5 ms·
This is one of those sites that hijacks your scrolling, which I wish there was a standard for "please just let me scroll freely". It's not super awful but its k
by giancarlostoro 3y ago
This is one of those sites that hijacks your scrolling, which I wish there was a standard for "please just let me scroll freely". It's not super awful but its kind of annoying, I like to read things on either the top or bottom edge of my browser window so I dont lose my spot.
- dekken_ 3y agoit's super obnoxious, even when it's only slight sensitivity changes (which it isn't here) I notice it and feel violated
- Pfiffer 3y agoReal question: Why is this even allowed at a browser level?
- MenhirMike 3y agoBecause some people think that Browsers should be the ultimate app platform, so hijacking your inputs or preventing proper zoom makes sense to them even though it's utterly user hostile.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoWhich has led us to regress in terms of building GUI desktop apps. Remember the 2000s and 90s how you could make a somewhat native UI in Visual Basic 6 and Delphi, now you got to use an entire browser to get there.
- duped 3y agoI remember UIs causing BSODs, horrible crashes, and corrupting files too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nilamo 3y agoYou can still do that. And it'll still only run on one operating system, just like it used to.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoJava didn't only run on one OS but for whatever reason Oracle seems to find no value in making its UI stack nicer and modern. It seems only Microsoft's C# stack is working on this. There's also Qt, which is not a single-OS solution, but its C++.
- Alupis 3y agoWell, there is JavaFX, which is really nice for modern java desktop UI's. However, Swing can be taken really really far - just look at IntelliJ and friends (most people don't even realize they're Swing UI's). With that said - most modern applications are webapps for good reasons. Making native apps sucks for a lot of reasons - including all the random OS-specific behavior you have to work around, specific versions of native OS libraries, etc. Building for the web browser means, without any extra effort, you app works on all operating systems, and it works exactly the same. That's a pretty good sell to anyone trying to make a modern application that's mostly just a front-end UI for an API...
- emchammer 3y agoIt's not just browsers, though. I have to scroll harder in News.app than in other MacOS applications. Real question: Why do designers do this?
- Intralexical 3y agoI think it's got a certain "cool" factor. For some types of content in some cases it might also make sense, almost like a slideshow or paginated document, allowing each jump have its own self-contained focus. For example this page has action buttons and community links with a video on the first page, a written blurb about system configuration on the second page, screenshots/visual showcase on the third page, etc. Personally I'm on the fence. I think it probably more often than not tends to be annoying, like most overrides of default conventions, and feels more like you're being force-fed marketing instead of reading information. This specific page would probably work just as well if they kept the sections, dividers, and even the animations, but just let you scroll naturally. But then, maybe it gets them more downloads or something.
- winrid 3y agoWebkit has lots of "advanced" flags. We should add this as one!
- hutzlibu 3y agoBecause you can make all sorts of games and apps with the browser now, which is very cool. In my game the scrolling is just a fast way to zoom in and out and there it is no text to scroll, so it is very appropriate. But yes, the downside is that some people think that websites, that really just should be pages, get gamified and abused like this.
- Qwertious 3y agoBecause stuff like that is what makes www.territorial.io possible
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoJesus. As a visually impaired person who needs to scroll almost line by line, this is horrible.
- ploum 3y agoIt is sad because I was interested but my first thought was "if you can’t make a basic usable webpage, how can I trust you to make a minimal usable operating system". And I closed the tab.
- JohnMakin 3y agoDid exactly the same!
- demandingturtle 3y agoThat's a bit harsh. If it was from a web dev company, sure. But this is from someone doing it as a hobby for the good of mankind. Yeah, the might not work for some people but it's not the end of the world. It's like saying that girl has one strand of hair out of place so I'm not going to date her. You must be fun to be around.
- alpaca128 3y agoIt takes effort to break scrolling on a website. It's not something that just happens unexpectedly, it's a conscious decision to prioritize fancy animations over accessibility.
- mrd3v0 3y agoI don't believe it is harsh given how this is a critique of the philosophy that permits a programmer to needlessly hijack user input. Especially given the context here is an OS, AND a supposedly minimalist one at that. P.S: Last sentence probably violates HN guidelines and is just rude and unnecessary if you want to prove a point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- esskay 3y agoYup did the same. I wont browse sites that have these idiotic scroll takeovers, it's incredibly poor for UX.
- Narishma 3y agoI also hijacks the back button.
- a3w 3y agoI had no idea I could scroll. So: don't scroll, if pages use this antipattern. After reading the hint here, and trying it out, my back stack is polluted a lot.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoDepends on the browser used to read it. No problems with the one I'm using, for example.
- kiwijamo 3y agoIndeed it worked fine in Firefox on Android.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoWell off-topic: Scroll bars universally suck nowadays. Maybe my "mouse accuracy" isn't what it used to be - since giving up first person shooters 16 years ago - but I shouldn't need railgun accuracy to hit a fucking scroll bar 99% of the time. Why are they a single pixel wide these days, it's not like screen-width is expensive real-estate these days, is this Apple/Ive design principles gone mad? And then there's the page resizing when the scroll bar appears that makes it look as if the whole screen has refreshed, and then it re-refreshes without the scroll-bar in the intervening time that I paused my actions wondering why the screen refreshed in the first place. /end old man rant.
- SoftTalker 3y agoThe page-up and page-down keys, as well as the arrow keys, should also work for scrolling, but often don't because of hijacked scrolling events.
- gdprrrr 3y agoAlso space, shift-space, home, end, and middle-click-drag
- WanderPanda 3y agoThats why I love the minimap in VS code, it is basically an enlarged scrollbar!
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI agree. I've also noticed, ctrl + c, ctrl + v fails really often, especially on chat apps, and I realized why: they'll copy your chatbox contents (empty) if you accidentally press ctrl + c, and so whatever you copied is now gone. I was going nuts because it could happen to me on every single OS I would use, copy and paste is like being destroyed by "helpful" application designs. If I'm not highlighting text, don't copy for me! I'm looking at you Teams, Discord and maybe Slack?
- Propelloni 3y ago
- ulrikrasmussen 3y agoArg! I literally get dizzy when sites do this. When I scroll on the mouse, I seem to subconsciously move my eyes in anticipation of the text moving, and when it moves unexpectedly I get disoriented.
- thisOtterBeGood 3y agoIt can be a nice tool but you can make mistakes. You should always visualize the scroll progress. In this instance for each scroll-tick they should move a focus or selection indicator over the screenshots, so that you feel your scroll progress... Edit: I went back... not they don't even recognize small scroll ticks, they just ignore them... :) You have to violently scroll to progress.