9 ms·
How BlackBerry failed to respond to the iPhone
- MichaelMug 3y ago> In reading the article it is clear that at that the BlackBerry leadership decided that it was important for them strategically to address the rise of the iPhone. It's my conclusion that RIM made a crucial misstep when it attempted to go head-to-head with the iPhone, as exemplified by the ill-fated Storm. Perhaps with the launch of the iPhone, RIM should of pivoted out of consumer electronics. My family is from Latin America. Circa 2007 BlackBerry Messenger (BBM) was all the rage. Carriers even offered specialized BBM phone plans. I recall seeing ads for plans with unlimited BBM's but low data and limited SMS. Fast forward to today, and WhatsApp has firmly taken the reins from BBM in Latin America. Looking back, I can't help but wonder if RIM had the potential to become the WhatsApp of today. Instead RIM locked BBM away in the confines of the enterprise world, guarded by their BlackBerry Enterprise Server.
- xp84 3y agoThis is certainly possible, especially because they could have done it before iMessage too, and thus been able to gain mainstream traction even in the US. In 2008 when the App Store launched, SMS 'plans' were still an annoyingly expensive add-on here, and iMessage didn't exist. That was the window where anybody who really had a vision to do so could have become the WhatsApp AND the iMessage of today, all in one. However, I'm really not sure how lucrative it would have really been to just control the messaging market. I'm assuming people wouldn't take kindly to a huge amount of ads to monetize it. Perhaps there could have been value in offering businesses a business-tier of account on the BBM network, kind of like Apple's Business Chat. On the other hand, I rarely see that feature actually being used today.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> In 2008 when the App Store launched, SMS 'plans' were still an annoyingly expensive add-on here, and iMessage didn't exist. That was the window where anybody who really had a vision to do so could have become the WhatsApp AND the iMessage of today, all in one. That already existed at the time. I had a BlackBerry in 2008. I never heard of BBM and would have had no reason to send a message that way, but I installed AIM on the BlackBerry just fine.
- xp84 3y agoGood point to mention that -- I agree BBM at the time was hobbled by the requirement to have a single brand of device. If your friends had all happened to have BlackBerries, I bet you'd have all used it. However, you point out that "that already existed" as AIM. I'd argue AOL similarly missed the opportunity for AIM. They ought to have, the day the App Store launched, immediately started a massive branding campaign to revitalize AIM, probably introduced purely phone-number-based accounts, the way Telegram and Whatsapp do, removing the "username creativity" barrier to entry for new users. Everyone in 2008 should have been immediately reminded: AIM is mobile now, it's completely free, shares media better than MMS, and works on every device with a data plan (BlackBerry, iPhone, Sidekick, Android, and ideally even those terrible flip phones with BREW apps). Note: I'm aware AIM was in the App Store right away. Their primary failures were in not winning over hearts and minds to actually use it on Mobile. I liked AIM and used it on my iPhone back then, but most of my Buddy List wasn't usually even online, because they didn't think of AIM as a mobile tool, it was for using on their laptop.
- apple4ever 3y agoThat's a really great thought. Their biggest benefit was the messaging... if they had that on the iPhone and Andriod in addition to their devices they may have survived. Certainly they would've had lots in subscription revenues.
- antoniuschan99 3y agoThey refused to have bbm on iphone and android so it was a big thing when they released it on the app and play stores in 2013. I remember they wanted to keep people locked into their phones to use bbm. But by then whatsapp started to take off so they had no choice.
- not_your_vase 3y agoTo this day there is no answer to the iPhone. Android's answer is "copy, but if we have to choose between quality/sw-support/security and low-price, the default choice is the second". But make no mistake. If someone could leapfrog Apple today (just like they did leapfrog the whole industry back then), the iPhone industry would crumble overnight. But you need that idea, that upfront capital, and that marketing budget...
- afavour 3y ago> Android's answer is "copy, but if we have to choose between quality/sw-support/security and low-price, the default choice is the second". Looking at their global market share you’d struggle to say they made the wrong choice. They’re responding to market demand for a device that’s cheaper than an iPhone.
- TryWhoIsHiring 3y agoIt's not about good and bad choices. It's that the he world's best answer to the iPhone is... the iPhone, but worse quality and cheaper. Which is a tautology at best, not a response.
- unethical_ban 3y agoThe Android experience is IMO much better than iOS. Apple wins on hardware and network effect.
- not_your_vase 3y agoThe Android user experience is a carbon copy of the iOS experience, with slightly different colors and differently sharp edges around the controls. Want to see something that's not only name different? Try Palm OS. Try WinCE. Try Symbian. Not necessarily saying they are better (there is a reason why they are dead). But it will nicely illustrate that the difference between Android and iOS is very similar to DVD+R and DVD-R - the underlying code is different, but in practice they are barely distinguishable from each other. (Except for the non-existent OS support, gigabytes of bloatware, overeager process killer, etc)
- KingOfCoders 3y agoLoved my BlackBerry Passport.
- mrcwinn 3y agoI love how they complain modern smartphones are addictive and distracting, while paying homage to something we called Crackberry.
- wmf 3y agoThe book Losing the Signal goes into detail about this. They thought their existing advantages of the keyboard, battery life, durability, and network efficiency would be enough to retain customers. By the time they realized they were wrong it was too late.
- rrdharan 3y ago(Also covered in the book) They also assumed, not entirely incorrectly, that they would have a bigger moat outside the Western market due to cost factors and so they spent a huge amount of time and money on their international expansion. Cheap Androids eventually ate them there. Plus the patent lawsuit.. and general bloat, infighting and innovator’s dilemma stuff of course.
- taspeotis 3y agoExcept the iPhone had good enough battery life because it was basically a battery… > The iPhone "couldn’t do what [Apple was] demonstrating without an insanely power hungry processor, it must have terrible battery life," Shacknews poster Kentor heard from his former colleagues of the time. "Imagine their surprise [at RIM] when they disassembled an iPhone for the first time and found that the phone was battery with a tiny logic board strapped to it."
- raverbashing 3y ago"Surprise" When given a constraint, you design for that constraint. Good engineers do that And also not forgetting the role of sw optimization. No wonder software companies won the mobile phone space.
- hgomersall 3y agoI wonder if that was the real trick of the iPhone: slightly less than a day is enough battery; work on that basis. It was dropped into a world where battery life was measured in days.
- 3y ago
- 0xChain 3y agoI operated N4BB.com, which was one of the largest BlackBerry fan sites. We had many insider contacts and broke many large, exclusive stories. Fun times. Miss them. Unfortunately, the way Mike Lazaridis was depicted in the recent Docudrama about BlackBerry it wasn't too far from the truth. They really believed Apple was lying about an all-touch, physical keyboard-less phone. Following the media buzz about the iPhone, Verizon put a lot of pressure on RIM to release a competitive device. The half-baked Storm 9500 was so rushed it released with a non-touch optimized OS that was hardly responsive to the piezo screen. Not to mention the bezel had such a gap around it that pocket lint often got stuffed in and under the screen, preventing the physical click. Sad. Compounded by other failed strategic decisions/devices such as the PlayBook tablet and refusal to pay triple A developers to port their apps to BB10, it was a nail in the coffin by their own doing. There was such a hierarchical structure that completely stifled innovation. A bitter-sweet story indeed.
- anotheruser13 3y agoI used to frequent N4BB back in the day, and thank you for your efforts. Moved from BB to Android, but still miss the little trackball and physical keyboard at times, as Google continues to enshittify Gboard.
- unethical_ban 3y agoI got a blackberry for work in 2012. It was, and still is, the lightest phone I've ever owned. A physical keyboard, decent screen, loud speaker for alarms. Perfect device for oncall. I was honestly upset to be forced onto iPhone 5.
- jan_g 3y ago> Once a fast-moving innovator that kept two steps ahead of the competition, RIM grew into a stumbling corporation, blinded by its own success and unable to replicate it Could read similar thoughts about Nokia. So, what is Apple's recipe against growing into a stumbling corporation and being blinded by your own success?
- ternaryoperator 3y agoMuch better marketing. RIM viewed the BB as a business tool. Apple viewed the iPhone as a consumer device and promoted it heavily that way. In short order, Apple had shipped more devices than RIM.
- makeitdouble 3y ago"Can't innovate anymore ? My ass" was the quote that came to my mind reading your take. That was a shout of the heart and we know how it went. Is Apple immune to getting stale and blinded by their own success ?
- astrange 3y agoBetter corporate organization, better execs, knowing about the Osborne effect, and not paying employees peanuts like Canadian companies did (and still do.)
- thereisnojesus 3y ago[flagged]
- ylee 3y agoNot just BlackBerry. The entire phone industry was caught flatfooted by iPhone. I helped cover Apple for a large investment bank. The day of the iPhone announcement in January 2007, I saw a press release from Motorola come across the wire, in which the company announced yet another phone with a keyboard. I felt pity for the unfortunate souls who had designed it, worked on its launch, and wrote the copy for the press release, and who now had to see their efforts fly into the iPhone Hurricane.
- mdasen 3y agoI'd also say that it isn't easy to pivot to respond to the iPhone. Apple spent a long time developing iOS and the iPhone. Early Android phones were really far behind. If Apple hadn't been an AT&T exclusive in the US and had adapted to the way people bought phones independent of carriers in most of the world, Android wouldn't have had a chance. Even in 2010, three years after the iPhone launched, Android was still mediocre. With most products, there's a general consensus about the way the market is going well before one company launches. They might launch first, but everyone is building in that direction. The iPhone really caught everyone off guard - even after Apple demonstrated it. Competitors said it would never sell without a physical keyboard. That wasn't just them covering their asses. They kept putting out devices with physical keyboards for years thinking that was the direction of the market. It wasn't just the day of the iPhone announcement. The Motorola Droid launched in November 2009 (2 years and 11 months after the iPhone was introduced, 2 years and 5 months after the iPhone went on sale). Apple had been selling its third-generation iPhone which was taking over the world and Motorola launched its keyboard-based Droid 5 months after. Apple had created something different enough that it required real work to catch up with - and real effort to even believe that was the direction to go. Literally, companies couldn't believe that Apple had found the right formula for the market.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> If Apple hadn't been an AT&T exclusive in the US and had adapted to the way people bought phones independent of carriers in most of the world I think some of those risks were insurmountable for a new entrant at the time Like, too far outside of their risk profile it just wouldn't make sense to pursue
- latchkey 3y agoAlways trips me out driving through Irvine and still seeing their logo on a couple buildings there.
- pixelmonkey 3y agoI only had a Blackberry for a short while -- a BlackBerry Bold 9000 (got it in 2009). It was my stop-gap between plain cell phones and my first Android phone (a Droid 2, got it in 2010). Then I moved to touch screens with the Samsung Galaxy S4. I'm currently a Pixel 7 user. Nothing ever matched the typing speed of the Blackberry Bold 9000. I was slowed down a bit by the slide-out on my Droid 2, and slowed down a TON by switching to touch. But I could actually "do email" on my Blackberry. At essentially the same speed as my laptop. Even today, with many years of practice -- including swipe, text prediction, and all the rest -- writing a mid-size email on my phone is excruciatingly slow vs my physical typing and thinking speed. Even more frustrating is that when people observe me typing on my touchscreen, they'll say, "my goodness, you type SO FAST." And I'll just think, this is half-speed for me. As a simple example, sometimes I try to transcribe text from a podcast I'm listening to on my phone. It's basically impossible -- I have to go back frequently, slow it down to 0.7x audio speed, etc. But, if I transcribe text on my laptop, I can do it so fast that I type ahead of the speaker, even a fast talker. It makes a difference. I could have transcribed a live speaker on my Blackberry Bold. I could even type short notes at thinking speed, which was awesome. It's true that modern iPhones and their Android competitors (e.g. the Google Pixel line) do way more than my Blackberry Bold 9000 did. But I still lament the fact that these portable devices shifted from mobile high-speed read-write machines to mobile high-speed read with quite-slow write. For many people, these devices are essentially read-only. And with so many people living so much of their digital lives on touchscreen smartphones, it also means the entire digital world is biased for consumption rather than a nice create-consume balance. Alas. Two steps forward, one step back.
- KenArrari 3y agoI think the shift from blackberries to iphones/touch-devices is symbolic of what phones were used for. Blackberry was a work device. So the keyboard was uncompromisable so you could send emails. But the iphone is a consumption device. So you need to fit as much screen as possible on it. And you're only supposed to absorb information, not put it back out there.
- pixelmonkey 3y ago
- idkwhatsgoinon 3y agoForget fancy tactile keyboards... BlackBerry has gone "full cyber".. Endpoint Management with their BlackBerry UEM suite, secure communication with SecuSUITE, real time OS (QNX) in millions of vehicles, EPP/EDR solution (CylanceENDPOINT) based on AI and wide range of professional services (MDR [CylanceGUARD], Incident Response, Tabletop excercises, Pentesting, Code Audits, ...).
- joshstrange 3y ago> I’m realising now just how much I hate modern smartphones. They’re big, heavy, breakable, glossy, distracting, and come with surveillance crap. I did think it’d take til I was in my forties before entering get off my lawn territory though… that’s a bit scary. The BBs I had were heavy, oddly shaped, didn’t fit great in a pocket, were very distracting (I had the “internet” in my pocket!! Though the iPhone truly put the internet in my pocket, I just didn’t know it at the time), and were magnitudes less useful that even early iPhone/Android devices. I can’t imagine how someone could look back at a BB and think it was superior. Again, even early iPhones (my first was a 3GS, the third iPhone) were so clearly a massive step ahead of the BBs I had owned.
- eimrine 3y ago9790 was tiny and durable.
- joshstrange 3y agoAnd that phone came out around the same time as the iPhone 4S which was almost the same size, well over double the resolution, and ~30g heavier. By that point form factor didn’t really matter. Capabilities did and that screen sucked, web browsing on BB sucked compared to iPhone, and apps were way better (in some cases no equivalent existed on BB) on iPhone. I was specifically talking about devices that came before the iPhone and how the iPhone was marked improvement over them. However comparing phones that launched at the same time as the 9790 still show the iPhone being far superior unless you weight the physical keyboard much higher than other features.
- eimrine 3y agoYour statements are corect, but my conclusion is that people weight a giant screen as much that there is even no market for someone who weights the physical keyboard. I remember keyboard smartphones from 00's and it became unexpected for me at that time that we are heading into the no-button future. How did that happened? Can I at least run Telegram, Viber, WhatsApp on ARM device with SIM-card and a physical keyboard which is not an ARM-laptop?
- INTPenis 3y agoWhen the first iPhone came out it was ludicrously bad compared to a current Blackberry. No copy/paste, no multitasking between apps, email wasn't in landscape mode, I mean I could go on. So it's pretty clear that iPhone won because of two factors, exclusivity/eyecandy, and the other manufacturers didn't try hard enough to catch up. Because for productivity the iPhone was just pure garbage when it came out, and for several years.
- sxg 3y agoCompletely disagree. You're just listing features and assuming they're all equivalent (e.g., 7 features is better than 5 features). What the iPhone got right was that it was actually intuitive for a regular person to use—it didn't feel like a business/work tool that you had to learn to use because you were forced to. Copy/paste, multitasking, and landscape mode weren't important for a v1 device aimed at the average consumer. What mattered was the overall ease of use, which can't be reduced down to a single feature.
- INTPenis 3y agoThe lack of those features made it very difficult to use for an advanced business user, of course that wasn't Apple's audience in the beginning.
- sxg 3y agoSure, but eye candy/exclusivity were certainly not the dominant reasons the iPhone succeeded. The early iPhones were $299 with 2-year contracts—definitely not prohibitively expensive for a huge number of people. Eye candy…sure the iPhones looked good compared to the competition, but there was nothing stopping the competition from making good looking phones too.
- lowken10 3y ago[dead]
- genmud 3y agoThey won because their browser wasn’t hot garbage. Blackberry browser was so limited, android was not great and iPhones come along with a browser that was almost equivalent to a desktop experience. By the time iPhone 4s came out it was a viable option for enterprise.
- passive 3y agoI worked for BlackBerry, then called RIM, for 3 years starting just before the launch of the Bold 9000. I implemented the automated test harness for our first touch devices. It wasn't the iPhone, or a lack of a desire to respond to the iPhone, that brought us down. It was consistently poor execution at scale. RIMs success grew out of the work they did when they were a couple hundred people spread around a neighbourhood in Waterloo. That group had excellent culture and good habits for execution, which failed to scale beyond that region. When I joined there were about 10,000 of us, spread in offices all over the world. I only visited half a dozen, but the vibe in every single one was notable worse then the HQ. People didn't understand the plans, were constantly duplicating work happening at other locations, and had very little ability to communicate with leadership.
- kkielhofner 3y agoI have a personal anecdote that says otherwise. A startup I was working with in 2009 was developing a mobile solution for the healthcare space. Our initial target was iPhone (yes, extremely early and that’s a post for another day). We met with some mid-level executives at RIM (Waterloo is cool, BTW). They obviously had the intention of us leading with RIM devices. That said, when we would talk about the iPhone they had overwhelming confidence and a superiority complex I haven’t encountered since. They were calling the iPhone a toy and going so far as to heap a palatable amount of disrespect on us for even considering it. Like we were complete idiots for not seeing the obvious future where BlackBerry continued to be reigning champ in the market and the iPhone would never grow up. They got comfortable and just didn’t take the iPhone seriously, story as old as time.
- passive 3y agoI think we're describing aspects of the same problem. The Waterloo core of the company was generally very successful with what it was focused on, so if you never got your head out of that bubble, you might assume things were going just as well elsewhere. There was definitely a lot of cockiness in the executives at the time, but it takes more than that to sink a company, as modern times have emphasized heavily. I can promise you that internally there was a ton of energy directed at competing with the iPhone. But RIM would have floundered against Android in the same way, because the company culture never scaled out of Waterloo.
- ta1243 3y agoCorporate IT loved blackberrys, they could lock them down so it was email only, great stuff, I'm sure it matched some policy which had been set by someone Then a couple of execs got an iphone for christmas and started talking about angry birds to their chums at the golf club Then those execs got themselves iphones, but didn't want to carry two phones around, so they forced corporate IT to make it happen Corporate IT never recovered
- apple4ever 3y agoCorporate IT - especially back in those days - loved control and loved saying no. It has improved a bit, and the iPhone really helped (along with younger people coming in changing the culture). I've always had a default answer of "maybe" - let's look and see what we can do. Much better than always saying yes (and getting in trouble with overwork or problems) or always saying no (leading to people angry and shadow IT popping up).
- dessimus 3y ago> Corporate IT - especially back in those days - loved control and loved saying no. It has improved a bit, and the iPhone really helped (along with younger people coming in changing the culture). That's because when Dipshit McSalesface loses his device out at conference with his confidential leads and sales info, the CxO's make it IT's problem to deal with, not Sales'.
- ta1243 3y agoIn my experience, shadow IT is where all the business benefit is added, its where all the innovation happens However shadow IT doesn't allow large procurement contracts and expensive steak dinners in the Maldives for those at the top.
- WoodenChair 3y agoSome folks in this thread who are saying it wasn’t the iPhone… then how come Palm, Motorola, and Nokia also had their phone business eliminated or greatly reduced? Was RIM the one company that the meteor did not hit and instead died of a pandemic?
- runjake 3y agoI think it was the iPhone that killed everyone off. But at the time, RIM had a particularly loyal user base with a good solid niche (mobile messaging) that they totally goofed up at the leadership and vision level.
- noonething 3y agoWhy doesn't someone just put a BB keyboard into an android phone?
- rdsnsca 3y agoRim has sued every company that tried that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Hithredin 3y agoBlackberry simply lost the appeal/marketing. Yes the Storm was horrible and the Torch was just ok. But Blackberry 10 didn't come that late. At release time it was superior to the current iPhone and Android in many points. Usability, dynamic permissions, the Hub, animations were so fluids and responsives, virtual keyboard, advanced dev toolkit... It was one single thing that killed it: Customers were told Blackberry is old and un-cool. So they think.
- canucker2016 3y agoI thought one of the main reasons for the iPhone's popularity in the USA was the unlimited data with AT&T. see https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/06/26AT-T-and-Apple-Announce-Simple-Affordable-Service-Plans-for-iPhone/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2007/06/26AT-T-and-Apple-Anno... [update: added following text about AT&T's subsequent iPhone marketing] from https://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/2017/09/12/10-years-ago-att-bet-on-apple-s-first-iphone-aiming-to-shake-up-the-telecom-s-brand/ https://www.dallasnews.com/business/technology/2017/09/12/10...: "Analysts wondered if Apple could live up to the hype. They cautioned that only the wealthy or the tech-obsessed might cough up the cash. Only 15 percent or less of phone users said in a 2007 survey by Jupiter Research that they were willing to pay $100 or more for a phone. Jobs said he aimed to get just 1 percent of the market by 2008. AT&T threw its backing behind the iPhone again a year later. It decided to subsidize the iPhone 3G — the second generation of the phone — to boost retail sales and ultimately add more wireless customers. It began paying Apple about $300 per device, according to analysts' estimates, to lower the cost for customers. It charged $199 for the iPhone 3G, a sharp price cut from the first phone. More than 1 million of the phones sold in the first weekend. By January 2008, the iPhone had become AT&T's most popular smartphone, leading to an uptick in wireless customers for the legacy telecom as landlines began to decline."
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> It was one single thing that killed it: Customers were told Blackberry is old and un-cool. So they think. The iPhone had GPS, mapping applications, a full browser, and unlimited data. The simple fact that I could stream Pandora on my commute was amazing. Pretty objectively, iPhone offered more utility per dollar than BlackBerry. And after iPhone 3G, there were literally daily publishings of new apps that you wanted to explore.
- i_am_a_peasant 3y agoi had a z10, shittiest speaker I ever had. almost killed my father when he had a heart attack, I couldn't understand the operator lady on my emergency call. thankfully they sent people over and he's still alive.