5 ms·
What I learned losing 70 pounds: Medical interventions work, among other things
- addicted 3y ago> I was surprised (but not too surprised, actually, because you hear this all the time) to discover when I got back to America that I didn’t gain any weight in Italy. Having made a trip to Italy very recently I can second this. We ate huge amounts of food (not necessarily any huge meals…the slow Italian eating style made it difficult to eat too much at any one meal) but we were eating a lot of different things because there was so much food we wanted to try. And we drank a lot of wine. I don’t usually drink much but Inwas probably averaging a bottle of wine a day in Italy. Ok returning to America after 10 days I hadn’t gained any weight and had even lost a little (although that was likely just natural variances). American food (including possibly many fresh ingredients…many fruits, for example, have extremely high sugar contents bred into them) are simply not good for you.
- n8henrie 3y agoHuh. I gained plenty of weight in Italy this summer, in spite of continuing to run a few times per week and doing tons of walking. Thankfully worked it off upon returning home to the states.
- addicted 3y ago> In general, I think exercise for weight loss doesn’t work — it just makes you hungrier. I believe this is wrong in general. The following research, for example, shows at least one form of exercise likely reduces hunger: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3761859/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3761859/ I suspect it depends on the kind of exercise.
- paulpauper 3y agoI can attest exercise is not that helpful. Over summer of 2022 I did 15 days strait of hiking, 33,000 ft worth of elevation gain. Weight loss: 0 pounds. I lost 6 pounds over the following 2 weeks. cause: mild covid. It was Covid that finally broke my plateau, not exercise.
- JackMorgan 3y agoI hiked 1000 miles of the AT last year over three months and didn't lose a pound. No real muscle gain, no real fat loss. Bodies can be extremely resistant to weight loss.
- paulpauper 3y agoWithin six months of not counting, I’d gained over 20 pounds. In January of this year, I went back on the program — time-restricted eating, counting calories, 10,000 steps per day, and a new exercise regime with super slow weightlifting. That is a huge, rapid regain. Yup even with surgery he's back to having the same problems as before and having to be careful to avoid overeating. Hardly a miracle. It also shows how hard it is to fight obesity when even after taking such drastic measures as having surgery the weight comes back so fast. The problem is surgery is just a temp fix. The stomach gradually expands again to accommodate food, and BMR/TDE falls a bit (metabolic adaptation is common after such procedures). Weight regain is very common 2+ years later ,so without fixing the underlying problem of food addiction/overeating, all or most of the weight will return even with surgery. The type of surgery he had has a higher risk of regain compared to to others. Surgery does not fix the tendency of the body to want to store extra calories, of formerly obese people to want to overeat. GLP-1 drugs help with this to a better extent.
- n8henrie 3y agoDepends on the surgical approach. Roux-en-y for example leverages much more than just stomach volume restriction. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK553157/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK553157/
- jokethrowaway 3y agoNice to read about this experience but there is a missing component: Modern diet is not what we evolved to eat. Until recently there was no agricolture, no bread, pasta, pizza or bakery. There was no basket of fruit readily available every day of the week (it was an occasional treat when in season). I had to lose weight a few times in my life (10kg, not too much) and I always struggled and counted calories like a maniac. The last time I was not only 10kg overweight but I had some severe stomach pain. After 2 years of struggling I tried the carnivore diet. In a week, all my stomach issues disappeared and I lost 8kg in a couple of months, without counting calories. If I eat animal fat I'm simply not hungry: I can't overeat. Demonising fats and meats was the worst thing society did and definitely contributed to the overweight epidemics.
- paulpauper 3y agoobese ppl gain weight on any diet, short of vegetables. Food is too calorie dense and obese ppl are too hungry.
- wonnor 3y agoIt's great that you found a diet that worked for you, but it's strange to say that the article is remiss to not include your specific diet - unless you also think it should include every diet. For any given diet, you can find people whom it helped tremendously, and the carnivore diet is no different. There's also very little evidence for its effectiveness (which is not to say it's not effective, just that it's not particularly well-studied). Personally, I could eat enough meat daily to get very fat if I wasn't counting my calories. When my compliance is struggling, I find high-fiber diets to be the most effective in curbing hunger.
- hombre_fatal 3y agoAgreed. Besides, modern meat is also hyper palatable since it’s engineered to have increasingly high fat content. Also seems weird to talk about what our ancestors ate while buying saran wrapped meat from the market as if you’re going caveman mode. Or that it will give you some magical defense against the explosion of available calories in the modern food economy. Most social media dietary discourse focuses on magic-trick memes instead of the basic principles. Twitter and HN acts like it’s the hamburger bun and some pasta alfredo making us fat and not the 4000 calories we eat per day altogether. How about eat less, move more, avoid calorie dense foods. For example, eating out is 1000+ calories. Unless you curb one of your other three meals and don't snack, you're going over your 2300 calorie (or whatever) budget right there.
- tiffanyh 3y agoWhy does media think it’s taboo to say “just eat less”. It’s basic Law of Thermodynamics. Energy in = energy out. And if you’re putting more energy into your body than you’re exerting out, it turns into extra weight. It’s literally that simple, and take that from someone whose done every type of diet plan in existence. Now yes, there’s food to eat that are very filling but lower in calories (like grilled chicken vs donut). But it’s still not anything more novel that calorie counting.
- peterashford 3y agoIt's not that simple. If it were simple, no-one would struggle. Overeating is usually a psychological issue.
- tiffanyh 3y agoIt’s typically not psychological. It’s more likely to be a function of people not knowing how many calories are in food. Eg, a salad from Chick Fila A might sound healthy, but it’s actually 850 calories. That’s nearly 1/2 of your daily intake. https://www.chick-fil-a.com/menu/cobb-salad https://www.chick-fil-a.com/menu/cobb-salad It’s also the same reason why schools in the US removed soda machines because it was a contributing factor to child obesity.
- doix 3y ago> It’s more likely to be a function of people not knowing how many calories are in food. I strongly doubt it. In the UK, they put the amount of calories pretty much everywhere and there is still a obesity problem.
- peterashford 3y agoThis is just not true. Plenty of people who explicitly count calories still struggle to lose weight.
- tiffanyh 3y ago