9 ms·
Profile of Sabine Hossenfelder
- drt5b7j 3y ago[flagged]
- fiforpg 3y ago> If you're promoting research into quantum gravity that doesn't respect special relativity, you're a crackpot. Is there a short argument for why MOND cannot agree with relativity, at least on the relevant scales?
- importantstuff 3y agoI don't have a quick explanation, but rather a quick anectode. The incompatibility of MOND with relativity used to be called "Bekenstein's Theorem", based on the idea that Bekenstein had tried to write down such a theory but failed to do so. Since Bekenstein was a very smart guy, if he couldn't do it, it couldn't be done. When he heard about this, he proceeded to write down an incredibly ugly theory called TeVeS, but, well, that theory's got fields too (Tensor, Vector, Scalar), so in the end it's just dark matter all the way down.
- markhahn 3y agohah - did you intentionally refer to ugliness there? I think one of her most cogent points is that theoreticians are often driven by "beauty", which is not a valid epistemological or metaphysical principle.
- edgineer 3y agoShe's said some of her views on theories are contentious. I'd like to hear from the other side. What claim does she make about quantum gravity, and how is it inconsistent with special relativity?
- prettyStandard 3y agoShe does seem to have a pretty compelling argument that the speed of light may not be the maximum speed. It's not that crack pot. https://youtu.be/9-jIplX6Wjw?si=nLokQYuvv2KRzCak https://youtu.be/9-jIplX6Wjw?si=nLokQYuvv2KRzCak
- jjoonathan 3y agoUsing gravity to "re-wind" the direction of time on a spaceship sounds considerably more speculative than she tries to pass it off.
- yieldcrv 3y ago> I'd like to hear from the other side. side note: I just wish that everyone that was "trying to keep an open mind" wasn't so impressionable and susceptible to the most unsubstantiated theories one of my side projects just sells merchandise to conspiracy theorists, such a predictable lot
- the__alchemist 3y agoThis attitude highlights an impediment to original research and discovery.
- woleium 3y agothe same comment, but with valid credentials attached may not though.
- kingTug 3y ago[flagged]
- Avshalom 3y agoI dunno if she's a crank yet but having a youtube fan base (really just a fan base at all) in part built on her disagreements with other physicists means she's probably going to end up as one.
- jjallen 3y agoSo every physics researcher should never challenge established theories and if you do you’re a crackpot? Can you make a cogent argument against one bit of her research instead of calling her a crackpot for challenging things?
- noslenwerdna 3y agoSpecial relativity is an article of faith now? So far it has survived all experimental tests, that doesn't mean it is guaranteed to do so in the future
- wtallis 3y agoAny theory that would supplant special relativity must agree with special relativity on everything that has already been experimentally verified. So it's not the theory of special relativity that's an article of faith, it's the associated mountain of evidence that imposes requirements on new theories.
- hotstickyballs 3y agoDoesn’t mean that it needs to take the exact form of special reactivity though, especially when we know when it breaks down.
- wtallis 3y agoNobody said it has to take the exact form of special relativity. The comment in question here only said that it needs to respect special relativity. A new theory can offer a wildly different explanation, as long is it does explain all the correct predictions of special relativity. In mathematical terms, that does mean your theory will produce the equations of special relativity when some limit or restriction is applied, just as special relativity reduces to Newtonian mechanics in the limit of velocities being much less than c.
- noslenwerdna 3y agoI would dispute that the comment in question said that, but now it is gone (deleted?). Your view is quite reasonable, the original post's was not.
- wtallis 3y agoThe comment has been flagged, so you can't see it without turning on the showdead option. The line in question is: > If you're promoting research into quantum gravity that doesn't respect special relativity, you're a crackpot. Using the word "crackpot" apparently went too far for some people, but it's not controversial to say that a theory of quantum gravity needs to respect special relativity: quantum gravity is about trying to unify quantum mechanics with general relativity, and general relativity is the generalization of special relativity to include gravity.
- fasterik 3y agoI've never actually watched or listened to anything by Sabine Hossenfelder, so I don't have a particular opinion on her work. But... >If you're promoting research into quantum gravity that doesn't respect special relativity, you're a crackpot. I think this statement is off the mark. Theoretical physics is often about simplifying a problem to a form that you know how to solve, even if it's not physically realistic. Once you have a solution in your toy domain, you might have a chance of modifying it to find a physically viable theory. A solution can also be useful in restricted domains, even if it's not true in the general case. If we look at the historical development of quantum theory, it wasn't modified to take relativity into account until 1928. Even then, the non-relativistic theory has independent value and makes many valid predictions. Another example is the AdS/CFT correspondence. We know we don't live in anti-de Sitter space, but study of it has led to a better understanding of black holes. I don't think we should rule out any line of research a priori. We should throw a bunch of different approaches at the problem and see which ones help us to make progress. Of course, crackpots are a real thing. In my mind, the definition of a crackpot is someone who claims to have a revolutionary theory without any track record of engaging with research-level ideas. Perusing Sabine's Google Scholar page shows that she has a respectable number of papers and citations, so it is worth taking her ideas seriously, even if you disagree with them.
- greatpostman 3y agoJust by reading the title alone I figured this was the case
- jackmott 3y agoReally misplaced negativity, her youtube channel is a treasure, almost nobody in the world manages to produce a breakthrough in physics research, that doesn’t make them garbage.
- agd 3y agoI don't understand how alternative research makes you a crackpot. If she was presenting her theories as fact without evidence then perhaps, but I haven't seen her doing that. Overall, she comes across as a very clear communicator with criticisms (rightly or wrongly) of some current research.
- ksey3 3y agoHow many didnt get famous? Thats what no one reports. If the UN report on the attention economy is saying 0.5% of content produced is consumed and dropping, then how are people getting views? It doesnt make any sense. Unless the game is rigged. People have limited attention to give anything but unlimited capacity to receive attention. The platforms are taking full advantage of that fact to keep this ponzi scheme running.
- permo-w 3y agoas long as you approach this kind of thing with knowledge of how Youtube works, I actually think there's a pretty high chance of success if you have a good mic and camera, show your face, speak clearly, consistently upload, and - most importantly - you broadly make one-off videos about common denominator subtopics - never going too deep or numbering your videos - then I wouldn't bet against you. there really aren't that many successful science Youtubers
- yorwba 3y agoThe UN report on the attention economy actually said: By the 2000s, so much information was being generated worldwide that only a small fraction (0.5% in 2015) of the digital data generated was being analyzed at all. https://www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/attention_economy_feb.pdf https://www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/attention_economy_... Where "analyzed" probably means something other than "got any views". In any case, the claim is unsourced, so I wouldn't put much stock in it. The way I see it, people's ability to give attention is limited, but the ability to do something worth paying attention to is even scarcer, so even the most trivial feat (like writing a comment on HN) is likely to garner at least a few views. Becoming famous is much harder than getting any views at all, because now you need to do something so attention-grabbing that some of your few initial viewers will tell others about it and your audience size snowballs from there.
- dredmorbius 3y agoDo you happen to know the publication date of that report? Internet Archive's first capture is April 2023. The most recent references within the report are for 2021.
- IG_Semmelweiss 3y agoIn the econtalk podcast, she does a really poor job (and is also somewhat rude with the host) in explaining why the periodic table, for example, is not analogous with supersymmetry or with grand unification. The question : One cannot have any expected prediction from supersymmetry (unlike say the periodic table) because ____________ (no explanation given)? Can someone expand? Transcript : Russ Roberts: I think that moment in science, and other related moments in physics, were things that were predicted--the Higgs boson being one example where things did show up. They just think, 'Well, it's just a matter of time; we don't have powerful enough colliders. We'll eventually develop them. And all these things have to be true.' They're holding onto that. And I get that. Because the history seems to encourage that viewpoint. Sabine Hossenfelder: No, it doesn't. Russ Roberts: Okay. Why not? Sabine Hossenfelder: That's a very sloppy look at the history (it continues) https://www.econtalk.org/sabine-hossenfelder-on-physics-reality-and-lost-in-math/#read-comments https://www.econtalk.org/sabine-hossenfelder-on-physics-real...
- hotdogscout 3y agoThe periodic table is a classification of the chemical elements based on their atomic number, electron configuration and chemical properties. It is a result of the empirical observation of the elements and their regular patterns. The periodic table does not depend on any particular theory of physics, but it can be explained by quantum mechanics and the structure of atoms.[1] Grand unification is a hypothetical scenario in which the electromagnetic, weak and strong forces are unified into a single force at very high energies. This would imply that the elementary particles of the Standard Model are composed of more fundamental particles, such as quarks and leptons, that interact through a single gauge group. Grand unification is motivated by the observation that the strengths of the three forces converge at high energies, suggesting a common origin. Grand unification also predicts the existence of new particles, such as magnetic monopoles and proton decay.[2] Supersymmetry is a theoretical framework that proposes a symmetry between fermions and bosons, two classes of particles with different spin properties. It implies that for every known particle, there exists a superpartner with the same mass and quantum numbers, but with a different spin. Supersymmetry is not based on any empirical evidence, but on mathematical aesthetics and theoretical convenience. Supersymmetry can solve some problems in the Standard Model, such as the hierarchy problem and the dark matter problem, but it also introduces many new parameters and complications. Supersymmetry has not been observed in nature, despite extensive searches at the Large Hadron Collider and other experiments.[3] The main difference between supersymmetry and the periodic table or grand unification is that supersymmetry is not a natural consequence of any observed phenomenon, but an ad hoc assumption that has no experimental support. The periodic table and grand unification are based on empirical data and physical principles, while supersymmetry is based on mathematical beauty and speculation. Therefore, supersymmetry does not make any expected predictions, unlike the periodic table or grand unification, because it is not constrained by any reality check. Supersymmetry can be adjusted to fit any observation or avoid any contradiction, making it unfalsifiable and arbitrary.[4] [1]Supersymmetry - Wikipedia. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersymmetry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supersymmetry. [2] Supersymmetry and what it means for particle https://www.space.com/supersymmetry-particle-physics-string-theory.html https://www.space.com/supersymmetry-particle-physics-string-.... [3] The status of supersymmetry | symmetry magazine. https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/article/the-status-of-supersymmetry?language_content_entity=und https://www.symmetrymagazine.org/article/the-status-of-super... [4] Supersymmetry: what? why? when? - Ohio University https://inpp.ohio.edu/~inpp/nuclear_lunch/archive/2005/kane_supersym.pdf https://inpp.ohio.edu/~inpp/nuclear_lunch/archive/2005/kane_....
- renjimen 3y agoLove Sabine. Great to have a news source that’s geared to those with a scientific background. Reminds me a little bit of a time when news was created to standards rather than attention metrics.
- mongol 3y agoI don't read many books these days, but I read her book "Lost in Math", and appreciated it. It provided a perspective to physics research that was enlightening to me as an outsider.
- lacrimacida 3y agoSabine is fun to listen to, love her. But to be honest her snark is a bit too abundant for me so I check her videos from time to time
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoI love the snark. It’s my favorite part
- fsh 3y agoI really like Hossenfelder's physics videos. However, once she leaves her area of expertise, the quality drops off a cliff. Most of these videos are just summaries of random articles with no critical thought.
- hkwerf 3y ago... and bad stock photos, like the one about microchips, where for a long time all the imagery is photos of PCBs, sometimes without any component that would resemble an integrated circuit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QFO_SXOcYM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QFO_SXOcYM.
- timmytokyo 3y agoI agree. I enjoy anything she produces that is physics-related but the social commentary and science topics outside her area of expertise are hit-or-miss. I also think she opens herself up to audience capture, especially now that she's being funded directly by viewers, and that concerns me.
- Retric 3y agoShe also made some significant errors in physics videos. One example is she calculated the power output of fusion reactions as energy created by fusion * heat to electricity conversion efficiency. However, energy that’s heating the plasma should also recoverable at the same conversion efficiency. Largely irrelevant a Q=1,000 but it plays a major role in what Q is breakeven and what Q is economically useful. Not on the surface such a big deal, but a sign she should reach out more to actual experts in these fields.
- jiggawatts 3y agoSo… she’s correct in the industrial regime that matters, but technically incorrect in the experimental regime where the energy is not recovered?
- Retric 3y ago
- thekevan 3y agoI love watching Sabine. It's nice to be able to both get great science educational content from someone who isn't afraid to put their own personality in the mix as well. She also often refers back to where she was "wrong" about things in the past, mostly where she said one thing, further research came out and she updated her takes based on it.
- adontz 3y agoI think there should be different types of channels for different types of viewers. While I appreciate VSause and Veritasium, Kurzgesagt as about equally informative, Sabine's quality humor makes her content very special.
- agumonkey 3y agoI want to see a podcast co hosted by her and lawrence krauss.
- sinuhe69 3y agoThe text-only site is really a godsend!
- agumonkey 3y agogodsend indeed here's more: https://github.com/localjo/awesome-text-only-news https://github.com/localjo/awesome-text-only-news https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35313232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35313232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17787816 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17787816
- dredmorbius 3y agoFreshnews is still live as well: <https://freshnews.org/ https://freshnews.org/>
- mal-2 3y agoSabine seems to believe any intellectual darkweb-esque argument she hears as long as it makes her feel heterodox. Her coverage of autism, transgender issues and capitalism were embarrassing.
- hsavit1 3y agoI only saw some of the "capitalism is good, actually" video and was horrified at how ideological it was. It was Prager-U level propaganda. She seems to fall in line with a few popular physicists (like Neil Tyson) who display chauvinist tendencies in their knowledge of everything that is.
- pollux66 3y ago[flagged]
- nosefurhairdo 3y agoWhat specifically did you disagree with?
- kbelder 3y agoAll of those are prone to highly emotionally charged reactions. Whether she is right or wrong, there would have been strong reactions, and therefore (in a bayesian sense) the strong reactions give you no information about whether she's right or wrong.
- willis936 3y agoIt gives you information about what she's optimizing for, and it isn't solely truth communication.
- leckpo 3y agoIt sounds like she upset you by challenging views that you hold emotionally rather than rationally.
- 3y ago
- johnklos 3y agoI think it's interesting to hear how some people are upset with her non-physics videos and how that compares with how her videos are received by experts in those fields. Her videos are generally well received, whereas people complaining rarely have more to say than some form of "stay in your own lane". When people have a hard time coming up with complaints that are actually about the subject matter, you're probably doing a good job :) I like the quote in the article from Patricia Rankin: "[challenging] people's assumptions ... because that's really what science is all about." I have much more respect for someone who disagrees with me, with whom I can discuss differences reasonably, than with someone who agrees with me, but does so dogmatically. The latter is unfortunately more common than the former, and I think that's why Sabine holds a special place in my heart.
- varjag 3y agoI like Sabine's work but in the areas where I do have substantial context or expertise she is sometimes subtly off. It tends to happen in feature videos more than in her weekly science summaries. To her credit, she does tend to issue corrections when it's pointed out.
- vagab0nd 3y agoSame. I appreciate her "hard" science videos very much, but dislike and skip the rest. Usually I have no problem switching to entertainment mode on YouTube, but her authoritative tone puts me off enough to not watch them.
- tobiasSoftware 3y agoI have substantial layman's expertise in quantum physics and while she correctly points out many mistakes that are even in textbooks, she also follows the very niche Superdeterimistic viewpoint and then presents hypotheses that follow from that viewpoint (Hidden Variables and Einstein's gloves) as if they are facts. For a science educator, this is a massive problem, and so she's become my least popular quantum physics educator even though she explains many quantum physics concepts very well.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoCan we un-click-bait this by replacing "she" with "Sabine Hossenfelder"? Yes, the article itself uses the title as used but there is no reason to not clarify who this is about.
- dang 3y agoThe whole title is clickbaity, not just by lack of name, so I've replaced it with something boring and straightforward. (This is in the site guidelines: "Please use the original title, unless it is misleading or linkbait" - https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html)
- dredmorbius 3y agoThanks! The original submitted title (from NPR) was "She got famous on YouTube. Now it helps fund her research in quantum gravity". I'd pinged HN mods about this, though dang ended up dong a wholesale replacement rather than s/She/Sabine Hossenfelder/.
- eh_why_not 3y agoThank you! Straightforward. Wish all titles were written like this.
- eh_why_not 3y agoSuch an annoying trend of click-bait too, and it's all over news sites. "Click here to know who this _woman_ is who did something so great"... As if being a woman, to the author and their target readers, supersedes in importance what the person actually achieved or had to say.
- GenerocUsername 3y agoThese comments are so full of people who think she is wrong because they have different opinions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- runarberg 3y agoThose are not mutually exclusive. And in fact they most often coincide. If many people are of different opinion, it may be because OP is simply wrong.
- Pat_Murph 3y agoShe's taken a weird and disturbing turn lately. She did a few videos about transgender and other lgbtq related topics. And well she had some seriously disappointing and eronious views on the subject. And was mostly regurgitatimg anti trans, terf talking points. It's sad and disappointing thatnshe has started using her credibility in one field to make propogandaish videos on other subject she either ignores or is lying to profit off the terf grift. It takes away from her well earned credibility in her field of expertise.
- sapiogram 3y ago> And well she had some seriously disappointing and eronious views on the subject. You have to get specific if you want to convince anyone.
- s1gnp0st 3y agoTERF is a slur, albeit one that's probably welcome on HN.
- jeh_noll 3y agoWhich is unfortunate, as those who would be most accurately described by that label, if it was taken literally and not used as a slur, actually have a sensible and thoughtful middle ground between the two extremes who are currently battling it out in the political arena.
- resoluteteeth 3y ago> Which is unfortunate, as those who would be most accurately described by that label, if it was taken literally and not used as a slur, actually have a sensible and thoughtful middle ground between the two extremes who are currently battling it out in the political arena. Perhaps not as many people self-identify as "TERFs" now that the term is widely viewed negatively, but as of a few years ago there were several subreddits on reddit where people identified themselves as TERFs (I'm not sure whether these subreddits still exist). However, the prevailing view on these subreddits was that all men are inherently poisoned by testosterone and dangerous. For this reason, I'm not sure it's actually a "thoughtful middle ground" as much as you might think.
- woopsn 3y agoI like Sabine and overall enjoyed her book Lost in Math, but I feel like her particular style of "snark" (mockery) is unproductive and kind of cheap. It makes some sense on YouTube, but not as much when she's interviewing colleagues for print. One of her recurring points is that physicists get to sort of make stuff up for their own gain now, because the public (and grant institutions, politicians etc) have become very interested in the field while being mostly illiterate in it. But she does this as well. Lay people aren't fit to judge whether eg the sampling algorithms used at the LHC detector are laughably stupid, nor compact dimensions of space, inflation, etc.
- the-alchemist 3y agoNo one's perfect, but I'm a fan because she'll tell you if something is her-possibly-unpopular opinion (see particle physics), well-accepted scientific fact, or her pet opinion. You know where she stands, and tells you her agenda, if any. Or, if she's trying really hard to stay away from _any_ bias (see her video on trans). More generally, I don't like the "stay in your lane" opinion. To more forward as a society, we need _more_ interdisciplinary work, not less. Mathematicians need to work with engineers and architects, psychologists with economicists, etc. Of course, let's call out bad science or bias, but let's not ignore valuable insights because they came from the wrong lane. I like her videos because I'm generally curious what a fairly unbiased intelligent person thinks about trans issues, economics, etc. Even if I don't agree with them on everything, not should you.
- MrJohz 3y agoFwiw, the only video of hers that I remember watching is the economics one because of the discussion it sparked, but I didn't get the impression there that she was communicating her ignorance or bias well at all. Rather, she made a bunch of dubious claims with all the appearance of authority and knowledge. She also doesn't seem particularly unbiased to me. Like, I don't think one can ever be unbiased, but someone with a lot of knowledge about a subject can do a good job of identifying the biases they have in that area and try and approach things more objectively, or at least indicate where they're speaking for themselves and where they're describing beliefs in the field. For example, I'm a frontend developer with a bunch of biases for certain technologies and styles of development, because those are the ones I'm used to and invested in. But I know the field well enough to - I hope - be able to recognise those biases and tell you that you don't need SolidJS for your next project, even though I think it's really cool and want more people to get involved there. Rather, Hossenfelder feels like she just doesn't know what her biases are in the first place, at least when discussing something like economics. Based on your comment, I'm sure that's not true for the subjects that she is knowledgeable in - you bring up particle physics as an example of an area where she knows her opinions aren't necessarily standard. But in the video I watched, she presented herself as this neutral figure telling you only the facts, and then said things that ranged from being out-of-date or untrue, to things that didn't even really make much sense. I agree with you that "stay in your lane" is a bad counter to these sorts of videos, because collaboration between fields is good. But good collaboration takes a lot of humility - you need to come to the table knowing that you know almost nothing about the other field, and accepting that you're going to have to learn a lot of stuff. At least from the stuff I've watched, I don't get the impression that Hossenfelder has put the work in to understand what she doesn't understand. And that, to me, is pretty much the definition of wilful ignorance - she knows she is not an expert in this field, but she doesn't seem to want to put the effort in to get the opinions and feedback from real experts. Instead, she's assumed her own knowledge is enough.
- eh_why_not 3y agoContrary to many of the opinions in these comments, I actually appreciate Sabine's videos that are not in her area of expertise. Not because I think they're accurate, or fully informed, or anything like that. But because usually they're a decent attempt at grokking important information from another field, which is a challenge we face nowadays in this sea of conflicting information about everything. When she gets something wrong, it's another indicator of how even a trained scientist can still make mistakes in these interpretations, and so brings me to a more realistic expectation of what myself, or any other person, could do on their own. Her latest video on how to do your own research puts this challenge in perspective.
- DrNosferatu 3y agoFor someone who's brought clarity to complex physics topics, Sabine Hossenfelder's “Capitalism is good” video jumps the shark. It feels like a slow-motion crash (course) into the Dunning-Kruger effect. With simplistic, naive interpretations and moralistic undertones, it propagates myths that many experts have spent years trying to debunk from the public space - some of them Nobel laureates, and, multiple times requiring the use of the expression "Zombie Ideas" in the book’s title.