9 ms·
Schneier removed from TSA oversight meeting at TSA request
- wpietri 15y agoThe committee membership is here: http://oversight.house.gov/committee-members/ http://oversight.house.gov/committee-members/ That's over 20 different states represented there, so odds are good you can contact one of the members and be listened to. Let 'em know this is bullshit, and that if we're going to spend money on security, it shouldn't be on theater.
- kungfooey 15y agoThanks for the link. I just emailed my representative on the committee.
- donw 15y agoSend a physical letter -- it has far more impact, especially if handwritten.
- jlev 15y agoJust emailed reps Welch and Guinta requesting that they read his testimony into the record. All the other witnesses are from the TSA, Coast Guard or DHS; one independent security expert should be allowed to balance out four security-industrial complex shills.
- vgnet 15y agoI couldn't find a peep about the meeting in TSA's blog. I find it ludicrous that they can boot a top tier expert without enough time to replace him by anyone that could bring similar points to the discussion.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoI think you're confused. Their blog is not an information-dissemination service, it is a marketing instrument.
- dangrossman 15y agoYou would've gotten the same message across without also insulting vgnet by omitting that first sentence.
- mattdeboard 15y agoWhat? People get confused. I get confused. You get confused (as evidenced by this post). Everybody gets confused, just like everybody poops.
- dangrossman 15y agoNobody's actually confused. He did not literally mean to say anyone was confused. He's essentially saying "you were naive to think this blog was more than a marketing channel".
- pavel_lishin 15y agoKwanEsq explained exactly what I intended with my introduction.
- KwanEsq 15y agoHe's not actually insulting him. The first sentence is ironic, because vgnet isn't actually confused, he just has reasonable expectations. It actually serves to further insult the TSA, and is a fairly common phrasing in these sort of comments (at least in physical conversation, perhaps it's less advisable through the medium of the web).
- gojomo 15y agoWe need the ability to upvote and downvote specific sentences!
- pavel_lishin 15y agoEvery comment ought to be a file in a git repo, so that we can send pull requests.
- joshz 15y agoI guess if anybody is to confirm that it's in fact a circus, it'll be the TSA themselves. It would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
- cliveholloway 15y agoWhen I heard Schneier had been invited I actually thought the government was going to take this seriously. Obviously this is now going to be just another whitewash. sigh
- jerrya 15y agoWhat is the point of an oversight hearing if you refuse to let your top critics testify?
- cheald 15y agoTheater, of course.
- jergason 15y agoSent Jason Chaffetz (my representative) the following email: Disgusted With The TSA I was looking forward to seeing the TSA respond to Bruce Schneier's criticisms in the Oversight Committee meeting today. He is one of the world's experts on security. The news that he was dismissed from the committee makes me think the TSA is much less interested in actual security than in their own appearance, which fits the definition of security theatre very well. Please hold the TSA accountable for their gross misuse of power. Please make them answer to actual security experts on their policies. Thank you very much.
- davidw 15y agoPhone calls and real mail are supposedly more effective.
- DanielBMarkham 15y agoThere used to be an old, old joke on slashdot. Whatever the topic, somebody would say "I, for one welcome our new X overlords" I, for one, welcome our new security overlords. For some reason, it doesn't sound as funny anymore. There was a story recently about how all sorts of various agencies now want their own drones to watch the citizenry as we go about our normal lives. I'll never forget an interview the reporter had with a Congressman. His basic stance was something along the lines of "Boys will be boys. This is just all sorts of other agencies wanting to get in on the UAV bandwagon." My point is this: I don't think our elected representatives take any of this very seriously at all, no matter what they might say during an election or on TV. I don't think it bothers them for one second that the TSA gets to pick it's own witnesses for each day, or that gradually we're turning into a security state. I just don't think it really registers on their radar.
- raganwald 15y agohttp://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-for-one-welcome-our-new-x-overlords http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-for-one-welcome-our-new-x-ov...
- fabricode 15y agoI thought the overlord joke was from the Simpson's, but it turns out that they got the idea from 70's high camp: http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-for-one-welcome-our-new-x-overlords http://knowyourmeme.com/memes/i-for-one-welcome-our-new-x-ov... More on topic: I believe that one of the main reasons why they don't take it seriously is because they are literally above the law here. They don't have to go through the same process that ordinary travelers do. I can't find an authoritative source, so either all of Congress or only those senior members traveling with a security detail are exempt, but either way, those in charge don't understand the full impact it has on ordinary people's lives.
- alain94040 15y agoNot true. Here's one famous case: Senator Kennedy was on the no-fly-list for a while, so security theater applies to congress members as well as you. (http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17073-2004Aug19.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/articles/A17073-2004Aug...)
- cheez 15y agoDuh.
- sedev 15y agoI probably shouldn't be disappointed, by now, that the TSA continue to live up to the reputation that they have around here. The agency is pretty much a pure creature of cognitive bias at this point - of sunk cost fallacies, of the desperate impulse to cover one's own ass, of irrational fears and irrational responses. I flew over the weekend. I reached a bit of a breaking point about taking the TSA seriously when I heard one of the screeners refer to a contraband item (a bottle of water) in luggage as a "party foul." Everyone but the higher-ups knows that it's an absolute farce and a waste of money. It's a great example of why the tops of hierarchies should _not_ be insulated from the consequences of their decisions - rather, the opposite.
- tptacek 15y agoWhy is Schneier presumed to be the most effective critic of the TSA? The body scanner program in particular has been roundly criticized by civil libertarians (both conservative and liberal), has generated credible concerns from professional scientists as to health risks, and has been repeatedly demonstrated by physical security experts to be ineffective. Schneier is an effective writer, particular when his audience comes with built-in respect for his accomplishments, but his broad disdain for virtually all of airport security† probably reduces his effectiveness in making a case to the wider public. He's easy to caricature, and traffics professionally in an image of "security muckraking" that suggests he'd oppose the TSA no matter what it does. † A disdain I share, mind you.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoBecause Schneier in particular has shown numerous weaknesses in airport security systems. And what you've described as "disdain" amounts to treating airport security like any other kind of security system, evaluating it critically, and correctly realizing that it has almost zero value, a huge cost (in both money and time), and a huge impact on civil liberties. In other words, he has very effective criticisms, which makes him unsuitable for hearings designed to publically demonstrate a lack of effective criticisms.
- tptacek 15y agoThis comment basically presumes that I disagree with Schneier and that the way to rebut my point is to re-argue what Schneier has argued. But I agree with Schneier, as do I think most people --- particularly security-minded people --- who pay attention to the TSA. My point is that Schneier has a lot of credibility with nerds and a lot of credibility with Jeffrey Goldberg but perhaps not as much credibility elsewhere as, say, an FBI agent who also disdains the TSA.
- JoshTriplett 15y agoNot trying to rebut your point, just answer the question you posed. I don't think anyone has assumed that Schneier represents the most effective critic, just someone with reasoned and thoroughly correct arguments, and background in a relevant field. I agree that Schneier's voice may not carry the most weight, but that just suggests the need for more voices.
- Bud 15y agoI found it quite illuminating to peruse the list of the shills^H^H^H^H^H^Hwitnesses who are going to be allowed to testify: Christopher L. McLaughlin, Transportation Security Administration, Assistant Administrator for Security Operations Stephen Sadler, Transportation Security Administration, Assistant Administrator for Intelligence and Analysis Rear Admiral Paul F. Zukunft, U.S. Coast Guard, Assistant Commandant for Marine Safety, Security & Stewardship Stephen M. Lord, U.S. Government Accountability Office, Director, Homeland Security
- jjcm 15y ago(meta comment - downvote so it doesn't appear in the discussion) Kill the name calling. We all agree on the ethical standing of these peeps. No need to state it, let's keep HN authoritative and professional. Great list of the witnesses though - really eye opening as to who they allow in.
- philwelch 15y agoQuick clarification: Stephen Lord doesn't work for DHS, he works for GAO, which is an agency established by Congress to maintain, as the title says, "government accountability". His jurisdiction is over DHS. This isn't to say he's a good guy, since GAO is mostly bean counters, but there it is.
- jimmar 15y agoWhen the GAO issues a report saying that your department is ineffective, people listen. They may be bean counters, but they are fairly well respected bean counters. The reports that I have read really help identify problems in government entities.
- WiseWeasel 15y agoSo I guess they answered the question in the title of the hearing before it even started: theater.
- bdunbar 15y agoA lady asked Dr. Franklin, "Well Doctor, what have we got a republic or a monarchy?" "A republic," replied the Doctor. "If you can keep it.” Feels like we've lost it: the monarchists have won it back. The pity is they're not even very good monarchists.
- nknight 15y agoNo, a lot of our extant problems would not be present under any reasonably sane (not necessarily benevolent) monarch, very likely including some of the more useless security apparatus. We'd just have different problems.
- bdunbar 15y agoI was not implying that we'd be better off with a monarchy. Only that the rascals in charge _want_ to be a monarchy, and they're not very good at it.
- sp332 15y agoFrom a comment on that page by "greg": Based on their logic, the TSA should also withdraw from the hearings as they're involved in the lawsuits.
- stblack 15y agoCanadian here -- a non-American perspective: your President has no cojones. If he had a pair, the TSA is one of the things he could have easily remedied, or better controlled.
- njharman 15y agoYour assuming that security theater, a large target for public's anger, and a ready source of media distractions aren't all very valuable tools for The Office of the President. 1984 was a very good instruction manual.
- stcredzero 15y agoIt's not like there's a lack of deserving decoys out there. However, the TSA has the advantage of "reaching out and touching" people literally by the multi-millions. The current situation was put in place by George W. as well. They may be the best outrageous government agency the current administration could hope for to look good by comparison to.
- jjcm 15y agoDarrell Issa (one of the committee leaders) is fairly active on twitter. Let him know your concerns: https://twitter.com/#!/DarrellIssa https://twitter.com/#!/DarrellIssa
- gkanai 15y agoI also emailed my rep. (Carolyn Maloney, D-NY) who is on the TSA oversight board.