4 ms·
> Software is so slow compared to hardware. It's embarrassing that we haven't moved not even a hundredth of what hardware has the last 30 years I don’t underst
by Aurornis 3y ago
> Software is so slow compared to hardware. It's embarrassing that we haven't moved not even a hundredth of what hardware has the last 30 years
I don’t understand this mentality. What, exactly, did you expect to get faster? If you run the same software on older hardware it’s going to be much slower. We’re just doing more because we can now.
From my perspective, things are pretty darn fast on modern hardware compared to what I was dealing with 5-10 years ago.
I had embedded systems builds that would take hours and hours on my local machine years ago. Now they’re done in tens of minutes on my machine that uses a relatively cheap consumer CPU. I can clean build a complete kernel in a couple minutes.
In my text editor I can do a RegEx search across large projects and get results nearly instantly! Having NVMe SSDs and high core count consumer CPUs makes amazing things possible.
Software is improving, too. Have you seen how fast the new Bun package manager is? I can pick from dozens of open source database options for different jobs that easily enable high performance, large scale operations that would have been unthinkable or required expensive enterprise software a decade ago (even with today’s hardware).
> Why get this?
If you really think nothing has improved, you might be experiencing a sort of hedonic adaptation: Every advancement gets internalized as the new baseline and you quickly forget how slow things were previously.
I remember the same thing happened when SSDs came out: They made an amazing improvement in desktop responsiveness over mechanical HDDs, but many people almost immediately forgot how slow HDDs were. It’s only when you go back and use a slow HDD-based desktop that you realize just how slow things were in the past.
- Almondsetat 3y agowhy is opening word or excel or powerpoint not instantaneous? plenty of people, me included, have to sieve through vast amounts of document and constantly open/close them
- mejutoco 3y agoMaybe they are waiting to make them right before making them fast? /s (Make it work, make it right, make it fast)
- JohnBooty 3y agoApplication "bloat" is one obvious thing, but operating systems are also doing a lot more "work" to open an app these days -- address space randomization, checking file integrity, checking for developer signing certs, mitigations against hardware side channel attacks like rowhammer or whatever, etc. Those things aren't free. But, I don't know the relative performance hit there compared to good old software bloat.
- soulbadguy 3y ago> address space randomization, checking file integrity, checking for developer signing certs, mitigations against hardware side channel attacks like rowhammer or whatever, etc. OS/Application have been slower way before any of those were a thing.
- rwmj 3y agoAnd yet, just a few minutes ago (the time it took to reboot my laptop), I clicked open the "Insert" menu in a Google doc and the machine hung. Even a 128k Macintosh with a 68000 CPU could handle that.
- sp332 3y agoClarisWorks would regularly hang my Mac Classic II. And with cooperative multitasking, I had to reboot the machine.
- josephg 3y ago> We’re just doing more because we can now. Are we though? Our computers are orders of magnitude faster than they were. What new features justify consuming 100x or more CPU, RAM, network and disk space? Is my email software doing orders of magnitude more work to render an email compared to the 90s? Does discord have that many more features compared to mIRC that it makes sense for it to take several seconds to open on my 8 core M1 laptop? For reference, mIRC was a 2mb binary and I swear it opened faster on my pentium 2 than discord takes to open on my 2023 laptop. By the standards of 1995 we all walk around with supercomputers in our pockets. But you wouldn't know it, because the best hardware in the world still can't keep pace with badly written software. As the old line from the 1990s goes, "what Andy giveth, Bill taketh away."[1] (Andy Grove was CEO at the time of Intel.) My instinct is that as more and more engineers work "up the stack" we're collectively forgetting how to write efficient code. Or just not bothering. Why optimize your react web app when everyone will have new phones in a few years with more RAM? If the users complain, blame them for having old hardware. I find this process deeply disrespectful to our users. Our users pay thousands of dollars for good computer hardware because they want their computer to run fast and well. But all of that capacity is instead chewed through by developers the world over trying to save a buck during development time. Every hardware upgrade our users make just becomes the new baseline for how lazy we can be. Slow CI/CD pipelines are a completely artificial problem. There's absolutely no technical reason that they need to run so slowly. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_and_Bill%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andy_and_Bill%27s_law