8 ms·
Japanese scientists working on creating human eggs and sperm in the lab
- toomuchtodo 3y agoBig if it works for fertility treatments. No more need for ovary stimulation and ultrasound guided egg retrieval (painful and complications can occur), and the math and need around reproductive tissue cryostorage changes for the positive.
- kylebenzle 3y agoDespite the concerns, the Japanese government is considering allowing scientists to proceed with creating IVG embryos for research. Fujita, who's on the committee the government formed to consider this, supports that. "The technology of IVG, its purpose is not only [to] have a baby — genetically related baby — but there are many benefits and good things you can know from the basic research," she says, such as finding new ways to treat infertility and prevent miscarriages and birth defects.
- victor106 3y agoWhat if in the future, the state, due to dwindling population growth creates humans from engineered eggs and sperms? The reasons to do this are obvious, no population, no growth, no profits. Also, what if, they engineer these "artificial" humans to die preciesly when they reach a particular age? The state can then accurately predict retirement benefits, design infrastructure, distribute benefits more uniformly
- FpUser 3y ago>"What if" replace it to "when". Hopefully we can avoid it and use the tech to fix health problems for existing people
- mysterydip 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan's_Run https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logan's_Run
- pineapple_guy 3y agoAnd what if we are already the product of this process from a long forgotten empire?
- a-r-t 3y agoI've seen things you people wouldn't believe...
- shadowgovt 3y agoIt's funny to me (and I've done it too) that people mis-remember how Roy's finite life-expectancy plot worked. It wasn't a feature; it was a bug. The company marketed it as a feature, but in reality (before Rachael, maybe) they didn't know how to build Nexus-6 with more than a four-year life expectancy. When Roy finally tracks down his creator and demands he remove it, Tyrell admits that he can't. ``` Tyrell: You were made as well as we could make you. Roy: But not to last. ``` It's the realization that his own creator, despite all the marketing hype, isn't a god, but just another flawed mortal... that the two of them are fundamentally equal creatures in this mad universe... that pushes Roy past the edge into madness and eventual redemption, when he realizes that in the face of a universe so cold and uncaring about the life within it, it's only life that can care about life. All of it, in all its forms.
- vsareto 3y ago>Also, what if, they engineer these "artificial" humans to die preciesly when they reach a particular age? Pretty much a science fantasy, but what stops the population from engineering it back?
- masklinn 3y agoWhat stops the population from engineering fertility back in gmo seeds?
- justrealist 3y agoGMO crops do not have terminator genes. Enforcement is via license, not biology. They aren't sterile (but 2nd generation crops often are less useful because it produces sibling crosses which lose the targeted benefits).
- whatshisface 3y agoEngineering people to die at a specific age is as far fetched as engineering them to live forever, so you might as well imagine the latter.
- unshavedyak 3y agoSpeaking purely capitalist for sake of discussion, i wonder what would be more beneficial / ROI friendly? I suspect a steady supply of young humans would be more likely to bend to your intentions and goals than a smaller supply of humans that become more wise, bored, etc with infinite life. Plus infinite life seems a near super power. Would they just hand it to nobodies? Seems like at that point they could produce a special few that live forever while the rest of the plebs have a largely normal life. And heck, to extend your idea further; if it is equally difficult than perhaps you could do both, not one or the other. So make many mortals and a select few chosen royalty bloodlines that live forever. You get a population you can predictably control and forever royalty. .. sometimes i'm glad i wasn't born 500 years later.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bee_rider 3y agoWithout knowing much of anything about either technology, I still want to speculate that we’ll probably have pretty good AI based automation before we’re creating out designer humans in bulk. So the whole economic structure would have to be very different. Maybe AI’s will be specifically designed to serve humans, and maybe they’ll design particularly rebellious humans, as they present more novel requests.
- almatabata 3y agoI think you could achieve the former more easily than you think. If we suppose you can gene edit to have certain characteristics. Why could they not add birth defects like heart problems and cancer? They then die from a heart attack at 30. Of course the technology might never get there either but to me gene editing for a birth defect sounds easier than gene editing to live forever but maybe i underestimate the former.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- kuratkull 3y ago"In Time" (movie) would be the more likely outcome: time-to-live is transferrable currency. But in the real world people already die at a predictable age - we are all statistics.
- powersnail 3y agoIt might be a good solution to infertility; but since infertility is not the main cause of dwindling population, artificial babies probably won't be effective in solving the general population crisis. People who don't want to raise kids probably also wouldn't want to raise artificial kids. If the kids are put in state's care, well, current society can't take good care of existing orphans. How are we going to handle more parent-less kids?
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y ago> If the kids are put in state's care, well, current society can't take good care of existing orphans. How are we going to handle more parent-less kids? I have two children whom I have tried quite conscientiously to not expose to the more toxic parts of our culture. They have, to my knowledge, never watched any of the sitcoms where some significant fraction of the comedy revolves around parents and other adults complaining about having children/families. None of the standup comedians of that ilk (supposing that's still a part of their schtick). I avoid anything that talks about how "your carbon footprint will be smaller if you just don't have kids". They weren't really aware of the term "overpopulation". Most of all, I've always talked quite fondly and genuinely of having become a father myself. And, now, even as teenagers, they seem to look forward to the idea of becoming parents themselves one day. I don't have a large sample size, and it's hardly scientific, but the biggest problem I think is that our culture revels in how awful parenting is. The act of believing that idea causes people to be incapable of enjoying it. I also suspect rather strongly that it is more than just some arbitrary meme that bounces around in everyone's collective heads, instead the idea itself causes people to fail to enjoy parenting and to avoid it. It becomes this self-fulfilling prophecy, should they fail to achieve lasting childlessness. Why should such a culture deserve to even survive? Your civilization requires that people continue to reproduce, but shows nothing but contempt for the concept. It shows contempt for itself. All of the very ideals this civilization embraces and exalts seem contrary to reproduction, and no one shows any awareness that that would have to change, let alone interest in making the changes.
- powersnail 3y agoI'm not quite sure how your comment is a response to mine, despite you replying to me and quoting my words. I don't personally have contempt to parenthood or the act of reproduction, and I don't see how it's related to my doubt that societies would be able to take care of artificial reproduced kids, given the poor state of existing care for orphans.
- rawgabbit 3y agoThat’s the plot of Bladerunner. We bioengineer a slave class with a fixed life span and prevent them from reproducing.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoI'm really curious how the bioethicist debate around this would work. At some point it feels like you're experimenting on humans without their consent. I guess that can be said about many treatments that are used to make babies (like IVF) or otherwise affect the young, but given the inherent uncertainty that would surround the first couple human babies that would be made using this technique, it does seem like a pretty wide bridge to cross.
- justrealist 3y agoI'll just note that if modern bioethics precautionary principles were applied in the 1970s, we would probably never have gotten human IVF treatments — nobody would have ever gotten the green-light to try it on a person. As someone who has a family because of IVF, I am very thankful that researchers were allowed to roll the dice on that one, and see that it turned out well.
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoThis puts the cart before the horse. If we have very good reason to believe we may be doing something immoral, it behooves us to be cautious. Also, this is not a question of precaution, but a known objectively gravely immoral act. There is no risk here that we might be doing something wrong using IVF. We know with certainty that IVF is gravely immoral. That we may have obtained some outcome that is desirable does not justify the illicit means. That is, applied to your case, while it is not wrong for your family to exist per se, the means by which they were brought into existence was definitely illicit.
- shadowgovt 3y ago> We know with certainty that IVF is gravely immoral. Why?
- Enginerrrd 3y ago>There is no risk here that we might be doing something wrong using IVF. We know with certainty that IVF is gravely immoral. Sorry but... what? What about that is immoral, or... even questionable?
- scohesc 3y agoWill be very _very_ interesting to see if the tech develops enough in my lifetime to where people can send in spit samples to a medical firm, have their genome processed and then the medical company can remove any genetic predispositions to certain defects, etc... You could then also (for a hefty price), choose to have different traits embedded in your embryo - different eye colors, hair types, jawline, etc. I'm sure we'll eventually get to the point where you can go to a medical company, throw your spit into a machine and be able to check on/off boxes for desired traits, remove negative traits, etc. etc. and have a baby ready for you under accelerated growth in weeks, not months. For added comedy, have it delivered by drone - instead of a stork delivering your child, it could be Amazon!
- hutzlibu 3y ago"For added comedy, have it delivered by drone - instead of a stork delivering your child, it could be Amazon! " Interesting dystopia? But as far as I understand, the understanding of genetics is changing. Meaning there are no simple flags to set, that will enable or disable certain diseases or traits. It is way more interconnected, so your custom ordered amazon baby might have to wait a little bit longer.
- BXlnt2EachOther 3y agofor anyone intrigued and/or frightened by the first half of that, here's a context-sensitive recommendation for the film Gattaca (1997) -- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gattaca https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gattaca
- cameldrv 3y agoA more limited version of this is already a consumer product [1]. You can't edit the genome, but you can pick the best (for whatever your definition of best is) of the dozen or so embryos. They sequence the whole genome of all of the embryos and give you all sorts of genetic information. [1] https://www.orchidhealth.com https://www.orchidhealth.com
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoNot a laughing matter, of course. The commodification of human beings is a huge problem, and one we already suffer from, a part of our cultural malaise.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoConsidering Japan has a huge birth rate collapse problem, it doesn't surprise me that they are leading the way for test tube babies.
- woah 3y agoWhy would that solve anything? I don’t think that anyone has any complaints about the process of conceiving a baby naturally, it’s what happens in the 18 years following
- esafak 3y agoI read that the Japanese aren't even having much recreational sex. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/20/young-people-japan-stopped-having-sex https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/oct/20/young-people-j...
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoSex isn't recreational. But having said that, this is true of the West as well. So-called "casual sex" (again, does not exist), sleeping around, etc. is occurring at lower rates today than in the past. People are instead becoming porn-addicted shut-ins unable to have any sexual relations, let alone a healthy sexual relationship.
- esafak 3y agoWhat do you mean? A lot of people use contraception so they can have sex without procreating. Most sex today is of this type.
- shwaj 3y agoOf course sex is (also) recreational. I’m guessing you’re coming from a religious angle, so I’ll ask: is it a sin for a married woman to have sex after menopause?
- the_af 3y ago
- morkalork 3y agoI never knew there was such an industry surrounding IVF until researching it. It's wild how hush hush and not talked about it is while simultaneously common enough there's a whole medical tourism industry for it. You can have prescriptions sent to you in advance, get picked up by a driver at the airport and stay at an affiliated beach resort. They'll deliver prescriptions to your room so you don't need to go to pharmacy in a foreign country. Hell, some providers even include a working SIM card in the package.
- Y_Y 3y agoThere's nothing quiet about it. There's a whole district near where I live dedicated to it, it's covered by my health insurance, I've contracted to an IVF company here to do ML for face matching, many of my friends have used it, it's well enough known that the acronym didn't need to be defined.
- syntaxing 3y agoPardon my ignorance, but they use ML to find sperm and egg donors that match similar facial features to the “parents”? Cause that is honesty pretty cool.
- Y_Y 3y agoIf you're talking about DNA, yes, but no. I've worked on that too and it's much harder. In the above instance we used photos of the donors and customers and the typical case was to get a close match for the partner who was shooting blanks in order to produce an offspring who ideally would look like both "parents".
- syntaxing 3y agoThat is really awesome, would you happen to know how effective the photo method is? As in, do the kids end up looking similar to their “parents”?
- 3y ago
- woodpanel 3y agoThree words: Servants, Drones and Sex-Slaves I don’t see how this is not going to end in this. What I’m less certain about is whether the Breeded will be the cannon fodder or we‘ll be…
- shadowgovt 3y agoYou can't currently create a human being via the old-fashioned method and (legally, in post places) force them to be any of those things. There's no reason creating a human being via a new method should suddenly flip the rules and allow it.
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoWha?! Because, religion! They are abominations! Not really, but in history children born out of wedlock were freely discriminated against, assumed to be subhuman and criminal, and killed without repercussion. It would be reasonable, extrapolating from (recent) history, to assume artificial humans would instantly be put in that category.
- efnx 3y agoWe have already had these throughout history without this technology! Humans are humans no matter what they look like or how they got here and we have to treat us all equally and with respect - that’s the solution to those problems.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoNone of which will happen at any sort of scale different than it happens today as long as children require a womb, 9 months in the womb, and many years of expensive care to reach an age they can become a useful servant, drone or sex slave.
- swfsql 3y agoJapan does have a demographic problem down the road, and the only thing politicians really do care about is that taxes aren't going to get paid by themselves, you need taxpayers for that. So it's Servants from your list.
- norwalkbear 3y agoUtterly horrifying
- JoeAltmaier 3y agoSomething a wag wrote when the Pope allowed the rhythm method of birth control: Now you couldn't use chemistry or physics for family planning, but math was ok. It was a joke, but it was also very true. Was a time folks assumed fairies planted children in women's stomachs. Nowadays we know better. Lots better: now we can control the process deliberately. To claim any particular advancement in this chain of understanding is an abomination or horrifying, is a terrible temptation to update that joke. I don't see how any human being is 'horrifying', but I fear there will be those that dehumanize some of us, and call them subhuman or make it a crime for them to be born. Resist this impulse!
- norwalkbear 3y agoI reject your worldview 100% and the false equivalency between previous beliefs about childbirth and this. It's utterly horrifying because we've seen repeatedly how corporations abuse such things.
- JoeAltmaier 3y ago"Such things". I've done a quick google and failed to find evidence of artificial humans created from scratch. Not sure where that was going, except as hyperbole. And it wasn't so much about childbirth as technology. Perhaps the point was hard for some to understand, so I'll elucidate. Reproduction is a biological process that can be understood at many levels. To understand and effect change at a new level is not horrifying, not evil, not even very surprising. It's just another step in knowledge and care for human beings.
- norwalkbear 3y agoMissing the forest for trees. You are extremely naive and Short sighted.
- iandanforth 3y agoI fully support this line of work. I hope all those behaviors which lead to significant harm are outlawed and all those behaviors that lead to good outcomes are supported. Just like with every other technology in the history of humanity.
- adolph 3y ago>I hope all those behaviors which lead to significant harm are outlawed and all those behaviors that lead to good outcomes are supported. It seems very optimistic to think that humans can (a.) perform that at a germ cell level, and (b.) distinguish between moral and evolutionary goods (because they may be at odds) [0]. If the history of dog breeding is any example, quests for some perceived good lead to maladaptive features in other areas. I’m more sanguine about possibilities in altering expression of somatic cells like what octopuses do [1]. 0. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quis_custodiet_ipsos_custodes%... 1. https://news.uchicago.edu/story/octopuses-other-cephalopods-can-adjust-cold-editing-their-rna https://news.uchicago.edu/story/octopuses-other-cephalopods-...
- almatabata 3y agoA lot of behaviors can lead to good and bad outcomes. We give guns to policemen to protect citizen. They might also misuse it. We write rules that govern these behaviors to avoid or minimize the bad outcomes. In this scenario we already have a good idea of what people might do when given the chance if you look at science fiction. Instead of waiting for the technology to get ready we should really think hard on which aspect of this technology we want to adopt and which ones we want to ban. For example if you can scale this technology by not requiring women wombs, should we allow the government to grow an army of clones? Would these clones have the same right as normal citizen? We can allow individuals to have kids through this method while banning the government from misusing it (in theory).
- throwawayfear 3y agoThis should be banned everywhere.
- nonethewiser 3y agoIt wont be. China in particular stands out as a place where this will be heavily utilized. There just arent any negative feelings towards this kind of stuff.
- RivieraKid 3y agoHow long until rich people start making their own clones for limb / organ / whole body transplantation?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lamontcg 3y ago> IVG would render the biological clock irrelevant, by enabling women of any age to have genetically related children. That raises questions about whether there should be age limits for IVG baby-making. Yeah, certainly can't let women breed at any age like men do.
- frank_bb 3y ago[dead]