3 ms·
> What is the rationale* for VAT? I have never, ever understood this. If you are an individual, you pay income tax on your earnings. Why should you be taxed on
by lmm 3y ago
> What is the rationale* for VAT? I have never, ever understood this. If you are an individual, you pay income tax on your earnings. Why should you be taxed on your spending as well?
> 'We want to use the money for worthy purposes' isn't a rationale. A rationale is a reason people should pay.
I could equally say "You pay VAT on your spending. Why should you be taxed on your earnings as well?". Ultimately governments need taxes and take them where they can find them.
The benefit of VAT is that it's a tax that's harder to evade, because the rebate system means everyone is reporting on everyone else. A high VAT rate is also a way to do stealth protectionism without falling foul of the WTO rules - domestic producers can pay de facto higher salaries (because the VAT revenue allows you to reduce income tax) whereas the full VAT rate gets paid on foreign-produced goods.
- charlieyu1 3y agoThe huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made. VAT, on the other hand, is not. We should not tax a transaction where a struggling customer is paying a struggling business.
- lmm 3y ago> The huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses regardless of whether profit is made or not. Cooperate Tax is fair; it is taxing on profits made. VAT, on the other hand, is not. We should not tax a transaction where a struggling customer is paying a struggling business. Why not? It seems like you're arguing for a tax break for struggling businesses, but those are the ones that most need to be subject to capitalism's creative destruction. If business A is making a lot of product and consuming a lot of resources, but that product is barely worth buying, and business B produces less but does so more efficiently, it seems to me that business B is more socially beneficial and it's better to tax business A.
- charlieyu1 3y agoAnd yet everyone complaining about places closing down. And I would argue that this eliminates competition and therefore not socially beneficial.
- lmm 3y agoClear, consistent tax rules are better for competition overall, even if they lead to more places closing in the short term.
- sugarkjube 3y ago> The huge downside is that VAT is taking money from businesses Businesses don't pay VAT (yes they pay it, but its deducted so they get the money back. The only thing VAT can be accused of regarding businesses is that it's essentially a free loan to the govt)
- carlosjobim 3y agoThat is a huge misunderstanding, and even business owners get fooled by that idea. It's one of the most pervasive myths in economics by now. If you have a business that has more money coming in from sales than your expenses, then you are paying more (usually much more) in VAT than you are getting back. If you are getting back the same as you pay in VAT, that means you are breaking even on the business side and should start worrying about bankruptcy.
- akvadrako 3y agoNo, the VAT is based on the client, it's not a business expense. In my case the clients are US based, so I don't charge them VAT. I get VAT refunds on my expenses because I pay more than I take in. If they were local clients they would also get the VAT they pay through me refunded, so it doesn't cost them anything.
- scotty79 3y agoWhat you are describing is not the core of VAT. It's auxilary scheme for supporting export. And it's a hole in VAT which enables various fraud. Without that loophole you should rais the prices for your foreign customers by x% but that could make you globally uncompetitive, hence the loophole. VAT is not a tax on customer, it's a tax on added value that every (profiting) company along the production chain creates. Ultimately customer pays it, because the customer pays for everything, both value added and all the costs from previous steps. But it doesn't mean it's a tax on consumer. Because in absence of it companies could just keep their prices as high as they are (because why lower them if the customer already pays them) while keeping all that money.
- 3y ago