7 ms·
Spyware can infect your phone or computer via the ads you see online – report
- quitit 3y agoIt's a bit odd to see old is new again. Goog's Ad network had a pretty shoddy history with ads that redirect users automatically, but I had the feeling they got on top of this. It seems like something that could be stopped automatically.
- Scoundreller 3y agoProblem is there are other ad networks. Especially on content that Google won’t run ads on or that webmasters can add in addition to Google ads.
- quitit 3y agoAlthough I understand that point - the problem here is that reputable websites should be able to rely on Google to not serve such content. As for website owners who are running unscrupulous ad networks, that's on them.
- thefurdrake 3y agoRemember tools like uBlock Origin and uMatrix. It is moral and ethical to block all ads and scripts from adtech companies. Contributing to ruining their way of life is a socially-responsible behavior. Failure to do so results in behaviors like this. You get what you deserve if you don't block ads.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>You get what you deserve if you don't block ads. I was with you until this piece. Not everyone is well educated enough on the nefarious nature of targeted online advertising and the technical processes of blocking them on each platform. In some EU countries we have pretty strict regulations on what ads are allowed, where they're allowed and for what they're allowed, precisely because not everyone can "mentally ignore" them and people can be easily influenced. So you can't just say "well, it's you're own fault you got addicted to opioids/gambling/drinking/smoking, so you get what you deserve", when the whole city is plastered with ads for such accessible addictions. "Got a tooth-ache? Ask your doctor about OxyContin." "Got trouble paying the bills? Get a loan with 500% interest rate from us on the spot." "Wanna look cool? Smoke Bullshit cigars." Usually, the less educated and less well-off people are, the more vulnerable to nefarious and predatory advertising they tend to be, so it's the responsibility of us as a society to take legal steps of ensuring the regulation and blocking of targeted web ads at communal/societal level instead of leaving it to the individuals and the mercy of the "free market".
- thefurdrake 3y ago> I was with you until this piece. Not everyone is well educate enough on blocking ads. The statement was directed to the audience, IE HN. I have confidence that everyone on HN is capable of installing those browser plugins and comprehending the complex clusterfuck that is uMatrix. I don't have a solution for the less-technical folks right now. The best I can do is encourage people who ARE capable of responding reasonably to that message to help the people who don't. uBlock Origin is already pretty friendly, but uMatrix is a nightmare.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>The statement was directed to the audience, IE HN. Unclear from your comment who the target audience was, but to me it would be equally inflammatory regardless. The non-tech-savvy users are a way bigger and more vulnerable target than just the HN userbase which is a microscopic minority on global level.
- thefurdrake 3y ago> Unclear from your comment who the target was, but to me it was equally inflammatory, regardless Eh, agreed. Kinda detracts from the point. I've gotten pretty vehement about the topic over the last few years I guess.
- LMYahooTFY 3y agoEqually inflammatory to tell people who should know better that they'll keep getting what they deserve? How is it unclear who the audience is on HN? Encouraging those who can to do is also a component of grassroots change. I don't think it took much charity to interpret their comment as being directed toward HN, and only a little more to imagine how pushing tech people to use/develop/polish ad blocking tools can result in the spread of such things. Seems like you're working hard to be upset.
- vik0 3y agouBlock can become decently complicated too if you enable "I'm an advanced user" in the settings menu I think it can be made to do the same things as uMatrix with advanced mode (I use medium mode on uBlock) - or am I wrong on this? Ive never used uMatrix before
- bt4u 3y ago[dead]
- 7373737373 3y agoIf only Firefox & Co had this installed by default... I suppose Mozilla gets a lot of Google money to not let that happen (?)
- kevingadd 3y agoSponsor money aside, if Firefox had a default adblocker you'd probably see many sites block the browser wholesale instead of only blocking people who install ublock
- thefurdrake 3y agoI would be annoyed if Firefox included a buncha plugins by default.
- donatj 3y agoI'm not so sure the morality is as black and white as you paint. If someone builds something and wants to be paid for their work, taking it for free against their wishes hardly seems ethical. The purely ethical solution here is just not using sites that have ads if you're opposed.
- thefurdrake 3y agoI see this whinging constantly. I don't care. Adtech is a pursuit that has turned into a scientifically-quantified attempt to subvert the executive function of other human beings with the aim of getting them to perform actions they would otherwise not perform. If you can't survive without engaging in amoral psychological manipulation of other human beings, you don't deserve to be paid, and your way of life should collapse. Find a different job. Let's not forget that this article is about adtech being used to distribute malware.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- usea 3y agoThey're giving it away for free. There's not an implied contract that says you have to look at the ad to see the website. The website is free. They ask you to watch some ads voluntarily. It's not wrong to refuse.
- bediger4000 3y agoYou're missing using Firefox and NoScript. Both valid as ad blocking.
- thefurdrake 3y agoMy reply was not intended to be an all-encompassing list of all possible avenues of resisting adtech's dominance on the internet, and at no point did I imply so. It'd suck if I had to post an entire guide/list every time I mention some tech that helps. Noscript isn't worth having in favor of uMatrix, IMO.
- bediger4000 3y agoI'll give uMatrix a try.
- cryptoegorophy 3y agoAlso, either use reliable blocker or pay for one. Don’t use Adblock because even though it doesn’t say it leaks your browsing history it actually does.
- thefurdrake 3y agoThat's why I mentioned uBlock Origin and uMatrix, yeah.
- thn-gap 3y ago> You get what you deserve if you don't block ads. I hope you do great contributions to the cause if you are already at the point of victim blaming.
- thefurdrake 3y agoMnn, somebody didn't read the rest of the thread! Oops!
- cf141q5325 3y agoThere is a stupidity component here that i think got lost in the framing. The larger that becomes the more blame is functional to sustain your agency. You shouldnt be doing very stupid stuff, the only point at which that becomes a non issue is if you are unable to do so and require a legal guardian. If you dont want one and keep your agency, be less dumb. This is a functional description not a moral argument. If somebody has to fix it for your, your say in the matter will drastically reduce.
- cmcaleer 3y agoWhile generally I agree, and I do run an adblocker for safety reasons, I'll also contend that you get what you deserve if you block ads and don't pony up in some other way. It's easy to forget this when every article has a web archive link bypassing a paywall, or you watch YouTube with Sponsorblock, but ultimately someone has to pay the bill at the end of the day. An individual writing an investigative piece over months incurs a lot of expenses, the 10 minute YouTube video you watched probably took many hours or days to produce, the storage and bandwidth cost of the 4K video you watched is not nil. An ideal world would have properly regulated ads on platforms like YouTube and Adwords held to the same standards as some European ad agencies. But since we don't live in an ideal world, pay for a subscription to a newspaper you read a lot. Give someone you enjoy like $5 on Patreon, maybe more if they're not the type to double dip with sponsorship spots AND have a Patreon (personal pet peeve) and immediately unsubscribe, that's worth several thousand ad-supported views depending on their CPM. Like having LTS versions? Donate to the devs or don't be surprised when they burn out[0]. Currently, almost everything you enjoy on the internet is made by other humans. Support them in doing so. [0]: https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/09/linux-gives-up-on-6-year-lts-thats-fine-for-pcs-bad-for-android/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2023/09/linux-gives-up-on-6-...
- akira2501 3y ago> I'll also contend that you get what you deserve if you block ads and don't pony up in some other way. I explicitly reject this idea. What did media do for centuries? They had a brick and mortar sales operation that went out and sold advertisements, took in creative, and than ran those ads inline. For those not big enough to support this, there are agencies that will do the entire thing for you. This idea that we need to allow untrusted third parties to run code on our computer because poor website operators would just have no other way to make money is bogus. This is particularly true for journalists who should be extremely uncomfortable that google has full access to their articles and can manipulate them before they're shown to end users. In an ideal world, people would take and make 100% of the advertising money for themselves, and pennies-on-the-dollar advertising aggregators would have no reason to exist.
- 3y ago
- taway1237 3y ago>It is moral and ethical to block all ads and scripts from adtech companies. Depends on your moral code, I think? Who made you a moral authority? You don't get a say in what I consider moral. I'm sorry for the aggressive tone of my post, but people telling me what I should think are a pet peeve of mine.
- thefurdrake 3y ago> Depends on your moral code, I think? Who made you a moral authority? You don't get a say in what I consider moral. I don't care what you consider moral. If you don't like it, you can do as you please. I would have thought that would have been obvious, since this is the internet and the only control over you I have is through text on the screen. Repeating this is tiresome; take your aggressiveness and peevishness elsewhere, because I'm about as obligated to care about them as you are to consider what I say moral. You're not sorry, so you shouldn't say so, which is a pet peeve of MINE.
- ravenstine 3y agoWhat you are saying is paradoxical. Morality necessarily comes from authority. Otherwise, it's nothing but a preference or a fashion. Everyone may have a different view of morality, but the whole point of morality is objective, if it is to have any comprehensible definition. Hence it is correct to state one's morality with authority if one truly believes it.
- l33t7332273 3y ago> Morality necessarily comes from authority That’s not true at all > Otherwise, it's nothing but a preference or a fashion Morality is definitely a stronger belief than a mere preference, but it’s still subjective. > the whole point of morality is objective, if it is to have any comprehensible definition I don’t understand where you’re coming from here. Morality has nothing to do with objectivity.
- smegger001 3y agoIf the ads were nothing but a picture/plain text with refer link it might be possible to argue that their payments to the websites are need to fund them and blocking was simply an issue of denying revenue. But this is unvetted third party code that is often malicious and could infect your computer enable identity fraud steal your data, encryption your documents and extort bitcoins to get your family photos back, not to mention the supposedly benign ad tracking code that enables mega corps to stalk you around the web and in some cases track your actually physical location and sell that data at a surprisingly low rate to anyone that asks for it. Sorry but no. Not using a ad blocker on the open web is like not using a condom when hooking up. Sure it may feel better not to but the risk are to high.
- ravenstine 3y agoExactly. They've had about 30 years to correct course and self-regulate, and not only can the adtech industry not help themselves but companies like The Google have proven that they'll be complicit with the swindle if they can get away with it. If fast-forwarding through ads on your DVR isn't stealing, then neither is using uBlock Origin. In fact, the morality behind web ads means that the right thing to do is to make ads, especially malicious ads, not profitable.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoUsers should not need to "block" ads. Imagine if the telephone worked like a "modern" web browser. Dial a number and the phone automatically calls 12 other numbers, chosen by the person at the number dialed, and the 12 other numbers are unknown to the person dialling. Everyone agrees the early internet and web was different. The auto-load resources "feature" was intended, or even Javascript, for a web that was experimental and fun to use. These features are now used almost invariably for commercial purposes. Most of that is surveillance. Without auto-load resources and Javascript, the user dials one number and only connects to one number. Most advertising and tracking stops working. When visiting sites submitted to HN, I'm not using a browser that auto-load resources or runs Javascript, hence there is no need for me to "block" ads; I control what request. People have been expending vast amounts of energy trying to counter "automatic" behaviour of the browser they choose to use. Perhaps the challenge is a new type of "fun". Otherwise, why use a browser that one cannot control. Find an open source browser. Remove the offensive "features". Re-compile. Done. This is exactly what I did with the browser I'm using to type this comment. Not everything that is "popular" is good. Perhaps that's an effect of advertising. Several so-called "tech" companies want the public, including government officials, to believe that advertising dollars are necessary to sustain a useful computer network.^1 Feel free to debate. Everything that is good does not need advertising. UBlockOrigin is one example. By generally all accounts, it's great and, AFAIK, it is not supported by advertising. 1. The truth however is that advertising dollars are only necessary to sustain those companies.
- pixl97 3y agoThis is nothing new. In 2014 a US senate panel recommended blocking ads because of malware risks. You owe the advertisers nothing.
- aaomidi 3y agoI believe FBI and NSA do too.
- calibas 3y agoWe really should look at ads as this service where random strangers get to run Javascript in your browser. They're an attack vector, and ads should be treated like the security/privacy threats that they are.
- Xeamek 3y agoWhy? Browsers already treat all the code that is run by the website as potentially unsafe. Why would we focus specifically on adds where there are other, equally unsafe vectors present? What advantages would that have over the current way?
- Zak 3y agoPerhaps because security isn't binary. Browsers should sandbox JS such that it's harmless, but sometimes fail at that. Letting fewer random strangers run JS in your browser reduces your attack surface area.
- bell-cot 3y agoTHIS, but `sed 's/fewer/far, far fewer/'` AND - the owners of the (relatively) few web sites that most people visit are far more invested in staying malware-free, vs. the Ad companies letting ~anyone on the planet run js in ads, at "what's their credit card good for?" scale.
- bhouston 3y agoAds generally run in iframes and iframes are considered a form of sandboxing.
- falcolas 3y agoIMO, because ad code is a step above “potentially unsafe”, it’s sometimes malicious, and even intentionally malicious.
- aaomidi 3y agoEspecially when you get to do hyper targeted attacks through the ad provider. It’s one of the reasons I do not turn on personalized ads anywhere.
- kibwen 3y agoWhat's the difference between an email spammer and an ad company like Google? One of them makes its money from intrusive, deceptive, malicious, unwanted advertisements, and the other is an email spammer.
- notyourwork 3y agoUnwanted? You don’t have to use google products, right? There is a difference. Google isn’t a non profit or a charity.
- krior 3y agoYes you have to. They killed all their competitors.
- thefurdrake 3y ago> Unwanted? You don’t have to use google products, right? There is a difference. Google isn’t a non profit or a charity. In case you missed it, this thread is about adtech. Google ads are deployed on more than just Google products, so when you say, "You don’t have to use google products, right?", what you should really be saying is "You don't have to use half the internet, right?" Which is definitely true, I suppose.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoIt's difficult to not use Google products. Particularly Gmail, YouTube, Maps, and Search.
- carlosjobim 3y agoApart from maps, there are much better options available: Gmail < Fastmail YouTube < YouTube Premium Search < Kagi Maps is Google's last stand. At least Apple has offline maps as does Organic Maps, but Google Maps is superior.
- shepherdjerred 3y ago
- _a_a_a_ 3y agoTurning off JS makes infection virtually impossible IMO, and pages load much faster. Some things break, but many don't and IME it's worth it.
- eduction 3y agoAd based exploits are not remotely new. Most ads these days have their own javascript- it would be surprising if they couldnt be used to deliver exploits. As other have said, this is a key reason to block ads.
- bhouston 3y agoThe idea isn't new, but the fact that a company is commercializing spyware deliver via ad-networks is new.
- autoexec 3y agoIt's also a good reason to block javascript. Most browser exploits (even fingerprinting) depend on JS being enabled. Disable it by default, and you're much much safer.
- xtracto 3y agoAnd also a good reason to block http/https, most exploits in the wild are distributed via this protocol. The percentage of malware in this protocol compared to others like ftp, nntp or gopher is outstanding. Disabling it will make you even much safer.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoWhy don't we just make JavaScript in ads illegal? Perhaps paired with some identifier per ad buyer, much like political ads must menton who paid for them. Ads don't need JavaScript or anonymity. Then ad providers can easily filter out those most dangerous, and remain in compliance. Regulators can easily scan for violators.
- aaomidi 3y agoI’d take a step further and say maybe origin only JavaScript should be a thing. If I go to example.com I don’t want JavaScript from other hosts loading and running. This could probably be a simple browser extension honestly - might give it a try. It’ll break a good chunk of sites but I don’t think it’d break them too much? Although it does completely break CDNs so probably an allow list would be necessary.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoIt would break countless, useful, embeddable widgets. Or at least until site owners become savvy enough to proxy it or put it on a subdomain.
- hn92726819 3y agoThis is what uBlocm Origin advanced mode does, but obviously it isn't default. Though, I really don't like this propisition because it just means google will require websites to host google-provided JavaScript from their domain.
- EMM_386 3y agoThere is a lot of talk here but no real answers. What exploit is this using to infect Windows computers and Android phones? Does this have to do with the 0-day exploit in WebP that is causing a huge mess for the entire ecosystem? Everyone seems to be fixated on "ads shouldn't be able to run JavaScript" and the like. What exactly is that JavaScript in the ad taking advantage of? Why would it matter that it's an ad and not just a website? If ads can do it, web pages can do it.
- chucksmash 3y agoYou select the web pages, but the ads select you.
- EMM_386 3y agoTrue, but either way the exploit needs to be addressed. While I agree the attack vector is pretty awful, I was just curious exactly what the exploit was. The article doesn't even mention it. It links to Apple, which is likely that 0-day 0-click that Pegasus uses (BLASTPASS). They report that as a flaw in PassKit though, which would not affect Android or Windows. That's why I was thinking the WebP overflow? That is actually worse, and makes the discussion here even more off-topic, because that has nothing to do with JavaScript. I has to do with decoding WebP images. https://www.tarlogic.com/blog/cve-2023-4863/ https://www.tarlogic.com/blog/cve-2023-4863/
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoThis article doesn't make any sense. I kept waiting for an explanation of how the spyware is installed, and just got this paragraph: > What sets Insanet’s Sherlock apart from Pegasus is its exploitation of ad networks rather than vulnerabilities in phones. A Sherlock user creates an ad campaign that narrowly focuses on the target’s demographic and location, and places a spyware-laden ad with an ad exchange. Once the ad is served to a web page that the target views, the spyware is secretly installed on the target’s phone or computer. That last sentence is simply impossible without an unpatched vulnerability on the device. If something is actually installed on the device, the vulnerability allowing this will eventually be patched.
- dexwiz 3y agoAny significantly complex attack leverages multiple vulnerabilities.
- solardev 3y agoYes, but the article is confusing targeted advertising (not really a vulnerability) with actual zero day vulnerabilities. They are not really related, but both can be part of a targeted campaign I guess.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y agoNo shit, but the article is making the unreasonable claims that: 1. This hack is not a result of a device vulnerability. 2. That whatever technique is being used to install spyware cannot be defended against (i.e. with an OS patch). That is simply impossible if an actual executable is installed on the device.
- superjan 3y agoThe article is really vague. Extraordinary claims should come with extraordinary evidence. That said, could it be that the ad has its own JavaScript that does its spying for the time it is visible on the page? Can adds do that?
- cf141q5325 3y agoBit off topic, but i think this is a good place to remind people that they should remember to enforce separation of two factor platforms. Attaching a modern smartphone you use for TANs for online banking to the machine you do online banking on is quite brave.
- ckbishop 3y ago[flagged]
- keyme 3y agoI actually know nothing about ads. When you post a graphical ad, what do you actually post? Is there a file format? HTML? Video? Is there a difference if you want your ad to appear inside apps rather than the web?
- smegger001 3y agoIn other news water is wet. This has been an issue for decades at this point. Letting random third parties exacute arbitrary code on your computer is a bad idea.
- 4sellff 3y agoBlocking ads in your browser is responsible behavior. It is the same as putting a lock on the door to your house. There are people in the world who will think nothing of taking advantage of you if it means they can put money in their pocket. That said, the OP is referencing malicious ads, which are not designed to sell a product or service. Instead, they are designed to infect your device. From which they can collect/extract data about you. The current ad-tech model needs to change and is due for disruption. Advertising is everywhere and it’s out of control. There seem to be more ads than ever, in every medium and in every square inch of surface area. In most cases, the ads are unwanted and not even relevant. Our attention is being stolen and massive amounts of money are being wasted by companies with a legitimate interest to make sales. The bottom-line is that consumers are being victimized by the constant bombardment of advertising. And the companies that sell products/services, who need to build awareness and grow sales, are being taken advantage of by the ad-tech giants. A new model is needed and we are actively working on a solution called Sellff Offers. This solution allows sellers and buyers to connect directly, without the middleman. Sellff Offers inverts the current ad-tech model in three significant ways: [1] Opt-in, [2] Privacy friendly, and [3] Pays cash rewards. Here is an example Offer [ https://sellff.com/$/ron.michel/offer/ewVkr https://sellff.com/$/ron.michel/offer/ewVkr ]. You choose whether to view the Offer. Your data and activity is not collected/shared/sold if you view the Offer. And, you are compensated for your time if you decide to participate in the Offer. Complaining about the current broken ad-tech model does not help to fix it. You need to take action to bring about the change you want to see. If you have an interest in building a new digital marketing/promotions solution, we would like to speak with you. Regardless, we are very excited to see the growing consumer awareness of the dangers of ad-tech and the interest in alternatives ways to connect buyers and sellers.
- autoexec 3y ago> malicious ads, which are not designed to sell a product or service. Instead, they are designed to infect your device. From which they can collect/extract data about you. At this point we can only assume that every ad is malicious. It doesn't matter if they are designed to sell a product or service. They'll still collect/extract data about you at every opportunity. At best, they're attempts to manipulate us. That might mean making us feel insecure about ourselves or our lifestyle so that they can trick is into giving them money. It might mean outright lying to us and feeding our fears to push us to support a certain politician or law. It might be promoting outright scams. Surveillance advertising needs to die. Paying people to view ads alone won't remove the harms advertising can cause, but at least it's a "pull" vs "push" model which I approve of since it can be safely ignored by anyone unwilling to subject themselves to manipulation and exploitation. You should consider a strict code of conduct for what types of ads you will/won't allow on your platform to keep the worst of it away. Fact-checking and vetting takes time and money, but it would keep your service from being used to spread disinformation and scams and could help prevent some of the harms.
- hobobaggins 3y agoOriginal source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37626238 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37626238
- almostnormal 3y agoI would like to see ads. Last time I saw some they were at least intersting (nothing to buy tomorrow, but good to know). But with the risks involved (malicious ads and being tracked), everything is blocked. It is "risk blocking" not "ad blocking". Not seing ads is just a side-effect. A newspaper will refuse to print unacceptable ads. Some ad-tech will deliver anything. Some websites use ads from ad-tech that delivers anything. Maybe there is a niche market opportunity for a guaranteed-safe-notracking ad-tech company to reach the target demographic of people blocking ads to reduce risk and avoid tracking. It would require cooperation with ad-blockers to provide a switch to drop to risk-blocking though.