4 ms·
The amount of data is irrelevant. Data by itself isn't actionable. We don't have a proven theoretical framework that could be used to turn data into good decisi
by nradov 3y ago
The amount of data is irrelevant. Data by itself isn't actionable. We don't have a proven theoretical framework that could be used to turn data into good decisions in a command economy. Plus it is nearly impossible to command innovation; command economies have occasionally produced innovations by throwing enormous resources at particular problems, but for the most part they are stuck with copying innovations from free market economies.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y ago> it is nearly impossible to command innovation Excellent point.
- sandpaper26 3y agoThe US military's many labs, test sites, software foundries, federally funded research and development companies, and research institutes are laughing at this sentiment. Innovation is routinely commanded -- look at Skunkworks, JPL, heck even the USSR's space program.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoThe problem is that too much of the innovation in our system targets ways of becoming a new middleman in existing economic exchanges, because collecting 1% of "all X" is much more valuable than collecting 100% of "a few Y". The incentives to innovate in ways that actually benefit people are weak in our system, because the disincentives to innovate in ways that just make you a bit wealthier are small to non-existent.
- nradov 3y agoThat's not a real problem worth worrying about. Look outside the tech industry bubble. There is a huge amount of innovation happening in sectors beyond of finance and software, but they don't get much attention on HN. Of the IPOs this year, what percentage are just middlemen? https://stockanalysis.com/ipos/2023/ https://stockanalysis.com/ipos/2023/
- cryptonector 3y agoWe could have oodles of data and yet not have the data that matters to making distributed decisions, which is price signals. A modern digital command economy wouldn't have price signals, but even if it did it wouldn't make decisions like the individuals would precisely because the point of a command economy is to deny individuals freedom. And that is a reason that digital command economies wouldn't have price signals: there's little point when the point of the command economy is to ignore those price signals.
- sandpaper26 3y ago> the point of a command economy is to deny individuals freedom. This is an unsupported generalization. Command systems exist to mandate production and distribution of goods, e.g. to ensure sufficient food production and equitable food distribution. They eliminate the "overhead" of competition and the need for marketing. Look at any self-sufficient commune and tell me their internal economy has anything to do with imposing limits on freedom. Don't let your negative feelings toward certain historical examples cloud your understanding of the matter at hand.
- nradov 3y agoThere have never been any self-sufficient communes. They always depend on external inputs. Over the long run, command economies always collapse into famine. It's impossible to command most people to work hard over a long career without free market incentives.
- sandpaper26 3y agoOver time, all systems collapse eventually. That sentiment is worthless. Furthermore, nobody said anything about working hard. Surely you're not about to claim that all pre-colonial civilizations with functional governments either somehow had free market incentives or collapsed into famine. "There have never been X" is always an extraordinary claim and you've done a poor job making it.
- cryptonector 3y ago
- throwaway_75369 3y agoI mostly agree with this sentiment, but I think it goes too far. > command economies have occasionally produced innovations by throwing enormous resources at particular problems, but for the most part they are stuck with copying innovations from free market economies. Hmm. This seems unfair to the military during wartime? WW1 feels like a huge example.of advancement driven from very command-ey institutions; from the idea of the tank to deal with machine guns and barbed wire to nitrogen-ating fertilizer in Germany to withstand the British blockade. (Never mind DARPA and the internet or the moon missions during the Cold War, or the Manhattan Project) (Yeesh, not that I'm suggesting it would be preferable to pursue this as a full-time model - it's literally fascism, but it's important to understand why these systems were pursued in the first place - the point is that there do at least appear to be high profile success stories)