5 ms·
I haven't followed this close enough to know, but I assume that writers will use AI heavily. It's a great tool for brainstorming and creating drafts.
by xnx 3y ago
I haven't followed this close enough to know, but I assume that writers will use AI heavily. It's a great tool for brainstorming and creating drafts.
- slg 3y ago>I assume that writers will use AI heavily Yeah, from a high level that is the question. Will the writers use AI or will the studios? Is AI a tool to make the writers more efficient or is it a tool the studios will use to replace writers. The writers generally have no problem with the former, but they wanted protection from the latter.
- junofan 3y agoStudios don’t want to replace writers. They just want to pay writers less by crediting AI if used. The writers want full credit so they receive full revenue.
- anonymousab 3y ago> Studios don’t want to replace writers They will do it the very first second they think that they can get away with it without major consequences (such as profit loss from bad AI writing).
- User23 3y agoDisney evidently doesn’t care about profit loss from bad human writing so it’s not clear that they'll care about same from bad AI writing.
- slg 3y agoI'm not sure if this is a comment written out of naivety of the profit focused nature of studios or ignorance of the writing process. Replacing writers and paying writers less is effectively the same thing. That "full credit" that you mention isn't just about what those writers got paid, it tells you what work they did. For example, a writer will often write a treatment of a movie which is effectively a short summary of a movie that is done before writing a script. Sometimes different writers will do the treatment and screenplay. This is generally the distinction you might see in "Story By" and "Written By" credits in movies (although these distinctions can and often are a lot more complicated). One likely goal of the studios is for an AI to write the treatment and then hand that off to a writer to turn it into a screenplay. That is one of the most practical ways AI can be used since treatments aren't an end product themselves and the AI's flaws can be corrected by humans when translating the treatment into a script. However, that is still effectively replacing writers by taking away one of their clearly defined jobs and in turn one of their paychecks.
- chii 3y agoIf the AI does a better job writing said treatments (aka, does the same or more for less cost), why shouldn't it take away the job?
- slg 3y agoThis question is irrelevant in the context of negotiating a collective bargaining agreement. The WGA's motivations are obvious. They are protecting the livelihoods of their members. If a studio thinks AI can genuinely do a better job than human writers, that studio has the right to replace those human writers with AI. The human writers likewise have the right to refuse to work with any studio that does so. The fact that no studio has even hinted at taking this route during a 5-month-long strike suggests that no one believes AI would actually do a better job than WGA members.
- willcipriano 3y agoNo way AI could write another remake of a movie from the 80's.
- krapp 3y agoThe list of things AI could never do, that it has already done, is getting rather long for a statement like that to read as anything but naive. Eventually, given enough investment, yes it could.
- shrubhub 3y agoWoosh!
- mrguyorama 3y agoAnd yet, the studios came to the bargaining table instead of doing just that. Sounds like they don't have that much confidence in such a plan.
- 3y ago
- DarkNova6 3y agoDisney has already announced to invest a billion into AI.
- bugglebeetle 3y ago…in their continued pursuit of driving their stock price down as far as it will go. If there was ever a company that needs to take that money invest it back into the kind of artists and work that made them such a powerhouse in the first place, it’s Disney. But, instead, they’ll pay out this money to some execs friend with a BS AI startup to procedurally generate another shitty Marvel or Star Wars thing.
- drumhead 3y agoThe plan eventually is to have AI churn out scripts, with a human script editor making whatever re-writes or changes are necessary to improve them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cf141q5325 3y ago> Is AI a tool to make the writers more efficient or is it a tool the studios will use to replace writers. Increases in efficiencies will still make people redundant. Automation means less people are needed. I dont think even the most optimistic executive thought you could get rid of writers entirely.
- DarkNova6 3y agoThey already do. But not in terms of actual writing, but as a research method on unfamiliar topics.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- corobo 3y agoDoes anyone have any input on a thought I've been kicking around? The Artist's Oath: AO0: I have used no AI AO1: I have used AI in a research or teacher role AO2: AI has been used for structural components, but not the art itself AO3: AI has directly assisted in the creation process AO4: AI generated this entirely from a prompt specifically engineered by a human AO5: AI generated this entirely from a basic prompt Slightly expanded thoughts and a few examples: https://cohan.dev/the-artist-oath/ https://cohan.dev/the-artist-oath/ The thinking is that once established creativity unions could specify at what level of AI they will accept, and for what compensation. You could also stamp an [AO2] on the box/website as you would the content rating. At the individual level as an artist you can specify the level you use for a work, and someone commissioning you could specify at what level of AI they'd accept. The rating would be per-project, however the draft includes the addition of an asterisk [AO2*] indicates "and I've never used AI beyond this point in my art", and a + would indicate "however as soon as we reach sapience I welcome our new AI friends into the universe of creativity" :) Would love to see what smarter people than I can come up with!
- satvikpendem 3y agoBut why, though? It's like stamping on the product whether Photoshop or Blender were used, they're all just tools, and customers, for the most part, don't care how something is made as long as the product itself is good.
- corobo 3y agoBecause people don't have strong opinions on photoshop and blender, basically. I got nothing better for you there. For the record I agree with you that current gen AI is just another tool to be used. I even use photoshop and digital art as my example when this comes up too :) A lot of folks don't see it that way though, hence they are striking. Just want to bring about clarity as to what people want in a way everyone can have an easier reference point :) E: also in fairness they do stamp the products they use in the realm of TV and movies. It's in the credits usually towards the end where you see all the Dolby, Arri, THX, etc logos. I'm almost certain I've seen the Blender logo in a a non-buck-bunny film somewhere at least.
- SamoyedFurFluff 3y agoYou might want to talk to writers first before making this assumption. Of the writers I know, there are two varieties: 1) AI is used essentially to generate grift/chaff, like marketing material for your actual work, or self publish dumb get rich quick books 2) AI is utterly repulsive to the creative process as it cuts out the actual passion-building part, which is brainstorming and drafting— editing is usually the shittiest part of the job actually
- slg 3y agoThere is a difference between someone finding something distasteful and someone wanting something banned. The majority of writers may never want to use AI themselves, but the WGA's stance has not been for an outright ban on its usage. My comment was in the context of the union's negotiations so my use of "writers" was mostly a synonym for "WGA" and not "individual writers".