5 ms·
Ági Szabados Does Not Need to Apologize to Me
- mark_l_watson 3y agoI really enjoy Scalzi’s books, and to the point: it is nice of him to try to take the heat off of a young content creator who has helped promote his works.
- developer93 3y agoDid you read the article? She runs one of the biggest bookclubs in Hungary. That comment seems a little patronising. :)
- gbalint 3y agoFor the note, I'm a Hungarian, I read books regularly and also read the major news outlets daily, but I never heard neither about Agi Szabados, nor about this controversy.
- developer93 3y agoMy bad :-)
- Y_Y 3y agoWow! Her hovercraft must be chock-full of eels.
- DandyDev 3y agoThe comment is factual, right? The person is young? Check. She is a content creator? Check. She promoted his books? Check. Nothing patronizing about that Edit: meant as a response to sibling comment
- zrail 3y agoÁgi Szabados is a 35 year old adult woman who runs a successful nationwide book club. "Young content creator" in this context absolutely is patronizing.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoI would trade my right arm to be young enough that I get offended when people call me “young.” Youth is really wasted on 20- and 30-somethings.
- lukas099 3y agoImagine this happened to Oprah (when she was younger) and somebody said "it is nice of him to try to take the heat off of a young content creator".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gilbetron 3y agoRoger Ebert helped Orpah when she was young (about the same age, 32ish) just before she exploded in popularity. I can't imagine Oprah being offended in that situation or seeing it as being patronizing.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- lukas099 3y agoI meant after she exploded in popularity.
- DangitBobby 3y agoThat would be pretty weird because basically everyone knows who Oprah is but nothing wrong other than that.
- bawolff 3y agoI have a lot of respect for this. It would be so easy for him to just ignore the situation, not get involved. It is after all some controversy in a far away place in a different language/culture. Despite being "about" him, he arguably has nothing really to do with it. He does not need to be involved; he can walk away. Instead he tries to stop the inernet mob from demonizing someone in his name who did nothing to deserve it. We should all aspire to act that way when thrown in such a situation.
- fishywang 3y agoJohn Scalzi also has DRM removed from his every book on Google Play Books (and some other ebook platforms supporting this). I always respect him for that. (And also for someone who is not native in English, I found his book easier to read compare to some other other authors.)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gnfargbl 3y agoAs far as I can tell, the story here is that 1. the person tasked with introducing an author talked more about her own initiative (getting people to read more) than the author; 2. the person was criticised for this; and 3. the author wants people to know that he doesn't mind not being talked about because he likes reading too, and he doesn't feel he needs help promoting himself. So far, so boring. There's also some mysterious implication that the criticism was due to some kind of undercurrents in Hungarian politics. Is this another tedious culture war thing?
- junon 3y agoI think he was more alluding to the possibility of a language or cultural or political barrier, one of which he was not aware because he is not from there, that could be a driving force behind Hungarian backlash toward this individual.
- kitd 3y agoThere's a comment on the blog that mentions the woman is a journalist at an independent media outlet not affiliated with the government. I am not familiar with Hungarian politics other than there being a right-wing populist leader in charge. They often come with shill hordes who see independent outlets prepared to criticise the gov as "the enemy". I can imagine she could become a target at the slightest provocation.
- bannedbybros 3y ago[dead]
- justin66 3y ago> There's also some mysterious implication that the criticism was due to some kind of undercurrents in Hungarian politics. Is this another tedious culture war thing? You're allowed to regard anything as a tedious culture war thing, and be annoyed or offended by it on that basis. That's what's great about a culture war. Feel the annoyance course through your veins. You know you want to.
- mkl 3y agoAre there any Hungarians here who can enlighten us about what was controversial?
- meindnoch 3y agoAuthor was the guest of honour for the opening panel of a book festival. An influencer was also present on the panel, and was expected to converse with the author. The influencer promoted herself instead of conversing the author. People who were there to learn about the author got outraged and demanded the influencer to apologize. The influencer apologized. The author says he wasn't offended, and doesn't think there was anything wrong.
- short_sells_poo 3y agoI suppose it's not just the author who was cheated, but the audience. The author might be OK with not getting as much limelight as planned, but if I went to a book festival to see and hear a favorite author, but instead it was some random instagram goober promoting themselves talking, I'd be pissed too.
- jamincan 3y agoIf you read the linked post from John Scalzi, it's pretty clear the audience wasn't deprived of him.
- littlestymaar 3y agoJust a random Tuesday on the outragenet.
- kcartlidge 3y ago> An influencer was also present on the panel It should be clarified that she is also a newsreader and runs a book club. There's nothing wrong with being an influencer, but to not mention the rest is incomplete.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- bowsamic 3y agoI really don't understand how we are supposed to deal with this modern outrage culture
- tibbydudeza 3y agoBy not being on or engaging social media - if you messed up you could go to the next village and not get tarred and feathered there. I read about this incident living in a different continent proverbially 8400 miles away from Budapest. A global village you tell me - meh - it is a curse.
- gorjusborg 3y agoNot engaging is a perfectly reasonable choice, especially when the negatives of engaging outweigh the positives. More selectively engaging could also work, in theory. In practice though, I suspect people succumb to industry engagement stimulation techniques and get pulled back in completely.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoOr develop a very thick skin as well - the internet amplifies the unsavory aspects of human behavior because of $$$.
- bowsamic 3y agoShe would have been targeted even if she did not use social media
- amelius 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance
- fnordpiglet 3y agoBy talking about computers and math.
- carapace 3y ago
- NBJack 3y agoScalzi is definitely one of my favorites right now. While I actually don't like the Old Man's War universe that much, his one-off books and smaller series have been absolute delights. They become even better when he gets Wil Wheaton to narrate his audio releases (I still smile thinking of Redshirts). Nice to see Scalzi use what influence he has to actually help someone else like this.
- madaxe_again 3y agoI read “Old Man’s War” a few weeks back, and it left me totally cold - while he’s of course attempting to reach a broad audience, it struck me as so tropeful it made me squirm. Space marines having knife-fights with giant bugs in a thunderdome was right up there. There was also a weird bit where all of a sudden all of the characters are asking each other how old they are over the course of a dozen pages, which felt like an editor had said to him “you aren’t making enough of the age thing” so he jammed in a bunch of references. I dunno. Sure it’s for plenty of people, just not for me.
- zrail 3y agoOld Man's War was published almost two decades ago and was Scalzi's first novel. It shouldn't be surprising that it took a lot of inspiration from Heinlein et. al. His later works either lean way into tropes intentionally (Red Shirts, which I feel is more an exploration of form than a proper novel) or develop entirely new concepts, like the one way travel in the Interdependency series.
- tempestn 3y agoHe also has a unique style. To me it appears intentional that he doesn't tend to write as realistic as possible depictions of possible futures, even allowing for the sci-fi elements. Rather, characters tend to act and speak like current day people thrust into a sci-fi scenario. Technology is highly advanced in some areas, but less so in others (which helps keep humans relevant). At times I found that took some getting used to, but it can also make the story more accessible, lends itself to humor, and can allow for exploration of how the kind of people we're familiar with would react in wildly different scenarios. Basically, I can see how his style wouldn't be for everyone, but I enjoy his books.
- chippytea 3y agoI am hungarian and haven't heard of this controversy before. I tried to look it up, it hasn't been in any of the major news sources (yet), except for HVG[1] but they are only referencing an article written in a relatively small online magazine[2]. The only real problem I can see with her speach is that she was asked to give a laudation, but gave a more generic speach instead. Laudation seems to be a custom at this book festival. Also it's kind of funny that she stole the first part of her speach from "rory's graduation speach" in Gilmore Girls TV series[3]. [1] https://hvg.hu/kultura/20230929_Kinosra_sikerult_Szabados_Agi_konyvfesztivalos_szereplese_ahol_John_Scalzit_kellett_volna_meltatnia_de_inkabb_magarol_beszelt https://hvg.hu/kultura/20230929_Kinosra_sikerult_Szabados_Ag... [2] https://konyvesmagazin.hu/nagy/john_scalzi_boldizsar_ildiko_konyvfesztival.html https://konyvesmagazin.hu/nagy/john_scalzi_boldizsar_ildiko_... [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MndMDj8uKUY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MndMDj8uKUY
- aidenn0 3y agoThanks for the context, it explains a lot.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoHow glad I am for the few people who still seem to have rather rational, common sense approach to life. Also, I red couple of books from John Scalzi and found them enjoyable.
- kervantas 3y agoThis is tabloid category, why is this on HN?
- beardicus 3y agoit's on HN so folks can rage about outrage culture and have their biases reinforced.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoThis comment is so meta it hurts… I think you win the internet for today :-)
- kevinpet 3y agoScience fiction is popular here, and in particular Scalzi is popular with the trekkie / comic con / geek identity crowd.
- sshine 3y agoJohn Scalzi clearly does not understand that being offended on behalf of someone else really has nothing to do with him.
- bawolff 3y agoI mean, i think he understands that perfectly fine. You can still engage with things that have nothing to do with you. You did it with your comment after all. You can still reasonably feel a moral obligation to intervene on stuff done in your name or on your behalf even if it isn't really about you.
- sshine 3y agoI think he understands it very well, too. I was being sarcastic. I apologise for the lack of indicators.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]