4 ms·
> This radio interference was also present on the aviation frequencies (around 124 MHz) How did this thing get FCC approval? What's it's FCC approval number?
by Animats 3y ago
> This radio interference was also present on the aviation frequencies (around 124 MHz)
How did this thing get FCC approval? What's it's FCC approval number? Who tested this thing? Want to look that up.
If RF got outside the charger and into the USB cable, it's very badly designed. The power in the USB cable is DC. There shouldn't be any significant RF component. There should be ferrite beads and capacitors in the power supply to deal with this. When the filtering is close to the switcher, it's much easier to deal with the noise, and very small ferrite beads, available in surface mount, can usually do the job. Once it gets out on an external wire, it's hard to filter.
This is an old problem for Apple. A report from 2013, from a pilot charging an Ipad in an aircraft.[1]
[1] https://pointsforpilots.blogspot.com/2013/06/radio-interference-of-12v-ipad-charger.html https://pointsforpilots.blogspot.com/2013/06/radio-interfere...
- wkat4242 3y agoYeah and the external wire will act like an antenna especially if it's got the right length. Very bad. Strange also because Apple usually gets their PSUs made by Delta afaik and they are as good as it gets.
- colechristensen 3y agoIt’s not very bad. Detectable signals is not at all equivalent to interference. Folks need to relax. People actually experienced with RF wouldn’t worry about this at all, and the FCC is perfectly capable of doing its certification job.
- amatecha 3y agoBreaking squelch on a scanning radio in the general vicinity is pretty bad. It shouldn't be generating such strong RFI on VHF frequencies. I use 2m (VHF) handheld radios at my desk at home with like 5 computers around me, countless chargers (including a wireless charger just like in the article). There is never a time that my radios are stopping on RFI generated within my office.
- galangalalgol 3y agoWhen people ask for certification. The stuff you get on amazon now doesn't have FCC numbers. Or silk screening on the pcbs or components to identify them. Also there was a possibly false tale of intel adding clock jitter years ago to spread the emi across a band to pass tests, and then forgetting to enable that jitter on production units.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- js2 3y agoI can't be sure this is the exact model as OP, but the FCC testing doesn't seem to indicate any issues from my brief skim: https://fccid.io/BCGA2548 https://fccid.io/BCGA2548 (I have not read the entire report and I have no expertise in RF.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Mistletoe 3y agoIs the original author certain he has an authentic Apple charger? I’ve seen teardowns many times of bogus Apple chargers that use worse designs and components. http://www.righto.com/2016/03/counterfeit-macbook-charger-teardown.html?m=1 http://www.righto.com/2016/03/counterfeit-macbook-charger-te...
- numpad0 3y agoWell, modern DC converters use PWM, and also the device in question is a Qi induction charger operating at 110 - 205kHz with up to 15W output so there is some significan- how are these unlicensed!?
- SV_BubbleTime 3y ago>The power in the USB cable is DC. There shouldn't be any significant RF component. Well that isn't even remotely correct. Any time you have switching, which this does, in DC you have VERY high frequency components in every rise and fall time. Much faster than your period or switching frequency, it's all about how fast you rise/fall. You switch, rapidly, through anything that has inductance, and you have RF.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mtreis86 3y agoThis, for reference see the book High Speed Digital Design by Hall Hall and McCall https://archive.org/details/highspeeddigital0000hall/ https://archive.org/details/highspeeddigital0000hall/ The sharper the edge of the digital pulse, the greater the strength of the AC high frequency components. A perfect square wave is the sum of the infinite series of odd harmonics of a sine wave with the same wavelength.
- SV_BubbleTime 3y agoI watched a video recently that had another author describe issues in a way that I found very intuitive. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdCJxdR7L_I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kdCJxdR7L_I
- genewitch 3y agoEven very expensive linear supplies will have Vpp of a few millivolts or microvolts "ripple". Vpp is voltage peak to peak, which you wouldn't expect on a DC device, but there you go. i didn't read the article and i don't know the expertise of the author, but depending on the type of antenna you use, you may have to choke literally every wire in the "shack", KB/mouse, power, speakers, ethernet, etc. Although, funny enough, this is for the inverse case - the radio messing with the computer! I wonder if an RF choke (AKA a 1:1 Current Balun) directly attached to the UHF port on the back of the radio would help in this circumstance - the feedline is probably coupling with the USB cable!
- 3y ago
- NovemberWhiskey 3y ago>How did this thing get FCC approval? Looking at the radio display, it seems like the peak power is about 7-8 S-units. At VHF, that would be about -100dBm; or about 100 femto-watts. I presume that the charger is pretty near the radio. With free-space path loss being inverse square law, it's essentially going to be completely negligible within a very short distance. Oh, and if the antenna is indeed near the charger (say within one wavelength, 2 meters in this case) it might be inside the near-field - which means that you're getting additional power transferred that wouldn't be reaching the far-field, and you might even be affecting the behavior of the device due to coupling. Looking at the FCC report, the radiated emissions are totally in-line with FCC Class B requirements. Modern ham radio equipment has exquisitely sensitive receivers and you easily hear all kinds of interference from digital devices that are completely Part 15 compliant. The prevalence of switched mode power supplies literally everywhere has made HF radio completely unusable for many people outside rural areas.
- crote 3y agoDo you have any idea how that power compares to regular FM radio broadcasts, which are somewhat close in frequency? Is this something a regular radio would detect, or is OP just trying to listen to a handheld radio half a continent away using a really sensitive receiver with the volume knob turned all the way up?
- NovemberWhiskey 3y agoTo get a very broad idea: if you had perfectly efficient but isotropic antennas (you don't) this would be about the power level you'd get receiving a typical 3W hand-held radio signal at 140MHz from 1,000 kilometers away. This is why you can talk to the International Space Station easily enough with vanilla ham radio equipment. Or, taking a notoriously powerful FM radio station like KRUZ 103.3, it would be like hearing that station from perhaps 300,000 kilometers away. Most loss is not free-space loss though - it's due to reflections from man made objects and absorption into the earth that results in line-of-sight effects at these frequencies.
- 3y ago
- marcinzm 3y ago>If RF got outside the charger and into the USB cable, it's very badly designed Wouldn't this then be a problem with whatever car charger he is using and not with the apple device plugged into that charger?
- jve 3y ago> a pilot charging an Ipad in an aircraft.[1] Fascinating. No wonders we have so much red tape on stuff that is in the air.
- rajnathani 3y agoCould the problem be with the DC current that is being supplied via USB power from the car / power adapter? If this DC current is very noisy, then it could make the noise generated worse I presume?
- wglb 3y agoSwitch mode power supplies such as this one emit RF. There are varying degrees of shielding that can help, but ham radio stations that are looking for good reception forbid using any such chargers (e.g., iPhone charger, Macbook chargers, etc). Far better to use a linear power supply, which has a transformer and as a result is far heavier.