4 ms·
> The Civil Aeronautics Board decided which airlines could fly what routes and how much they could charge In this era, it was commonplace to fly with only a fe
by WalterBright 3y ago
> The Civil Aeronautics Board decided which airlines could fly what routes and how much they could charge
In this era, it was commonplace to fly with only a few passengers aboard. Full flights were rare. Immediately after deregulation, the flights became routinely full.
I.e. the airlines became far more efficient and served the flying public much better.
- riscy 3y agothat could only happen because of service reductions along routes. that gives the public fewer options for when they fly and makes them less comfortable being crammed into planes with ever tinier seats. doesn’t sound like a benefit to me. the benefits to society is in terms of reduced fuel consumption, only because that’s directly aligned with the airline’s profits.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe benefit to customers was the planes were directed to where the customers were and flew to where they wanted to go. There was not a sudden decrease in aircraft flying. > the benefits to society is in terms of reduced fuel consumption, only because that’s directly aligned with the airline’s profits Companies don't burn fuel for fun. The fuel is about 40% of the cost of your ticket. Increased fuel efficiency is the major driver of new airline designs.
- autoexec 3y ago> The benefit to customers was the planes were directed to where the customers were and flew to where they wanted to go. FTA: "Worse still, without mandated service, cities and regions across the country have lost commercial air service" It sounds like planes stopped being directed to where customers were and no longer fly to where they wanted to go in many instances. This is not a win for the consumer.
- twoodfin 3y agoPlanes stopped being directed where Congressmen wanted them to fly.
- autoexec 3y agoCongressmen who are elected to represent the will of the people and serve in their interests. I'll take that over the airlines who serve only themselves and whose only motivation is to take as much money from the public as possible.
- vxNsr 3y agoRight, because famously, politicians are totally selfless and never do anything self-serving.
- autoexec 3y agoWhen are aren't doing their job to our liking, we have the ability to remove them and replace them. Try doing that with the CEO of an airline.
- hiatus 3y agoAn individual has about as much power in either case. How many congress people have been removed at your bidding?
- jefftk 3y agoAn individual has more power in the airline case: you can fly a different airline much more easily than you can move to a location with a different representative.
- boredpeter 3y agoNot at all, one individual won’t do anything against a business that large. And what if 1000s more people fly the airline and it becomes so wealthy it buys up all the other airlines? Corporations are authoritarian, tyrannical institutions where only the wealthy have any ability to make change. The US government may be immensely corrupt, owned by the rich, etc but at least it’s a democracy.
- Spooky23 3y agoThe downside of that development is that it created an unsustainable market. So you have an industry that periodically starts a fare war that requires federal bailouts.
- nradov 3y agoThere is no requirement for federal bailouts. Large airlines have at times been allowed to go bankrupt, and that's fine.
- Spooky23 3y agoThey've also been allowed to consolidate to the point that they are too big to fail.
- nradov 3y agoBankruptcy doesn't mean failure for large airlines. The shareholders get wiped out and bondholders take a haircut but the airplanes keep flying during the bankruptcy resolution so it's fine.
- missedthecue 3y agoWhy would an airline be too big to fail? They don't have counterparty risk like banks. The airline would go bankrupt, the shareholders would lose their investment, the bondholders would own the new corp, and perhaps the aircraft fleet would get a new livery.
- Spooky23 3y agoPolitical factors - even in these times, the obvious impact on pricing that the failure of Delta, American or United would bring isn’t tenable.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> an industry that periodically starts a fare war that requires federal bailouts American airline tickets contain a 7.5% excise tax, $5.60 per-trip September 11th fee and another excise tax of $4 per flight segment. (That's in addition to the usual sales, payroll and corporate taxes.) Taking just the former, I'm curious what the net give/take ratio is. Because it might be argued that we run our airlines as an indirect tax on high earners to fund the jobs program that is the TSA.
- LudwigNagasena 3y ago> the benefits to society is … only because that’s directly aligned with … profits. Yeah, that’s the magic of capitalism. You make society more efficient and get paid for that. You say that being crammed into planes isn’t a benefit. But the opportunity costs should be taken into account. Every resource not spent on airlines is a resource spent on something else.
- WalterBright 3y agoAirplanes crammed full of people are a lot more fuel efficient per passenger than one mostly empty.
- riscy 3y agothere is no magic to capitalism, only greed. when that aligns with your definition of efficiency it’s a coincidence. capitalism can also be very harmful and inefficient for society. companies draining aquifers and producing tons of disposable plastic bottles to sell people that water for profits is a net negative for modern society. that money should go towards improving our water infrastructure so no one feels that their water is unclean. so much plastic pollution is the result of capitalism too.
- nickpp 3y ago> here is no magic to capitalism, only greed It certainly was magical after the fall of communism in Eastern Europe to be able to visit capitalist countries and wonder at the shelves full of products and the countless affordable offers. Starving under communism on the other hand was not magical at all. We were told incessantly that we were making the world a better place, improving the society unlike the evil capitalism that was destroying everything - but we were starving. Funny enough the capitalist countries looked better and were less polluted too. Turns out rich societies tend to care more about the environment and invest accordingly too.
- riscy 3y agoi never implied communism is the answer. the world is not black and white.
- jabroni_salad 3y agoIt also happened because airlines were suddenly allowed to offer discounts to fill seats as the takeoff date approached. That practice did not exist during the pricefix era.