10 ms·
> Broomfield said: “It seems clear the Schengen ban and my harassment by the UK police are driven by direct or indirect pressure from Turkey, on the basis of my
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Broomfield said: “It seems clear the Schengen ban and my harassment by the UK police are driven by direct or indirect pressure from Turkey, on the basis of my work and reporting in Rojava and around the Kurdish issue.”
This sort of crap is nothing new unfortunately. Erdogan's Turkey has been abusing international cooperation agreements at scale [1], not to mention holding up Sweden's entry to NATO, purely to fight against legitimate domestic resistance against his quasi-dictatorship/sultanate/caliphate (depending on whom you ask, but Turkey is certainly no democracy anymore). And that repression includes journalists such as Deniz Yücel [2], even foreign TV shows [3] and comedians [4] - everyone who criticises Erdogan or recognizes the Armenian genocide becomes a target.
And where legal avenues fail, there is always the Grey Wolves, nominally a terrorist group, and closely linked to the Turkish government, to do Erdogan's bidding [5].
As for why no one does anything to hold Erdogan accountable... the answer to that is simple, he threatens to unleash refugees like he did in the past [6], and Turkey's cooperation regarding the Bosporus is vital in the Ukraine war.
[1] https://www.justsecurity.org/87260/after-spotlight-on-red-notices-turkey-is-abusing-another-interpol-mechanism/ https://www.justsecurity.org/87260/after-spotlight-on-red-no...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deniz_Y%C3%BCcel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deniz_Y%C3%BCcel
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erdowie,_Erdowo,_Erdogan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Erdowie,_Erdowo,_Erdogan
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%B6hmermann_affair https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/B%C3%B6hmermann_affair
[5] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey_Wolves_(organization) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grey_Wolves_(organization)
[6] https://www.dw.com/en/eu-strongly-rejects-turkeys-use-of-migrants-at-border/a-52640976 https://www.dw.com/en/eu-strongly-rejects-turkeys-use-of-mig...
- orochimaaru 3y agoWhy complain if you need him? Not being snarky - but when it comes to things like these either you need some entity or you don’t. Sometimes they are needed bad enough that we excuse horrible behavior (US black sites, Saudi’s and Yemen, etc.). I think if you look you can put forth a rather long list. Point is unless you have the power to remove turkey from nato the complaining is pointless.
- f6v 3y agoWe’re allowed to dislike hypocrisy, aren’t we?
- orochimaaru 3y agoI didn’t mean the “you” as in personally but rather the states that represent you. As an example - Sweden and NATO. If the Turks weren’t needed I’m sure NATO members could have come up with a method to remove them. Otherwise, Erdogan is going to press his advantage. From his perspective Kurds are terrorists. The reality is more complicated - but its what everyone is going to hold their nose and live with.
- nradov 3y agoInstead of being "sure" you should actually read the treaty. NATO members can withdraw, but there is no mechanism for other members to remove Turkey. And due to their geographic position they are absolutely still needed: removing Turkey would play into Putin's hands and could lead to catastrophic geopolitical consequences far worse than putting up Erdogan.
- Y_Y 3y agoIf Sweden is willing to host the missile sites that are currently in Turkey then it might be an interesting proposition, seeing as they have a similarly strategic location.
- nradov 3y agoWhat missile sites? There are no strategic missiles in Turkey. The USAF does store some other nuclear weapons there. Sweden is not really an equivalent replacement option. Do you want Turkey to turn into a Russian ally? Because driving Turkey out of NATO is how you turn Turkey into a Russian ally.
- aaronheid 3y ago[dead]
- throwxx2 3y ago[flagged]
- hef19898 3y agoPoint one, while true, has nothing to do with point two, which is not true.
- hef19898 3y agoThe West is way to cooperative with regimes like Erdogan, Modi, the UAE or Qatar. To name a few. But what do you expect from a government, Germany which just so happens to be mine, that sees no problem in letting others do the dirty work of repulsing migrants in the Mediterranean, to their death sometimes, not intervening when the US intern German citizens in Guantanamo for years. Most of it out of fear of the far right since the refugee crisis in Europe. With great success regarding the containment of the far right, they poll quite often on second place now. Oh, I forgot, while our police isn't holding journalists, or people threatening and harassing others for that matter, they happily use similar powers to lock up climate activists for a couple of days without trial. Rant over. If Western democracies don't start to stand up for our proclaimmed values, we will loose what little soft power we have left.
- mschuster91 3y agoFully agree with you. (I'm German as well, in case that matters)
- hef19898 3y agoWe have elections on state level coming up. Hard choice, because for once a single vote really matters (before every government was more or less the same, now there is the risk of having the AfD sitting there). And those voters are voting! So, two choices, vote on principle and hopefully strengthen the oposition enough to count, or vote for the conservative government hoping to make thek strong enough to not need the far right. Well, it actually isn't that hard a choice, but still.
- pjmlp 3y agoAs first generation out of portuguese dictatorship in the 70's, living through the whole west/east split, and spending half of my life in Germany, it isn't fun seeing that happening. Similar increase is happening in Portugal, Chega party being one of them. It is as if the younger generations have no clue what they are voting for. When they discoverer, it will be too late.
- bemusedthrow75 3y agoIt's not so long ago that a gang of Turkish government thugs beat the crap out of protesters on US soil and pretty much nothing of consequence came of it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clashes_at_the_Turkish_Ambassador%27s_Residence_in_Washington,_D.C.#U.S._Congressional_action https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clashes_at_the_Turkish_Ambassa... I think our (British) border staff capitulating to these abusive international policing requests is pretty humiliating. But as you say, it's not new to anyone that this is happening.
- skippyboxedhero 3y agoWe have to capitulate because the British policing system is forced to cooperate through international agreements (this isn't often reciprocated, these agreements hand massive power to undemocratic countries because we have to comply and they comply when they feel like it). Turkish judges are actually part of our legal system, we are told that this is an essential part of our legal system respecting the rule of law...people want to have it all and every way (the UK is a horrible police state...but we have to accept the primacy of Turkish judges in our laws...you cannot have it both ways).
- lessname 3y agoI would like to add, Turkeys concerns about the NATO entry of Sweden were not without cause: Sweden has introduced an arms embargo against Turkey, prohibiting arms exports to Turkey. NATO is a military alliance and in case one member gets attacked, others have to support this member. However, one cannot really be sure if that will happen when one country has been initiating arms embargos against another member.
- tpmx 3y agoThat was lifted a year ago. https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/sweden-resumes-arms-exports-turkey-after-nato-membership-bid-2022-09-30/ https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/sweden-resumes-arms-exp...
- saiya-jin 3y agoWasnt it to get US F35s?
- xorcist 3y agoThat's a complicated story. Turkey bought the Russian S-400 system instead of NATO weapons, partly because they have economic incentives to be on good foot with Russia, partly because want to be ambivalent enough towards the West to have take advantage of credible threats in upcoming negotiations, partly because of domestic policy reasons. As was expected, they pretty much immediately found themselves under US weapons embargo. Modern weaponry form integrated systems, and integrating a Russian system in a NATO system is pretty much out of the question for various practical reasons. The Swedish embargo however was different. Swedish law simply forbids export to countries that use force against civilians. There are plenty of well supported evidence of this taking places, not only in Syria. But all this have to be taken into context to understand the Turkish situation. Perhaps unfortunately, depending on your perspective, the Swedish embargo was lifted when the NATO negotiations started. That is Realpolitik for you. Nobody wants to risk a Turkey allied with the Eastern block. And Turkey knows perfectly well to take advantage of that. Thus far it seems to be working for Erdogan. The deal maker image gains popularity, which is sorely needed with Turkish economy being what it is. The open question is how far he can push it.
- Cenk 3y agoIt doesn’t seem THAT clear, given that they asked him about his reporting on the British government and did not ask him about Turkey?
- wsc981 3y agoIt’s been said that the Turkish government has videos of a former secretary if justice of The Netherlands (Joris Demmink) engaging in sexual acts with young boys in Turkey and that Turkey has used this at times as leverage against the Dutch government. In return the Dutch government is supposed to have jailed a Kurdish leader Baybasin (under a pretense of him smuggling drugs) perhaps to get some leverage over Turkey in return (eg threaten to release him from captivity if anything on Joris Demmink is ever released into the public). Of course this is all hearsay, but the whole situation around the captivity of Baybasin in The Netherlands sure is fishy. And Joris Demmink also had some weird relationships in the past (I believe once with an eastern European pornographic actor) and was known to pick up men for sex at certain places.
- Gabriel54 3y agoI find it incredible that when a British "freelance" journalist goes to Syria (!) and upon return gets questioned about their work there, the default reaction is to... blame Turkey?
- ImPostingOnHN 3y agoit seems like the ones responsible for the wrongdoing are the ones being blamed, what makes you find that so incredible?
- aaronheid 3y ago[dead]
- illumin8 3y agoI don't understand why the west, including us in the US, even put up with Erdogan's regime at all. I remember when Erdogan's personal bodyguards decided to start attacking peacefully protesting US residents in Washington DC in open street violence. They didn't even get arrested (diplomatic immunity I suppose) for assaulting US residents and citizens protesting against his brutal non-democratically elected regime. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LraNlv__AU4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LraNlv__AU4 It infuriates me that this injustice was allowed to stand. Are we just going to let brutal dictators visit the US and cause open violence on our streets against peaceful demonstrators exercising their 1st amendment rights?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 3y ago> even put up with Erdogan's regime at all. Because like it or not they play a critical card in NATO strategy against Russia.
- asdff 3y agoProbably against china or any threat as well. Turkey houses nuclear weaponry. I'd imagine its globally reaching vs only being in range of Russia, as having some redundancy between launch sites is probably good for your side of world war three.
- illumin8 3y agoGood point. I think NATO will realize eventually he's more allied with Putin than he is with the west.