8 ms·
Discovery Steering Committee re Google Antitrust Litigation [pdf]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"At the September 15 hearing, Judge Anderson pressed Google to explain how it could have permitted what the court termed an egregious and very significant problem in this case: I'm not understanding how this could happen with what should have been at least two levels of oversight. (9/15/23 DOJ Action Tr. at 52, 54, 59.) As the Court noted: You produced how many documents since the filing of this lawsuit? 1 million. So you're talking about potentially five times what you've produced, and you're saying you thought there was substantial completion done? Its false. It wasnt; was it? (Id. at 55.) After hearing from Google's counsel, the court stated, It's no excuse and Maybe it wasn't malicious, maybe it wasn't in bad faith, but it clearly was not being done under proper supervision, either internally or externally. And you've put everyone in an unfortunate situation by your failure to do that. (Id. at 56, 58.) The Court appeared further concerned about the delay in jumping on this issue sooner: You've known about this for a month now. You knew about it starting on August 18th. You knew there was a real issue. There didn't seem to be a call to arms then. The first time I heard about it was September 1, and it was this, you know, like, whoops, we've got a problem. It wasn't as clear as I now know how egregious this is. (Id. at 59.)"
- metadat 3y ago"We get sued all the time, so how could we have known this was a special case?"
- synctext 3y ago> There didn't seem to be a call to arms then. The first time I heard about it was September 1, and it was this, you know, like, whoops, we've got a problem. They seem to have significant problems. Its broader then "not discovering" 5 minus 1 million of documents. There seems to be multiple smoking guns in evidence: https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-09/416652.pdf https://www.justice.gov/d9/2023-09/416652.pdf Google internal Email instruct: never to talk about 'market share' or even 'markets'. This is clear and deliberate behaviour to evade government regulators. It is institutionalised through legal training class 101. Disclaimer: not a lawyer, CS professor with some courtroom experience.
- kuchenbecker 3y agoNAL - I'm failing to see how telling your employees not to do things that violate or give the impression of anti-trust law is a smoking gun. That seems like a no-brainer thing a company should be doing.
- detaro 3y agothe problem is when it becomes more instruction on "if you do X, make sure you don't say suspicious words so nobody notices we are doing X"
- professoretc 3y ago"...so that when we get sued and in discovery they ask for all documents discussing markets, nothing will come up."
- side_up_down 3y agoYou can be sure Google's lawyers vetted the training to ensure it was lawful instruction.
- pagekicker 3y agoThe ruling also documents a pattern of Google performing badly in discovery which suggests that it is a strategy.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> The ruling also documents a pattern of Google performing badly in discovery... So, Google is bad at finding things.
- Kamq 3y agoGoogle search has been going downhill.
- klabb3 3y agoTheir motto (after “don’t be evil” was phased out) was something like “organizing the information of the world, making it accessible for everyone”. Objective failed, I guess?
- charcircuit 3y ago>after “don’t be evil” was phased out It wasn't https://abc.xyz/investor/google-code-of-conduct/ https://abc.xyz/investor/google-code-of-conduct/
- hn_version_0023 3y agoSo why are they continually evil? OR are those just words on a page?
- okwhateverdude 3y agoYou're assuming the goal posts on evil haven't been moved. Easy to justify all of your nonsense if you lower bar of evil to "not committing genocide."
- UncleMeat 3y ago
- belltaco 3y agoThey couldn't put ads on the search results so they didn't serve them to the DoJ.
- Mistletoe 3y agoDoJ tried to contact them about it but there’s no way to contact a human at Google.
- belltaco 3y agoThey also deleted chat messages without verifying if they needed to be reported. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/02/23/doj-says-google-destroyed-chat-messages-it-should-have-saved.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/02/23/doj-says-google-destroyed-ch...
- ImAnAmateur 3y agoIsn't Google going to get some sort of sanction for this specifically? I'm having a hard time following it all now, but I remember reading that the DOJ was going to "sanction" Google and have been waiting for the court case to begin to see what that will amount to.
- jeffbee 3y agoLegal sanctions for spoliation are not always as satisfying as you are probably imagining. Putting aside whatever predisposition you have about Google and this case, I do find it troubling that American jurisprudence is headed for a future where there is no such thing as going off the record, if you are using a chat app. Nobody thinks you have to record and preserve face-to-face communications, but apparently people want it to be that you always have to record and preserve them if there was some intermediate device used to do it, other than by voice. In the WFH era this bothers me.
- eep_social 3y ago> no such thing as going off the record Hard agree. I have personal bias in this case, but it’s crazy to me that sentiment on off the record chat in these threads has been so heavily weighted towards normalizing the idea that everything should be recorded. I would be horrified if certain of my Slack DMs end up in discovery at my current job. I have to admit that sometimes I just need to blow off some steam to my teammate who sits two states over, and we communicate on Slack or Zoom, both of which are automatically recorded and preserved for at least a short time. Bob in procurement is not a literal gnome-fucking-shit-smear-artist but sometimes I do feel that way. My barber doesn’t know Bob but my teammate sat in the same meeting where we got a raw deal so we bond over the experience by saying stupid things in a Slack DM conversation. Under the developing regime this kind of casual talk on company systems is a risk for both myself and my employer if it ends up getting keyword matched during discovery. Not sure where a reasonable line is but it does seem like the grey area needs urgent attention before tech turns into finance.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dang 3y agoPlease don't editorialize titles. This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. If you want to say what you think is important about an article, that's fine, but do it by adding a comment to the thread. Then your view will be on a level playing field with everyone else's: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=%22level%20playing%20field%22%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... (Submitted title was "Google's 5M Document Discovery Failure: "Egregious", Says Magistrate Judge [pdf]")
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoNew title should say "In re" not just "re".
- dang 3y agoWhy?
- rdtsc 3y ago> Google stated that “it has come to our attention that the search terms that Google agreed to use for the litigation were mistakenly not run over all of the ingestion sites where the custodians’ documents are stored.” > So you’re talking about potentially five times what you’ve produced, and you’re saying you thought there was substantial completion done? It’s false. It wasn’t; was it?” (Id. at 55.) Well, what can you do? :shrug: Dogs eat homework papers, evidence slips and falls into shredders accidentally, unfortunate fires happen /s But really, what could the court really do in cases like this, a slap on the wrist fine and everyone goes home and promises to behave better next time.
- toast0 3y agoCourts can issue sanctions for failure to cooperate in discovery. There's a big list of possible sanctions here [1] under "Sanctions Sought in the District Where the Action Is Pending." I'm not qualified to guess at which if any of these sanctions might be granted in this case... But that's the kind of things available. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_37 https://www.law.cornell.edu/rules/frcp/rule_37 (added link, thanks)
- harry8 3y agono link. But in that "big list of possible sanctions" is there anything that would inconvenience google as much as a $200 fine inconveninences someone on minimum wage? Is there anything at all that isn't just a trivial business expense dwarfed by what they will pay their lawyers just for this one case? Is there any risk of a human being held accountable for anything?
- verve_rat 3y agoAh, yeah. The possibilities include the judge just straight up ruling against Google in a summary judgement. The worst case scenario is Google just looses the case and the FTC gets whatever it has asked for. The likelihood of that happening is up for debate of course, but that is the very very very bad thing that could happen.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bdd8f1df777b 3y ago[dead]