3 ms·
> The huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made
by lmm 3y ago
> The huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made. VAT, on the other hand, is not. We should not tax a transaction where a struggling customer is paying a struggling business.
Why not? It seems like you're arguing for a tax break for struggling businesses, but those are the ones that most need to be subject to capitalism's creative destruction. If business A is making a lot of product and consuming a lot of resources, but that product is barely worth buying, and business B produces less but does so more efficiently, it seems to me that business B is more socially beneficial and it's better to tax business A.
- charlieyu1 3y agoAnd yet everyone complaining about places closing down. And I would argue that this eliminates competition and therefore not socially beneficial.
- lmm 3y agoClear, consistent tax rules are better for competition overall, even if they lead to more places closing in the short term.