5 ms·
Looks like a more labor intensive refinement of the much older techniques of copping and pollarding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coppicing https://en.wikiped
by Retric 3y ago
Looks like a more labor intensive refinement of the much older techniques of copping and pollarding.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coppicing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coppicing
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollarding https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pollarding
- culi 3y agoI don't think copping and pollarding are "older". They're just the European (rough) equivalents
- Retric 3y agoCoppicing predates writing, pollarding was written about in 1st century BC so it’s at least that old. Daisugi is mentioned as 600 years old so ~1500 years more recent. Daisugi could in theory be significantly older than 600 years, but it’s origins seems well documented.
- culi 3y agoSure but the practice of whatever-you'd-call-Japanese-pollarding is obviously older than daisugi since that's just pollarding with the discovery of a particular tree that's really really good at it. That discovery wouldn't have been made if people weren't already pollarding. Other extremely meticulous plant manipulation traditions like bonsai are confirmed to be over 3k years old
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoI'm quite confused. Japanese people practiced pollarding, and then later developed a more complex and refined variant of it known as daisugi. That's the original comment's claim, and you seem to making that exact same claim here, but phrasing it as if you are right and the original commenter is wrong.
- culi 3y agoI believe the person I'm responding to is using "pollarding" and "coppicing" to specifically refer to the European tradition. I'm not sure what the Japanese equivalent would be called
- Retric 3y agoNo, I am referring to the techniques. Daisugi is a loan word used to describe a technique the same way Bonsai is. They are the English terms. The Japanese equivalent of coppicing is coppicing because we are speaking English and we already have a word to describe the technique. Also to correct your older post no it’s not “pollarding with the discovery of a particular tree that's really really good at it.” Daisugi uses Bonsai techniques making it labor intensive across a long period. Pollarding only takes labor when you’re actually harvesting the tree.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- scoot 3y agoIf it's more labor intensive is it a refinement?
- huytersd 3y agoDepends on what you’re optimizing for. Daisugi looks more aesthetically pleasing to me.
- Retric 3y agoIt produces straighter wood and looks less harmful to the tree. So it’s a question of trade offs.
- manxman 3y agoIt’s interesting you say this. There’s something cultural in Japan that optimises the hell out of something even after it becomes obsolete everywhere else and then cannot let go of that investment. Or perhaps the people involved in the process stop questioning whether other processes may be better and then simply iterate upon the path they are already on? Take the buses: They have the most amazing automated machines for giving you change from banknotes and then collecting/calculating the correct fare payment in coins. Similar machines exist in some retailers. Try to pay by card and you won’t travel very far. Much of the rest of the world moved to contactless card payments over a decade ago I sort of sympathise on some levels - the investments they made in these ”refinements” are not trivial. I suspect Japan will stick to its legacy processes. IMHO It will succeed as a niche curiosity that outsiders find interesting as the world passes it by. I have to wonder if such curiosity tourism will ever be enough to cover its economic needs.
- brutusborn 3y agoI don't know how true it is, but I have heard that many large Japanese companies still make significant use of fax machines. This surprised me because of how advanced Japanese industrial automation is. The only example that I think makes sense is the Japanese intelligence services still using paper records. In this context it is advantageous since paper filing cabinets cannot be hacked remotely.
- charles_f 3y agoArticle literally says > Daisugi (台杉, where sugi refers to Japanese cedar), is a similar Japanese technique in its intro
- Retric 3y agoSimilar as in related, not similar as in identical. All 3 involve how trees grow back after you cut them but the methods are different. Daisugi involves a lot more effort after the initial cutting process, it’s roughly Bonsai + Pollarding. Though you keep a little more of the tree than with Pollarding.
- benj111 3y agoIs it coppicing or grafting? The title suggests the latter, but the article doesn't go into details.
- RoyalHenOil 3y agoThe title is misleading; it's not multiple trees. It's just one tree that is pollarded and shaped to produce vertical branches.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoCoppicing is used a lot in my neighbourhood (and in the Netherlands as a whole) on willows close to water banks; I don't know if the wood is used for anything, but the trees have deep and sturdy roots that stabilize the soil, without the tree growing to a size where it might fall over in a storm or drop a lot of materials in the water.
- BoxOfRain 3y agoI love willow trees, they have such an impressive will to live even if their lifespans are fairly short as trees go.
- galangalalgol 3y agoDoesn't coppicing or pollarding reset the lifespan of the tree to an extent?
- leethargo 3y agoMy Dutch boss explained to me that the willow branches harvested there are used to reinforce the dykes nearby.
- TotempaaltJ 3y ago(I'm Dutch) I don't think this is true. It may have been true in some instances, but I can't find anything about that. Dikes are reinforced using rocks, stones, and tarmac.
- leethargo 3y agoOK, maybe I was misunderstanding something. It was also not at the sea, but more water between agricultural plots, so maybe just for drainage?
- Dutchie987 3y agoWillow shoots were and still are used to reinforce waterworks. Look up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascine_mattress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascine_mattress or the Dutch word "zinkstuk" for a detailed description.