3 ms·
This is a weird comment. We focus on suicidal thoughts because suicidal thoughts are scary to people in a way that vomiting or a rash or blurred vision is not,
by vidarh 3y ago
This is a weird comment. We focus on suicidal thoughts because suicidal thoughts are scary to people in a way that vomiting or a rash or blurred vision is not, because the former makes people consider a potentially life ending outcome, while the latter do not. Whether or not you agree with the relative ranking of these concerns, it ought to be easy to understand why.
And the rate of suicidal ideation per reported adverse event is irrelevant as something to compare unless you've also confirmed that the rate of adverse event reports is comparable between the two drugs. Have you? If so, why are you citing the rate per adverse event case rather than the rate relative to number of users, or doses?
Even so, even if they are in fact comparable, we're focusing on these drugs because they're fairly new and have seen an explosive increase in use, just like we've focused on other drugs when they've seen the same explosive increase in use. That people are extra interested in any potentially serious effects of a fairly new drug should not be surprising at all. Why does it surprise you?
- arc-in-space 3y agoDon't worry, I could have made it a much weirder comment. You know what else was reported in similar numbers as suicidal ideation, for Ozempic? Death. I'm pretty sure that's a whole lot scarier than thinking about death! That's a definitely life ending outcome! Incidentally, in a way really emblematic of how useful adverse event reports are, Wegovy has a single case of a gunshot wound, and I don't think the new exciting drug caused that. Yes, I do play tricks with the aspirin comparison, but only to show just how wacky the original article is. If you think my two numbers are hard to compare, presumably you also agree that using a random case count with literally no context is effectively meaningless. Furthermore, I think journalists doing statistics must be destroyed.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoThinking about death is surely scarier than death itself my friend.
- mym1990 3y ago> Furthermore, I think journalists doing statistics must be destroyed. Because you think there are no journalists out there that can do statistics, or because you think they will always use it to make their own point?
- arc-in-space 3y agoYou do see a lot of really poor understanding of statistics out there, but on reflection, I want to say the latter is much worse. If journalists with an agenda were actually good at manipulating data, it would be much harder to put trust in anything.
- mym1990 3y agoI totally understand that, statistics really is a double edged sword. I think a good journalist can do a lot of wonderful things with data. If we end up living in a world where journalists are banned from using data at all, that would be very disappointing.
- dang 3y agoHey, could you please not post in the flamewar style to HN? You can make your substantive points without that. You may not owe journalists doing statistics better, but you owe this community better if you're participating in it. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.