox C315?
- mjcohen 3y agoYou might try a separate duplex scanner. Less than $200. There are a number of very compact ones. Connect with wi-fi or usb.
- smeej 3y agoI'm surprised how many people are writing about their solutions for printing. I thought by now most people had done what I've done and just set things up not to need to print. Xournal allows me to fill out anything I could print from PDF with a stylus on my touch screen. If I want to read and highlight something, I convert it to PDF and read it in Logseq with the same stylus. I can highlight in four colors and it automatically collects my notes! If I need to mail/ship something, I just have the ship shop print it. What are people intentionally printing to paper for, often enough that it's worth having a printer?
- mattlondon 3y agoMany places still ask you to physically sign and then scan/post back things. E.g fill in a pdf with a computer then print and manually sign with a pen. It is not every day, but frequently enough that not having a printer is a pain.
- smeej 3y agoI scanned a copy of my signature probably a decade ago and have yet to find anyone who can tell the difference between my adding that to a doc and sending it back, and actually printing, signing, and scanning it back.
- dsr_ 3y agoWrite your signature. Scan it in. Apply it to documents that want signatures. To some people, this doesn't "feel right" the same way that it doesn't "feel right" that I have rolling star-base office chairs around my dining room table. They are far more comfortable than any "dining room chair" I've ever been in. In both cases, when people don't take my good advice, I shrug and move on.
- mattlondon 3y agoOk sure so use a pen or use the printer to write your signature - that doesn't change the need sometimes to go give the doctor/school/solicitor/etc a physical copy. You can keep your "good" advice, but please do move on.
- Lucasoato 3y agoIn my case, after one year and an half my HP printer auto-updated (without my consent) and bricked because I was using the ink from a different brand. This happened even if I didn’t subscribe to their shitty Hp instant ink offer. I’ve immediately returned it, bought a Brother printer and I will avoid any HP product for the rest of my life. I’m genuinely worried that companies will just perpetually try to get into dark patterns, until laws will be powerless against them. People should spend years in jail for coming up with ideas like these…
- CamperBob2 3y agoHow'd you get the return accepted after a year and a half? That's pretty impressive service. People should spend years in jail for coming up with ideas like these… +1 for sure on that. It'll never happen, though. We wouldn't want to pass laws to interfere with "innovation."
- SoftTalker 3y agoPossibly bought at Costco or similar that will take returns pretty much indefintely.
- kd5bjo 3y agoIn the EU, basically everything comes with a minimum warranty of 2 years[1]. If your printer will no longer print within that time, the retailer is required to fix, replace, or refund it. [1] https://europa.eu/youreurope/business/dealing-with-customers/consumer-contracts-guarantees/consumer-guarantees/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/business/dealing-with-customers...
- dbttdft 3y agoThese kinds of bugs are common with all consumer electronics since they "went digital" though, basically anything 1999+. The market is so saturated with blatantly broken products like this that you seem like a freak just to complain about it. Just littered with shit design mainly caused by duct taping components together and letting the outcome of that be the design. The solution is for consumers to get a brain and stop wasting it on overcomplicated nonsense like some autoconfiguration crap based on XML that never works except for someone who so happens to have 5 hours of experience with that protocol. Just return bullshit like this. I always do, I decide to return most of my electronics within 5 minutes of first turning it on.
- strbean 3y agoThis pattern emerged around the same time as "can't print black when out of colored ink" and "printer cartridge DRM". I'm extremely incredulous that this is a bug rather than intentional.
- j45 3y agoBrands like Brother, Epson are far more preferable to HP, etc in the multi function printer category for many reasons.
- dosman33 3y agoIn the 2010's I had a project I'd do about once a year where I needed to print ~100 pages of directions that was mostly text with light-duty images mixed in for products I was selling. I was using my trusty inkjet printer, but over time the capacity of the carts degraded to the point I could only get ~80 pages of B&W printing out of a single inkjet cartridge. I had tried buying refill carts but they consistently failed and cost me time I couldn't afford to loose so I also gave up on non-authentic carts. So that meant I was having to buy two inkjet carts each run which pushed my cost per print up towards nearly $1 per page... for a product I was selling for $20. I finally had enough and bought an HP full color laser printer for $250 around 2015 or so. Even with the degraded toner carts that came with it out of the box I was able to cut my cost per sheet down to about 25 cents or better. The last set of toner refills I got hurt my wallet at ~$450, but my price-per-sheet gets down to a dime per sheet on those. I'm thankful my printer proceeds these nutty subscription drivers though! I swore off ever using inkjet again after my first season of use on this laserjet. But of course I'm thankful this printer proceeded these nutty drivers that disable your printing without a subscription. We've reached the end of the infinite expansion economic system and subscription services are the natural next step to that. Market forces have driven down the cost of durable goods to the point most consumer goods have been disposable for decades now. The next step is subscription models of everything to maintain similar profit margins. Likewise, CBDC's are a natural extension of the banking system as it hits the same growth limits. They outright state in their whitepapers that one of their core purposes is to "prevent recessions" by setting expiration terms on funds held by consumers which will "induce spending" as needed. It's all the same ball of wax.
- ryukoposting 3y agoI have an Epson flatbed scanner for my photography, a V600. It's a lovely little device. Crapware-free functionality. Granted, it seems like the bundled software hasn't been updated since the stone age, but that might be a good thing. My HP inkjet, on the other hand, is a wreck. I had to install an app on my phone, pair over bluetooth, connect it to wi-fi, and create an account just to get a damn test page. No USB cable included, by the way. Many cursing matches eventually got it working, but I regret buying it. Once the ink runs out, I'll probably send it to Goodwill or something.
- vel0city 3y agoScanning is the only thing that Brother has let me down on the whole working without extra software idea. Scanning in Windows without their software stack just can't get the same quality scans. It's limited to 600dpi, it doesn't have as crisp quality, and it doesn't natively do PDF. Installing the drivers and software stack, it'll do multipage PDF at 1200dpi looking crisp no problem.
- ryukoposting 3y agoMy Epson will do 6400dpi optically, but it can do some upsampling shenanigans all the way up to 12800dpi. Unnecessary levels of resolution for documents, but it's amazing what it can do for your grandma's old film slides. It's not cheap, but the performance is hard to argue with.
- hakfoo 3y agoOne thing I've noticed is that the bottom of the standalone scanner market completely disappeared. You used to be able to easily find parallel-port flatbed scanners for $50 or less, and they eventually shifted to USB. I suspect it was often used to "fluff out" a PC bundle-- "Buy a $1200 AMD-K6 machine and get a scanner and terrible inkjet printer free!" They were probably more than ample for the "scan in this document we need a copy of" use cases-- a few hundred DPI. While I still see there are a handful of sub-$100 scanners on the market, it's hardly the variety you used to find. It's like a "compliance" product-- being sold because they need to to fill some obligation rather than a vital market full of advancement. Also note that it's a lot less easy to do the "recycle quality vintage hardware" thing for scanners than printers. Many of them are stranded with ancient drivers and often no support past WinXP or 7. (Yes, there's things like VueScan for ongoing support, but paying for that impacts the overall math). I ended up finding a scanner I sort of liked used that did have drivers (Epson V39, I wanted something USB powered because I don't have room for any more power bricks) but it involved way too much Googling in the electronics aisle of secondhand shops. I assume that this is because the market has basically assumed anyone not buying commercial-grade stuff will buy an all-in-one reliability nightmare that won't scan without yellow ink. This sort of thing didn't occur in other markets: They sold low-end VCRs and DVD players built into crappy TVs, but they also still sold standalone ones.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoI picked up a colour laser Brother MFC for $100 three years ago, with 600 DPI scanner / copier. Wifi printing from our phones works with no additional setup than having the printer connected to wifi. It needed new drums and toners, and continues to function like new to this day. Not quite $50, but $100 Australian, so not far off.
- akrotkov 3y agoThe lack of a low end scanner market could also be attributed to the fact that everyone these days has a device with a camera that is either good enough or in some cases better for digitizing documents than those old scanners.
- 3y ago
- carom 3y agoI bought the best printer on wire cutter a few years ago, it was an HP ink jet. That was the biggest piece of garbage I ever bought. It would refuse to print when it was low on ink. It would be low on some random color despite me printing in black and white, rarely at that. It locked me out over using after market ink. I bought a brother laser jet and love it.
- kakaz 3y agoMaybe I put there a note that HP produced SSD server disks which fault at preengeneered number of writes, making your raid faulty. No one should ever use this brand
- adrenvi 3y agoWhat is this trend of the headline, sub-headline and first sentence being totally identical? It feels like I've been violated somehow, like a mild brainwashing. One less reason to click on the article link.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Angostura 3y agoI know a lot of people say just get a laser, but I just want to shout out to my bottom of the range Canon Pixma inkjet I bought about 3 years ago. It’s solid, works with third party inks, supports airprinting from my phone and has never caused me any trouble. It’s the second barebones Pixma I’ve had. Previous one lasted about 7 years.
- ed_elliott_asc 3y agoI’m looking forward to the day there is a HN post about printers that doesn’t go straight “buy a low priced laser printer… I have a xx from 1987 and it is working just fine”
- HybridCurve 3y agoIf you come across a newer HP printer, the best thing you can do with it is disassemble it for parts to make other things. They are full of precision rods, rotary encoders, DC motors, and such. If it has a built-in scanner, you'll also get a contact image sensor and a decent pane of glass. But on no circumstances should you ever expect rely on it to function as an output or input device.
- egberts1 3y agoStill, our only recourse on a good reliable laser jet is the Brothers mid- range printers. Do not select the models that touts the “Refresh” feature (that one phones home and gives all your LAN deets to Brothers. It is getting slim pickier nowadays for a privacy-oriented and quality printer.
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoHP's existence has become free advertising for Brother.
- eMPee584 3y ago"HP is committed to becoming the world's most sustainable and equitable technology company" .. while maximizing device quality, shareholder profit and executive salaries at the same time. Absolutely no conflict of interest. Funny capitalism.