7 ms·
I see publications like this come out of CISA every so often, but they always follow a similar format: "security is a really big problem", "the industry is cons
by lolinder 3y ago
I see publications like this come out of CISA every so often, but they always follow a similar format: "security is a really big problem", "the industry is consistently failing to apply well-known solutions", "will you pretty please just get on top of this already?"
There is no regulatory body equivalent to the FTC or SEC or FDA for software, and it shows. Big software isn't magically more altruistic than big pharma or big agriculture or big finance. Given a choice between making huge amounts of money with very little overhead and raising overhead in order to protect consumers, they will consistently choose the former. It's high past time we have an agency with real teeth to regulate the software industry.
- CamperBob2 3y agoIt's high past time we have an agency with real teeth to regulate the software industry. As long as you understand who will pay for it: you. Along with the rest of us.
- halJordan 3y agoAnd you think that youre immune to the cost increases Clorox or Colonial Pipelines pass along so they can pay their literal ransoms?
- CamperBob2 3y agoCompared to paying $10,000 for a Windows license, yeah, I'm pretty much immune. You people literally do not know what you're asking for, and you don't understand what would happen if you received it. When you stand on the shoulders of giants, it's bad form to kick the ladder away.
- bioneuralnet 3y agoTrue, but we're already paying for not having it.
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoConsidering how bad the state of software is, it's pretty obvious that we should have started paying for it long ago.
- CamperBob2 3y agoMy software works just fine, thanks.
- deciduously 3y agoSo says every dev who introduces a memory safety bug.
- insanitybit 3y agoAs opposed to right now where our users pay for it.
- stouset 3y agoWe are already paying for it. This is the same argument against universal healthcare: “oh but look how much it will cost”. Yeah, it’s a lot. It’s also less than the price tag of the current system.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- belval 3y agoYou don't want government-mandated security specs for software projects, that would be an absolute nightmare with prescribed "sanctioned" languages and checklists applied with zero understanding of the underlying subject matter (the threat model of a video game is exceedingly different than one for a medical device). The real solution is to come up with a framework around data leaks and their disclosure with provisions for mitigations (à la GDPR, keep only the data you actually need). Anything else will end up boiling down to "Java is the best language for everything" because Oracle spend $N on lobbying.* *Replace Java/Oracle with another pair.
- jowea 3y agoBut some types of software like medical or airplane controls do have those types of regulations around them, don't they? How well do they work?
- tick_tock_tick 3y agoDon't planes need to be restarted every few flight or all the flight input data goes crazy? https://gizmodo.com/turn-it-off-and-on-again-every-149-hours-is-a-concernin-1836818094 https://gizmodo.com/turn-it-off-and-on-again-every-149-hours...
- stouset 3y agoIf anything, I hope we’ve learned that node uptimes are unimportant. It used to be a badge of honor to show some system hadn’t been rebooted in $years. Now that just implies that there’s unpatched vulnerabilities and countless hand-made configuration changes that nobody remembers and that will be lost if the machine dies. A sign of a responsible organization these days is how short-lived their hosts are. If every machine in an organization has an uptime less than a week, I feel pretty confident in that org’s ability to recover from a disaster. I also know it’s harder for attackers to keep a foothold once in the system, since everything is being constantly updated and reimaged.
- 3y ago
- ASalazarMX 3y agoEven highly regulated fields like medicine or aerospace have frequent instances of irresponsibility for profit. Only fines that wipe out the profits of operating irresponsibly will get through them. Conversely, we don't want to lose FOSS because single developers can't cope with the legal risks. Maybe there's opportunity for incentivizing cheap security certification of FOSS, or a CISA-approved subset of FOSS that is guaranteed to follow strict security practices.
- V__ 3y agoI dont't think this would be a problem for FOSS. If I release an unsafe or not code compliant kitchen/house/etc. blueprint (and don't make claims to the contrary) nothing would happen to me. If I sell them the situation might be different. I think the same would apply to FOSS.
- insanitybit 3y agoUnless code somehow stops being speech, I see no way that this could impact FOSS (in the US).
- ThrowawayR2 3y agoAll that that strategy would mean is that the costs of security auditing would fall onto the business using the FOSS code. It will start looking very attractive to instead buy code from an established software vendor who will provide some level of liability guarantees and assistance in auditing rather than going it alone with FOSS and in-house or external auditing.
- hiatus 3y agoThe costs of security auditing already fall onto the businesses using FOSS code, though. A business just blindly incorporating code without static analysis, vulnerability checks, etc is not exercising due care.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoSo basically, it would work like in every other industry? FOSS, for all the good it does, it also did break the economics of software. How much of the current problems with adtech, surveillance capitalism and VC funding stems from FOSS making it impossible to simply sell software components like products?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jahewson 3y agoIf the Boeing 737 MAX nicely demonstrates why this is an awful idea.
- thfuran 3y agoYou're saying you think defective planes/poorly trained pilots would be less common in the complete absence of rules regarding certification of pilots or airframes?
- mywittyname 3y agoIf anything, Boeing 737MAX demonstrates how effective regulations have been. I bet you'd have to look up another similar event, because they are so rare. People lost their shit over the 737MAX. Boeing lost a ton of money and credibility. It made everyone realize that strong regulations need to be maintained and how it's a bad idea to allow manufactures to review their own product. It's also likely to result in even more regulations and a executives at Boeing being criminally tried. Regulations are incredibly effective, but you can't go soft because they are working. Regulators have to be ever vigilant and politicians who push for softening of regulations need to be voted out of office. We are finally starting to see that conspiracies to skirt regulations constitute criminal behavior by senior company leadership, this is a good thing for the public.
- thfuran 3y ago>and politicians who push for softening of regulations need to be voted out of office. I'm not sure I really see a distinction between that and a hardline tough on crime position. Not all laws/regulations are good and even an ensemble of individually good rules could be problematic in aggregate. Though in the current political climate, I would tend to agree that those pushing for reducing regulation are mostly not doing so as part of a well-intentioned effort to reduce adverse effects of regulation for the public good.
- midoridensha 3y agoAs I've said countless times before here, the 737MAX software had nothing wrong with it. It performed exactly the way the specifications required.
- cerradokids 3y agoI recommend the reading of Atlas Shrugged to really understand why this is a bad idea.
- ActorNightly 3y ago“There are two novels that can change a bookish fourteen-year old’s life: The Lord of the Rings and Atlas Shrugged. One is a childish fantasy that often engenders a lifelong obsession with its unbelievable heroes, leading to an emotionally stunted, socially crippled adulthood, unable to deal with the real world. The other, of course, involves orcs"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw20230924 3y ago[flagged]
- barrysteve 3y agoOh come on. Computing was designed since day zero to be an completely open to all connections and possibilities. So now you want to regulate in security, for a device that was never meant to be secure in the first place?! This security business is a racket. If you wanted computers to be secure, you would have designed and sold ASICs from day one. You can't regulate software without also regulating the hardware. The UK locks down privacy laws and now you guys want to "secure and regulate software". The internet, no more. Offline is the only way to program, and keep software in-house.