6 ms·
That seems to make them 1/69th the size of Microsoft by revenue but 1/270 the size by profits. Notice that Red Hat's profits are about 1/10 of income but MS' pr
by joe_the_user 15y ago
That seems to make them 1/69th the size of Microsoft by revenue but 1/270 the size by profits. Notice that Red Hat's profits are about 1/10 of income but MS' profits are about 1/2 of income. Shows the incentive to get monopoly.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RedHat http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RedHat
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft
- carguy1983 15y agoI think what you mean is revenues. Profit and earnings and income are similar (but slightly different, depending on who you ask), but all 3 are on the other side of the fence from revenues.
- reitzensteinm 15y agoWell, it shows the incentive to run a product company. Even with a monopoly on consulting you're not going to have great profit margins. That said, it really pisses me off that you were down voted like you were. There seems to be a rash of that on HN now. You were contributing to the conversation and backing up your argument with numbers. Right or wrong, that doesn't deserve a drive by dismissal. The voting buttons mean "More or less of this content on HN", not "I agree or disagree". If you disagree, post a reply. You might teach the OP something, or might even learn that you're wrong, as I have plenty of times on HN. Edit: I've turned this into an Ask HN thread here, since I think it would be helpful to have a discussion about this: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3760275 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3760275
- avree 15y agoActually, pg has stated that the downvote arrows mean the latter. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171
- david927 15y agoPaul is wrong on this, though. We as the community should override that.
- rudiger 15y agoI downvoted you because I don't agree with you.
- rimantas 15y agoLet's be fair, people up-vote the stuff they like/agree with whether it contributes a lot or little. Symmetrical actions in UI should do symmetrical things, how hard is to grasp it? Something I like/agree—up-vote. Something I disagree—down-vote. If you want different behavior then remove down-vote button. There is "flag" if one thinks comment is inappropriate.
- nitrogen 15y agoFlagging a comment can get the entire account banned, so use that option with care. Also, there are more important things to consider than an OCD-fueled (yes, this affects me, too) obsession with UI symmetry, like overall discussion quality.
- rwmj 15y agoSlashdot got this (nearly) right. You select from a list of moderation options like "Interesting", "Informative", "Funny", "Off Topic" etc.
- flomo 15y agoInsightful - I agree, completely Informative - I agree, but you may be full of shit Interesting - I agree, stick it to those other guys Funny - I agree, either schadenfreude or grits Idealistically, humans would only vote based on content quality and not their personal opinions. But Slashdot is certainly the counter example on why this doesn't actually work
- 15y ago
- reitzensteinm 15y agoWell, thanks for not just downvoting me :) PG posted that comment five years ago; reflexive downvoting just wasn't a problem then like it is now[1], so I'd be interested in hearing if he's still got the same opinion - it wouldn't change mine, though. [1] It's easy to look at the past through rose colored glasses, but that's not what I'm doing in this case. I actually think most of HN has improved with its new size. Niche areas are more likely to have discussions between experts, there are more people like Grellas who write lengthy and insightful commentary, a significant number of startups get successfully launched on HN, and we still managed to do all that without making too many of the original core users leave. That said, get off my lawn. Edit: Now you're being downvoted. This is ridiculous.
- willvarfar 15y agoThis tangent is close to my heart - what we need is a filter bubble! http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/15581427232/self-organizing-reddit http://williamedwardscoder.tumblr.com/post/15581427232/self-...
- vacri 15y agoSilent disagreement should not stop someone from being heard.
- doktrin 15y agoMaintaining a civil discussion is one thing. Literally silencing and erasing opinions we do not agree with is completely different. Does anyone actually believes this is the approach we should be taking?
- kinleyd 15y agoI tend to agree that using a down vote to express disagreement eventually isn't constructive. I've seen a number of posts that didn't say anything objectionable or controversial, nor were meaningless in the context of the discussion, and yet were down modded. My theory is that while the risk of being down modded on HN is a helpful factor in keeping discussions more courteous than on an out-and-out anonymous forum, the same cannot be said of down votes, which are in fact anonymous. As a result, users tend to be more careless or perhaps even callous in the use of down votes. I'm not sure what the solution is though: making down votes transparent might help in creating a bit more discreetness in their use, but might spill things over into flame wars into the comments themselves when exercised. Still, I think it's the total anonymity that causes its over use.
- throwaway00 15y agoMore worrying is the fact that when downvoted too much, your account gets 'silently banned'. Also if you post anything critical of YC companies this tends to happen. Behind the scenes, many accounts are silently banned, and many comments are removed if they don't sit well with the powers that be. If you're pg and you disagree, you don't downvote, you just remove the comment you disagree with.
- recoiledsnake 15y agoMoney from selling Windows goes only to Microsoft, whereas Linux is widely used without paying a penny to Red Hat. Not to mention distros like CentOS which you RedHat without needing to buy it.
- davidw 15y agoAnd Redhat sells lots of software they don't pay a penny for either.
- emarcotte 15y agoReally? Developers are not exactly the cheapest resource on the planet, and while they don't code every piece of software they package... they still package it, they still give it at least some form of testing (e.g. will it install if it's on this image)... it's not expensive in some cases but it's not free either.
- davidw 15y agoYes, really. They contribute a lot back, and are good (model!) open source citizens, but they still distribute a great deal of code they haven't written.
- maratd 15y ago> but they still distribute a great deal of code they haven't written. Don't we all? If you include my stack as part of my software, then really I only write like 1% ... I didn't write the OS, the SQL server, the http daemon, and the billion other things I'm dependent on. That's just how software works.
- clarkevans 15y agoRedhat sells support services, among other things. They hire key people in key projects so that if something goes wrong for their clients, they can get it fixed expediently. When your production is on the line, you'll gladly pay for the piece of mind and the very real reduction in business risk.
- nextparadigms 15y agoMarket leaders have higher profits than the rest of the industry in general, because many factors allow them to do this. There's also sort of a rule that you can't have a higher price than the market leader because it offers higher value (gets a lot of benefits such as biggest 3rd party ecosystem, most known, most trusted, most experienced, etc), so the competitors have to price their products at a discount, and try to win customers on price, even when their product (in isolation) is "better" than that of the market leader. This leads to the market leader having the biggest profit.
- pavanky 15y agoMeh @ incentives. If I could make decent money doing what I love, working with like minded people and changing the world for the better, I would take even smaller odds / profit ratios. Add to that the open source projects they fund, the shares they gave away to the likes of Linus, you have a company with a much better conscious than Microsoft.
- 0xABADC0DA 15y agoIt makes them 69x the size of Microsoft in contributions to humanity and 270x the size of MS in dignity. I feel that Red Hat contributes more to OSS than all the big software companies combined, even including Apple.