5 ms·
"Smart" glasses erode everyone's privacy unlike any other technology. Cameras and cell phones have to be held up to record. Glasses can stream effortlessly and
by esafak 3y ago
"Smart" glasses erode everyone's privacy unlike any other technology. Cameras and cell phones have to be held up to record. Glasses can stream effortlessly and continuously, without anyone's consent. If that is not reason enough to object what more do you want, my fist in your face?
- freedomben 3y agoI think your point would be a lot better without the threat of physical violence at the end (which seems both silly, uncalled for, and unnecessary). I'm very deeply concerned about privacy, but a simple thing like an "on" or "recording" light on the glasses could alert people that recording is on.
- esafak 3y agoBy the time I am close enough see that puny light you've already recorded me. It's an opt out mechanism, not opt in. Maybe if there was an unobtrusive way for me to prevent recording through a wearable, like a ROBOTS.TXT file, or a universal gesture (a middle finger, or a grimace) to indicate my desire to be erased from your recording, I would consider it. I would also want some assurance that my request is honored. Given how unlikely this all is, I am simply saying "nope" today. It's fine in situations where consent is obtained in advance; e.g., events. I should add that I take more pictures than the average person, and used to be a street photographer, so I have been in situations where people did not want their likeness captured. Also in countries where people objected to photography altogether on the grounds that it stole their spirit. I always had to make a decision with my trigger finger, so I was able to apply human oversight. My stance is informed by experience.
- nickthegreek 3y agoCommitting violence against others who are not doing anything illegal seems like a pretty easy way for you to lose a lot of privacy. Edit: OP removed their reference to punching people who would dare film them. This thread will no longer make sense to other's trying to catch up.
- pzo 3y agoTry taking your phone out and start recording when talking to some random people on the street or in shop at cash register, or when talking to policeman etc. and see if none of them will start getting very annoyed or even aggressive - even if it's not (maybe) illegal people won't like it.
- nickthegreek 3y agoPeople are allowed to be annoyed. If you punch someone, or break/steal their property for recording, there are actual LEGAL consequences that could befall you. People record others all the time, there is this whole Karen phenomenon that is kinda hard not to know about..
- Gud 3y agoThere is a big difference between actively choosing to film, showing you are filming someone and a passive camera always on. The first one can be easily avoided, the second one not so much.
- nickthegreek 3y agoWho is talking about passive only on recording? This device would melt your face before if it tried that.
- esafak 3y agoThat is a technicality; I object on principle. I extrapolated current capabilities to underscore the argument, because more people will lifestream/lifecast the easier it gets. Tomorrow it may be a neural link. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lifestreaming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lifestreaming
- esafak 3y agoPeople should not be recording others all the time. It is not consensual. This is the crux of the debate. The legality is debated, and it varies by jurisdiction: https://www.notta.ai/en/blog/is-it-illegal-to-record-someone-without-their-permission https://www.notta.ai/en/blog/is-it-illegal-to-record-someone... Don't squander your right to record in public on something as mundane and personal as a civilian minding his own business. Record a crime, at least. Otherwise the law may change and you may lose that "right".
- pzo 3y agosuch LED can be covered with tape, paint or damaged on purpose.
- antiterra 3y agoThe copy claims the glasses will complain audibly if you cover up the LED, but doesn’t say whether or not it stops recording. It’s also not clear how easily circumvented this is, but they’ve obviously considered the angle.
- tjpnz 3y agoBut there will be physical violence if that light goes on infront of the wrong person. Make no mistake.
- ActorNightly 3y agoIf you are in PUBLIC, that is by definition NOT PRIVATE.
- esafak 3y agoCorrect, and people do have expectations, albeit reduced, of privacy in public too. Moreover, this expectation is thankfully backed by the law in various jurisdictions. I would very much like to see those rights beefed up for the machine learning age, after reading all these comments. Or would you like to live in a panopticon like the Chinese? Hey, you're on PUBLIC property, citizen! Smile for the camera, and don't think we can't read your lips. Like for real; we got software for that.
- vunderba 3y agoI'm surprised you're not already aware that this is already the norm. The number of cc style cameras in London alone should give you pause. If we're already dealing with ubiquitous recording in public, I'd rather give some of that power back to individuals rather than the government.
- esafak 3y agoIt is not the norm everywhere and, in any case, we should push back. It gives me no joy to walk past video surveillance cameras. They stick out like sore thumbs to me and make me feel treated like a potential criminal. I believe we reclaim no power by recording our fellow citizens going about their daily lives. We merely augment the corpus of corporations and governments. My beef with these smart glasses is that while they can be used to document crimes, I estimate they will typically be used for mundane purposes, while eroding the privacy of law-abiding citizens. More so than cell phones, which require you to at least hold the thing up and press a button. You will do so to document a crime, but not to mindlessly and continuously record everything you see. This changes the balance.
- ActorNightly 3y agoIn case my top level comment was not clear: if you are in public, you have no expectation of privacy outside of physical interaction in your immediate space outside your body (and even then, on crowded public transport, this is not the case). If someone can see what you are doing, there is no difference between that and them recording it. If someone can hear what your are saying, there is no difference between that and them recording it. If you don't agree, you are essentially saying that you are entitled to do and say what you want, but gathering any evidence of you doing so is not allowed, which not only doesn't make sense but is also pretty indicative that you are looking to be up to no good.
- diffeomorphism 3y agoNah, earbuds and phones could do audio recording just fine and for longer. Adding video does not make it "unlike any other", so this is rather a minor erosion on top. > Glasses can stream effortlessly and continuously For a rather limited time duration and with a glowing light and with actually quite a bit of effort. > without anyone's consent. Why? You still need the same amount of consent as with any other camera.
- smolder 3y agoAdding video is not a minor erosion on top of recording from a microphone.