5 ms·
Any country (including the US) that tries to prevent AI from replacing some jobs will find its economy buried by another country that did not.
by WalterBright 3y ago
Any country (including the US) that tries to prevent AI from replacing some jobs will find its economy buried by another country that did not.
- Modified3019 3y agoConversely, a country that allows AI to replace too many jobs will find itself buried in masses of angry people with little to lose except their devalued lives.
- jschveibinz 3y agoBoth of these comments are excellent. However, countries don’t make decisions. Individuals (that are mentally capable) make decisions, within their economic framework, and the result emerges at the national or global level. Individuals will decide how to respond to AI, and we will see what happens. My guess, based on past adoptions of work-saving technologies, is that anyone capable of using AI to make their job easier will do so. And that may result in the elimination of other jobs.
- andsoitis 3y ago> countries don’t make decisions. Individuals (that are mentally capable) make decisions, within their economic framework, and the result emerges at the national or global level. The economic framework, including rules, regulations, incentives, and penalties, amongst others, are set by government (“the country”). Also, if government decides to employ and find AI, that already pushes things in a certain direction. So yes, while individuals decide how to use AI, it is very much governments that have tremendous capacity and interest to bend and accelerate or decelerate its adoption patterns.
- creer 3y agoCountries (governments) make lots of decisions as (governmental) entities with their own (effective) lives. Probably too many too fast. The problem is they often make the wrong decisions in spite of having very large and often educated staff. That's a problem. Someone asked recently what are the large problems facing humanity going forward and I think this is one of them. Government as entities will make lots of decisions in this case and no doubt most will be at counter-purpose. And this is a huge problem for humanity in general (because of the gross, terrible economic inefficiency of the process.) We must find far more effective ways for governments to think, deliberate, simulate, act or not act, implement, enforce.
- Aeolun 3y agoHave this in too many countries, and we’ll have a world war on our hands again.
- makeitdouble 3y agoThat's a good point. A nuance to that would be that not every field impacts the economy, or put another way, our economies work with a lot of inefficiencies. There could be a future where the fields that matter the most are heavily impacted and most of the work is automatized, while a flurry of other parts are strictly kept off AI and automatization. I have in mind the extent to which agriculture requires way fewer people that we'd imagine given its scale and importance, while we have people making money doing funny faces on camera [0]. [0] that's also absolutely needed by the society, but it's not at the same primary level
- VoodooJuJu 3y agoAnother edgy soundbite to further pump up the AI hype-mythos.