8 ms·
Is this ‘which’ dead?
- bitwize 3y agoI use this form of "which" all the time.
- emodendroket 3y agoYou know, I tend to be a bit formal myself but I cannot imagine busting this out in conversation at all.
- defen 3y agoThere’s a character in the Aubrey-Maturin series who uses this construction often. I always wondered if it was an idiosyncrasy, a regionalism, or an archaic usage. Guess this answers it!
- atombender 3y agoFun to see the Aubrey-Maturin series mentioned here; that was indeed the first thing I thought of. Killick's use of "which" always struck me as odd. I'm not entirely sure if it's the same grammatic construct as the one in the article. Here [1] is a discussion about it. The top answer argues it's just a meaningless discourse marker. It was also covered in Mark Liberman's Language Log [2]. Apparently the conjunctive "which" is increasing in usage as a discourse marker [3]. [1] https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/245363/what-is-the-name-of-the-grammatical-device-where-18th-and-19th-century-sentences https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/245363/what-is-t... [2] http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/000118.html http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/000118.h... [3] http://colinmorris.github.io/blog/which-discourse-marker http://colinmorris.github.io/blog/which-discourse-marker
- sambeau 3y agoThe most surprising thing I read here was that 'homicide' was a word in 1390, so older than English itself.
- master_crab 3y agoYes, because like many similar words (ex. fratricide) it is derived from Latin. In this case specifically, the Latin word for manslaughter.
- hug 3y agoEnglish has existed in one form or another for longer than that. The Cantebury Tales, in Middle English, was published before then.
- pasc1878 3y agoAnd thta is just about rteadable to modern eyes. Old English like Beowulf is another language but does have some words that are still in Modern English. Old English existed by 800AD
- killjoywashere 3y agoWhich 'wich?
- emodendroket 3y agoIt sounds about right that the example they came up with was from a legal context because that's easily the most likely place I'd expect to hear this.
- canjobear 3y agoIf you’re interested in hard-to-parse English relative clauses, check out the first sentence of George Washington’s first inaugural address: “Among the vicissitudes incident to life no event could have filled me with greater anxieties than that of which the notification was transmitted by your order, and received on the 14th day of the present month.”
- anon_cow1111 3y agoI'm very sorry but someone's going to have to translate this for me, please? bonus points for a successful haiku.
- chronogram 3y ago"I'm happy to have received your message" / "Thanks for the heads-up" / "Notification marked as read"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 3y agoargmax(DREAD, g_life->getVicisstudes()) == getNotifications().find(from:you, date:{day==14}).getSubjectEvent()
- Zecc 3y agoBug report: current month not specified in RHS.
- bananapub 3y agoyou sent me a letter and holy fuck was it a bummer
- wongarsu 3y agoBy your order a message was transmitted. I received it on the 14th of this month. That message was about some event. This event filled me with great anxiety. The anxiety was greater than that caused by other events from the vicissitudes incident to life.
- noobermin 3y agoSo...I'm pretty sure I've used "which" in this very way before.
- fsckboy 3y agoi use which like that all the time
- xvedejas 3y agoI would sometimes use "whose" in this situation; despite referring to an inanimate / non-person noun, it fits grammatically.
- Twey 3y ago‘Whose’ here is general but takes on a slightly different genitive meaning of something belonging to (or used by, related to, etc.) the referent. ‘I saw a cat, which toy had black fur’ → the cat is a toy, and the cat-toy has black fur; vs ‘I saw a cat, whose toy had black fur’ → the cat has (owns, is playing with, etc.) a toy, and the cat's toy has black fur.
- Twey 3y agos/general/grammatical/
- dclowd9901 3y agoI do see usages of which in these cases only with the addition of prepositions to tie things together more cohesively. Take the example case: “Upon the submission of the cause the appellant made a motion to amend its assignments of error, which motion is now granted.” In 2023, I would expect this to read “Upon the submission of the cause the appellant made a motion to amend its assignments of error, in which motion is now granted,” where “in” is the change.
- lifechoseme123 3y agoAny article with a headline ending with Question mark is: - unoriginal & low value - written by a low quality author - edited by a low quality editor - defaults to an answer of NO stop the question mark BS
- SanderNL 3y ago[X] Critical of unimportant detail [X] Did not read the article [X] Disconnected from reality: article hits front page of HN [X] Makes value judgements based on incomplete or irrelevant evidence Quite impressive! Developer by any chance?
- lifechoseme123 3y agoDefinitely did not read the article. If it ends in "?", I publicly question its validity and denigrate its author & editor by default.
- petercooper 3y agoI've seen the word "said" used for the same job, at least in British English.
- draw_down 3y ago[dead]
- ptidhomme 3y agoIn french these 2 usages are distinguished through "que/qui/quel" vs. "lequel". This phrasing is often seen in legal texts. You'd translate "The appellant made a motion which is now granted" with "Le requérant a déposé une requête qui est maintenant acceptée". vs. "The appellant made a motion, which motion is now granted" with "Le requérant a déposé une requête, laquelle motion est maintenant acceptée". ("granted" might be translated differently than "acceptée" but you get the point).
- orbisvicis 3y agoWhich with the noun after it is rare, but in every case omitting the noun preserves the meaning while generating more commonplace sentences. I think the most common usage is "of which", in which (heh) the noun is omitted.
- EdSchouten 3y agoThis construct is still used a lot in Dutch (‘which’ -> ‘welke’).
- deaddodo 3y agoConsidering Dutch is the nearest (major) linguistic neighbor, that makes a ton of sense.
- noobermin 3y agoIs not German a closer language than Dutch to English?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- andyferris 3y agoNope - old English comes from the Ingles and Frisians, which live in modern-day Netherlands.
- deaddodo 3y agoEast Frisian is technically the closest extant lingua, but is rather niche. Old English would be mutually intelligle to Frisian speakers. Dutch is the next nearest. It's a "Germanic" language in that it's in the same family as Danish, Norwegian, German, Dutch, etc; but the High German, Swiss German, etc spoken today are one step further back. That all being said, while linguistically it fits in that family of languages and about 50% of the vocabulary can be directly connected to them, it's a massive mutt of a language with plenty of romantic influence (mostly in vocabulary) via Norman French. Along with smatterings from Indian, Japanese, Spanish, various Native American languages, etc.
- noobermin 3y agoI don't know Frisian at all, but German is a lot easier to understand for me at least when reading than Dutch is. I know that Norman influence basically made English into its own Frankenstein of a thing so may be Old English matches Dutch better. It's regardless of the history german being close to English makes sense from just my naive experience of both languages (dutch and german). Or may be I just dont touch enough Dutch.
- playingalong 3y agoI fail to understand how is that different than let say... "I read an article which I didn't understand". Is it really that different than: "I read an article about English grammar, which article I didn't understand" ?
- TylerE 3y agoI have literally never heard the latter formulation from a native English speaker. It's very awkward phrasing.
- fastaguy88 3y agoA pedant might point out that "I read an article which I didn't understand" should be written "I read an article that I didn't understand" or "I read an article, which I didn't understand." In this case, the "which" case is appropriate, but the sentence needs a comma. In general, if there is no comma, you should be using "that", and if you are using "which", you need a comma.
- drt5b7j 3y agoHow about "I read an article and I didn't understand it"? Why complex why simple is just as good ?
- zarzavat 3y agoFor me the second one seems like it is asking a question. My brain wants to swap “I didn’t” into “didn’t I” and add a question mark to the end.
- smitty1e 3y agoThis is sort of thing I might write: "I read something by Victor Davis Hanson today, which article I didn't understand". But I like retro phrasings for their own sake.
- tikhonj 3y agoIf you say something like "I read an article about grammar, which I didn't understand", it's ambiguous whether "which" refers to "article" or "grammar". In this specific example it's pretty clear from context, but it could be a bit confusing with a different object ("I read an article about the new theory, which I didn't understand.") I'd just rephrase the whole sentence to avoid ambiguity if it were a problem because saying "which article" doesn't quite feel right in this context—a bit too formal and old-fashioned?—but this use of "which" seems like a reasonable way to disambiguate if it fits in context.
- leereeves 3y agoI think it's been replaced by "that", as in: "Upon the submission of the cause the appellant made a motion to amend its assignments of error. That motion is now granted."
- puzzledobserver 3y agoAlso: Why does / did legal writing prefer the structurally complex multipart sentence in the original article to this simpler two sentence version? Is there some formal ambiguity in the two-sentence version which the one-sentence version does not have?
- randomcarbloke 3y agoon this subject does anyone have any texts that detail the formalities and intricacies of legalese? I have often found the writings of legal professionals especially compelling when I've encountered them informally in the wild (newspapers, articles etc) and would like to replicate it myself.
- Sprocklem 3y agoThis notably differs from the example in OP by its position outside of the first sentence. AFAICT, your second sentence cannot function as a parenthetical like the example with "which motion".
- spondylosaurus 3y agoAmerican English generally uses "that" for restrictive clauses and "which" for relative clauses. E.g.: > The local cafe that my dad loves has a lot of lunch options. > The local cafe, which my dad loves, has a lot of lunch options. But British English generally uses "which" for both: > The local cafe which my dad loves has a lot of lunch options. The "cannot function as a parenthetical" is essentially what a restrictive clause is, although of course the person you're replying to broke things into two sentences.
- 3y ago