10 ms·
New York City declares state of emergency amid flash floods
- philipov 3y agoAgain?! Didn't this same thing happen last year or maybe the one before?
- Johnny555 3y agoIt'll probably happen next year and the year after that too.
- madaxe_again 3y agoEvery year until the underwriters refuse to underwrite - as is already happening on the gulf coast. Not with a bang, but with a whimper.
- bobthepanda 3y agoAt least in New York the geology permits a seawall, if they get their shit together and build it.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoDoes a sea wall help with too much rain at once?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- discreteevent 3y agoI don't know about NYC but in general a sea wall could hold back a high tide. A lot of coastal cities flood when there is high rainfall coinciding with a high tide. When the tide is low the rain just drains into the river and out to sea.
- lxgr 3y agoIn this case though, as far as I can tell it really was mostly a lot of rain at once, i.e. too much for sewers to drain to the sea to prevent flooding. I don't think a sea wall could improve this; only better storm drains could. I think this was different for Hurricane Sandy, where a storm tide was actually pushing in water from the sea/rivers, which is the scenario where a sea wall would help. And I suppose often it's a bit of both – storm drains stop working once the sea level is too high.
- nostrademons 3y agoNo, but better drainage would. In my sister's ex-subdivision in Houston, the streets were designed to flood, channeling any water away from property and into bayous, rivers, and ultimately the Gulf of Mexico. It worked as designed over several tropical storms. The streets were a mess but everybody's home, driveway, and property stayed dry. NYC needs a similar effort - change the streets and subways to channel water away from property and into the harbor, while providing means to harden the underground parts that can't get wet. It will be crazy expensive, but it's an engineering & construction problem, not a geographic or climate one.
- bobthepanda 3y agoDumping water into the harbor only really works if it won't just come right back out onto the land. Most of the flooded areas are at sea level.
- nostrademons 3y agoHence the seawall idea.
- telotortium 3y agoThough as you may be aware, the 3rd and 5th wards are not so well protected. Low-lying parts of highways are often flooded out, especially during hurricanes.
- bobthepanda 3y agoIt does if you can drain into the body of water you are blocking with the seawall.
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoI'm pretty confident it will happen, there's too much real-estate money to not do it.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThe current project has been beset by problems with this as well. Anywhere with a seawall will have lower flooding inside but more flooding outside. When it was originally proposed at the Narrows, Staten Island, Brooklyn and Queens were not pleased.
- user3939382 3y agoSandy the subway stations were filled with water. There were emergency flood gates built into the tunnels in some places but they weren’t maintained.
- pixl97 3y ago"Didn't we have record floods last year too?" "Didn't we have record highs last year too?" "Didn't we have record tornadoes last year too?" "Didn't we have record fires last year too?" Welcome to the age of climate instability.
- Alupis 3y ago*Welcome to the age of constant 24/7 sensationalized news cycles. Gotta get those clicks! One doom-n-gloom done, onto the next!
- spicybright 3y agoThese are the actual results of climate change though. What's being sensationalized here?
- Alupis 3y ago[flagged]
- lxgr 3y agoBoth of these things can be true at the same time: Climate change can increase the likelihood of events like this (warmer sea water roughly translates to more energy available for tropical storms, if I understand it right), but for any individual storm, it's impossible to say whether it would have happened anyway without climate change, and it can make sense to be prepared. Climate change is real, but climate change awareness alone is not a reasonable protection strategy for a city by the sea.
- Alupis 3y agoIt's a fair point you raise - my issue is the immediate blame of damn near everything on climate change. If everything is climate change, then nothing is climate change... it's tired and overused. There's no way the government of NYC conducted a study and learned this particular storm was caused by climate change in real time while it's still happening. Yet... here's the blame parade already. Climate change activists need to understand this pseudo-religious fever harms their position.
- digitalsushi 3y agoI'd like to hear from people who are there right now. How scary is this? Because it looks like the end of the world. But are we all watching the same whirlpool video and it was cherry picked doom, or is it really that bad everywhere?
- BoxFour 3y agoIn Manhattan, at least, there has been a significant amount of rainfall, but things have mostly cleared up now on the streets.
- yowzadave 3y agoThe videos show the worst spots--in most cases you can get around them, assuming you have time and aren't worried about getting wet. It's definitely scary and dangerous if you or your car happens to be stuck in the water. If you're in an apartment that doesn't have drainage issues, you can probably stay inside without noticing much. If you own a house with a basement in some neighborhoods, there's a good chance you have (potentially sewage-contaminated) water flowing into it.
- Grazester 3y agoIts not all areas of Brooklyn that are flooded of course. Some of those areas flooded usually experience some kind of flooding when it rains heavily. There was a heavy monsoon like downpour on 4 th of July for about an hour and there was flooding in the Prospect Park area and Windsor terrace area(flooded now again); Enough that given I was in my previously lowered car I wouldn't have been able to drive through it. Another flooded area Borough Park is flat and I believe gets a lot of run off from the more elevation Sunset park neighborhood nextdoor.
- syntaxing 3y agoI have family all over NYC. Seems like Brooklyn got hit the hardest. The video they took and sent me, some streets are about knee height. Other borough are flooded enough to effect homes and basements but nothing catastrophically bad. The worse part is the backed up drains and sewers.
- d_watt 3y ago
- seneca 3y agoIs anyone aware of major civil engineering effort being undertaken in NYC to deal with this? They've had several major flooding events in the last handful of years. Seems almost as if they need levees.
- bobthepanda 3y agohttps://www.6sqft.com/army-corps-of-engineers-releases-first-renderings-of-nyc-sea-walls-for-coastal-storm-protection-plan/ https://www.6sqft.com/army-corps-of-engineers-releases-first...
- seneca 3y agoThank you for the link. A bit unfortunate for the aesthetics but likely necessary.
- mnutt 3y agoToday’s flooding was caused by excessive rain, and I think the problems are mostly around inadequate drainage? Whereas Sandy was a storm surge and could have been mitigated with something like levees.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoNYC might be able to do something like that if it wasn't being strangled budget-wise by an insanely expensive, overstaffed, and ineffective police department.
- anotherhue 3y agoUWS/HK seems fine - I suspect we're at a higher elevation. BK seems the worst hit from the videos.
- oatmeal1 3y ago[flagged]
- juujian 3y agoOk? And? You can get cancer even without being exposed to asbestos...
- johnnyworker 3y agoNot with that that frequency and magnitude. https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-how-climate-change-affects-extreme-weather-around-the-world/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/mapped-how-climate-change-affect...
- catlover76 3y agoYou would fail the LSAT with that kind of logical reasoning ability; just because something (y) might have occurred in the absence of a potential cause (x), does not mean that the claim that x caused y is prima facie false or "a joke". Trying to bury one's head in the sand about climate change, on the other hand, is of course arrogant and morally corrupt.
- thefurdrake 3y ago> What a joke. Severe weather, including rain even worse than this, could have occurred even if there were no climate change. "I've coughed before while I'm healthy, that means the common cold is a lie; could have occurred even if there were no common cold."
- oatmeal1 3y agoI only criticized the confirmation bias. Don't put words in my mouth.
- thefurdrake 3y agoI wasn't putting words in your mouth, I was lampooning your position by making an equivalent statement.
- game_the0ry 3y agoNYC resident, here. Its crazy bad.
- timr 3y agoNYC resident here. It is not "crazy bad". Other than the trains not running (which, let's be clear, is unfortunately not super rare), I barely noticed a difference. Zero-content exaggeration like this is infuriating. Obviously, if you're in an area that got flooded, it may well be the worst thing you've experienced in years. One person cannot speak for a city of 8 million people.
- macNchz 3y agoI mean...I don't disagree about context-free doom, but unless you work from home and had nothing to do today, you were likely affected by this in some way. Basically the entire subway and commuter rail serving millions of people was barely functional all day long, there was massive gridlock traffic because the highways flooded, many hours later three major road links out of the city (the Saw Mill, Hutchinson, and Bronx River parkways) remain closed to traffic, and there's widespread water damage to people's property–down the block from me cars floated out of the street and onto the sidewalk! Not great!
- Wowfunhappy 3y agoFor what it's worth, I live in Manhattan and don't work from home, and this didn't affect my day at all beyond my evening commute taking an extra half hour or so.
- game_the0ry 3y ago> NYC resident here. It is not "crazy bad". Other than the trains not running (which, let's be clear, is unfortunately not super rare), I barely noticed a difference. You must not have been in BK. 1/2/3, 4/5/6, N/Q/W/R all stopped running or partial service in BK. Local and express busses down in that area. Major streets shut down, including the ones around BK bridge. I spent 4 hours in traffic picking up my wife today. Also saw 4 accidents, bc drivers here seem to prefer driving more reckless in rain. If that's not "crazy bad", I don't know what it. > Zero-content exaggeration like this is infuriating. Obviously, if you're in an area that got flooded, it may well be the worst thing you've experienced in years. One person cannot speak for a city of 8 million people. Too many new yorkers have adopted this attitude of "its not that bad!" when it gets ugly here. I get it, I like the city (when its working) too, but I want the city to be better. I have been living or consistently visiting the city (and by "city", I mean all of NYC, not just Manhattan) since 2011. Thing have been getting worse, especially since covid. I have seen a video of people open cooking a roast pig on the sidewalk. NYC is 3rd world. The only thing keeping me here is my job that requires me to come into the office 3x/week.
- spandextwins 3y agoI feel so bad for all those who just moved there, I hope they’re all ok.
- thefurdrake 3y agoWho?
- pauldenton 3y agoThere's been planeloads of new arrivals
- thefurdrake 3y agoOh? Which ones?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shin_lao 3y agoNYer here. NYC infrastructure is old and unmaintained. The sewer system is 175 years old. These floods happen every year at different magnitude.
- game_the0ry 3y ago> NYC infrastructure is old and unmaintained. The sewer system is 175 years old. These floods happen every year at different magnitude. Given the amount of money I pay for taxes to the state, perhaps the state/city should update that infrastructure.
- bobthepanda 3y agoThey are, but they are a bit backlogged on what exactly they need to do. Part of the issue is that New York is so old it runs a combined sewer/storm drain system. Modern practice is to separate the two since the former needs to be treated and the latter generally doesn't, but when they're combined the outflows overwhelm the sewage system and then that's how you get backed up sewage, sewage emergency discharge into the harbor, etc. Actually separating the two is quite difficult. On the one hand that means requiring building owners to separate and plug into a new system. Then you run into the fact that in New York 170+ years of haphazardly planned utilities by multiple public and private actors means there is no accurate map of where exactly things are underground, which makes building a new system going under every street expensive and full of legal issues. (The city has been trying to get a handle on this problem for years but doesn't get a lot of cooperation since a lot of these entities treat the location of their stuff underground as trade secrets, if they even have accurate information themselves.) Right now, the projects taking up most of their time are * the construction of Water Tunnel no. 3, since the other two tunnels that deliver all the water to NYC have never been shut down for inspection at any point in their 100+ year lives and can't be unless a backup tunnel exists * lead pipe remediation, because there's still a lot of it.
- game_the0ry 3y agoSo...too much legacy technical debt. And no political will to do anything. In an environment of rising interest rates (more expensive gov bonds) and lower tax receipts. Makes sense, given quality of life and city services have been getting worse. And things should (predictably) get worse.
- renewiltord 3y agoEveryone's constantly declaring states of emergency. It's hard to care. Over the last year, San Francisco and Alameda have been in a "state of emergency" over: - monkeypox - COVID-19 - homelessness - drug use This weekend I might go look back at everything and see what duration we have not been in an emergency over.
- MAGZine 3y agoHow many people need to be affected, in your opinion, to have a bonafide emergency?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoone. renewiltord.
- renewiltord 3y agoHahaha, that's brillo mate. No, I don't think it's a number of people thing. I think there's got to be some anomalous event. You can't constantly be in an emergency. That's just the new normal, eh?
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoThat's why it's called The Long Emergency....
- djaouen 3y agoIf you can’t stand the heat, get off of Earth, as Elon says.
- sghiassy 3y ago[flagged]
- afavour 3y agoI waded through knee high water earlier and a bunch of friends have flooded basements. My building’s elevators shut off so I’m not sure what my basement storage unit looks like right now, probably not great. It’s, uh, not a mystery where the flooding took place today. But glad it’s a source of amusement!
- goosinmouse 3y agoWow, how are you posting on here if you don't have access to internet? Surely if you had internet you'd see one of the hundreds of videos in and around NYC of flooded streets.
- ctvo 3y agoIf it's not happening to me, is it really happening?
- weatherlight 3y agoI had 2.5 ft (0.762 meters) of water in my basement this morning :( (Clinton Hill/ Bed-Stuy Brooklyn) my kids school P.S. 11, basement level also flooded. my coffeeshop that I go to in the morning, flooded.
- gadflyinyoureye 3y agoI’m going to purchase a house with a basement. Do you know how the water got in?
- weatherlight 3y agothe NYC sewer backed-up into the apt. All the rain water and the sewer go to the same place because NYC's sewer system is from the 1800's. If you do get a house, get one with a sump pump. if it's the bottom floor of an apartment building, get one with a back flow valve going into the building. When buying used, make sure to look over the HOA's minutes to see if they've had issues with flooding in the past and what repairs they've done to address those issues.
- a_square_peg 3y agoI seem to be hearing about these torrential rain/flood in the news more often and this data visualization that I made a couple of years ago seems relevant. https://twitter.com/oikoweather/status/1338691244470403075 https://twitter.com/oikoweather/status/1338691244470403075 Basically, since 1950, we've added 2 litres of water per square meter of earth's surface to the atmosphere. This is twice the volume of Lake Erie.
- effnorwood 3y ago[dead]
- VincentEvans 3y agoEmployers letting their recently brought back to office remote employees go home early to try to beat transit issues caused by extreme weather events that are becoming more common due to global warming caused by everyone commuting to office every day burning energy and creating pollution. It took a global pandemic to spur us to switch to a more modern and as it happens environmentally friendly way of working, which could even help us alleviate housing issues by allowing more people to disperse around the country, help local economies in more rural places, but no, let’s go back to doing things exactly how we did before. Everything is fine.
- TheHappyOddish 3y agoSure... But how much extra energy is consumer by people heating/cooling their 1-2 person homes now they're in it all day? Likely less than transit, and not zero. Regardless, the primary impact on climate change has always been and likely always will be those who manufacture your clothes, plastics, electronics etc - which people bought more over over said pandemic. Rural areas invaded by "COVID refugees" are broadly losing out on their culture and filling with yuppies with too much money and no interest in community. I admire your passion, but the problems are more complex.