7 ms·
DOJ finally posted that “embarrassing” court doc Google wanted to hide
- peter422 3y agoIf this is the most embarrassing document as part of this case then I don’t think anything is happening to Google.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe entire Justice department under Lina Khan has been a failure, a first year law student could pose holes in most of her arguments. She has been slapped down repeatedly by judges.
- grobbyy 3y agoPerhaps. I don't think this reflects anything unethical on the part of Google, but it does represent that market dynamics aren't working. The point of antitrust isn't so much to punish bad people as to make for efficient markets. Under mainstream economic theory, Google ought to be regulated. That's good for everyone, Google employees and most Google investors included (by numbers and not dollars; most Google investors hold diverse portfolios). If the industry and economy as a whole grow, at the expense of Google, both my overall investments and my job options improve. Corporations aren't human beings with moral rights, and laws are there to keep them beneficial and efficient, but to preserve some abstract corporate freedom.
- scarface_74 3y agoNo it’s not good for everyone when the government has more power. It’s usually bad and the government regulators always seem to want to regulate content that the party in power disagrees with. The government rarely understands technology and pays no thought to unintended consequences
- djbusby 3y agoThis is government using existing power.
- scarface_74 3y agoThen maybe we should think about taking away existing power?
- Eisenstein 3y agoYou think they should not be able to regulate monopolies? The free market only works with regulation or else we end up back in the 1800s Trust era where a few people owned all the industries and you couldn't get your shipments transported on rail lines owned by someone with a competing business interest.
- scarface_74 3y agoThe difference is that people choose Google. You can go to any website you want to. Just like the asinine browser choice in the EU made absolutely no difference in the market share between browsers. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/12/windows-browser-ballot-comes-to-an-end-as-ec-obligation-expires/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2014/12/windo...
- nuancebydefault 3y agoMost people I know use Google but did not choose Google. They just bought a smartphone. There are limited options, buy a more expensive fancy apple, or a less expensive, a bit less fancy android. That is the only choice given/taken. I know, people on HN will counter argument that there are tons of other options, but most people I know that use Google, are not aware. In fact that is where this lawsuit at its core is about.
- scarface_74 3y ago
- timmaxw 3y agoTo clarify: what specific remedy do you want the court to impose on Google, and how would it make things better for everyone?
- pdonis 3y ago> The point of antitrust isn't so much to punish bad people as to make for efficient markets. That's the story those who favor antitrust want you to believe, but it's not true. Antitrust actions historically have made markets less efficient, not more. A classic case is the breakup of Alcoa aluminum, whose "offense" was to supply aluminum to its customers at lower prices and larger quantities than any of its competitors. The breakup both raised prices and reduced quantities, making things worse for customers. > Under mainstream economic theory, Google ought to be regulated. Even leaving aside the concerns above, Google is not a monopoly in the sense of antitrust law. The real economic problem with Google is that its users are not its customers; users are just a resource to be exploited to maximize profits due to ads. If the government were to do anything to "fix" this, the obvious thing would be to outlaw that business model.
- CamperBob2 3y agoA classic case is the breakup of Alcoa aluminum, whose "offense" was to supply aluminum to its customers at lower prices and larger quantities than any of its competitors. The breakup both raised prices and reduced quantities, making things worse for customers. Much the same story with Standard Oil. What young people learn in school from left-leaning economics professors often diverges quite radically from what actually happened.
- pdonis 3y agoYes, Standard Oil is another classic case, with much the same results after the breakup: higher prices and smaller quantities available to customers.
- belltaco 3y agoThen why did they fight so hard to keep it secret.
- dgfitz 3y agoI have a hunch. https://www.simplethread.com/looks-great-lose-the-duck/ https://www.simplethread.com/looks-great-lose-the-duck/
- nuancebydefault 3y agoNever heard that story. It is funny. I have to try out this technique some time. Add an obvious flaw or oddity, which is easy to leave out afterwards, to a deliverable, so it covers up other problems or imperfections.
- lolinder 3y agoThe degree to which a document is embarrassing if shown to the general public is not necessarily related to its legal significance in an antitrust trial. The court may very reasonably conclude that this is weak evidence given the context, but it could still be extremely embarrassing when compressed into meme form. Conversely, evidence that is far too dry to make a good embarrassing meme could be the conclusive proof the court needs to take action.
- akira2501 3y agoThe case isn't "Did Google do embarrassing things?" The case is "Did Google break federal law?"
- thewildginger 3y agoIf your company execs are basically bragging about ignoring fundamental principles of a healthy capital based market due to total control of said market, in an anti trust hearing, then yeah that's some pretty solid evidence you are breaking the law.
- somenameforme 3y agoI'm curious how we can read the same thing and come to such different conclusions. Can you elaborate on your view? When I read this, I see a company effectively gloating about establishing such a firm monopoly, in part through "marketing/distribution investments", that they could effectively ignore their customers, and focus instead on entirely exploiting them. The document voluntarily choosing to parallel their level of control over their users as something normally only obtained by illicit industries, like drug dealers is, to me, just one of those 'wow I can't believe you were stupid enough to put this into text' type things. In your mind, what would be reasonably viable smoking gun for a monopoly pursuing corporation to write down? The Sherman Antitrust Act is described by Wiki [1] as prohibiting "1) anticompetitive agreements and 2) unilateral conduct that monopolizes or attempts to monopolize the relevant market." It goes on to mention that "[a] monopoly achieved solely by merit, is legal, but acts by a monopolist to artificially preserve that status, or nefarious dealings to create a monopoly, are not." [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act
- pdonis 3y ago> they could effectively ignore their customers, and focus instead on entirely exploiting them Google's users are not customers. Google is exploiting their users precisely because they are not customers, so their only value to Google is as a resource for maximizing their profits due to ads. Which actually makes them worse than, say, cigarette manufacturers, since at least their users were their customers, choosing to purchase a product.
- nuancebydefault 3y agoWhether Google users are customers or not, is just wording. They are part of the eco system, just like the OS, the servers, the HW or SW devs, the agencies paying for advertising and so on. Google needs to keep all members of that eco system content and treat them respectfully, labeled customer or not.
- pdonis 3y ago
- phailhaus 3y agoYeahhh this is pretty weak. Reading the doc [1] there's nothing about getting users "hooked on search". The point is that Google is able to "ignore the demand side" simply because search is so sticky: it turns out that users are not likely to switch search engines if the results are good enough. That means it has similar economics to drugs and cigarettes, but not that search is addictive like the headline heavily implies. Ars is usually better than this. [1] https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-09/416692.pdf https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-09/416692.pdf
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> is able to "ignore the demand side" simply because search is so sticky Because of their “marketing/distribution investments,” not any product attributes [1]. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-29/google-search-is-like-cigarettes-or-drugs-executive-said https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-29/google-se...
- timmaxw 3y agoThe full quote from the trial exhibit is: > When talking about revenue, we could mostly ignore the demand side of the equation (users and queries) and only focus on supply side of advertisers, ad formats, and sales. Sure, we had to build the best product, made smart marketing/distribution investments to get our product everywhere, but we could essentially tear the economics textbook in half. They explicitly mention "we had to build the best product", so I'm not sure where you're getting the "not any product attributes" bit from. (Your linked article is paywalled.)
- pdonis 3y ago> They explicitly mention "we had to build the best product" But to them, "the best product" is the one that maximizes their profits from ads, not the one that does the best job of giving users what they want. Obviously there is overlap between these, but they're not the same thing.
- 3y ago
- jqpabc123 3y agoThe cure for Google is to "legally" mandate opt in/out for personalized advertising. Personalized advertising is built around an obvious violation of human dignity and the right to privacy as recognized by the UDHR. https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-human-rights https://www.un.org/en/about-us/universal-declaration-of-huma...
- philjohn 3y agoIt's not at all. If someone was sitting there going "Oooh, jqpabc123 is into anime" then maybe. There are paid alternatives now, if you want to opt out of what allows them to offer search for "free" then go use those.
- RunSet 3y ago"The burden of proof falls squarely on advertising to justify its intrusions into users’ attentional spaces—not on users to justify exercising their freedom of attention." https://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2015/10/why-its-ok-to-block-ads/ https://blog.practicalethics.ox.ac.uk/2015/10/why-its-ok-to-...
- jqpabc123 3y ago* There are paid alternatives now, if you want to opt out of what allows them to offer search for "free" then go use those.* Paying for search won't change the fact that 75% of all web traffic contains Google trackers. This is a fundamental violation of privacy that no one should have to "opt out" of. Basically, you value Google's business model over human dignity. https://whotracks.me/ https://whotracks.me/
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago> Personalized advertising is built around an obvious violation of human dignity How? Does a village grocer, who knows you like chocolates, and points out a new brand of chocolates violate your dignity? What is the philosophical difference between this and an algo doing it?
- 3y ago
- voytec 3y agoDupe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37715211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37715211
- omoikane 3y agoThis one has more context in noting that the PDF linked earlier was training material: At trial, Roszak told the court that he didn't recall if he ever gave the presentation. He said that the course required that he tell students "things I don’t believe as part of the presentation." He also claimed that the notes were "full of hyperbole and exaggeration" and did not reflect his true beliefs, "because there was no business purpose associated with it."
- pvg 3y agoIt's newsticker updates of a very minor trial detail that is now getting its own front-page newsticker updates on top of the trial newsticker updates. that sort of thing tends to be hn-offtopic just by it's high sample rate, more or less independent of what it's about.
- dude3 3y agoSeeing this, I hope they dig more into the motivation and decision making behind massive ranking updates. Essentially, is it only about improving search quality.
- lsedgwick 3y agoThey're saying these were notes for a speech for a "communcations class" where he was cosplaying Gorden Gecko and not presenting his true beliefs? That so hard to believe. These notes could not more obviously be an internal memo, filled with clear reasoning about balancing the needs and visions of different internal departments, meant to persuade and stimulate conversation about Google's strategy. I don't see how this "it was for a speech and I was being hyperbolic on purpose" thing isn't getting laughed out of the water.
- Simulacra 3y agoMoney buys lawyers who can argue about anything. With seemingly unlimited legal funds, the company can work to thwart everything just to slow down the trial.
- giantrobot 3y agoYeah their defense being "...in Minecraft" smells very much of bullshit.
- nraynaud 3y agowhat's interesting is that the results of google search are getting more and more crappy like illicit drugs on the market. But somehow I don't disagree with the comment, it's extremely addictive to believe you could get the answer to any question instantly, even if in reality you'll often get a lot of garbage if your question happens to be in an area where a lot of people have something to sell.
- suyash 3y agoMore of a reason for ChatGPT to disrupt Google Search.
- thefurdrake 3y agoWow. Is Ars really stretching this hard? Can we not just let the evidence speak for itself? Despite their desperate attempt to scarequote and chop up excerpts from a direct quote, they fail to demonstrate "Google exec said users get hooked on search engine like “cigarettes or drugs.”" He didn't say that from what I'm seeing; the quotes they use don't say that, and anyone who can read can clearly see the evidence they provide doesn't support the claim. The unquoted part ("with /economics/ that[...]") even indicate it's not a behavioral observation. That subheadline really detracts from the point of the article.