14 ms·
Please do not take down the Sality botnet
- kevinchen 15y agoDoes anyone know exactly why it's illegal to take down Sality?
- jbri 15y agoThe "takedown" technique presented works by exploiting the botnet's functionality to have all the machines remove themselves from the botnet - actually carrying out the removal requires you to hack into at least one third-party server, and it would probably count as gaining unauthorized access to each of the machines in the botnet as well.
- micaeked 15y agothe c&c servers are sites hacked by the owners of the botnet. you would have to hack them yourself and upload your own payload to take down peers
- aptwebapps 15y agoWhat if one of the site owners 'fixed' their server? That'd be nice and legal, wouldn't it?
- jroll 15y agoSounds like the author figured out a SQL injection vulnerability in the website the bot downloads logos from, and a way to give the removal tool as the image in a way that infects Sality itself. This would distribute the removal tool very quickly. The hacking of the website seems to be the legal issue here.
- lewi 15y agoBecause technically the methods used (i.e. SQL injection) are illegal if you dont own the equipment your using it on. Also he is a civilian and does not have any power or jurisdiction to do so.
- ertdfgcb 15y agoSlightly off-topic: Is SQL injection itself illegal? Because I was under the impression that only using SQL injection to gain unauthorized access to someone else's computer (like the OP is suggesting) was illegal.
- azelfrath 15y agoYou can do SQLi against your own database 24x7 and you'd be just fine in the eyes of the law.
- colbyolson 15y agoIs that network yours? No? Then it's illegal. It's an interesting way to have someone do the dirty work. I would love to see a postmortem writeup.
- meepmorp 15y agoPresumably because it involves exploiting a SQL injection attack on one or more control servers, and then using the control servers to install software on thousands of other people's computers without their knowledge or consent.
- jonknee 15y agoIt's illegal in a similar manner to robbing a drug cartel--getting arrested is probably the least of your concerns. No one will step forward to law enforcement over it, but organized crime has their own law enforcement.
- pluies_public 15y agoMessing with other people's computers in any form without their information and consent is usually prohibited by law. A slightly broken analogy would be breaking into a house to remove a hornets nest. Even if you do it carefully and not do any damage and what you do is beneficial for the community as a whole, it's contrary to the law.
- piggity 15y agoIf my neighbours hornets nest had killer hornets that were biting all the children in the neighbourhood and the police / council refused to do anything; then it'd be a damned shame if someone neatly removed the hornets nest. Of course that wouldn't make it any more legal; but your defence would have a field day with the prosecution I'd imagine. IANAL but I've watched the first double episode of The Firm, and I reckon I've got a pretty good grasp on how the law works now!
- Frelette 15y agoExcept that: we aren't 'ENTERING YOUR COMPUTER CASE'... we are removing code that you are running to infect other computers. There is no world equivalent, ridiculously phrased analogy that applies. You might want to just stay off the internet if you are afraid. Here's another example of fearful users, frozen into not doing anything: http://ddkportraits.com/2012/02/why-i-tearfully-deleted-my-pinterest-inspiration-boards/ http://ddkportraits.com/2012/02/why-i-tearfully-deleted-my-p...
- polymatter 15y agoI'm curious now. What if my neighbours house was on fire? That fire threatens the whole neighbourhood. Surely I can protect my property by attempting to put out the fire. Do firefighters have indeminty for attempting to put out fires? What about volunteer firefighters? Obviously I consider a house on fire to be analagous to an infected computer, but I do have some protection putting out a fire right? Nobody would sue me for fire damage (as long as I'm reasonable etc).
- DanBC 15y ago
- brokentone 15y agoWhile yes this is technically illegal, honest question does the letter of the law stand in a situation where those "wronged" by the infraction are themselves in the wrong? From a legal standpoint, charges would have to be brought against you by someone, and I doubt that anyone who sustained damage from this situation (the bot network's owner) would have the ability to demonstrate such a thing without substantially incriminating themselves. From a purely philosophical standpoint, you could take a utilitarian approach ala J.S. Mill and say that it would do the greatest quality of good to the greatest number of people to take such action. Granted at the point we're discussing philosophy, we're outside the judicial process which is all that's up for debate here.
- jacalata 15y ago'where those wronged by the infraction are themselves in the wrong' - it is certainly possible for this to be a crime, consider killing a burglar.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- etrain 15y agoI would love to hear a lawyers opinion on whether the OP has any legal case whatsoever if his "not suggestions" are ever used, his identity is identified, and someone decides they want to throw the book at him. Basically, if some DA decides this is modern day vigalanteism, a step removed - could the OP ever defend himself in court?
- aptwebapps 15y agoI think the OP might be in difficulties in that event (totally not a layer, just guessing). But perhaps the OP felt it was less risky this way not just for legal reasons, but because it's easier to send one email anonymously than to carry out the whole operation without being traced. Or maybe he or she had other stuff to do.
- yukyukyuk 15y agoNot a lawyer. But this would never come to pass - no DA would have the brains let alone the skill or political will to prosecute. Also, seems like a freedom of speech issue. Otherwise it would be difficult for educators to discuss computer security. In fact, I'm pretty sure he could even do away with all of the "non-suggestion" text and still be fine. If I say, "I think you should hack website X, humanity will be better off for it" that's just my opinion. I can even say, "I think you should empty all of Goldman Sach's bank accounts and use the proceeds to buy up endangered rain forest land in Brazil." As long as I'm not materially facilitating the commission of the crime, I'm just another guy on the internet with an opinion. Edit: After reviewing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country#cite_note-Biederman2007p457-77 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_of_speech_by_country#ci... I'm coming to the conclusion that the above is pretty far from accurate in any country. Apparently freedom of speech has been under serious assault for decades. Which is sort of sickening, but also a fact of life.
- a3camero 15y agoLaw student. These sort of situations have been considered by the people that write criminal laws. If you recommend a crime to someone and then they do it then you're a party to that offence (http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/page-6.html#h-5 http://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/C-46/page-6.html#h-5 [Canadian Criminal Code, but I assume US is quite similar on this]). There are a variety of ways to become a party to a crime, and then you're as guilty as the rest of 'em.
- ricardobeat 15y agoSo why can't those nice guys from the FBI go and do it already? It's so easy to replace sites when piracy is involved...
- eck 15y agoVictims of piracy have better lobbyists than the victims of identity theft.
- chives 15y agoCouldn't have said it better myself.
- joelhaasnoot 15y agoDutch police infiltrated a botnet recently, and left a message for victims. No one was too happy with them and they weren't really allowed to...
- rplnt 15y agoThey simply can't. This is very different from closing down some "piracy" sites. In this case they need to mess with data on your computer. Do you want FBI to have a legal way to read, modify or destroy data on your computer? Even if you want (which I don't believe), there is no way that would work on international scale. I remember a case from some years back when some group (some AV group or something like that) took control over a major botnet by taking control over domains botnet would use in future for receiving updates/commands. The algorithm was pretty sophisticated as it generated dozens of new domains each day and was trying to contact them on random. E.g. generate 100 domains, try to contact 15 of them, if none responds wait a day. Statistically the bot would get its commands in a 2-3 days (I don't really remember exact numbers so this example might not add up). Well, in order to stop the botnet you'd need to register all available domains out of those 100. So, they were doing just that for some time. They practically blocked the owners operating on the botnet. But they couldn't destroy it. Because that would require manipulating with data on random peoples' computers without their consent which you simply can't (legally). And I think it should stay that way. So anyway, they left it be and owners took control back. But what can be done? You have to run your operating system updated. Having AV software (which is quicker in updates and act as a prevention) doesn't hurt either. And as this is not a real option for a some time, this is a good way. You destroy it in illegal fashion. But no official organization can do that.
- trotsky 15y agoYou're not actually a law abiding citizen if you just publicly recruited for people to join your felony conspiracy.
- maaku 15y agoWhat if I get permission from the owner of one of the infected systems to "penetrate" his setup and upload the botnet-destroyer. Would that still be illegal?
- eridius 15y agoI think the issue is that to remove the botnet, it requires having your code be executed on all infected machines. You can't possible get permission from the owners of the millions of infected machines to do this.
- zacharypinter 15y agoYep. Imagine if it bugged out and broke all the infected machines. Even if the bug that broke the machines wasn't his fault, he'd probably still be in a grey area.
- vidarh 15y agoEven a bug that affects just 0.1% of a 1 million big bot net would still leave a 1000 unhappy users with broken setups that might consider themselves to have been better off with the bot net.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- majmun 15y agoYou should NOT takeover botnet and harden it.
- acqq 15y agoReading README in the linked zip file, inside is, first, an executable which is a QBFC (http://www.abyssmedia.com/quickbfc http://www.abyssmedia.com/quickbfc) packaged and slightly modified version of AVG's Sality Removal Tool (http://free.avg.com/us-en/remove-sality http://free.avg.com/us-en/remove-sality) to automate the removal of the Sality virus. Then, there is the encrypted version of the same executable, so it will run properly when downloaded by the Sality virus. And finally, there's a simple Python script that queries super peers from a bootstrap list for the most recent URL pack pushed to the Sality P2P network.
- ucho 15y agoAllow people check for themselves http://uploadmirrors.com/download/1DQGRXOQ/byesality.zip http://uploadmirrors.com/download/1DQGRXOQ/byesality.zip
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- micaeked 15y agowould this be completely prevented if the botnet owners signed (with a private key) their payloads?
- nathan_f77 15y agoYes, I believe that would be very effective.
- majmun 15y agoaccording to wiki this botnet already had this feature, but this bug aperently exploits something else.
- s_henry_paulson 15y agoThe guy takes all the time to put this together, write this up, and is perfectly ok with the outcome, but instead of going to a coffee shop and doing this himself, he spends a lengthy amount of time writing up instructions and giving the criminals a chance to fix their injection problems before someone can take down the botnet. Baffling. Not only that, but this guy seems to know what he's doing and instead of someone who knows what they're doing completing the task, he's willing to watch script kids bork the whole thing, or run the risk of russians (or others taking over the whole network and hardening it)
- acqq 15y agoI also don't understand how he expects that the botnet won't be taken over or hardened based on the results he published before it gets shut. I did try to download the images linked in the post, not a single one is as I write replaced with his removal utility, so observing just these few links there's no evidence that somebody already decided to follow his recipe. I'd really like to read some news writeup in a few days.
- tedivm 15y agoTo prove a point- the current system of law is completely broken when it comes to dealing with malicious software. Law enforcement is a joke, to the point where reporting a botnet c&c located right in the US to the FBI will result in a six week run around before you finally get a phone call from someone in the right department, and this is assuming you've dealt with them enough to be on their quick list. Guess who moved their servers four weeks ago? Actually taking matters into your own hands, as an individual or a company, opens you up to a ridiculous level of liability and is probably illegal in a number of cases. Hell, even analyzing malicious software itself has the potential to be illegal due to draconian copyright laws (fortunately most malware authors aren't willing to claim owner of their software, so this isn't an active issue). Even once all that is done, more malware will be written, and probably by the same people since it's not like taking the botnet down actually puts people behind bars. This isn't to say the bad guys are winning- I may be a bit bias (I work for Malwarebytes, although this post is my own rambling mess), but a lot of technological strides are being made. There is still a fair bit of frustration out there with law enforcement though, as they continue to impose draconian and orwellian systems but haven't implemented the low hanging fruit in policy changes for actually dealing with this crap.
- hackermom 15y agoSo, is it down yet?
- jakejake 15y agoPlease OP, you obviously have done the work, just go to a library or any free wifi location and run the damn thing.
- jakejake 15y agoIs it just me or did the OP just blow a rare opportunity to be a hero? The power of a zero-day exploit is that you don't announce it and give the target a chance to make a patch.
- daemon13 15y agoLooks like the OP is doing a hack - he is trying to achieve his goal [of destroying parts of the botnet] by hacking legal system, since he can not do this on his own... Resourceful!
- psb 15y agoDoes anyone know if the actions described in the article have been carried out? I'd hate to think that the "current owners" of the Sality botnet have fixed this exploit.
- rdl 15y agoI'm kind of confused why one would publish the HOWTO-kill anonymously. It would be totally reasonable to publish the howto and "wouldn't it be horrible if this happened; don't do it" under your name (if you want fame, without legal liability). Or, just publish and do it all anonymously. I guess I'm motivated by either fame or kills, which might be different than the anonymous party here. I guess even publishing legally-protected information doesn't protect you from the nuisance of civil lawsuits, or potential extralegal/illegal actions by either the botnet staff or anyone who is harmed by the botnet or removal of botnet.
- Dove 15y agoI am reminded of the "wine blocks" sold (legally!) during the prohibition, which came with the following warning: After dissolving the brick in a gallon of water, do not place the liquid in a jug away in the cupboard for twenty days, because then it would turn into wine. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_States#Winemaking_during_Prohibition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prohibition_in_the_United_State...
- _sentient 15y agoI can't help but think that must have tasted terrible!
- bravura 15y agoIt probably does. In Quebec, wine can only be imported and sold in state-controlled liquor stores. As a loophole, dehydrated wine is imported, rehydrated, bottled, and sold in corner stores ("depanneurs"). It tastes rank.
- ahorne 15y agoWould you be able to provide a reference for this? As a Quebecer, this is of interest to me.
- gcb 15y agocalifornia always one step ahead on the recreational stuff.
- bdg 15y agoNot unheard of at all. In dry countries today you'll find all the ingredients in one spot of the grocery store to brew your own beer/liquor/wine, but nobody really says it's for brewing they're just conveniently put together
- seanp2k2 15y agoGuys, the reason that the author didn't use these tools himself is because /they will kill you if you mess with their stuff/. That's what global crime syndicates do.