4 ms·
More useful is one of his references on how to build a CNC router.[1] This one covers all the usual mistakes one can make building a CNC router. (He skips the r
by Animats 3y ago
More useful is one of his references on how to build a CNC router.[1] This one covers all the usual mistakes one can make building a CNC router.
(He skips the real n00b mistake - trying to use a Dremel tool in a CNC router.
That never works. Dremel tools slow down or stall under load, and the CNC controller doesn't detect that, so it keeps pushing a stalled tool around.)
[1] https://mattferraro.dev/posts/cnc-router https://mattferraro.dev/posts/cnc-router
- syntaxing 3y agoTo be fair, most hobby CNC tools were opened looped until more tools came out that were BLDC + zero cross detection for speed control. That being said, stalling your tool more or less means you’re just blindly cutting a part. Calculating the correct feed rate is absolutely essential for any router/milling operation.
- dheera 3y agoInstead of open loop calculations, why not just actually measure the current (or motor RPM) and do a feedback loop?
- syntaxing 3y agoMixture of motor technology, cost, and application. Take a dremel for instance, adding all these features cost money and most dremel users won’t care for it. Also certain motor technology makes it impossible to control in a meaningful fashion. If you stuck an encoder on a dremel, you’ll still have a lot difficulty maintaining the set RPM.
- dekhn 3y agothat doesn't give you step-level accuracy. Some systems do this- for example Prusa MK3 and newer don't have physical endstops, instead they monitor current. And FluidNC supports this but clearly points out you shouldn't use it for step-level accuracy.
- numpad0 3y agoSimple voltage control for spindle motors and open loop stepping motors for everything else is just precise enough and most cost effective for hobby machines. Closed loop is technologically superior but ultimately not necessary. (note: "sensorless homing" and sensorless BLDC are different things)
- dekhn 3y agoA few comments for those who want to go down this route: 1) you probably should buy a machine, rather than designing and building one, if your goal is to use the CNC. It will be cheaper and more of your time will be spent CNCing instead of rediscovering the painful lessons learned over the past decades. 2) he says woodworking equipment is only good for wood, but it also works for aluminum 3) ignore all the talk about grbl on arduino due or mega, use FluidNC on ESP32. 4) a dewalt 611 will work better than any spindle that costs less than it, and also many spindles that cost more, if you're working in just wood. This is a controversial opinion, if a spindle makes you happy, go for it.
- itronitron 3y agoYes, don't build your own CNC or plotter (from scratch). OpenBuilds has a good range of options and also a fairly active community of people adapting their platform for custom uses.
- nomel 3y agoA nickel DSP/microcontroller, and a microphone, should easily close that loop.
- dtgriscom 3y agoThe original Dremels had actual speed controls; if the spindle loaded down, the motor power would be increased to restore the speed. Modern ones (at least as of a few years ago) were just constant power, so they indeed slow down as a load is applied. (Probably still a bad idea...)