7 ms·
Getty made an AI generator that only trained on its licensed image
- ericol 3y agoI think the point of where goes the money they make from this is still a valid point? Derivative work and all that jazz.
- junon 3y agoWhy? It's their work.
- jeroenhd 3y agoThey have bought the licenses in good faith, but I wouldn't be surprised if there were tons of images on their platform that the original seller had no right to sell to Getty. If the copyright lawsuits do end up ruling against image AI statups, Getty may face problems when inevitably someone demands Getty takes down the images they had no right to buy and use, and retrain the AI to exclude those images from generated works as well. However, until something like that happens, Getty has every right to generate images, of course.
- tyingq 3y agoSometimes. Often, they hold a license for something that's also in the public domain.
- junon 3y agoAt which point it doesn't matter, does it?
- sebzim4500 3y agoIt does if they successfully sue the guy that actually took the picture.
- junon 3y agoBut if it's in the public domain, then it can be used for anything. There's no basis for a lawsuit.
- anticensor 3y agoIt still steals the time of original photographer. It is not like dismissal of a lawsuit takes no time.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoNo thanks
- amelius 3y agoI'll wait for the Unsplash version.
- dieselgate 3y agoNot sure if this is relevant or not but Unsplash is owned by Getty
- drcongo 3y agoSurprised they've only got one licensed image.
- broscillator 3y agoIt's a really big image.
- ThomW 3y agoI think this is where all the AI stuff is headed. Authors, artists, etc. are suing projects whose models just inhaled their work and generate derivative works and I'm surprised the studios aren't getting more involved with going after AI models that included their properties in them. I can see this going the route of us having a Disney AI, Sony AI, Discovery AI, Amazon AI, etc. where you can generate stuff using models owned by the studios, but only those studios and any public domain stuff they suck in too.
- mistrial9 3y agoagree - it seems also that they are going to build it, whether customers want it, or regulators object
- gpm 3y ago> I'm surprised the studios aren't getting more involved with going after AI models that included their properties in them. If you're the first group to sue you have to spend millions extra on lawyers to establish the precedent. I don't see much reason for Disney and friends to rush to be first. The current state of AI isn't really a threat to Disney and friends, just suggestive of a future threat. No need to rush on that account either. Especially since if they win the lawsuit - they're still going to benefit from all the R&D on neural networks that is happening on other peoples dime right now. And all in, do studios stand to lose more or gain more to AI? Drastically cutting their costs might be worth some extra competition.
- AJ007 3y agoIt's a lose-lose for the studios. If they win on the IP side, all of the generative content of the future will exclude their IP. If they lose, then they don't get paid for it, or worse they have to pay for it. Most people seem to have a difficult time grasping that if the model is trained in such a way that Disney's IP is excluded, the model doesn't know Disney even exists. Consider if every Disney website was excluded from Google and every Disney related trademark was blacklisted. As of mid 2023 it is very clear personal assistants are going to replace traditional web search. In my use case, they've replaced it 100%: excluding searching a single website or product name. Will these generative assistants -- which must be capable of both processing and generating images -- know the rights holder's IP even exists? The idea that a useful LLM is going to be trained on 100% public domain, copyright free data is absurd. IP owners are suggesting that future personal assistants would need to pay them for the knowledge of even the mere existence of their IP. That would be like if every website indexed by Google and every trademarked keyword required Google to pay the copyright owner per search. That isn't possible. To the contrary, the reverse occurs. What if the future is in fact the opposite of what IP owners are now suggesting? Nike pays the generative AI company for Nike shoes to appear in the one-off movie generated for a single viewer based on their personal preferences? The world is drowning in IP: text, video, music. The future will be a deluge.
- elzbardico 3y agoWell, but did the image creators agree with this when licensing their images to getty?
- minimaxir 3y agoUsually these licenses are of the "we can do anything with your images" variety. There could be an AI carveout going forward but that's not retroactive.
- felipemesquita 3y agoTitle should be edited to include an 's' at the end, actual title is "Getty made an AI generator that only trained on its licensed images"
- wongarsu 3y agoSame strategy as Adobe's Firefly, which was trained on their catalog of stock images. Not so long ago many predicted that stock image sites will eventually become obsolete or at least much less important due to AI image generators. But it might turn out that stock image sites are uniquely positioned to dominate commercial AI image generation because of the "ethically sourced" high quality training data they posses. They might still have minor legal fights whether this is a legal way to use the data licenses to them, but the list of people who could possibly sue is much shorter, known to the stock image site, and consists of people who have already signed some form of contract about the use of these images. The legal risks are well scoped and predictable, unlike "we scraped the internet" models.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoOkay, but the text model Getty and Firefly are using, that was trained on LAION2b. So it’s all bullshit.
- leet 3y agoNo. Firefly is not. Cant speak for Getty.
- doctorpangloss 3y agoHow do you figure? Because they say so? Anyway, where do they say it, for Firefly? I haven’t seen it. They don’t address the text encoder at all, which uses images, precisely because it’s something like T5 or CLIP. I’ve emailed them through my enterprise Adobe account about it, and they simply didn’t reply. And then suppose they did talk about this, who audited it? How do you know they’re not biding time? Those text encoders take forever to train. At the end of the day, we’re only talking about these models because someone published research completely tainted by the copyrighted training. So it’s still totally unknown, until a lawsuit, if even a “redo” of every part of the model on all licensed stuff, which may not even work because there isn’t enough variety, if it’s all that it promises legally.
- mistrial9 3y ago
- iagooar 3y agoPhilosophical question, but: if AI is supposed to learn stuff that otherwise only humans would know, how will AI ever be able to become as good, if humans actually ARE trained using copyright content?
- londons_explore 3y agoBecause each individual human has only read a tiny tiny subset of the documents in a lifetime. Yet the AI can read most of the documents (just not the copyrighted ones). End result: AI outperforms humans.
- smithkenneth 3y agoIn Getty's case that is a sizable portion of professional images in the world.
- blincoln 3y agoThe Getty website claims that this system will somehow compensate the original authors of the work that went into the training model. Have they discussed the specifics anywhere? i.e. is it a blanket fee of some fraction of a cent per image to every Getty contributor whose images went into the training set? Statistical analysis of prompts users submitted in the last month and assign more of the money to contributors whose images had matching keywords? I'm pretty firmly on the side of "large-scale analysis of content that's accessible to the public should be entirely outside the scope of copyright, regardless of what one does with the output", even though I also sympathize with artists that see generative AI as a potentially existential threat to their careers. But I'm curious if Getty is actually going to make meaningful payments to the creators of the images that went into the training set, or if this is more of a "we could continue to pay our existing royalties to content creators, or we could keep most of the money for ourselves by selling access to a model trained on that content" type of situation. [1] "We’ve created a model that compensates our world‑class content creators for the use of their work in our AI model, allowing them to continue to create more of the high‑quality pre‑shot imagery you depend on." (https://www.gettyimages.com/ai/generation/about https://www.gettyimages.com/ai/generation/about)
- JacobThreeThree 3y ago>"But I'm curious if Getty is actually going to make meaningful payments to the creators of the images that went into the training set, or if this is more of a "we could continue to pay our existing royalties to content creators, or we could keep most of the money for ourselves by selling access to a model trained on that content" type of situation. Adobe is also dealing with this question with Firefly. So far they plan to pay creators annually, but how much each artists gets and how the amount is calculated is yet to be determined. Since a model is only as good as its training data, hopefully this can be a new revenue stream for artists? https://techcrunch.com/2023/09/13/adobe-starts-paying-bonuses-to-stock-contributors-whose-content-is-being-used-to-train-firefly/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/09/13/adobe-starts-paying-bonuse...
- catchnear4321 3y agoobvious approach for corporations is to simplify the math. the model is made from X images, from Y artists, each artist has a percent contribution to the total. between 0 and 100 percent. so each time money is generated by the model, the contributors get their share. as a bonus, it is easy to understand how that share was derived. so it is implicitly fair. (please keep in mind that this “artist’s share” will be a percentage of the net revenue generated, and that this percentage will probably be a trade secret or some such.) (any works from artists unable to be paid, meaning public domain or otherwise, will be handled by the corporation for the continuous and never-ending improvement of the platform that makes it all possible.)
- padolsey 3y agoThe real news here is the uncapped indemnification and protection from any copyright lawsuits. This is a good move from Getty.
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoIt's imperative we use this window to push open and free models otherwise the entire future of this tech will be locked behind a Getty or Adobe paywall forever as those are the only sort of companies with licenced libraries able to provide the training data and the models will be substandardas stock photography from both those sites has a look to it that isn't always desirable.
- broscillator 3y agoI have an image in my head of the future o AI that looks like abandoned malls. That any potential that there was just eventually died behind paywalls and bad business practices and it couldn't sustain itself.
- TheRealPomax 3y agotitle's missing an "s" at the end.
- lacker 3y agoThis reminds me of when YouTube first came out. Lazy Sunday went viral, although it was a clip from SNL which the poster didn't have the rights for. Naturally many voices in the media were critical of YouTube. Soon afterward Google Video launched a product which was "like YouTube, but we make sure we have the rights to everything!" And they actually got the rights to the Lazy Sunday clip. Media coverage of this launch was pretty positive. It ended up not really mattering, because the product people preferred to use was YouTube, and the branding, media coverage, lawsuits, all that stuff took so long to resolve that it happened after YouTube was the winner of the space. Of course if the YouTube lawsuit had worked out like Napster then everything might have ended differently....
- artursapek 3y agoSmart move. They would be extinguished by this tech if they didn’t embrace it.
- ambicapter 3y agoThey should've named it GAIetty (pronounced like gaiety). Why yes I do not work in marketing.