8 ms·
DAWproject: Open exchange format for DAWs
- allears 3y agoNice idea, but not useful unless each DAW manufacturer supports the format. And there are a lot of DAWs.
- sedivy94 3y agoMaybe I’m misinterpreting the readme but other DAWs would not need to cooperate if you’re developing a tool to transpile between formats. I think most of the proprietary specs could be reverse engineered.
- jesusofnazarath 3y ago[dead]
- phero_cnstrcts 3y agoWell, you have to start somewhere.
- noizejoy 3y agoMIDI was enthusiastically supported by Yamaha and Roland, two of the biggest synth players of that era. So I imagine, for it to become widely successful, that this new standard would need the wholehearted support of at least 2 of Steinberg, Apple, Ableton, and Avid.
- surfingdino 3y agoIndeed, MIDI 1.0 is one of the oldest implemented standards in existence. Unfortunately, MIDI 2.0 is not as successful. Let's hope Bitwig's initiative takes off.
- izenme 3y agoXML, why? And... 99% of the issues will be around plug-in management.
- hellotheretoday 3y agoProbably a relic of the musicxml format which still holds some popularity in programs based around sheet music/western notation
- follower 3y agoOn the subject of MusicXML, there is currently ongoing work to develop a successor (currently named MNX): https://w3c.github.io/mnx/docs/ https://w3c.github.io/mnx/docs/
- brtkdotse 3y agoXML is fine. Schema validation is really handy more often than you’d think.
- speedgoose 3y agoYou can do schema validation with other formats too. For example you have JSON Schema, that many people experience through Kubernetes.
- anigbrowl 3y agoDid someone say plugins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CLever_Audio_Plug-in https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CLever_Audio_Plug-in
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phero_cnstrcts 3y agoWhat would you propose? Json?
- steve1977 3y agoWhy not?
- rebolek 3y agoeasy to parse, supported by basically anything and not a shitty format like YAML for example
- royjacobs 3y agoThis is pretty nice. I've written some tools for my own softsynth that revolved around parsing various DAW formats and having a standard format, even just to export to, would have been very nice to have.
- ckbishop 3y agoBitwig is quickly becoming my favorite DAW. Big fan of how they develop software.
- lagniappe 3y agoBitwig knocked it out of the park coming out the gate with Linux support. Can't say I'm surprised though, it's made by the original team that made Ableton Live.
- steve1977 3y agoBitwig was founded by people who were previously working for Ableton. Some longer, some less long. But they were not the original team that made Live, that is a bit misleading.
- IndySun 3y ago"Bitwig ... founded by Claes Johanson, Pablo Sara, Nicholas Allen and Volker Schumacher. Our experience in the computer music software industry includes Ableton, where we were all part of the development team behind the successful music software Live ... "
- mxmilkiib 3y agoOn Linux it steals/hogs the hardware MIDI, so you can't connect to it with other JACK MIDI apps.
- dmoreno 3y agoI am also very bothered by this. I developed rtpmidid just to be able to use rtpmidi on bitwig.. and I need to use the virtual midi device hack. I was just thinking if there is a way to ask for features.. and there is! https://bitwish.top/c/features/5 https://bitwish.top/c/features/5 I will add the request for ALSA sequencer devices, which I think should include Jack ones.. but I will investigate this further, as maybe I'm wrong. There is a bridge for sure. Anyway just don't hijack the MIDI device and be nicer with the linux MIDI ecosystem is a must.
- 3y ago
- dmicah 3y agoIt would be nice if Bitwig would support existing plug-ins formats like AU.
- sctb 3y agoDo you encounter many AU-only plugins? From what I can tell, the limitations of VST/AU/AAX are more pressing and Bitwig are working to address that with CLAP: https://u-he.com/community/clap https://u-he.com/community/clap.
- unshavedyak 3y agoMan i hope more people (plugin developers too) embrace CLAP or something open. I'm writing a Rust program and i really want to allow for Modart's Pianoteq plugin and VST just makes it feel so difficult.
- dmicah 3y agoThere have always been plug-ins, especially by small developers on the Mac, which are AU only. Apple Silicon macs can now run iOS / iPadOS AUs as well, so there are a ton of plugins from that world that are not available as VSTs. Apple Logic can't load VSTs, so typically on the Mac it makes sense to just have AUs. Ableton Live on the Mac can load VSTs or AU, but there isn't really a reason to keep the VSTs around.
- duped 3y agoFewer hosts should use AU
- teilo 3y agoWhy would they want to support AU? The only reason to use AU is Logic. Everything else (Protools excepted) supports VST, and all the plugin devs release in VST and AU, so it would be a waste of time. Bitwig is putting their time into CLAP, and for good reason. It's cross-platform, much easier to develop against, and much more advanced that all the alternatives. Even Avid has shown interest in CLAP. So has Image Line. I expect Studio One to support it in v7.
- elihu 3y agoOne thing I'd like to see is native support for some notion of pitch other than 12-tone equal temperament. Looking at their example, I see this: <Note time="0.000000" duration="0.250000" channel="0" key="65" vel="0.787402" rel="0.787402"/> ...which looks like it's basically just a representation of the underlying midi. One way they could represent other pitches is for "key" to allow a floating point value rather than an integer. So, for instance, 65.5 would be a quarter-tone (50 cents) above note 65. According to their reference document, "key" is currently required to be an integer: https://htmlpreview.github.io/?https://github.com/bitwig/dawproject/blob/main/Reference.html https://htmlpreview.github.io/?https://github.com/bitwig/daw... There's other ways to support microtuning. They could apply a tuning table to the midi notes, for instance. (Ideally they should support more than the 128 notes that midi supports, because 128 isn't enough for some use cases.) They might also allow you to apply pitch bend to individual notes (which isn't allowed in midi 1.0 but was added to 2.0).
- gravitronic 3y agoAt this layer of note information, fact is the data will be either sent to a MIDI device or a plugin as a MIDI event, so you might as well keep it in the native format and not convert to a frequency.
- londons_explore 3y agoI feel like we're only months/years away from software and file formats being obsolete for this for this sort of thing, and instead songs are composed by humming a tune to ChatGPT and have it add all the other instruments, some nice vocals, and output the MP3. If you want to make changes, you give ChatGPT the MP3 file and say "switch out the trumpet for a piano and make the singer a guy".
- johnnyworker 3y agoAs someone who makes music as a hobby that's about as enticing as outsourcing sex. I don't care if the machine can do it better.
- CharlesW 3y agoIf the goal is widespread industry adoption, I'd recommend the approach of extending a professional, standards-based interchange format already supported by major DAWs: AAF. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Authoring_Format https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advanced_Authoring_Format https://www.loc.gov/preservation/digital/formats/fdd/fdd000004.shtml https://www.loc.gov/preservation/digital/formats/fdd/fdd0000...
- conradfr 3y agoThe README extensively references AAF.
- thrtythreeforty 3y agoIndeed. This is a Bitwig project. I think the default for Bitwig engineering should be "assume extreme competence."
- moleperson 3y agoWhat's wrong with Bitwig engineering?
- russelg 3y agoNothing, they are praising the engineers.
- CharlesW 3y agoYes, which is why the Yet Another Standard approach is so mystifying. Bitwig is surely aware that AAF has wide support and could easily be extended to support everything they want to do.
- devthane 3y agoI found it interesting to discover that an Ableton Live project file is a gzipped xml file as well, so you can get at the xml by gunzipping it. I've played around with trying to generate a schema file from a project file with mixed results. I very much wish Ableton would support this format or at least publish their schema somewhere so translation could be done.
- r9295 3y agoThis. I've been trying to write a VCS for Ableton projects but their schema is way too complex to try to make sense of it. Ableton is incredibly hostile to third party devs building upon their work. Eg: There is no official documentation for any of their Python APIs.
- thomashop 3y agoAlthough the python API could be documented, it was not meant to be a public API. And it seems the open source community managed to generate the documentation. I don't know any other DAW that allows as deep integration for third party devs through their Max for Live API.
- r9295 3y agoIf it was not meant to be public, then why do vendors who partner with Ableton and build hardware for Live complain about the lack of documentation? The documentation generated by the community is severely lacking and it enables only elementary usage of the API
- boffinAudio 3y ago>I don't know any other DAW that allows as deep integration for third party devs through their Max for Live API. REAPER?
- thomashop 3y agoAh makes sense. I was just thinking of the "big name" ones. I need to look into Reaper again.
- dottjt 3y agoIncredible. If Ableton adopts this it'll be a huge thing.
- xoac 3y agoProbably not happening any time soon. Bitwig’s potential for growth is in users migrating from Ableton Live and making that easier is likely not in Ableton’s interest.
- raincole 3y agoIt sounds nice but I don't know how they're going to convince other DAWs devs (bigger than Bitwig) to adopt this.
- throwaway290 3y agoIf Reaper and Bitwig supported one interchangeable arrangement format it could already be big.
- Borgz 3y agoThe readme says that PreSonus Studio One supports the format, so I think it's possible others might in the future.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dzonga 3y agowhy do applications prefer zipped xml's ? what are the advantages and disadvantages ?
- bobim 3y agoYes please! I went for Mixcraft because friend has it already, but still struggling to make it running alongside Spitfire with wine. Spitfire needs win 10 but then no sound with the "low latency" driver in Mixcraft. Anyway… an exchange format would help me go native while keeping friends!
- crazal 3y agooh my god thank you
- sim7c00 3y agoepic project, one of my fav DAWs already supported too. So damn happy to see this. Hope Renoise will pick it up too though that one moves a lil slow :P maybe someday! just wanted to say thanks. this is needed sooo much!