12 ms·
Singapore: Right to own a car costs $76,000. And that doesn't include the car
- repelsteeltje 3y agoKeep in mind that this is also the country that fined shops selling chewing gum up to S$2,000. Incentives uses to nudge our behaviours... Why not — to the max. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chewing_gum_sales_ban_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chewing_gum_sales_ban_in_Singa...
- pclmulqdq 3y agoThis is also the place that famously canes people for petty crimes.
- avgcorrection 3y agoAnd a death penalty for smuggling drugs. EDIT: It seems that Singapore is more authorian than I thought (based on the Human Rights Wikipedia article). People would be complaining more about that were it not for the fact that it is a market-based economy.
- lostlogin 3y agoOn the bright side, the LGBT community got some rights this year. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Singapore https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_rights_in_Singapore
- eddmakesio 3y agoLook at what drugs can do to a place (SF) - if it works maybe it's worth it?
- lostlogin 3y agoThey also have a well regarded healthcare system. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_Singapore
- boeingUH60 3y agoMakes me love Singapore the more. Very pragmatic leadership. Can't be characterized as "right-leaning" or "left-leaning" or whatever...it's like the leaders just sat down and thought, "Let us borrow any idea that works and implement in our country"...grew from third-world levels of poverty to enviable first-world development in a few decades. I'm not Singaporean and have never visited if you're wondering...
- eddmakesio 3y agoNot just enviable, they have the worlds highest GDP per capita, the only Asian country with a triple AAA rating by all ratings bodies, good integration policies (low crime but basically a 20/20/20/20 split between Buddhism, Atheism, Christianity, and Islam - not completely 20:20:20:20 but can't remember the right numbers and it's close-ish), one of the highest life expectancies in the world, and pretty awesome food! It's almost like cracking down on crime in a tough way with liberal economics can lead to a great place to live.
- lostlogin 3y agoUser Joak lived there and has posted here - it’s an interesting take. The oppressive state behaviour has repercussions in their view.
- avgcorrection 3y agoPrivileged migrants (I mean expats) might not be terribly affected by how unfree or authoritarian a society is. > As an expat, the censorship and oppression was only materialized by the absence of a decent art scene.
- Gibbon1 3y ago> what drugs can do to a place (SF) I miss raves and house parties in 90's San Francisco.
- eddmakesio 3y agoAt least the Tenderloin has a 24/7 block party! /s
- boeingUH60 3y agoWhen I see how people behave recklessly in some places, I'll be low-key wishing for this kind of law.
- sokoloff 3y agoCrimes for which judicial caning applies seem like fairly serious ones to me: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_in_Singapore
- jonathankoren 3y agoOne of most famous cases was a dipshit American with a spray can, so you and I are going to have disagree about the definition of “serious” crimes. Especially when the entire impetus of the vandalism law to stop graffiti protesting the ruling party in 1966. (Previously, vandalism was punished by a small fine, rather than caning.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_of_Michael_Fay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caning_of_Michael_Fay
- sokoloff 3y agoVandalism is a felony in my state (Massachusetts). That seems to define it as being a serious crime here.
- gottorf 3y agoI wonder how many people have been actually convicted of vandalism in Massachusetts?
- sokoloff 3y agoLooks like tens of thousands of occurrences per year and thousands "cleared" (unclear how close to 'convicted' that is, nor on whether all 'criminal damage' is vandalism). https://ma.beyond2020.com/ma_tops/report/crime-overview/massachusetts/2022 https://ma.beyond2020.com/ma_tops/report/crime-overview/mass... How many people have been caned for vandalism in Singapore? I'd wager that far, far more people have a felony vandalism conviction in MA than were caned for it in Singapore.
- jonathankoren 3y ago
- zolbrek 3y agoForget a few grams of bud in your suitcase while transiting through Singapore? Just get a handed a death sentence as a foreign national, hope you enjoy your holiday execution.
- jessepasley 3y agoEverybody knows the laws, why would you insist on breaking them?
- zolbrek 3y agoWhat makes you think I insist on breaking Singaporean laws?
- laweijfmvo 3y agoWhere is it legal to bring weed across country or even state lines? There's no way to "forget" to remove something from your luggage that's universally illegal, unless you've choosen to flout the law because it's easy to get away with elsewhere.
- jondwillis 3y agoYou’ve never left something in a pocket before, or dropped something into an open suitcase without noticing it?
- jessepasley 3y agoMaybe coins or random pocket trash, but never illegal drugs. I think I would notice 500 grams of weed, which is the minimum to receive the death penalty in Singapore.
- zolbrek 3y agoHalf a kilo isn't easy to overlook, I'll give you that.
- expertentipp 3y agoWhen I count all my pieces of clothing damaged by chewing gums, recall the felling of disgust when accidentally touching a chewing gum attached under a seat or table, see the awful black stains created by trampled chewing gums... yes, this industry deserves it.
- avgcorrection 3y agoI always throw chewing gum in the bin. But I guess if only one in a thousand does not do that then you can end up with gum all over the asphalt (in a city state).
- gwbas1c 3y agoHaving spent my entire life where chewing gum is legal, I find this attitude absurd. What are we going to do next, ban farting?
- expertentipp 3y agoOnce farting will become billions dollar industry with fat executive boards, with stars and celebrities advertising farting as a way of living, and farting casually introduced in mainstream movies. Then some farting restrictions might be really necessary.
- peteradio 3y ago> farting casually introduced in mainstream movies That could actually be pretty funny.
- LargoLasskhyfv 3y agoDo you know https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0387808/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0387808/ ?
- 11235813213455 3y agoI like this, particularly their rules against cigarette smoking, that ruins my day and air outside
- cm2012 3y agoI wish I could ban weed smoke smell in NYC. One person smoking makes a 30 foot diameter smell like skunk. Just use edibles and/or vapes people!
- daxaxelrod 3y agoRight? I always feel worried about getting a contact high through the second hand smoke too.
- jondwillis 3y agoThat is very unlikely to ever happen in all but the most enclosed situations, by the way.
- unforeseen9991 3y agoBack in my day we used to hotbox on purpose lol. 6 people all crowded into a small bathroom, towel under the door
- goodbyesf 3y ago> One person smoking makes a 30 foot diameter smell like skunk. Even better, a couple of idiots in a car smoking with their windows rolled down. I'm all for banning smoking cigarettes or weed in public spaces. If you want to ruin your health, do it in the privacy of your own house.
- cm2012 3y agoEven in your house, so many apartments have shit ventilation. Weed smell goes into windows, hallways, etc.
- chaostheory 3y agoTo be fair, it does work if you value security above both freedom and creativity. Singapore is one of the safest if not the safest city on earth when it comes to crime
- theironhammer 3y agoI was told by someone who lived in Singapore it was because people put the chewing gum on the lasers that counted passengers on the transit system. It was an expensive system.
- expertentipp 3y agoChewing gums were probably put on many places and things, and their removal was nasty and expensive.
- janandonly 3y agoI guess living in a city state means that for your needs walking 8or on rainy days, public transport, will be sufficient. Another post today made this point: city’s are not noisy, but cars are.
- sokoloff 3y agoEven the car-free parts of cities are noisy. Go to any bar or restaurant district in a pedestrian-only zone with a sound meter and tell me it’s quiet and I’ll tell you that your hearing aids and meter’s batteries need to be replaced. Cars are noisy. People are noisy, whether inside or outside of cars.
- trgn 3y agoweird. Walkable cities are much more quiet than the car ones. Sure, a busy area is noisy from revelers. Cars are just loud technology, compared to bikes or walking.
- estebank 3y agoYou're wrong. https://www.chem.purdue.edu/chemsafety/Training/PPETrain/dblevels.htm https://www.chem.purdue.edu/chemsafety/Training/PPETrain/dbl...
- mytailorisrich 3y agoI think that the fact that this is a city state is a bit of a red herring here. It's like living in Manhattan/Brooklyn and cost of owning a car in such locations will naturally include cost of parking space. So this is really a conscious decision to use taxes to limit cars for the majority of people while letting the rich have one but I suppose it'll always be that way.
- saltysalt 3y agoEVs?
- gnicholas 3y agoA college friend of mine was from Singapore. After he got a job at FAANG, he bought an Aston Martin. He said it was so cheap compared to owning a fancy car in Singapore, that it was an appealing deal from his perspective. I learned that his tires cost as much as my car. A year or two later, he bought an second Aston. He eventually moved back to Singapore, but kept his cars here, at his in-laws house.
- alephnerd 3y agoDid your Singaporean friend's family have a house in Singapore? If so, that explains how they could afford a couple Aston Martins. For reference - house ownership is almost impossible in SG without either being old money or making millions and moving back.
- puppymaster 3y agoDifficulty in owning a house in singapore is pretty similar to other developed countries. Like in HK, they have HDB (Housing Development Board) flats, which are government-subsidized housing, the median price is around S$500,000 (approximately $372,000 in USD). Only citizens and PRs can buy with subsidies for first time home owner. I would say around 60-80% singaporeans live on HDB housing.
- alephnerd 3y agoI said a house, not a HDB flat. A detached house in SG goes for millions of USD [0] on top of having PR and Citizenship requirements. This is because they are Freeholds (aka if you buy the property, you also own the land underneath). HDB flats are also leaseholds (aka 99 year leases). My ex's family HDB was screwed after the govt began the whole Jurong East expansion there a couple years ago. Unsurprisingly her family voted Workers Party before switching to the PSP. [0] - https://www.propertyguru.com.sg/property-for-sale?market=residential&listing_type=sale&property_type=L&property_type_code[]=TERRA&property_type_code[]=DETAC&property_type_code[]=SEMI&property_type_code[]=CORN&property_type_code[]=LBUNG&property_type_code[]=BUNG&property_type_code[]=SHOPH&property_type_code[]=RLAND&property_type_code[]=TOWN&property_type_code[]=CON&property_type_code[]=LCLUS&search=true https://www.propertyguru.com.sg/property-for-sale?market=res...
- mistrial9 3y agothe people that collect that money, now have enough income to be car owners at that price
- Bostonian 3y agoI think climate activists want to drastically raise the cost of owning and operating a car, which will make a cars a luxury good unavailable to the middle class. As people catch on, this policy stance will become very unpopular.
- avgcorrection 3y agoGreens are already unpopular among that segment.
- jplrssn 3y agoIf the cost of owning and operating a car included paying for externalities like CO2 emissions it would already be unaffordable to the middle class. Internalizing those costs is only fair.
- gottorf 3y agoIf the full costs of existing as a human being were internalized, nobody would be able to afford to live. Existence itself imposes a cost on the environment. Even Grok the caveman had to burn wood for warmth, releasing CO2 and particulates into the atmosphere. I think the better approach is Locke's "enough and as good" proviso.
- avgcorrection 3y agoBurning wood (certainly before things like medieval deforestation) isn't a cost on the environment. The carbon from firewood is already “in cycle”. Unlike the carbon that is millions of years old that we have dug up from the ground. A false equivalence.
- gottorf 3y agoBurning wood is absolutely a cost on the environment; just ask anyone who grew up in homes heated by firewood. But of course, as you say, the scale is different. Should your example of medieval deforestation have been impermissible for environmental reasons, then? Where should the line be drawn? Who has the authority to draw that line? No (non-nuclear) renewable technology currently exists that can by itself meet the energy demands of developed world standards of living. I'm not sure if wind and solar alone can even meet a developing country's standard of living. I'd really like it if we could build a thousand new nuclear power plants, but of course, reality is often disappointing and we get things like Germany shutting down its nuclear reactors and burning more coal instead.
- boeingUH60 3y agoSingapore is a city-state with limited space and stellar public transport...the absurd cost of owning a personal vehicle is easily justifiable. You can hardly justify this structure in most other places...residents will revolt, lol A developed country is not a place where the poor have cars. It's where the rich use public transportation.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoFees to own gasoline cars in Norway and Denmark are fairly comparable as far as I understand, and they haven't revolted.
- HideousKojima 3y agoFees to own cars vs. fees to own gasoline cars, I'm sensing there's an important difference here.
- seper8 3y agoFairly comparable? Not even close
- dagw 3y agoThe 'fees' are primarily in the form of high taxes on new gasoline cars, and especially high taxes on new cars with large/powerful engines. If you want, say a BMW M3 with the biggest and most powerful engine, then you're probably paying a $76k premium compared to the US. If you want to buy a small 30 year old piece of crap then the additional taxes aren't anywhere near that high.
- karaterobot 3y agoIt looks like they pay a VAT, plus a greenhouse tax. But the greenhouse tax seems relatively small, equivalent to around $100 USD—though there are many factors that would change that number a little bit. The VAT is much higher, something like 25% of the vehicle price. But I would not consider VAT a tax on car ownership, per se, since it is applied to many other goods, and we would not consider a VAT levied on, say, a microwave to be a tax on microwave ownership.
- HenryBemis 3y agoI was in Singapore some months back. So clean, so humid+warm+sticky, and when I compare the headcount cost in various locations (countries & cities), for the same grade: 1 Singaporean = 1.3 Londoners 1 Singaporean = 1.8 Warsawians 1 Singaporean = 4 Chennaians So.. yes.. car ownership IS expensive but a "Director" in Singapore nets crazy amounts. And if you think car ownership is expensive.. wait to look to rent a flat in a cozy area...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- todotask 3y agoIt can be tough to find a full-time jobs as I found the prospect for web developer roles in the current economy is low that could left quite a lot of us jobless or pursue part-time jobs despite the workforce group has been keeping us in contact. Living between a multi-story car park (the rich parking their cars), luxury estate and a neighbour park (Punggol Park), with a construction noise pollution that can last 24 hours. I'm just a poor guy but I have been reaching government for assistance, yet failed lots of times. Those my neighbours just sleeping well.
- justrealist 3y agoSingapore's fertility rate is 1.1
- avgcorrection 3y agoAt this rate they might raise the military service time from two to four years.
- SXX 3y agoSingapore is one of few countries where population aging not gonna be a problem anytime soon due to how many immigrants are working, live there or just want to move there to live.
- justrealist 3y agoI think it would be ethical to consider that pricing current residents out of the chance to have a family is not good, and that a supply of willing immigrant meat into your fertility shredder metropolis does not cancel out the harm to actual people.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoOne would think they should make a lottery if they want to limit the number of cars. Like the Green card lottery for visa in the US. Then it would depend on income. And every person in the household can participate, so larger families with perhaps greater need would have higher chances of winning. Bidding also opens a lot of problems, see NYC taxi medallion auctions.
- SeanLuke 3y agoWhen I lived in Hong Kong long ago, IIRC there was an approximately 400% sales tax on new car sales.
- bogtog 3y ago> Failing that, there is the option of getting a motorbike – permits for which are a relative snip at $7,930 I don't understand why this is so much lower. Motorbikes can park in smaller spaces but on the road, require similar area/clearance
- foxyv 3y agoMotorcycles are a lot easier on infrastructure and are much less dangerous to other road users. (No A-pillars or blind spots) They take up way less space too. You can park 6 motorbikes in the space of one car. Keep in mind also, most of the bikes there are 125cc models for local deliveries and such.
- AndyMcConachie 3y agoI wish we had this cost where I live in The Netherlands. So many people here don't need cars.
- expertentipp 3y agoThen how will Wassenaar inhabitants and drug clans self-stigmatize? VanMoof and Urban Arrow bicycles and not that expensive.
- gottorf 3y agoIt's nice to be able to have things that you don't strictly need. In fact, you could call that human progress.
- poulpy123 3y agoironically I remember the jokes about owning cars in soviet union
- jonathankoren 3y agoI never understood public policies that making something so expensive only the wealthy can afford. Just make it illegal and seize the car for destruction. Same effect, and fairer.
- saltysalt 3y agoSeizing private property for destruction is fair?
- jonathankoren 3y agoYes. Much fairer than two tired system.
- saltysalt 3y agoHard nope from me, sorry. Seizing people's property and destroying it is never cool.
- jonathankoren 3y agoSeizing property used in the commission of a crime is done all the time, and has been done for hundreds, if not thousands, of years. What do you think happens to guns used in a robbery, or illegal drugs? You think they’re being sold off in a GSA auction?
- josephcsible 3y agoFor drugs, destruction makes sense since they're inherently illegal. But since you can legally own guns, they should be auctioned off.
- pauldenton 3y agoEquality by kneecapping the rich. Want to know how I can tell you are from California?
- pcdoodle 3y agoJanuary: 26°C (79°F) - 31°C (88°F) February: 26°C (79°F) - 31°C (88°F) March: 26°C (79°F) - 31°C (88°F) April: 26°C (79°F) - 32°C (90°F) May: 26°C (79°F) - 32°C (90°F) June: 26°C (79°F) - 31°C (88°F) July: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) August: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) September: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) October: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) November: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) December: 25°C (77°F) - 31°C (88°F) The temperature there is quite stable. Good place to try something like this.
- kmlx 3y ago> April: 26°C (79°F) - 32°C (90°F) i travelled there during April for a couple of weeks. big mistake, humidity was close to 100% every single day. i was literally sweating while sitting.
- nikonyrh 3y agoOn the other hand, the southern hemisphere is only 150 km away! I used to live there 2+ years, I think I could walk about 100 meters before I started really pushing the sweat. Also after a few months your body gets adjusted, and it is only 95% as bad as it used to :D
- kmlx 3y agoyup, this is what people that moved there were telling me. you get used to it.
- glimshe 3y agoGood luck getting elected in most of the world with such proposal.
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe]
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoSome more discussion over here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37770533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37770533
- totallywrong 3y agoIf you factor in the high salaries and super low taxes, it's not that bad. Also taxis and ubers are high-end cars readily available at very reasonable prices.
- tempaway36741 3y agocheck latest prices/bidding here https://onemotoring.lta.gov.sg/content/onemotoring/home/buying/coe-open-bidding.html https://onemotoring.lta.gov.sg/content/onemotoring/home/buyi...
- foxyv 3y agoThe USA needs to build a country where we can do this too. Car dependency is a scourge. The horrible housing policies of our states, counties, and cities is slowly destroying the fabric of our civilization. The fact that you need to own a car to exist in this country is absurd.
- tamimio 3y agoOver taxing a “need” in a way to counter it is never a good strategy, you will just make that need a privilege for the wealthy, destroying more and more the middle class. And yes, cars are a need in a lot of cases, places, countries, and environments, not using a car might work for your specific situation and/or city, but can not be generalized.