4 ms·
> Why is this the case? In a sentence: because doing FOSS is just a way for some people to enhance their careers. Anything not related to the code is extraneo
by kazinator 3y ago
> Why is this the case?
In a sentence: because doing FOSS is just a way for some people to enhance their careers.
Anything not related to the code is extraneous to that.
Running a mailing list (for example) isn't resume-stuffing material for someone who isn't a sysadmin.
A popular, well-known FOSS project enhances your career better than one that is unpopular and obscure. From that perspective, that forum system is best which facilitates popularity.
Then there is the youth factor. I think that mostly older developers care about this issue. Younger developers who didn't live through the Unix wars and the rise of GNU/Linux and all that are deaf to the issues. They take an Internet full of wall-gardened social networks to be the norm; it's what they were already born into. Asking the kids not to gather in some Discord group is like asking kids of yesteryear not to hang around at the mall. (The mall is proprietary, so what?)
- tredre3 3y ago> because doing FOSS is just a way for some people to enhance their careers. That's a very cynical view. Perhaps it is somewhat more true when it comes to the HN audience, but outside of here "enhancing career" is probably not even in the top 5 motivations behind FOSS work...
- kazinator 3y agoI am positing that in fact self promotion is the motivation if we restrict ourselves to those decision makers at the top of the FOSS project who decide matters such as that the associated forum is going to be on Discord or Slack. They are not the only contributors to the actual project, of course, and not everyone is in their Discord or Slack because they like Discord or Slack. If you want to promote yourself as a developer by means of having your name on a lot of source code out there that people are using the only way that's going to happen is if it is open source. If that's all you care about, open source is just a means to that end. Your name is still in a bunch of code that people are using if the documentation happens to be in Microsoft Word. Open source has been promoted that way to a bunch of young people are starting out in software. "Oh don't have much industry experience? Show that you can code by starting a free software project or contributing to one. Anyone who's anyone has half a dozen or more Github repositories."
- _lvbh 3y ago> In a sentence: because doing FOSS is just a way for some people to enhance their careers. Doubt It’s just that most people are on discord. I tried running a matrix space/room for support but people would keep asking if I could use discord instead. Kept the matrix room running for a while but nobody ever showed up while the discord server was at over a 1000 people. Left both after the project was archived.
- shrimp_emoji 3y ago> They take an Internet full of wall-gardened social networks to be the norm; it's what they were already born into. And it's the older developers' fault for letting that happen!
- soulofmischief 3y agoThat doesn't line up with my own experiences at all. Many of the hardcore FOSS devs I know focus on their passions, at a detriment to their career. > A popular, well-known FOSS project enhances your career better than one that is unpopular and obscure I just don't think any of us care about that when choosing FOSS products. You're talking about an entirely different class of developer and massively generalizing. > Younger developers who didn't live through the Unix wars and the rise of GNU/Linux and all that are deaf to the issues. Again, incredibly generalized. Many young people today express the exact same hardcore stances toward privacy and security, and are the reason why we have things like Matrix bridges. > Asking the kids not to gather in some Discord group is like asking kids of yesteryear not to hang around at the mall You got close, but still missed it. The reason so many FOSS products choose Discord is the ease at which they can build large and successful communities, due to the networking effect Discord provides. If a FOSS tool could match that level of discovery, that would be a step up, but it still doesn't solve the other big issue: Discord is where many passionate, creative people are. You can provide a product that is better in every way, and FLOSS, but without a successful marketing campaign and a bit of luck, no one will ever show up.
- lucideer 3y agoThis is a rather absurd comment. > Running a mailing list (for example) isn't resume-stuffing material for someone who isn't a sysadmin. The assumption here is that an open-source maintainer has the time, energy & expertise to run a mailing list, but chooses not to for cynical career-related reasons. This completely dodges the very obvious oft-discussed point that most FOSS maintainers are under-resourced & overstretched. People use Discord because Discord does the work for you, so you have more time to make the thing you're making.
- kazinator 3y agoCareer-related reasons are not cynical; they're perfectly legitimate, and that person's prerogative. I mean there are situations in in which prioritizing your career objective over something else may be immoral. Like say if you choose a path whereby you get a promotion but large numbers of people suffer. But if you're making something free you don't owe anybody anything. If people don't like it that you're using Discord or whatever else, too bad.
- jdlshore 3y agoYour assumption that this decision is being made for career related reasons is what people are saying is cynical.
- kazinator 3y agoIf I say that a certain observed behavior is probably due to a certain hidden reason (whether I'm right or off the mark), then that will appear cynical to those who think that the reason is nefarious. That's not my problem if I think it's a fine, even commendable reason.
- lucideer 3y agoThese are fair points so I'll rephrase: the comment may not be cynical, it's just absurd.