8 ms·
If you want to do this, you should put a gear box between the engine and generator. Sure your car engine can run at 3600 rpm (I've seen exceptions, but they ar
by bluGill 3y ago
If you want to do this, you should put a gear box between the engine and generator. Sure your car engine can run at 3600 rpm (I've seen exceptions, but they are rare), but typically it is most fuel efficient when run at closer to 2000 rpm at high load. At lower loads lower RPM is more efficient (but not as efficient as high load at 2000 rpm) - but your car probably doesn't have a large enough cooling system to handle high loads for very long, so perhaps run the engine at 1800 rpm and use a 1:2 gear box to get the right rpm for the generator, which makes design simple and is "close enough" to ideal without needing to see the exact efficient/power/rpm curves of your particular engine (a 3d graph).
- lloeki 3y agoCar gearboxes are a spectacular cause of power loss (in the order of 20% IIRC), so probably better to come up with a simple gear reduction or a belt-driven pulley system.
- dylan604 3y agoThey didn't say use the car's transmission. The suggestion of a 2:1 gear reduction could easily be a simple gear reduction or a belt-driven pulley. You've tried to inject something on your own accord for possibly a misunderstanding??
- cduzz 3y agoYeah, they didn't mention many specifics; I also imagine that they're just pulling the power off the engine using the accessory belt connected to their existing alternator -> inverter setup. Similarly -- the concerns about how to cool the device if it s putting down 100hp -- that's 74570 watts; it's unlikely they're using a harbor freight generator's alternator to generate that kind of power.
- lloeki 3y agoI read "gearbox" as, well, an automotive gearbox, which would hardly be surprising in the context of the article. 2:1 could easily mean crank the gearbox into a gear that approximately produces that ratio. > You've tried to inject something on your own accord for possibly a misunderstanding?? WTH is that supposed to mean? If I misunderstood anything it was a honest mistake. GP suggested a RPM reduction for fuel efficiency reasons, it would be counterproductive to offset that efficiency gain with a high-loss mechanical device. There was neither ill intent nor hidden agenda.
- polishdude20 3y agoWhat about them makes them so inefficient?
- bluGill 3y agoIf the torque converter doesn't have a lock that is a big loss. Those same transmissions also tend to have low efficiency hydraulic pumps internally to select the gears. Modern automatic transmissions tend to be much better than older ones.
- lloeki 3y ago> Modern automatic transmissions tend to be much better than older ones. I seem to recall improvements in that area around 2015 (probably driven by emissions regulations) but don't know the implementation details. One change was also a marked increase in available ratios (7, up to 10) which combined with better logic drives mpg down overall, sometimes lower than stick or dual clutch on standardised tests.
- lloeki 3y agoAutomotive gearboxes prime goal is to: a) expand the workable range of the IC engine (1000-5000rpm for Diesel, 1000-9000 - at best - for NA petrol, turbocharging dials it down) b) solve the zero-to-low rpm problem that causes stalling due to nonexistent torque It results in a complex device where many parts are still spinning even on the non-engaged gear. Look at a cut out of a manual transmission. The irony is that an epicyclic automatic transmission is mechanically efficient, up to the torque converter which uses fluid coupling. Efficiency is a secondary goal to the ones above, without which the car would be useless.
- bluGill 3y agoSome car gearboxes are that bad. However others are much lower. Are we talking about a "slushbox" automatic without a locking torque converter, or an all gear manual transmission - there is a big difference. I didn't specify what type of gear box because there are many different options. Belts of the front pulleys would work. You could rig up a chain drive system as well. there are pros and cons to each.
- lloeki 3y ago> Are we talking about a "slushbox" automatic without a locking torque converter, or an all gear manual transmission - there is a big difference. Correct. IIRC again (numbers from 2010ish, probably there were some improvements since but I bet physics limit those) the best stick were 15%-20%; slushboxes were 25%-30%. Such loss is justified by making the car able to operate on a much wider range, from standstill to highway speeds, and solve the ~zero torque at <1000rpm problem. IOW without a gearbox the car is useless. Without that requirement a simple reduction would be much more efficient. One of the huge benefits of going electric is that - in addition of having stellar electric to mechanical energy conversion efficiency (90-95%, vs a very lousy number I can't recall for chemical to mechanic energy) - the engine can basically be put on direct drive because torque is immediately available starting at 0rpm and all the way to max rpm, so no additional loss. > I didn't specify what type of gear box because there are many different options. Belts of the front pulleys would work. You could rig up a chain drive system as well. there are pros and cons to each. Totally fair! I didn't want to sound dismissing, only complementary.
- ehaliewicz2 3y agoI'm curious what the loss for a typical constant-mesh manual gearbox would be. I assumed 90% or more efficiency.
- tantalor 3y ago> cooling system Didn't watch the video yet, but under normal conditions the car is flying down the freeway so (I'm assuming) gets some cooling effect from that flow of air. But that's not happening in this case. Might be a problem.
- bombcar 3y agoMost cars are cooled by a fan these days, and many use an electric fan that can vary speed to keep the engine cool. Best efficiency would be to use the fact you’re not moving to have more radiator surface area available but it’s probably not worth it.
- yetihehe 3y agoThe fan in cars is typically not enough to keep it cool while stationary under load, but in typical home applications you won't have that big load anyway. Big load for a car is >10kW. You can also pretty cheaply get a bigger external fan, like those used on dynamometers. One nice side effect of using car as generator - free heat in winter if you extend cooling loop to your home.
- dylan604 3y agoHow is a stationary car engine under load? Oh right, like my asshat neighbor that likes to sit in the driveway a 6AM revving his engine every. single. morning.
- cduzz 3y agoIf by "gearbox" you mean "Pulley" -- a setup such as this is probably most efficiently done by just putting a big (wide) pulley on the front crankshaft accessory belt and correct diameter pulley on the alternator, to get to whatever the target RPM of the alternator and whatever low RPM works under maximum load for the motor. Put the whole thing on a reinforce pallet and you're done. This whole setup almost certainly isn't going to be able to supply "north america normal household power demand" volumes of power reliably for months at a time, but almost certainly do whatever a cheapo generator was doing before that cheapo's sketchy 150cc motor crapped out.
- bluGill 3y agoBy gearbox I mean anything to change from one RPM to another. Chains, belts, or gears are the obvious options. They all have pros and cons, but any would work. There are other options as well, but they tend to be a lot less efficient which destroys the whole point.
- lostlogin 3y agoI’m very much not an engineer, but a below and pulley changing the ratio seems the most efficient.
- worik 3y ago> By gearbox I mean anything to change from one RPM to another I thought you meant the car's gearbox
- bluGill 3y agoUntil people replied I hadn't considered that. It would be an option, but I was thinking about a surplus gearbox which you can sometimes pickup with a fixed gear ratio.
- Aurornis 3y agoYou're right that the best Brake Specific Fuel Consumption (BSFC) occurs at higher loads. If anyone wants to see a map of this, search for "brake specific fuel consumption map". More modern engines might actually have their peaks closer to 3000RPM due to improved technology. The trend is toward smaller engines that rev higher, so peak efficiency is steadily shifting to the right. However, it probably doesn't matter due to the extreme mismatch between the engine's output and the generator's maximum power. The generator appears to be rated at 5500W, which is 7.4HP. Efficiency of electrical generators is high, so we'll call the load 8HP maximum. An Toyota Sienna engine has a peak power output around 200HP. For reference, a car air conditioning system might consume around 4HP, or half of this generator's load. The generator is barely more than running the air conditioning. So ideally, you'd pick a set of pulleys that let the engine basically idle. The goal is to minimize internal engine losses at this level, because you're nowhere near the peak efficiency islands on the BSFC map.
- foota 3y agoWow, I had no idea that a car engine produced more than a hundred kilowatts of power, that's ridiculous! (For comparison, an average household consumes something like tens of kilowatt hours per day, so driving for an hour (I guess at peak, which an engine wont always be) may be similar to 5 or 10 days of a household's power usage, and not to mention much less efficiently generated.
- infinityio 3y agopetrol is roughly 9.5kW/litre (~35kWh/US gallon) if that's a better reference for consumption (of which maybe 30% will make it to energy through a modern engine?)
- Negitivefrags 3y agoThe rediculoussness of the energy use of transport is especially noticeable when you are driving a Tesla which by default shows you a dial of power consumption and generation in kW. When rolling down a hill with regenerative breaking, the car is generating 50kW. You can literally power many average homes with that.