3 ms·
> Bergson emphasised the cultural and technological context in which Einstein formulated relativity and argued that a theory of time that relies on clocks but d
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> Bergson emphasised the cultural and technological context in which Einstein formulated relativity and argued that a theory of time that relies on clocks but doesn’t understand their history and significance, is incomplete
This is hard to get on board with. A theory of time is incomplete without a history of clocks? Have I misunderstood?
- uoaei 3y agoA theory of time is only complete without a history of clocks if you believe a theory of time can be completely physically correct, period. Do you know of any completely physically correct theories?
- croes 3y agoYou wouldn't know if you would
- whatshisface 3y agoRelativity isn't even about clocks, and is practically difficult to verify with any but the absolute best... its most common applications are related to radiation physics. The only conflict science has with philosophers is its role as a stumbling block for people with high verbal abilities and a belief that they don't have to know anything about the subject they're writing about. If they had the same attitude towards glassblowing or archeology they would have the same results.
- CreateAccntAgn 3y agoIt is incomplete in that it cannot replace older ideas of time in all contexts. It is perfectly valid/complete for use in scientific contexts. But the general population's use the idea of time for other purposes as well where Einsteins purely Relativistic formulation cannot be a stand in replacement is how I read it.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> It is incomplete in that it cannot replace older ideas of time in all contexts. It is perfectly valid/complete for use in scientific contexts. It seems to just be saying: your theory uses clocks to illustrate it but doesn't include the history of clocks. I don't think that's quite what you're describing.
- vintermann 3y agoThere is a distance-free notion of time which predates, and necessarily predates, all experimental theories of time. This is (loosely after Kant): * Every thing that happens, happens at a time. Let's call those things "events" from now on. It's nonsense to claim that a thing happened, but never (at any point in time) happened. * Every event happens in a place. It's nonsense to say that a thing happened, but nowhere happened. * Every event MAY be related to one or more events, called its causes. * There is an ordering on points in time, so that an event's time-point comes after the time-point of all its causes. Without these assumptions, how are you going to do experiments, or draw any conclusions about the world? In fact you pretty much need one more, which is that every event has at least one cause (otherwise there's not much point in scientifically investigating it). These basic categories are certainly no replacement for physics. They're just the bare minimum to start an investigation into physics. But if the way you describe your physics contradicts it, then at best there's a communication problem.
- spiralx 3y agoCause or pre-condition? It's simple to state the pre-condition for quantum tunnelling to occur, but as a probabilistic event the cause seems hard to define...
- mikhailfranco 3y agoPoints 1,2,4 imply absolute Newtonian space and time. They are completely and utterly wrong. Einstein showed us this more than 100 years ago - please keep up.
- vintermann 3y ago
- throw310822 3y agoIt's to take in due account the cuckoos, of course.
- acjohnson55 3y agoI think most people can relate to sometimes feeling like their experience of time is incongruent with objective clock time. We're educated and socialized to believe that it is our perception that is incorrect, because the clock is right. Some philosophers and other types of scholars would question whether we should cede all sense of reality to that which can be objectively measured. You might say that there's no one "real" time. Perceptual time is real because it matters to the person experiencing it. I don't think the point is to deny objective time or physics, but just to say that it is incomplete as a way describing lived reality. And probably also that we'll never have an understanding of neurology that's complete enough to let us even fully characterize perceptual time scientifically. So, we should accept that there is more to time than what physics can tell us.
- gus_massa 3y agoThis is like claiming that there is no physical temperature because "hot" water for a bathtub is different from "hot" water for a tea (and different from "hot" air during a summer day). Perhaps we should use two different word for the "perceived time" and for the "clock time". The good days, when I go to sleep all the night appears to go away in an instant, but it isn't. It's more useful to have a physical defined "clock time" and then explain why the brain is bad estimating durations using the "perceived time".
- acjohnson55 3y agoYeah, I think his point is just to argue against scientific supremacy. Using different terms for the scientific and perceptual aspects of time would be one way of meeting his goal.
- conquistadog 3y agoThere is only one "now", is there not? All else is perception of speed.
- tonfreed 3y agoPhilosophers are a special breed.